Mileto&#x27;s Sub Shop

Good appetizers! Margherita pizza is really good . I have been going for years. The lighting is…read moreamazing. Service is good.

Had dinner with hubby here last night. Interesting location, down an alley - fun!! We had The…read moreStonehouse pizza and roasted vegetables. Both were very good! The staff was all very friendly and attentive. It took longer to get our pizza, than we expected, but the restaurant was nice to sit and relax and the pizza was worth the wait - says this Chicago girl.

Dining Area at The Stonehouse Wood Fired Pizza and Pasteria

Steak and Focaccia (Steak with Arugula, Pesto, Roasted Roma Tomatoes & Fresh Mozzarella) with Steak Fries at The Stonehouse

See all

Storefront for The Stonehouse Wood Fired Pizza and Pasteria

Venice Pizza Shop Italian Restaurant

4.5(43 reviews)

4.7 mi

The service is fast and the pizza is amazing and super greasy like I love it. The staff is nice and…read morefriendly.

Let's be perfectly clear from the jump: This place IS…read morewinning the Billtown pizza crown. Not just once. Year after year after year. This isn't a competition anymore--it's a recurring public humiliation. This place walks into Williamsport like it already has the trophy in hand and proceeds to teabag the competition like a feral 2006 Xbox Live gremlin. Every other pizza shop shows up hopeful... and leaves P N P W N E D. All caps. Extra spaces. Maximum disrespect. That meme energy. The crust? Locked in like it studied film. The sauce? Confident. Loud. Knows it's better than you and doesn't apologize. The cheese? Melted so perfectly it triggers flashbacks to the best pizza you ever had--and then beats that memory in a 1v1. This pizza doesn't just win. It stands over the defeated, crouch-spamming, announcer screaming "FATALITY" while the controller disconnects on the other side. One bite and suddenly: * Other pizzas owe you an apology * Your personal pizza rankings collapse * A Halo voice whispers "Double Kill... Triple Kill... Unfrigginbelievable" Is it fair? No. Is it balanced? Absolutely not. Is it getting nerfed next season? Also no. Billtown crown champion. Repeatedly. Relentlessly. Other pizzas: PWNED. This place: GG EZ. Final score: 11/10 slices Williamsport--this is the meta.

Cooked perfectly

See all

Large cheese

Old School Pizza

3.1(67 reviews)

2.8 mi

This is total crap. Their food is dog food. Go to joes pizza instead. I spent 45 dollars when I…read morecould have just bought 2 cans of dog food. Their fries are like cardboard.

Ordered a pizza with extra sauce and extra cheese . Got home and there is zero sauce .. NONE !! I…read morecalled and let them know he says let me pull the ticket.. yup you ordered extra sauce extra cheese let me ask in the back. Come back and said well we're sorry . I said well I want another pizza well we're closing , I said well then I want a credit for another pizza for the next time. He says well we can't credit you for a whole pizza but we won't charge you for the extra sauce next time ... are you serious !!! I said no way I want credit for another pizza ! I'll bring this one back . He said do you w Ant to talk to the manager . I said yes . He goes in the back and then says sorry he's not available. Call tomorrow if you want . Unbelievable!!! Who ever was making pizzas tonight Monday evening 9/9/24 needs a new profession .

Pizza

See all

Pizza

Bart's Pizzeria

4.1(25 reviews)

2.2 mi

Great pizza, definitely one of my favorites. Try a thick crust cheese pizza with extra sauce, you…read morewon't be disappointed. Staff is always friendly and the place seems clean.

Best pizza in Williamsport. It's a little pricey but worth it am hoping they get on board with the…read moreNew York style Pizza

Large cheese pizza from Bart's

Pizza by barts

See all

Cheese party pizza

Joe’s Pizza

4.1(55 reviews)

4.7 mi

Great food I experienced a great cheese steak love the homemade bread. The price was very…read moreinexpensive for the amount of of food

Ordered take out from Joe's for the first time today. Pizza was easy to order, lots of options…read more Pizza was ready when expected. Though it is a busy place on a Saturday night, check out was quick and friendly. We had sausage and mushroom pizza. I liked the pizza crust. Overall, it was good, but a little salty. Will definitely go back.

