Stopped by for a cookie after I had brunch next door. Red velvet cake in a cookie with delicious frosting. So yummy. Service was quick.

This is such a gem, and we love having it in our neighborhood. They have such a great variety of cookies, bars, cakes, and other treats. They do custom orders and always have seasonal items. We love picking up cookies here on our way to a party or for special occasions. Everything is always really fresh. Our friends just visited for the first time over the weekend to see Elsa, and the kids absolutely loved the event and the fun princess themed cookies. Looking forward to picking up some Valentine's cookies this week! read more

Miggy’s Bakes - Super Bowl cookies - Desserts Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

People are so friendly and you can't beat the treats! I love that it is a local business and they work very hard to please all their customers. Yummy stuff. read more

Miggy's Bakes offers aesthetically adorable treats at premium prices for the Madison area. Located in a strip mall in Middleton, there has been a buzz about the spot which led me to try it. I have liked everything I've had here but can't rave about flavors or freshness. The treats are pleasing to look at, and the combinations for the cookie cups are like having two treats in one. They are rich! I am always looking for a cinnamon roll to exceed the best in the area (from that European style bakery, also in Middleton) and tried the Miggy's version too. It was a bit small which does strike me as common for this shop. I have always taken treats to go. The shop is suburban strip mall pretty, but I never see anyone hanging out. Maybe its just that kind of place. I know they do a good special order business, as I have been to events where Miggy's treats were offered. Depending on what you think of when you think of a bakery or treat, Miggy's may or may not be your spot. Its worth giving a few tries to decide. read more

This may be the best pastry I have ever eaten! EVER!! It is croissant with chocolate chip cookie baked into. We are talking buttery crispy baked to perfection croissant teamed with a gooey perfectly baked inside cookie. What could go wrong?! You can taste the brown sugar cinnamon chocolate chip flavors that pair well together but inside the croissant are almost too yummy. Had this at shop small boutique event today and then stopped at bakery to get one for later! Also bought this but haven't eaten it yet but I mean cookie inside another cookie.... read more

See all

The cookies looked beautiful in pictures, so decided to give it a shot. The place was silent, but neat. I tried 3 cookies - chocolate peanut butter cups, chocolate chip cookie cup and s'mores cookie cup. All were excellent cookies to try. May be liked the smore's one the most. read more

See all

Visited the storefront for the first time! The pink walls pop and are cheerful. I have gotten the cookie cups from craft fairs they've attended. We came in super late so I didn't expect a lot to be available. To my surprise, there were sugar cookie cups, so I couldn't pass it up! Also, we got a stuffed red velvet cookie, homemade Oreo, and hot chocolate cookie. Check out this bakery for baked goods with a creative twist. read more

Miggy’s Bakes - Desserts Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

Unfortunately I'm 0/2 with experiences at this bakery. Last year we successfully purchased a birthday cake and even delivered our own cake toppers to the bakery shop. But when we got the cake home, we discovered that the cake toppers had not been used. So our 5 year old had a cake with no decorations at all. Fast forward to this year and I decided to give them another chance. I called the bakery to complete an order inquiry and was told someone would call me back to finalize. Nobody ever called me back. The customer service and organization has left me down now twice. I won't be going back. read more

First time here and it's a cute little bakery across from Metro Market. Came on Sunday at 1 pm where they got 5 people ahead. Got a biscoff chocolate chip cookie and pumpkin cheesecake cookie. Tasty and definitely premium price. Wish they offer better packaging since the cheesecake icing stuck to the bag. Lots of chocolate in the biscoff one and quite soft on the pumpkin one. Unsure if I will pay $3.5 again for 1 cookie again. read more

See all

Really delicious treats, although quite pricey. Some items could possibly be made smaller in size and cost less, IMO.

