Go Order from here for beautiful custom event cookies! I had tried to order here a few times having seen how gorgeous Mimi's custom cookies were and finally was able to align the stars and got a dozen for $78. (In August 21, 2021 I didn't provide sufficient notice for a 9/5/21 party and on 9/20/23 I was trying to get an order for the following Saturday but someone called out sick so they were unable to fulfill the order). I guess the third time is a charm, because on 9/22/23 i ordered and paid so I was finally was able to pick up a dozen up the morning of 10/28/23 and they came out cute! (They open at 10am Saturdays). I had asked for champagne bottles and didn't specify a color and normally wouldn't have picked pink but they worked out great. See the pics attached. The storefront is actually super cute and they have many beautiful cookies for purchase inside...I was going to get more but they were mostly $7+ each and I didn't want to break the bank as they are only good for 2 weeks so if I had extra I was afraid they would get wasted and there wasn't any in the store that would really fit my tailgate theme. The place is located in the grey concrete building (located on the corner of Harrison) and connected in the same building as the chicken wings place. Got a parking spot right in front by the apartments and was able to run inside quickly. They have a cute little casual outdoor patio set right in front which would be great for a cookie/coffee/tea date! The reason for taking off a star is because of the price as it was a little higher then I was expecting and I was expecting some sparkly bubbles around the champs like I saw these the first time...which had more of a white/gold/silver color scheme. I can only imagine the costs to have a storefront and employees so totally understandable about the pricing. I don't eat sweets but tried the cookie and it was ok but don't go by me, there are not many cookies I actually like to eat. Hope you find this review helpful! read more

See all

Awesome, awesome, awesome! We reached out to Mimi's cookies extremely last minute to get a small order of custom cookies turned around same-day. They were an absolute delight to work with and delivered beautiful cookies by end of the day with our client's logo it. Exceptional service. Beautiful and delicious cookies. Highest of praises...and they delivered!!! Couldn't have asked for a better experience. read more

i ordered custom cookies for my son's baptism as party favors. the cookies came out beautiful and were very tasty. i got a lot of comments as to how nice they looked. they came out exactly as i had requested. note that the cookies are pretty big and run about $6 each. definitely would recommend to anyone looking to order for an event. read more

Mimi's Cookies - a box of decorated cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

I ordered cookies for my husband's 60th birthday party. Not only were they beautifully decorated, they were delicious! I also provided them with what I wanted them served on and they accommodated me and arranged them so they could be displayed the way I wished. Highly recommend Mimi's cookies, the owner and employees are extremely pleasant. I love supporting our local small businesses read more

Mimi's Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Wow. If I could give this place less than one star, I would. I walk in to find that instead of the 12 cookies I ordered, there were 24 cookies made. A very nice associate explained the mistake and offered either the 12 or 24 cookie option. When I asked if the owner would work with me on pricing to take the 24 cookies, she refused. Additionally, it should be noted that these were miniature cookies, only about 2.5" and I was charged $4.00 PER cookie. This was the biggest RIP OFF I've ever experienced!! The owner was RUDE, unaccommodating and unapologetic to boot! Not only will she never earn my business again, but I will let everyone know not to support her small business! Next time Michele, work with your patrons! read more

I ordered 50 custom cookies for a baby shower(half hearts and half butterflies) and they not only looked amazing (and exactly like the inspo pictures i provided) but also tasted great!! Highly recommend for any custom cookie needs!! read more

Great service and wonderful cookies! Ordered a batch of cookies for my boyfriend's med school graduation rather last minute but they were very accommodating and helped me create a set of cookies for my budget! I placed my order over the phone and picked up a few days later. It was seamless! Their website has a bunch of examples that aren't on this yelp page (https://www.mimiscookiesonline.com/graduationcookiesnj). These cookies are a perfect addition to a gift or a fun treat a party. I've kept in mind for other events. I hope to see them add more classes - the ladies night events are a tad expensive and only offered Monday nights :/ Would love to gather my girlfriends for cookie decorating and brunch class if you guys can offer that!! Great potential for to grow. read more