See all

Vinnies' Italian Eatery

3.5(39 reviews)

2.7 mi

Second visit to Williamsport for the LLWS, second visit to Vinnie's!…read more We called ahead both times and the order was ready when anticipated. Basic cheese pie. Pictures are one year apart, consistency! Staff are friendly. Pie was hot, crust had a crunch. There is indoor seating. Standard pizza shop atmosphere.

Vinnie's is great! The owner Juan and his son are amazing and friendly and the pizza and Stromboli…read moreare terrific. Lasagna was good too. And I love the name. -Vinnie

Deluxe Stromboli

HUGE Pastrami sub

See all

The pizza box that Stromboli arrived in

Long Island Pizza

4.1(64 reviews)

2.5 mi

disappointed. I've ordered from here before with great results. ordered the family pack, meatball…read moreparty pizza for delivery. ground beef taste like vegetarian meat. very bland. cheese was too thick. called restaurant to complain to manager, told they don't have a manager, but it was made the way they always make it. said she was sorry that we didn't like it. no offer to make it right.

I've been here a few times, the pizza is fabulous and the price is right ! I tried the sub for the…read morefirst time -it's so good ! Nice people own-work here , support local

In Good Company

S'mores Dessert Pizza

See all

Kramer!

Park Pizza

3.7(36 reviews)

0.6 mi

They have the best Pizza and Wings in town. The only thing I…read morewish they would have is on-line ordering.

I grew up eating NY style pizza, so I'm not generally a fan of many of the pizza places around…read morehere. However, Park Pizza hits the spot. The crust isn't too thick or too thin. They are generous with the cheese and toppings. I like that they put the pepperoni under the cheese, that's a new one for me. I've only gotten take out, but the staff at the counter are always super friendly. Plus everything is always ready when they say it will be. The inside is clean and there are plenty of tables if you'd like to eat there instead.

Interior decor

Menu

See all

Joe's Pizza West End

4.1(23 reviews)

1.7 mi

Stopped in for lunch and grabbed two plain slices and a drink for $6 (daily special). Slices…read morewere very good!

Great subs I recommend to anyone and everyone worth the money. Price is good and so is the foodread more

Front of menu

Back menu

See all

Cheese pizza

Riverside Subs & Pizza

3.9(19 reviews)

2.1 mi

Must have for me every time I visit. Don't listen to the bad reviews because they obviously didn't…read morelike what they ordered. My family loves it and always will. The subs are definitely the thing to get though. Try the mountaineer!

The subs are alright but nothing special. It does have the worst pizza I have ever tasted. I…read moreordered extra sauce and made it clear. They didn't get it right. The pizza was dry and tasted terrible. Threw it away.. It used to be a really good place. Their food used to be very good. I guess that's what happens when you hire children who don't care and just slap the food together just for the paycheck. I've been a customer there for many years but after several disappointing meals I give up. Not going there again...

Things to do in Williamsport

See all

Menu 3/31/17

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Steve E.

76

25

88

8 years ago

I'm not from around here. Therefore I have no idea what this place was like over the years that led up to my visiting this spot. I got turned onto this place from a Facebook ad that boasted a full pound of sirloin steak on a cheesesteak! Most places in this area either use a sub par "steak-um" type meat or barely any meat at all. So, upon arriving here I noticed parking was ok and the restaurant inside was really nothing to write home about. There was a couple of fridges with self serve drinks, a couple racks of chips, and some games including the new pa gambling machine. They have a bar type area where you could tell a bunch of friends and locals gather by their conversation. So where did they put the money that didn't go toward a fancy parking lot or a newly remodeled interior? The food. The cheesesteak I got was indeed a huge beast of a sub. The meat was cooked perfectly and very juicy while being well done. The fried onions were just right, not still raw nor overdone. The bun was soft, yet chewy enough and robust enough to soak up the inevitable juice that comes from all that meat and condiments. Would I recommend it, yes. Will I order another whole cheesesteak, no way. They are far too big to eat a whole. Which is a good thing. Not many places anymore can you order food and leave full. read more

Danette M.

0

1

0

5 years ago

On a whim decided to take two large sub trays to a pool party. From out of town, I had no idea who to call. With short notice this team delivered awesome trays which were a hit. The rolls, meat, and other items were fresh and served with mayo, awesome peppers and oil on the side. The subs were fully loaded and everyone enjoyed them. I would highly recommend this shop. Thank you Mileto's. read more

John S.

