Wow.. stopped in for the 1st time yesterday! The place is cookie heaven. I've been to cupcake only bakeries, but never a cookie paradise. The cookies are just what you imagine they would be! Like all the grandma's in the world teamed up to make the best of the best recipes and said you my children deserve fresh out of the oven warm cookies. I ordered 4 and now I wish I ordered 24.... who is counting calories anyways! I got a chocolate chip, a chocolate cookies and cream, Pecan pie cookie and a Carmel cinnamon Leche cookie. Wow were they top notch. Huge cookies. Several options to choose from along with cookies of the week. My entire family agreed that we just found our newest favorite cookie shop. Not to mention the smell of this place was magical and free. I may have dreamed about those cookies smells last night! Lol. We will be back again soon to try more. read more

Love the cookies and the menu. The app is great EXCEPT- I often order delivery and the last time I ordered I could not confirm that the cookies were delivered. They were not. I couldn't find any information to track or report this issue. If ordering delivery, I highly recommend using an app with support that offers tracking or refunds. I was able to call and speak with a real person, they do use door dash so they were able to replace the order. I'm pretty disappointed as I was using the cookies for a little get together. Cute little shop though and very positive sup read more

Some cookie flavors are too sweet but some have been wonderful! The four pack goes a long way when sharing.

Warm cookie. Beautifully presented in a pretty box. What's not to like? Pick out out my selection from their website before I arrived, and joined their birthday club to get a free cookie on my birthday. Yum. read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Chocolate Chip cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

seriously. the crumbl cookies tastes like someone fucking sprayed it with cleaning solution! its not edible. I had to throw away all 4 because I swear to God they literally sprayed it. it tastes like literal cleaning solution. Im beginning to feel sick and lightheaded. read more

I've heard the hype of this place for a while and today finally decided to check it out. I was craving some gooey, warm and delicious cookies and I was not disappointed. These cookies are so darn delicious! The oatmeal chocolate chip was just a classic good cookie. It was the perfect amount of crunch and giant chocolate chips. The fruit pizza cookie was the special of the week and it was amazing. The frosting was to die for cream cheesy and decadent! The sugar cookie literally melted in your mouth. My sweet tooth has a new bad habit and I will for sure be back, a lot. read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Oatmeal chocolate chip and peanut butter brownie - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Shiny & new! On a snowy day in Madison, I needed a sweet pick me up and Crumbl was just the place! Newly opened in Sun Prairie (and a new location in Hilldale coming soon), I stopped in to a bright spotless room! Contactless ordering, large screens for the menus and marketing. I was able to meet some of the managers who were super friendly and explained the process of coming up with flavors and their promotions (grab one of their biz cards to find out how to win a free party box!) I tried the frozen hot chocolate and the sugar cookie. I love chocolate so the hot cho was delicious. The cookie was soft even though cold. I don't even know if you'd call the top frosting- I think it was a marshmallow fluff mixture? It was my favorite part! The sugar cookie was tasty as well. It' large than any ordinary sugar cookie, that's for sure! Definitely worth a stop if you're in the mood for some sweets. read more

See all

This is one of my all time favorite places for dessert! The weekly release of different cookies is what keeps me coming back. I love to try new flavors. Some better than others but that's personal preference. Cookies are always super fresh and staff is always friendly. Tried the ice cream for the first time and it was delicious as well! Can't wait to keep trying new flavors! read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Apple Pie cookie and Aggie mint. Snickerdoodle ice cream - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

First impression was wow, these cookies are big and thick! I saw Crumbl store once in Houston but didn't try. Had the classic milk chocolate chips cookies and it was too rich for me. I managed to eat 1/2 and it was good. They are quite expensive but the pink box is eye catching! read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Too sweet?! There's no such thing to me! I know people give Crumbl a hard time because they think the cookies are too sweet but I think they are perfect! I absolutely love cookies and adore how I can try new ones at Crumbl each week. They always have the most fun flavors! My personal favorites are the butterfinger, Nutella, sea salt caramel, corn bread, and pop tart! I really haven't had one that I didn't like. I also love how they come out hot! The service has been fantastic every time I've gone. The staff is super friendly and efficient. They greet you at the door and have your cookies out in a flash. They also have self-check out if you'd like to do it yourself. The Sun Prairie location has tons of parking and is fairly easy to get to. There is no dine in but I think that's pretty standard for all Crumbl stores. I definitely recommend to my fellow sweet tooth's! read more

See all

Surprised at the "gift wrap" I paid extra for being a simple stretchy band tied into a bow, I asked if this was really the "gift wrap" and was given a super rude answer. This "gift box" was also disgustingly dirty, sticky and gross - to the extent that I would never give it to the recipient this way without first going home to clean it off. As I was leaving I saw another customer take a bite out of his cookie, promptly spit it out in the nearby garbage and throw the entire cookie away. My order was over $60 with a tip added in - I think I'll save my money next time around and just bake my own cookies or at least take my business somewhere where it's appreciated and the workers aren't rude. The cookies are meh. read more

See all

Hands down the best cookies on the planet!!!!!!! Crispy on the outside warm and chewy in the center how do they do it!

Always good service never had a bad experience And their cookie selection changes every week so you cannot go wrong with that and you don't have to get all the cookies if you don't want to there's more than one option you could buy a single cookie if that's all you want a four pack a 12 pack I think they have a 24 pack two so you can have as many of the cookies as you want including several duplicates of the cookies depending on the size family you have or if you're sharing with a friend read more

Traditionally I'm not a sweet cookie kind of person, until I met crumble cookies and they are out of this world! Went to Dean SSM health Saint Marys COVID 19 erea and delivered dozens of your cookies to there most excellent staff doctors , nurses ! All of them are precious!! They loved them and I know that they will be back for more. read more

Always at least one cookie that hits the spot for everyone in the family which is always a plus!

