I am born and raised in Wood Ridge and Mills Bakery has been a part of every sorrow and celebration in our lives. I recently ordered a birthday cake and I wanted It to be as dye free as possible. White writing, roses and only one layer of chocolate in the middle the other was buttercream. The bottom I asked for a ring of rainbow sprinkles. When I got the cake I was amazed at how pretty It was!!! You could easily read the writing and the taste was incredible. The cake was fresh and was absolutely delicious. I will always recommend Mills. They have never let us down. I highly recommended the dye free look. The photo doesn't do It justice. read more

Mills Bakery - Buttercream birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Wood Ridge, New Jersey

This place has heavy traffic due to lovely set up and many options. I was eyeing the strawberry cheesecake for a birthday coming up and the price was decent. It was good and loved how the middle had hidden strawberries (that was a nice surprise). Quick and friendly service. read more

Mills Bakery - Strawberry cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Wood Ridge, New Jersey

Ok so I order my birthday cake for my 1st day as a senior. It was a big celebration for me since I never celebrate my birthday just other ppls. First the cake was good everyone agreed BUT the BIG disappointment & shock was NO FLOWERS on the cake!!! How do you have a birthday cake & no cake flowers?? It was just plain white buttercream that said HAPPY BIRTHDAY nothing else. I didn't know that when ordering a birthday cake you need to specify that you want cake flowers on it. I've ordered plenty of cakes & never had a problem with that from other bakeries. This is the 2nd time I've ordered a cake from here & had a problem. Again it tasted good but something so simple made a difference. read more

This review is just for their service. Their bakery goods are decent and have shopped from there a couple of times. All the times I have been there no matter who I order from they never smile nor are they friendly. They behave as if they don't want your business so maybe I will support some other local business. No matter if you take a kid with you to shop but they never smile nor do they answer politely. read more

Holy crap, I went in with no expectations, went home and started laughing it was so good. The lady working at the store was very kind, and gave me phenominal recs. Every pastry i took a bite out of was chefs kiss. Will definitely be coming back! (Also the prices were really freaking good) read more

Mills Bakery - powdered sugar bread, finger cookies (AMAZING), chocolate cake, chocolate bomb?, and oreo cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Wood Ridge, New Jersey

Everything about Mills is epic- the products, the service , the cookies. I called and asked if they could make me a carrot cake for a birthday- decorated it in oink for the bday girl- delicious- 2 day pickup!! The danish- yum!! Reasonable prices!! Fabulous!! read more

The pastry chef at Mills Bakery is an artist! My family surprised me with a cake for my annual Harry Potter watch party. My favorite character is Hagrid and I love the scene where he surprises Harry with a cake for his birthday. Apparently, all they did was hand over a photo of the cake from the movie and the Mills team took it from there! It was PERFECT! I've been to the Harry Potter studio in London and the store in New York and neither had a cake that looked this authentic. The colors were spot on, the handwriting looked identical - they even worked in the lines/creases on the top! I've been getting my birthday cakes from Mills ever since I was a kid, but this was the best by far! Fresh and delicious cake, yummy fudge, and the buttercream wasn't crazy sweet, which I like. Thank you Mills team! You're amazing! read more

Mills Bakery - Special order, replica cake from the 'Harry Potter' movies. Look identical to the one in the films - and tasted delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Wood Ridge, New Jersey

See all

Mills has always been a solid bakery...I've been stopping there for almost 50 years, alright I don't go on a daily basis or even a monthly basis I go when I go... but to the staff can you just 1 time be pleasant / happy and smile or just fake it....Just 1 time ...please... read more

They were advertising apple cider donuts but were all out when we went in. The pumpkin donuts were still not bad, though, and for $2 each was ok for a cake donut. No line when we went in, but as we came out, people were waiting outside the door, and we were able to take our time. Big cookies, lots of cakes, turnovers, and other selections. Will have to try breads here another time! read more