Everyone loved the birthday cookies, we asked for White Castle ones since my husband has an obsession with the place- and they were a hit! They did such a great job and the cookies were delicious!!! read more

Mimi's Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Mimi's cookies was amazing!! I ordered cookies online for my husband's 70th Birthday. I sent two pictures of him and she made they perfect and they tasted delicious! I emailed her to confirm they were ready and she responded right away. I will use her again in the future. Thank you so much! Liz read more

I ordered cookies for my sister's bridal shower from Mimi's Cookies. They came out beautiful!! We ordered 2 different designs and everyone complimented us on how beautiful cookies were with her boho-themed bridal shower at a Mediterranean restaurant. Mimi and her team did a great job and we appreciated all their hard work!! My sister, the bride, was very pleased and so were we!! I've also ordered cookies for my son's Communion this past year and they came out beautiful too and cookies taste great as well!! Thanks so much Mimi to helping make our family parties so special!! I tried to post pictures of all the cookies, but it didn't upload, but I was able to post pictures if you scroll above to pictures. read more

See all

After hearing such wonderful things about Mimi's Cookies, I am so disappointed to say that I had the most awful experience. I reached out a month in advance to order 18 very simple cookies, 6 each of 3 different designs, 2 of which were personalized. Communication from the start was horrible, waiting days on end for email responses which were curt and did not answer many of my questions. After no communication for 2 weeks, I called the day before the event to ask about pick up where it seemed like Michele had 0 clue what I was talking about and quickly said "They will be ready in the morning". Imagine my surprise when I went to pick up and the 2 personalized designs were generic cookies that I was made to spend $5 a piece on. Nearly 100$ spent on 18 plain, boring cookies!!!! When asked what happened, the responses were, "Well no one is here to fix them" , "That is not what I have written in my notes" and "What you asked for was not possible to do". How is it possible that the owner of the store is incapable of decorating the cookies herself? And what type of business person does not reach out to the customer when something is not able to be done (after assuring me multiple times that they could do it) and instead does what is most convenient for them? I would have gladly asked for a different design if given the opportunity rather than being surprised upon pick up just before the event started. After many complaints, I got a measly 20$ back. Next time I will gladly support another business that actually cares about its customers. read more

I would give Mimi's Cookies LESS than 1 star if it were an option! I gave very specific instructions for cookies I ordered for my daughter's baby shower, telling Mimi IN WRITING that the theme was "Oh Baby." However, she didn't pay enough attention to my email and followed a picture I sent her as a sample instead, which said "Oh Boy." On Tuesday at 9am (prior to the shower which was scheduled for the following Saturday) I noticed that she had invoiced me for "Oh Boy" cookies, and naturally she requires payment up front. When I called to inquire regarding the theme, I was told that they had "probably" already started personalizing them, but she would check and get back to me. At 5:30 that same day, I had to follow up again to ask and she informed me that they were nearly done. When I forwarded my original email, I was RUDELY informed that the invoice stated the "Oh Boy" theme and that this was what the sample picture included. Then on top of everything, she sent me a picture of the cookies she had made; out of the picture/options I had shown her, there were 3 different samples - an adorable striped onesie, a rattle and a rectangle with a scalloped edge. So for $6 a cookie, she selected the easiest one to make - the rectangle with the scalloped edge!!! And let me tell you, they were AWFUL; who makes cookies 5 days before an event? They tasted like cardboard! When I picked them up, she just handed me the box and said, "Oh I'm sure no one will even notice." Not one word of apology for the mix up or an offer to compensate me for anything. I just took the box and walked away... the most horrible customer service I have ever encountered!!! Thank GOD for Lotito's Deli & Bakery in Ramsey; for $3 a cookie, Estella made the most adorable and delicious cookies that looked like a baby onesie with this wonderful icing and piping... they saved the day! My advice: don't EVER use Mimi's Cookies unless you want to deal with someone who clearly doesn't care about her customers! read more