They're good cookies. For the prices they charge, they'd better be good, right? And they are. Really good cookies. But that's about it. Not great. Just good. Are they worth the price? Probably not. But they're good. I've never not seen customers in there, so people are definitely buying. I've gone in twice. For the cost, I'd rather go get a 24-pack of cookies from Metro Mart for $5. They're just as good. read more

Crumbl cookies is the sweetest new dessert place in town!!! I thought it was like any other bakery, and I was completely caught off guard with how awesome it is. They have five new flavors of cookies every week that'll knock your socks off. I fell in love with their sherbert cookie. This place for sure will help your sweet tooth and you'll want to keep coming back. The cookies are huge and reasonably priced. The service was great and everyone was kind. Can't wait to go back! read more

ok. Not really my type of taste and texture but it's decent. Probably the wouldnt order this unless someone requests it.

Cookies were good, but for the price they should have been out of this world! Also disappointed that they don't offer sugar-free option...SF is a staple today and the option would be great for folks watching their sweets input as well as diabetics and others who have to control sweets for medical or other reasons read more

Cookies yes! Sugar free no. There are so many of us who can't eat sugar and so many new sugar substitutes. It would be so nice to have a healthy choice. Anyway I went in to check it out. The place is small and really cute. They had plenty of staff to keep up with customers in line and curb side pick up. It smelled really good in there but I can't eat sugar. It was tempting!! read more

Nice team.They we're listening Gina was very helpful to my son Thanks to each team members read more

The smell when you enter is heavenly, so if they could work on bottling that I'd appreciate it. We got an assortment of 12 cookies - they are generously sized so it was quite a treat! One cookie at a time is plenty. My favorites are the chocolate cookies with frosting and crumbles and the lemon cookies. The upbeat attitude of the cashiers was very nice, though it was overwhelming to my senses to be inside for very long between the loud (but nice and enthusiastic) greeting to every customer, the sound of the cookies being made and the music. It was nice to place our order using a screen, but it would be great to have a hands sanitizer dispenser there after using it. Also, the placement of the screens in the store isn't great. People came in after us and pushed past us to get in line. We felt crowded and unsafe in those moments. Next time, we'll order ahead online, but we'll definitely be back! read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Assortment of 12 cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Ordered cookies on opening day for delivery and they were AMAZING! We tried them all and they did not disappoint. Cookies were huge, easily cut into 4 for sharing. Delivery was quick and driver was friendly. Will be back again! read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Yummy cookies! Flavors sometimes don't come around as often as I'd like but, they're good!

My husband brought me some crumbl to try! His boss sometimes orders for the employees to share and it's very close to his work. I haven't been to Crumbl yet but finally got a taste! I had some of the lemon and I believe cookies n cream. Definitely left me wanting to try more flavors and will be in the future. read more

I saw that this place opened and I just had to try it since I have an intense love for sweets. And WOW these cookies are very very sweet. My boyfriend and I got 4 cookies to share and I had a couple bites of each and felt a bit sick afterwards from all of the sugar haha. We tried the cornbread which was surprisingly really good, the oatmeal chocolate chip and two chilled cookies, the cookies and cream and the sugar cookie. Both were good! They were still soft even though they had been in the fridge. This place was a bit chaotic today, there were about 20 employees in the back working and a lot of people waiting around for their orders. They'll work the kinks out eventually but for just having opened recently things were moving pretty quick. I would definitely go back, but maybe in like 4 months once I have another craving for something sweet. read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Cornbread, oatmeal chocolate chip, cookies and cream, frosted sugar - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

See all

Use to think people were exaggerating when they said a cookie would just melt in there mouth, but that's really how it feels when eating some of the cookies at Crumbl Cookies. There's different flavors every week and they're usually always pretty creative and interesting. Staff are also usually always friendly. read more

A little pricey but the cookies are big. It's a great snack and a nice new place to have in town! I'm excited to see what new flavors they will have in the future. read more

Absolutely fantastic! If you're craving a cookie, this is the spot. It's extremely clean, everyone is friendly and the cookies are to die for. They are MASSIVE, delicious, and there are many flavors to choose from. Will definitely be back! read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Ooey gooey chocolate chip!! 3 - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

We are so grateful once again to Kayla and the Bakery staff for going above and beyond to make his Police retirement that much more special with his photo cake!!! read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

This place was amazing when it first opened. However, there's been some inconsistencies with the cookies that I find myself hoping I'll get a great cookie when I randomly decide to get one. :( If it's not a good cookie, I would just drive to Chick-Fil-A for their cookies. read more

When we got there the line was out the door. Decided to order curbside and they were out right away. The cookies were amazing as was the service. This is a great place to stop and get a sweet treat once in awhile. read more

Crumbl - Sun Prairie - Peanut butter and jelly, cake batter into Twix - Bakeries Near Me - Sun Prairie, Wisconsin

Had to see what all the fuss was about &&&& it's absolutely delicious. The bakery is so cute! Highly recommended. read more

Ok, Crumbl Cookies, you've won me over at first bite. I was skeptical at first but these are seriously the best cookies I've every had: hot and fresh, not to sweet, inventive flavors and that slightly underbaked center. I've stopped eating all other cookies, because why bother when you've had the best. Strawberry chocolate cheesecake, hot frozen chocolate and cornbread cookies are my favorite so far. read more

Super delish is all I can say! There goes my diet! Maybe have the small pieces available from the counter and not just through catering!

Went there at 5 minutes to close and woman was very rude. I think they get paid till close? Won't be going back anytime in the near future.

I ordered my cookies at 6:15 and it is now 8:01. It shouldn't take that long to drive 10 minutes