pickup online order : 6 perogies for $6 says on menu ..but I got a handful of tiny perogies, was not impressed with the Italian sub either. The lunch meat used was cheap and lousy. would not recommend. Also offered paperplates on take out order and they didnt have any. read more

The "famous pounder cheese steak " well, it was definitely really good. It was very tasty with a mixture of a couple of different flavors. I definitely enjoyed it, and although it was pretty big, it felt light going down, which was good on my stomach. As for the pizza, well, it was ok. It's like almost there as far as being good pizza. They said they had a new recipe for the pizza, which shows me they are working on getting it to a really good tasting pizza. I can respect that. Overall, it's worth a visit, especially with affordable prices. read more

See all

I was skeptical because, on the outside, it could use a little curb appeal, but this sub shop had one of the best cheesesteaks I've ever tried. We bought one large with everything and had leftovers to take home. We were waited on promptly and the food was ready quickly even though they were busy. It's definitely a "locals" regular spot, and while it's nothing fancy, there were tables inside and it was air conditioned to escape the heat of a hot day. Not sure about the other menu items (although they looked good) but the cheesesteak was excellent! read more

Driving home through central PA to Pittsburgh and found Mileto's as a sandwich shop stop! So glad we stopped in! Quite a hole in the wall and very limited parking. No frills here. great food! We had the buffalo chicken cheesesteaks. We ordered a whole sandwich and shared it. There is no way one person could eat a whole one alone! It was served on a standard sub roll and with a fork. The chopped chicken and cheese were so good and served with hot pepper spread. It was nice and hot and Buffalo-y, so be prepared if you don't like spicy. Quick friendly service which was perfect for a fast lunch stop. Lots of locals clearly there for lunch which is always a good sign. Only reason I'm giving 4 stars is because the restaurant is very dingy and it's clear the shop could use a good deep clean. read more

See all

Horrible customer service. Placed an order online. Got an update that 10 minutes was added to my pick up time as they were busy. Show up for my order and was told that it would be a few more minutes. Waited over 20 minutes and went back up to the counter and the girl asked again who I was picking up for just to be told my order was ready. Why was I told to wait when my order was ready all along??? Maybe pay attention to your customers instead of bs'ing with your co-workers! read more

The service was really polite and fast. They can stamp a card where you get a free sub or sandwich after 5 visits. The chicken is whole breast meat and taste really good. They even have the old school Arizona's. Highly recommend (today's special is:) a dozen wingz for 11 bucks. read more

Mileto's Sub Shop - Chicken cheesesteak without cheese and sub toppings. - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

Great food, good service. I would definitely eat here again. We phoned in a large order for multiple people. Mileto's handled it easily and we had no complaints. read more

We had a very negative experience ordering a large order online and received little help or concern when we called in to inquire on why our order was changed drastically with no notification. It wasn't even remotely what we ordered and we didn't find out until we got home and opened the bags. I called and was told to call doordash. I did call and complained to doordash and received a partial refund, but none of this was doordash's fault. I also wrote a review here and on Google and received a full refund from Mileto's, so I've raised my review from 1 star to 3 stars. I'm sorry to say I still highly doubt I'll return because the staff were horribly rude and the food was sub-par, but I do appreciate the owners making things right in the long run, and so I'm changing my review from 1 to 3 stars. read more

Best Philly cheesesteak I've ever had and I lived in Philly for 6 years. It's hard to eat more than 1/2 foot.

This is the place for the perfect cheesesteak. The bread is soft and the hot peppers just the right spice. We ordered the 16 inch whole hoagie with mushrooms, cooked onions, hot peppers, lettuce and tomatoes. It came out hot and fresh with a fork. A fork for a sandwich, you ponder?? Yes!! This sandwich was so full it was falling all over the place. Strangely, I find a messy sandwich the best tasting sandwich. read more

Mileto's Sub Shop - Fully loaded cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Cheese steak is the truth. I had mine with the hot pepper relish. Bacon cheddar fries were a nice guilty pleasure. Solid meal for a solid price. read more

Such a great cheesesteak! Found this place through yelp and it did not disappoint! Half a cheesesteak is way too big, but bun was fab and meat was tasty! read more

Cheesesteak is very overrated, especially for the price associated. Bread was not of great quality and there was too much steak on it to eat it normally. I had to eat this thing with a fork and knife due to the amount of steak used which seems like more of a gimmick than a pure cheesesteak. read more

Awesome subs! Visiting from Florida, nothing even close there! Sandwiches had tons of meat!

Tried the new Montoursville location today. Cheesesteak is just as good as the newberry location and the staff are just as friendly.