Mimi's Cookies - Mimi's incredibly uncreative cookie that tasted like cardboard because she made them 5 days before the event! - Bakeries Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

See all

I ordered 10 cookies, 2 dozen strawberries and a "smash size cake" for an engagement party I was having for a family member. I believe the strawberries and cake were through a third party vendor but I paid and picked everything up from MiMi's cookies. Cookies-absolutely beautiful! Exactly what I was looking for and she was creative with the design. Infused Strawberries-very small, small amount of liquor, and not at all the color I asked for. I asked for pink, gold and cream colors with engagement decorations but instead I received cream with gold. Cake-I asked for a yellow cake with chocolate icing then a thick layer of flowers all around the cake. On the outside the cake looked to be what I asked for but the inside was not at all what i asked for. It was white cake with white icing. Unfortunately I will not be doing business with MiMi's cookies again unless I'm only ordering cookies. read more

Ordered cookies for my best friends engagement! Gave mimi only a couple days notice and only gave a little direction for what I wanted. I was blown away by the decoration and detail as well as the taste!!! Will definitely be using Mimi's cookies for future events. Thank you so much again!! You will not be disappointed with Mimi's! read more

Mimi's Cookies - Engagement cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Poor customer service, rude, they do what they want not what you ordered and when you tell them to change your order to what you told them originally they get mad and tell you you are wrong! read more

Mimi's Cookies are the absolute best ! I order cookies from here at least once a month and they always exceed my expectations. The owner is kind and professional and I would recommend her to anybody. People don't realize how time consuming and difficult these cookies are to make and I'm so grateful to know I will get perfect cookies every single time when I order from here. read more

I had a horrible experience with Mimi's Cookies. I changed my order with a full week's notice and I was still charged a portion of the cost because the cookies were "already made" but not decorated. (This is questionable to begin with because why are cookies being baked 7 days in advance?!) But I agreed to the fee since I was changing my order. Then when I went go pick up my order, I was expecting the to receive both the decorated cookies and the undecorated cookies since I did in fact pay for them. Much to my surprise, I was told that they keep the undecorated cookies to resell - I do not get to take them home. So I paid for them and then they turn around and make money on them!! How disgusting. This is a complete turn off - I feel like I was robbed. Not to mention that the cookies were baked a full week before pickup. So they're obviously not fresh. All around horrible business practices. read more

I ordered 4 dozen cookies from Mimi's for my son's rehearsal dinner. I was very clear with what I wanted, when I wanted them (in 4 days)through a phone call and follow up texts. Firstly when I called to see what time they would be ready the following day, the owner said in "two days", I said "no tomorrow", the owner then said "oh yes tomorrow, pick them up at noon". The following day, I called at 11 to make sure the would be ready and again the owner says " tomorrow" and I said " no today" the owner then says "ok pick up at 3:00". When I went to pick them up, they were not what I asked for and the owner went on to berate me in front of a store full of people for about 10 minutes before finally giving me the order, for which I paid almost $150 while still being berated. The next day the owner decided it would be prudent to text me a long dissertation on why I was wrong and berates me again. The cookie were delicious but the service was horrible. If you want to leave a business, after paying a good deal of money for a product, feeling like you just got scolded by your mother then go here otherwise find another cookie maker. Wasn't worth the mood downer on what should have been a very happy day. read more

Delicious custom cookies. When the baker for my sons wedding told us she could not make 175 cookies 2 weeks before the wedding MiMis cookies delivered. The cookies were beautiful and delicious. I recommend them for all your cookie needs. read more

Mimis cookies in Waldwick is not closed its open and has amazing cookie favors for all occasions. Very creative and very beautiful creations. Check out the design s at Mimiscookiesonline. read more

The Best cookies and designs. The cookies are delicious, elegant and creative.