The staff are all very nice and willing to help. Always knows the answer to my questions.read more

Kate is wonderful! Her chocolates are amazing! She is…read morealways cheerful, happy to help and always supports the community whenever I ask her for a chocolate basket for an event! Thank you so much!

THE GOOD ----------------…read more+ Lots of variety and delicious homemade chocolates to choose from behind the counter - too many to mention - but there's a hugeeeeee assortment of milk, white and dark chocolates. + Approximately $27/lb (as of February 2026) depending on the size of assorted chocolates box you want to purchase. 1lb is about 30+ pieces of chocolate, which is PLENTY to enjoy!! + There are plenty of prepackaged chocolate boxes/packs to choose from too. + Chocolate sampling seems to be allowed here, if you choose to do so. + Private parking lot to the side, which is greatly appreciated in this busy area of River Edge. THE NOT SO GOOD ---------------------------- - Nada. MIXED THOUGHTS --------------------------- = Nada. RANDOM OBSERVATIONS -------------------------------------- = Was preeeetttty busy the day before Valentine's Day 2026. Parking lot was packed, but there were still plenty of chocolates to add to a box from behind the counter. Prepackaged items were running low though.

I've shopped at Critchley's several times since moving to Oradell and have always loved supporting…read morewhat I believed was a local, homemade chocolate shop. That's why I recently spent nearly $70 on chocolate roses to give as gifts. When I got home, I realized they were actually made by Madelaine Chocolate Company -- a brand sold on Amazon -- not made in-house. Even more disappointing, a Critchley's sticker had been placed over the original branding, which made it appear they were their own product. After tasting one, it definitely didn't resemble the quality of their homemade chocolate. It tasted like a mass-produced bar. Had I known they weren't made by Critchley's, I would not have purchased them -- especially in that quantity. Transparency matters, especially when customers are intentionally choosing to support local. Gave two stars because the chocolates that they DO make are good. Really disappointing experience. Hoping they address this.

Always great supply of the best tasting chocolate - non stress related but not handicap accessible…read morefamily owned business passed down from generation to generation. I only get my candy from here for every holiday or occasion

My husband (Lodi, NJ native) grew up eating Genevieve's chocolates for 50+years... this "talented"…read morefamily-owned, third-generation CHOCOLATIERS have created so many childhood memories & traditions by mastering their OWN handmade AUTHENTIC style chocolates ... what more can we say, THESE chocolates are made with LOVE ... THANK YOU~ THANK YOU~ THANK YOU~!!!

I have stopped in this place and left without buying anything usually; i always expect to find…read moreunique, local and delicious products but leave a bit disappointed. Of the chocolates I have tried, I haven't been super impressed but haven't had a whole lot either. The few chocolates I have purchased haven't tasted super fresh. They have a collection of various chocolates and cookies, candies and related gifts. It reminds me of the Rocky Mountain Chocolates chain. No issues with service. Since this is a local business, hoping that it can stay afloat... some people do some seem to enjoy their products!

Best dark chocolate covered pretzels I've ever had! The pretzel is crisp not stale and the dark…read morechocolate is not too sweet!

They sell the Dubai chocolate and so many other chocolates. They have chocolate designs perfect for…read moreparties and gifts. So many themed chocolate gifts, absolutely perfect. I was very impressed with the selection! The owner is so sweet, I was able to place a special order for the Dubai chocolates. I purchased some to take home and we had them last night, the chocolates were absolutely delicious! The chocolate covered Oreos and pretzels were so fresh. The shop itself is so beautiful and organized with the layout making things easy to find. Everything was fresh. Very happy to have this shop open up in the neighborhood. Chocolates are my go to gift - simple, inexpensive, gorgeous and who doesn't like chocolates? Love it.

Lovely chocolate shop that makes specialty trays for gifts. I stopped in here before Christmas to…read moreget a tray to bring to a party, and they had a lovely assortment. One of my staff members bought a bunch of small trays to give as gifts to the members of his department, and everyone raved about the chocolate. They have a really nice selection for Valentine's Day so I ordered something for my daughter. The chocolate covered pretzels are a delicious treat. This is a really nice business with great people who go out of their way to help customers. You can't go wrong getting a treat here.

I just received the most delicious chocolates for Valentine's Day. These wonderful individually…read morewrapped little roses are so tasty & this solid heart looks really beautiful. I hope everyone gets to try these treats

i picked up a toogoodtogo order today and received expired items. when i returned to ask about it…read morethe person says yes thats what you get with this type of order. im shocked

I was looking for a very specific Fossier biscuit but couldn't find them in stock anywhere. The…read moreGourmet Palace helped me stock on them and I'm throughly impressed with the customer service I received. Incredibly nice people.

This is such a beautiful store, bright, colorful, gorgeous designs all around. They have an amazing…read morecollection of chocolate and ice cream flavors. The boxes and packs are also perfect for gifts. I have been to this store couple of times. Loved some of the chocolate flavors they had. The staff members were friendly each time. In also got 10% discount for signing up with their rewards program. But overall the products are little bit pricey.

Venchi is so good. I've gotten from the one in Manhattan and this one is just as good. It's located…read morein the Garden State Plaza mall, had some seating and is super clean. The employee who assisted us was very friendly, excellent at her job and even while we sat to eat our delicious gelato, I watched her come out from behind the counter and straighten up the shop. She tidied and arranged the chocolate bars, fixed anything that was crooked and really showed that she cares about her shop. The gelato she prepared for us was so good - dark chocolate, hazelnut, pistachio. We tasted a few others, but combined those 3 into a large cup. They sell other confections here, coffee and have many varieties of medium chocolate bars. Ugh. This place is so delicious.