See all

I need to give an official "Thank You!" to Yelp Elite Cassy B. - it was her initial review that let me know this place even existed. (And it's just a stone's throw from one of my absolute fave Italian delis, Luigi Meats, too.) This place is petite. 6 or 7 customers and it would feel like the subway during rush hour. But there's no wasted space and they've got a nice mix between rolls and pastries, from fresh bread crumbs to empty cannoli shells (stay far away from a place that has them filled just sitting there for hours or days!). The breads are delicious with that beautiful crunchy top-layer, the oversized treats (like the almond twists to the apple turnovers) are decadently delicious. Staff - always attentive and friendly. Pricing - solid. Street parking. (And the tip bucket is right next to the 'free sample' tray... mighty clever of you, Mills!) read more

I'm gonna update my review to 5 stars because it's so necessary. I've popped in a few times to grab bread and some quick desserts and everything has been so so delicious. Their long Italian rolls are absolutely delicious. I actually bought it one night when we were having a seafood boil and it was the perfect companion to dip in the delicious sauce. Super crusty outside and perfectly soft inside. Now, onto the tiramisu! Hands down, my favorite new dessert. They have little cups of this whipped delicious goodness all on top of a perfectly soaked in strong espresso lady finger. Truly such an explosion of flavors. I love it. My next birthday cake will be their tiramisu cake. Yum. I also recently tried the lemon bar - which is truly also life changing. It's thick and gooey and delicious. The complete opposite of a boring stale lemon bar you're thinking of. Their cookies are also delicious. They have small chocolate chip cookies and they're fantastic. The small Italian cookies with the chocolate buttercream frosting - omg! I can see why they had so many made on Friday because I'm sure they sell like crazy on the weekends. The chocolate buttercream is really really good. It's everything you want in a chocolatey treat. As always, everytime I went the women behind the counter were super nice and friendly. Definitely my new go-to bakery! read more

See all

I ordered a birthday cake from this bakery for my daughter's 14th birthday, I left them with multiple reference photos and a detailed descriptions of what the cake should look like. All she wanted was a simple white cake with a pink 14 and a few ribbons on the top, when I first went to the bakery they asked if I could put the ribbons on myself, Isaid yes to make things easier for them. when I went to pick up the cake today, not only did it look nothing like the photos, but the big "14" is not centered whatsoever. the cake looks like they didn't even try, there are air bubbles, marks, and even a hair on the cake. to say i'm disappointed is an extreme understatement. read more

See all

First thing's first, there will be a line. The bakery allows 2 people or a small party of 3 at a time. So depending when you go the wait time can vary. Now on to the goodies. We came in for a cake so we ordered the regular size fruit tart with cream. But then saw more and more biscuits! We ordered mini sweets: two fruit tarts, a lemon bar and a key lime pie. A customer recommended to get the donuts from there and dang, I couldn't help myself and got them anyway. The miss assisting us was helpful, patient and kind!! Next time we'll get the upside down pineapple cake. I loved the pastires here because it wasn't overly sweet or pure sugar like other places. I wouldn't get the key lime pie again though. There is a good amount of metered parking in the area. Enjoy! read more

See all

5 magic words posted in their window did the trick. "Apple Cider Donuts Are Back."Established in 1929, this small bakery was mentioned in past conversations with friends. Mills Bakery offers breakfast pastries, cupcakes, cookies, donuts, breads, custom cakes and more off of Valley Blvd in Wood-Ridge. Rumor has it that their donuts sell fast. One has to get there early in the day during the week or not much is left. Luck was on my side today as one other customer and I had the whole place to ourselves. So I managed to get 1/2 dozen of apple cider doughnuts loaded with cinnamon sugar at $2 each. It was fresh, delicious, moist and didn't disappoint. Please don't miss out on this wonderful local bakery that has been here for over 90+ years which I could recommend. read more

See all

Excellent one of the few real bakeries left and they do it right. They always have been very consistent.