Attended this Yelp event at marigold's kitchen. Miggy's bakes is inside marigold's kitchen. I did not know what to expect. I asked about the yellow event and was directed to grab a Yelp bag from the rack behind me. No one checked off my name from a list or double checked that I'm on the invite list. That's insignificant. What's great is the box of dessert inside the bag. An assortment of desserts. I wished i knew what they were though. The brownie, i recognized that, was very good. The cookie with nuts was too sweet for me until i took away the frosting and it was very very good. Everything tasted home made and fresh. I would get more be desserts from miggy's bakes the next time I'm downtown. read more

Miggy’s Bakes - Dessert assortments - Desserts Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

See all

Literally the best bakery, dare I say, in the world. Their baked goods are so beyond amazing, I've loved everything I've tried. It's unlike any dessert ever. The workers are so so nice and the vibes are amazing. So cozy and lovely and I seriously end up coming here at LEAST once a week. TRY THE APPLE CRISP COOKIE AND THE APPLE PIE BAR!!! Definitely a fall favorite!!! read more

The shop is adorable and has a nice ambiance, but the turtle brownie was very dry and left a lot to be desired. It was definitely not worth $4, but I guess you're paying for the aesthetic... read more

Miggy’s Bakes - Turtle brownie - Desserts Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

Treats are yummy and creative. Favorites is lucky charms cup! Must try! Will be back for more

I have had 2 cakes & 2 order of cookies made by Miggy's & the attention to detail & creativity is top notch. They also do a wonderful job for holidays & any special occasions. The variety & uniqueness make them my choice every time I need something. And the most important thing is EVERYTHING tastes amazing!!!!!! Visit Miggy's....you won't be disappointed! read more

Miggy’s Bakes - a happy birthday cake - Desserts Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

See all

We had the opportunity to order Miggy's Bakes for two corporate events last year. The first was a large order of cookies to hand out at a convention. They were a great magnet to attract convention member to our booth, and everyone was who tried them on the spot said they were delicious. (Plus myself who was able to sneak a leftover one ) The second was an order of holiday treats we were going to ship to 20 different clients. We were concerned about handling the logistics of shipping ourselves, but when I mentioned what our plan was for the treats, the Miggy's team said they could do the shipping themselves. That took a big stress off our minds, and made sure the boxes were able to arrive on time for the Holidays. And we have received nothing but positive feedback from our clients on the treats they received. Whether its for a corporate event, personal party, or a treat for yourself, I would highly recommend Miggy's Bakes. read more

Miggy’s Bakes - a table set up for a conference - Desserts Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

See all

Went to Middleton for the mustard museum, googled Bakery in the area. Found MIGGY'S online, went there, as soon as we walked in, it was just AWESOME!!! brought back great memories. Inside was very clean, young lady behind the counter was very pleasant, explained delicious items we inquired about. The Bakery we purchased was absolutely delicious!!! We came up from West Allis, and will make the trip again just for the Bakery and the Ambiance. Stop there, you will not be disappointed. read more

It has really pretty designs on their cookies. And they actually taste good! Get the decorated sugar cookies, the Kit Kat one, the pb one, and the scotcheroo. Bathrooms are wildly decorate, like the 70's. Cute pink design, cute cakes. read more

Could not recommend this place more. We always visit when we are in madison. The treats are unique and taste great. The owner also runs a cake decorating class that my girlfriend and I did for Christmas which was very fun and turned out amazing! read more

Shelby is beyond rude, she is an awful owner and takes forever to reply to her customers. her cakes are dry, cookies are dry, brownies are dry. She has a child like interior and it matches her child like personality. If you want an overpriced cake that tastes like pure sugar and sand, I highly suggest miggy bakes. If you want a well balanced cake that doesnt taste very american and like pure sugar, i suggest Pasture of Plenty! read more

Great, creative selection of baked goods, super clean and bright space, great location, friendly and welcoming owner! 100% returning :)

Terrible experience, cake cost $85 and looked like it came from a grocery store. Terrible communication, was not told she couldnt do design I wanted for my cake even though she had me send pictures of the design I wanted - I was never told she would just do what she wanted on cake, it looked terrible. Horrible customer service, will never order again read more

Overall great service, love the aesthetic of the ambiance. As far as food goes the cookies were amazing. Definitely would recommend the snickerdoodle cookie. By far my favorite snickerdoodle cookies i have ever had! read more

Amazing cookies, brownies and cookie cups! Great customer service and an awesome person to work with. Definitely will be ordering more in the future read more

Miggy's Bakes makes super delicious peanutbutter cookies! They were offered for a reasonable price too! I had to ask for the cookies to he made sooner than I originally said and Shelby did her best to accommodate my schedule which I really appreciated! I will be contacting Miggy's Bakes in the future. P.S. I love supporting local businesses also!!! read more