The cheesesteaks here when they are toasted are decent. However, I had to drop a star due to a store policy. They sell these yellow cheesesteak tickets, but if you want it toasted you cannot use these yellow tickets. They want full price for it; Obnoxious, upsetting, and silly. Thanks for the soggy cheesesteak. It was not the worst in town. read more

Drove from Texas to drop off a college student and found this hidden gem in this small town. The family and I were happy to have found this shop! Mission to finding a good cheesesteak "check!" read more

Mileto's Sub Shop - Famous Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Excellent cheese steak! Full of flavor and more food than I could handle. Highly recommend if you are craving a good cheese steak!

The kindness shown to the community from Kristi was unmatched by any I've seen. Besides the food is outstanding and staff is always friendly and helpful. Keep up the excellent work. Thank you all! read more

Mileto's Sub Shop: 4/5 DoorDash 0/5 Stars Ordered for the family of 5 via DoorDash. An item was not available so was refunded the amount. No call of any sort to consider an alternative for the order. I attempted to call Mileto's and line was always busy. Despite the difficulties, 4/5 LOVED the food. 1/5 Family got Wendy's. DoorDash - Billing was inaccurate and Customer Service closed chat on my 1st attempt to resolve after stating the problem. 2nd attempt different person closes chat and sends me an automated e-mail and a sorry for the inconvenience with the ticket number. read more

I live 10 minutes away. Grub hub gave me an estimated time of 1:15 to 1:39. It needs to be a little more precise. Food was done at 1:19. Food was great just a little old. read more

Big sandwich with tons of meat good price. Ordered trough DoorDash got order right and quickly.

Best cheesesteaks ever, hands down. I am always greeted with a smiling face when I go here.

Excellent Cosmo Cheesesteak!!! I heard from word of mouth from one of the locals that they have the best cheesesteaks in town. Well they weren't lying. Great taste and a lot for what you pay for. Highly recommend to any cheesesteak lover or anyone that wants to be introduced to a cheesesteak! read more

Mileto's Sub Shop - a sandwich in a plastic container - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

On a whim decided to take two large sub trays to a pool party. From out of town, I had no idea who to call. With short notice this team delivered awesome trays which were a hit. The rolls, meat, and other items were fresh and served with mayo, awesome peppers and oil on the side. The subs were fully loaded and everyone enjoyed them. I would highly recommend this shop. Thank you Mileto's. read more

Do not buy hoagies on Wednesday. Bread from day before. My italian was horrible bread was very steal. CALLED AND ALL I GOT WAS A APOLOGIZE and was told Wednesday is cosmo day because rolls are from the day before. Not go for business Andi W read more

Ok I'm from outta town and I was looking for a good cheese steak and man did I find it!! I'm really picky when it comes to cheese steaks and this one didn't disappoint! It's just a little sub shop but I'd recommend it to anyone! If your looking for a quick amazing lunch for under 15 bucks this place is for you! They don't have an extensive menu but they have what counts and you will not leave there hungry. I for one will be a repeat customer!! read more

Mileto's Sub Shop - Cheese steak with hot pepper relish,mayo,mushrooms and onions!! Heaven on a bun!! - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

This is a good mom and pop shop, possibly the friendliest place in town. The food is good, the dining room is small but it's a nice 'greasy spoon' kinda spot. Been in town for decades, hope it stays. The literal only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because, out of the four people that had a hand in preparing our sandwiches, only one wore gloves. Other than that, this place is good and I'll still eat there despite the risk lol read more

Mileto's. What is there to say besides consistently satisfying. I found this place over a year ago and was hooked to their chicken cheesesteak ever since. I had to go to Chicago for 8 months, but as soon as I returned Mileto's was one of my first priories upon returning to Williamsport area. The bang for the buck here is impeccable. They have multiple cooks who deliver that cheesesteak I so much desire for lunch everyday. I work nearby and probably get Mileto's 4/5 days of the work week. My office coworkers literally know me for going to Mileto's most days of the week. At one point I could just call and say my name and they already knew my order. The Josh cheesesteak. These cheesesteaks are right up there with Dalessandro's or Jim's or Max's in Philly. The staff is friendly, the owner is a really hard worker, and they do a little punch card system where once you hit 10 punches you get a whole cheesesteak for free. 11/10 recommend you go here and try their cheesesteak read more

Always awesome subs. They do not skimp on the meat. Used to go here when worked nearby and loved the small family running it. Stop here for pick up every few weeks or so, never disappointed. Try it. read more

If you haven't been here lately, you really should give them a try! Cheese steak sandwich with or without the bun is excellent!! 16 oz. of great sirloin steak, with any and all trimmings that you would want! read more

Good subs, for great prices. Nice quaint mom & pop type. Can get a lunch for 2 people that will fill you both up for under $15. Pizza isn't the greatest... that is being nice. read more

This subshop has cheese steaks that won't disappoint! they are the best in town and you will not be disappointed, with cheap prices!

Oh, yeah! Fantastic neighborhood fixture, been there all my life. Mary Mileto was an extraordinary woman, community-minded, and I am proud to say I knew her. And these subs are the 'real deal' in the Williamsport area. read more