Surprisingly I had never been in this place even though I have passed it hundreds of times. I am…read moremore of a custard person than an ice cream. guy. We had a free scoop coupon so of course we had to give it a try. I was impressed by all of the flavors - it was very hard to decide. Both my scoop and my wife's were tasty. I definitely will stop in again even if I have to pay!

Delicious finger licking good ice cream! Great selection of flavors both classic & creative…read morecreations. Friendly folks, samples are free, community supporting & long lasting ties to Madison. Fun & colorful shops.

Stopped in for some ice cream after a Devils Lake hike. They offer a lot of flavors and even some…read moredairy free options. I decided to go with the honey and fig and I really enjoyed it. The flavor was subtle but just the right amount of sweetness. It was honey forward, but got some chunks of fig which was nice!

Came here toward closing time for an ice cream treat at the end of the night. I'd never been here…read morebefore and was excited to try it. I don't generally like wild combinations of flavors, but they had an Oreo ice cream that I just couldn't resist. It was incredible - not just some vanilla ice cream with Oreos in it... this felt like the actual creamy ice cream part was also Oreo flavor loaded. I could have eaten the whole tub by myself. The staff person there was very nice. I saw on their menu that they can also make some boozy ice cream concoctions, which is always a fun option so hopefully I'll be back to sample some of that goodness. The spoons also changed colors when it contacted the cold ice cream, so that was super fun. They also had a food/cafe menu if you want a meal with your ice cream!

This shop was right across the street from our hotel. We decided to check it out and we were not…read moredisappointed. They didn't have a lot of flavors but I did feel like they had pretty unique flavors so I loved that. My mom & I split a flight. We enjoyed all 4 flavors we tried, the peaches, peaches, peaches one was probably one of my favs. It was a smaller shop, only a couple of seats to dine in but I did see that people were sitting outside so that's an option.

Madison is lacking in good, artisanal ice cream spots - but this one fills that gap tremendously!…read moreThat and the business's continued mission of donating a portion of their profits to local social justice organizations makes it a no-brainer for you to stop by and spend your money here. This is my must-go spot when I have friends visiting from out of town. The flavors are constantly rotating, but if you follow their Instagram they update it with whats in stock. There is some indoor seating and outdoor as well during the summer months. I don't think I've ever had anything I *disliked* here. But the stand out flavors for me includes: lavender honeycomb, harvest moon, and fluffy the mint slayer!

So many assortments of ice cream and too many to count. While my friends had the pleasure of eating…read moreice cream, I was very impressed by the fact that they can make your chicharrones with cojita cheese and lemon juice. There is Valentina hot sauce on the side if you need it. Would recommend for a quick snack. Staff are very friendly and more than happy to help you.

As always, really good Mexican style ice cream in a non-descript, empty strip mall in Madison's…read morewest side. All about bringing back memories, we went out of our way to go back to one of my daughter's favorite ice cream places while growing up. We frequented La Michoacana soon after it opened, loving the observation that it seemed to start out slow, but became a lot more busy as the word got out. It was the first Michaoacana that we frequented. Since then, we've visited others in SoCal, but there really is something about a first, especially if infused with nostalgia. I loved getting their goat's milk caramel ice cream, and as my daughter observed, we couldn't find this flavor anywhere else since we moved away. They still have it (though they call it toffee now). Prices have gone up (of course) and is actually comparable to the chain ice cream shops across town. As always, the workers are super friendly. Two scoops is $6.13 in a cup, and I got the mentioned toffee ice cream made with goat's milk. For me, it is still very good: very creamy with a very rich caramel flavor. My daughter said hers wasn't as good as she remembered, and she is pretty good about things like that so it must be different (which makes sense since they changed the name).

Made our pilgrimage... We rarely visit UW Madison and The Terrace without a stop at Daily Scoop. My…read morepartner always gets the orange custard chocolate chip. This time I got a double scoop ice cream cone with orange custard, chocolate chip and the occasionally available, Blue Moon. It's always hard for people to describe what the flavor of Blue Moon is. It's kind of berry flavored but not blueberry. But it is delicious. I was wearing a tie and the person working the cash register offered me a cup along with my cone "just in case." It was very warm outside. The clerk knew exactly what he was talking about. I still ended up with "Blue Moon" ice cream on my purple tie. It's off to the dry cleaners now.

Came with some friends for an after dinner treat on a Wednesday evening. It's a busy place and…read moreexpect to wait in line for ~10-15minutes. They don't give out samples. Enjoyed sitting lakeside and eating my blueberry vanilla ice cream. The lakeside terrace is a wonderful place.

The owner was very generous sharing all the delicious unique flavors as samples before we ordered…read more It was hard to decide with so many options but I went with a scoop of cherry almond and a scoop of Purple Moon (citrus/almond flavor). Very friendly service, bright clean store with comfortable outdoor seating!

The owner was super nice, just as everyone mentioned. She clearly loves the shop and the ice cream…read moreher family produces out of Milwaukee. You don't need to ask for samples, she'll just start handing them out. Their flavors are inspired and unique but still have classics available. The mint cookie crunch was exactly what you would expect, they don't have smaller cups so no matter what size you get the same one. I got the cherry almond which was good, but could have had more almond in it. It was very distinctly almond extract flavored. Otherwise, I didn't love all the flavors but appreciated all that they were trying to do

We are so grateful to have an ice cream shop downtown Stoughton. It has some great varieties…read moreavailable for scoops, as well as some pints TO GO. Price points are what you'd expect from a small ice cream shop. You are able to get sugar, waffle and cake cones or a dish. Single scoops in a waffle cone were $6 and a junior scoop in a sugar cone was $4.

I recently visited Icki Sticki and this place is the perfect stop for a sweet treat. The moment I…read morewalked in, 1 was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere, complete with colorful decor that immediately lifted my spirits. There are so many ice cream flavors to choose from as well as other sweet treats such as bakery items and sandwiches. They also have a variety of drinks from coffee to boba tea. This last visit I got a hot dirty chai and a money business waffle that were both delicious. I also really liked that. They have a pay it forward wall, where several people paid for items for people in need. Staff was very friendly but it was a slight wait as there was only one person working. Overall great place.

I am excited to see a new Icki Sticki. I was there within couple of days of their opening. They…read moredidn't have everything they generally offer. The smore's waffle which was a holiday special was good. The simple egg and cheese sandwich tasted good as well. Winter chai latte was a good drink to try. I had a muffin as well. They had several Wisconsin specialized products like sprecher and rishi tea. I took a chocolate shoppe locorice ice cream as well. Flavor was slightly spicy, but ok for me. But it was full of black food color. Next couple of days you could see the color leaving your body.