Mills Bakery made the most beautiful and delicious 1/2 sheet cake which they delivered to my daughter's baby shower. My guests commented how moist, , fluffy & delicious the cake was. I have never been disappointed with anything I have purchased at Mills Bakery. It was definitely a hit! Thank you Mills Bakery!! read more

Mills Bakery - My daughter's baby shower cake from Mills Bakery. Beautiful & Delicious!! - Bakeries Near Me - Wood Ridge, New Jersey

excellent bakery got elephant ears, coffee cake, strawberry cake slice and cheesecake. the elephant ears wasnt that good but the rest were yummy. cant wait to try other things! read more

Yummy, came in here one day just wanting a couple specifics.. left with a whole lot more than I intended. All very good and fresh. Cute little spot and staff was friendly and knowledgeable of the goods they were serving. read more

Your local neighborhood bakery. They know most of their customers by name (that's how often they come back for their baked goods, coz it's that good and the staff are super friendly). You walk in and you can't figure out what to try first. Everything smells and looks so delicious. Try the Strawberry Shortcake, Tiramisu and Eclairs. Heaven. read more

A BIG THANK YOU TO MILLS AND MY FRIEND MIKE!! Ok I lived in Nj for 19 yrs, if my dad didn't , I did when I turned 17 and started driving go to Mills in Woodrige to get fresh crumb cake and variety of buns some times cookies too. I recently got with the staff At mills , thanks Bella, to pack up some crumbs buns and donuts and other buns and my ole high school friend Mike picked them up and shipped them to Florida. Oh man one bite of a crumb bun then jelly donut bam back in NJ as a teenager. They were awesome better than remembered please everyone go to Mills over 40 yrs still same great stuff. If you do, don't eat all my crumb cake n save me a crumb ring I'll be up at some point. We need a Mills south down here in Florida and I'm serious about that . I'll staff it n run eat even bake some stuff I just not good at decorating. Mills owners if you want to expand next time I get buns sent down we can talk No 100% serious... thank you all again .... Be blessed read more

Found this bakery through a friend and it's been my go to since! They have a super nice staff and a good selection of fresh cakes, cupcakes, cookies, etc. If you're not sure what to get try out the strawberry shortcake, can't go wrong with it. read more

Mills Bakery - a cake with strawberries and cream frosting - Bakeries Near Me - Wood Ridge, New Jersey

Friendly staff!! Went out of their way to help make sure I was able to bring the cake safely to its destination given that I was going to take a 12" on subway and a bus. They were super sweet and helpful and patient while I decided what I wanted to order!! Would definitely recommend this cute bakery to everyone! Cake was delicious and fresh!!! Not a crazy price for custom cake!! read more

Love their Philly fluff cakes! Buttery and moist. The staff that work there are very friendly also. There's usually 1 or 2 people working in the front so you might be waiting a while if there's a couple people ahead of you. read more

Good bakery in town, always fresh and always delicious. So many options from cookies to cupcakes to pies! Staff is helpful and friendly. Always buy more than i intend to! read more

This spot was very good and affordable. The tiramisu was incredible, highly recommend trying the single serving!

I had a horrible morning dealing with the dregs of bureaucratic society but this little bakery saved my afternoon. What a wonderful smell. The service was polite and bubbly and the baked goods are excellent. I'll be returning for more. This time around I grabbed an apple strudel, a pound loaf, and loaves of Italian bread stuffed with garlic. read more

We stopped in on our way back to NH. Grew up in NJ and wanted crumb buns. We also go some cookies. They did not disappoint! Customer service was great read more

I love this bakery. The cookies they sell are my favorite. The pricing however is a little expensive. Especially for just a pound of cookies. I wish they were a little cheaper but I still love those things. read more

Ordered for Christmas Day - picked up Christmas Eve. Pastries were ready to go! Workers were super nice. Loved the pastries and so did the company I was having. Love ordering from mills! Btw - the lace cookies are amazing! read more