0

3

0

10 years ago

The food is pretty good and it used to be the best price around but they have raised their prices and now it's just kind of run of the mill. Pretty much same as any other sub shop around here. Mediocre at best. read more

Ashley G.

159

2

0

8 years ago

I love that you can make a hoagie into a salad for no extra cost! Best hoagies around!

Carl A.

0

1

0

8 years ago

full fill, great taste, ok pricing, also fast and polite service.

Kristi M.

182

1

0

15 years ago

Best subs at the best prices.

Mileto's Sub Shop - pizza - Updated September 2026

Best of Williamsport

People found Mileto's Sub Shop by searching for…

People who viewed Mileto's Sub Shop also viewed

Newberry Sub Shop

4.1

(57 reviews)

Great shop. First time here during the covid and the service was great…read more Fast hoagies and curbside pickup. Ordered their cheese steak in the garden with fried onions, very very good. Fresh bread and steak wasn't dry. Italian full of meat and bread was perfect. Thanks for providing take out.

This sub shop was a random find while driving east on I-80 through Pennsylvania. It was dinner…read moretime and we were getting hungry. I suggested looking up sandwich shops and of the list of places, Newberry Sub Shop, was the random pick. Located in a picturesque area of Williamsport, PA, and a decent trek off from I-80, Newberry is a local, mom & pop type shop that is popular among the locals. Their menu offers a nice variety of sub sandwiches which is what we were interested in. The shop is a counter-service type establishment. Menu is on the wall and also on paper near the ordering counter. There's a small dining area inside the shop and also, an outdoor seating area. We were taking our food to go. We ordered 1) cold Salami Sub and 1) Mushrooms and Bell Peppers Cheesesteak with cherry (hot) peppers. We also grabbed a local brand of spicy jalapeno flavored potato chips. We received good, friendly service. The staff was helpful to us in deciding what we wanted to order. The menu items were reasonably priced and you got good bang for your buck. The sandwiches were huge and loaded. Both the sandwiches were good. I got the cheesesteak and it hit the spot. The meat was well-cooked and flavorful, and the veggies and the cheese added a delicious taste. My only gripe about the cheesesteak was that the bread was very soft where the sandwich fell apart due to how hot (temp.) the cheesesteak was, thus making for a sloppy eating experience. But that's why you have utensils like fork. The Salami sandwich was also delicious. The chips were okay. They were a bit salty for my liking and not quite spicy. Overall, this was like a hidden gem of a find for us (since we were visitors passing by and not locals). I would like to have more of their other offerings. I am not sure when I'll be back in that area but suffice to say that I will be going back to Newberry when I return to this part of Pennsylvania in the future. Check out Newberry. Definitely recommended.

Joe's Pizza West End

4.1

(23 reviews)

Stopped in for lunch and grabbed two plain slices and a drink for $6 (daily special). Slices…read morewere very good!

Great subs I recommend to anyone and everyone worth the money. Price is good and so is the foodread more

Hoby's Hoagies & Pizza

3.5

(32 reviews)

I really enjoy the food from this place I love their pizza it's delicious their sub sandwiches are…read morereally good

Do NOT waste your money!! They have no idea how to deliver a full order or how to make a hoagie…read moreperiod. 1 cold and 1 hot half hoagie and a hot side isn't a hard order to deliver less than 5 minutes away (being lazy) Got delivered a cold hoagie and hot side. Called said it would be 45 mins to an hour to get the extra toasted hoagie they forgot to make supposedly. Less then 5 mins later the hoagie shows up and I open it up to a soggy nasty mess!! 1st time ever trying this place too. Called back yet again about the same hoagie just to let them know how bad they suck and we will NEVER order from them again! I don't care about my money a credit or anything they had to say I was so disgusted that y'all don't even know how to make a hoagie right not once, but twice. Do NOT waste your time or money on this place! They are not worth it!

D'Agostino's Pizza & Subs

4.4

(14 reviews)

They are a fantastic family! The food is always delicious and prices are reasonable! Definitely…read moregive them a try!

Great sandwiches, good pizza. Super nice people. It's a good old family run restaurant. They make…read moreyou feel welcomed. The prices are good.