I had heard good things about this bakery. Decided to try it myself. I purchased a crumb bun. Very, very, good. Almost as good as B&W Bakery in Hackensack. Bought a Linzer Tart. Nope. Very artificial tasting and a total disappointment. Tried their cheese puff. Decent amount of cheese and tasty. Overall, what I tried was good. However, I'm not sure this bakery lives up to the hype. I was expecting more. read more

I LOVE the Seven Layer Cake!!!!!! Get it! EAT it!!! Thank me!!!! As a NYC visitor I'll get this while visiting family. Bring one home and finish it in a couple sittings (those are large portions). The bakery is open now during Covid and practices safety measures for Covid. Love it here. read more

I absolutely love this bakery! Everything I've had is fresh and flavorful. They have a great selection to choose from and it's all baked to perfection! I first loved their donuts, but soon ventured into their danishes (pecan) and cakes (lemon and the strawberry shortcake) . If my waistline could sustain it, I'd be here everyday. But alas, I have to exercise some measure of control. Needless to say, I'm eagerly awaiting my next visit. read more

My wife's family has been going here for generations, just moved in the area. Place is as good as it gets. Old school NY/NJ bakery

Of course I came here right after I just had a filling breakfast over at Lucky Larry's...honestly who puts these two stores right next to each other?! I heard about this place from a friend of mine who swore by their doughnuts. As a sucker for doughnuts, I knew I had to stop by, and I am so glad I did. The two special doughnuts for the day was the cannoli doughnut and Reese's doughnut. Unfortunately for me, Reese's was already sold out, but I think that's a sign that I didn't need both at once. Cannoli doughnut was to dieeee for. I legitimately gobbled it in under 2 minutes. It was PACKED with cannoli cream inside, barely leaving any space for actual dough. Topped with cannoli shells, more cannoli cream, and a drizzle of chocolate, it's safe to say that I went into a food coma very shortly after. I'll need to come back to try their other baked goods! read more

Mills Bakery - Cannoli doughnut - Bakeries Near Me - Wood Ridge, New Jersey

Cakes were not moist at all. Not sure why all the deceiving reviews. I bought two cakes and neither one delivered.

We have been going to Mill's for as long as I can recall and we are never disappointed. Though this was the convenient and local bakery to my childhood home, I still find myself driving over 30 miles to get pastries, especially for special occasions. John is a phenomenal baker and runs a tight ship. Make sure you try the doughnuts; they're the best around. Thanks for making fantastic cookies for our engagement party! read more

very disappointed with the pastry which was preordered. When picked up all the cream pastry was on top of each other, very messy and not worth the money...didn't even get a bag to carry the box.. read more

Unassuming bakery shop located on Valley Blvd. I stop here on occasion for donuts, when I'm in the mood for bakery donuts, rather than Dunkin Donuts. I've tried the glazed and jelly donuts here. They have both granulated sugar and powdered sugar jelly donuts. I like the granulated sugar jelly donuts the best. I've also tried some of the other items they have here, like the fruit pockets and some of the cookies. But the granulated sugar jelly donuts are what keeps me coming back. In the morning, the granulated sugar jelly donuts are super fresh and soft. But even during the day, although the donuts aren't as fresh and chewy, they still taste great. It's almost like a different donut, if you compare how it tastes, if you buy it in the morning and if buy it during the day. Both are pretty good. read more

Mills Bakery - Blueberry pocket - Bakeries Near Me - Wood Ridge, New Jersey

Placed my first custom cake order- Hands down the BEST we have ever gotten! Order yellow cake/ chocolate mousse fill/fresh whip cream. Fantastic!!! read more

I can't believe I haven't reviewed this place yet. Very friendly and accommodating, great variety, good to great prices, an most of all, absolutely delicious. I have yet to try anything here that struck me as anything less than great. The presentation is very good. Let me put it this way though: take nothing away from Mills, but I do know bakeries that will do a fancier job VISUALLY. When it comes to actual taste though, this place stands out. Highly recommended! read more