Humpty Dumpty Creek Side

4.5

(17 reviews)

I've been going to Humpty Dumpty since I was a kid and although the decor has changed a lot (for…read morethe better) the food is still amazing. Having traveled the world in the Military for many years I can say that beyond a shadow of a doubt the "Grinder" sub sandwich at Humpty Dumpty is as good as it gets. A marvelous take on the classic American sub, oven toasted to a crisp perfection and served with a rushed, but heartfelt smile. As far as sub-shops go, this is my personal favorite and one that I would strongly recommend you try.

I have been going here for years, and this used to be one of my favorite spots. Unfortunately, the…read moreattitude and level of service I've experienced recently have really gone downhill. My last two interactions have made it unlikely that I'll be going back anytime soon. Example 1: I called at 7:23 p.m. and specifically asked how late they were open because a friend and I wanted to get cheesesteaks. I was told they were open until 8:00 p.m. We arrived at approximately 7:35 p.m., only to be told that the grill had already been turned off and they were no longer serving cheesesteaks. I noticed there was a sign stating that the grill closes at 7:30 p.m., but that information was not mentioned when I called. If I call ahead to ask how late you're open, it seems reasonable to mention that the grill closes well before the actual closing time. Otherwise, saying you're open until 8:00 is pretty misleading when a major portion of the menu is unavailable by 7:35. Example 2: A few days later, I came in with another friend to get food. After ordering, I sat in the chairs and waited. When I saw my food come out from the back to be finished and wrapped, I stood up and walked toward the counter to get ready to pick it up. I had been standing there for less than three seconds when I was abruptly yelled at for being too close to the counter. What made this especially frustrating was watching other customers approach the same counter, stand there, talk, and place orders for considerably longer without receiving the same treatment. Less than 30 seconds later, my food was ready, meaning I had to approach the counter again anyway. If there is a rule about where customers are allowed to stand, that's fine post a simple easy to read sign then just politely ask customers to wait in a particular area. There was absolutely no reason to yell at someone who had simply stood up to collect an order that was visibly being finished. I've supported this place for years, which is why these experiences are so disappointing. Good customer service require only a little clear communication and basic courtesy. Providing that minimal quality of service would have made both situations nonissues. Unfortunately, after being treated this way twice in such a short period of time, I don't have much desire to return anytime soon.

Tonino's Pizza

3.1

(40 reviews)

I'm working in town and stop from time to time for lunch. Great selection of individual slices, hot…read morehoney, meat, margarita, stuffed and more. Easy access and plenty of parking. Service is OK.

ordered the stuffed pizza, one of the meats were funky tasting and they didn't put in any…read morericoocheese. Called and was told they'd have a manager call me. Never happened. Very disappointed.

Original Italian Pizza

3.8

(40 reviews)

I live in NC, and for whatever reason none of the sub shops have bread like they do in PA, so it's…read morealways a real treat to stop in here and get one of their delicious Italian Subs! Sometimes I even get a couple sub rolls to go! Their pizza is really good too, highly recommend this place!

Family Owned for two generations, fresh baked bread for all subs. Have moved from the area but…read morealways enjoy stopping in for a meal when I'm in the area ... Great Eats !!

Long Island Pizza

4.1

(64 reviews)

disappointed. I've ordered from here before with great results. ordered the family pack, meatball…read moreparty pizza for delivery. ground beef taste like vegetarian meat. very bland. cheese was too thick. called restaurant to complain to manager, told they don't have a manager, but it was made the way they always make it. said she was sorry that we didn't like it. no offer to make it right.

I've been here a few times, the pizza is fabulous and the price is right ! I tried the sub for the…read morefirst time -it's so good ! Nice people own-work here , support local

Riverside Subs & Pizza

3.9

(19 reviews)

Must have for me every time I visit. Don't listen to the bad reviews because they obviously didn't…read morelike what they ordered. My family loves it and always will. The subs are definitely the thing to get though. Try the mountaineer!

The subs are alright but nothing special. It does have the worst pizza I have ever tasted. I…read moreordered extra sauce and made it clear. They didn't get it right. The pizza was dry and tasted terrible. Threw it away.. It used to be a really good place. Their food used to be very good. I guess that's what happens when you hire children who don't care and just slap the food together just for the paycheck. I've been a customer there for many years but after several disappointing meals I give up. Not going there again...

Santino's Italian Cuisine

3.6

(58 reviews)