Meyer's House of Sweets is located in a Wyckoff strip mall and has been around since the birth of…read moreaviation (1904). From what I saw, if you can't find your sweet desire here, you don't need it. They also take pride in making their chocolate on premises. During this visit, I purchased raspberry and rum cream chocolates. Every chocolate was heavenly and I should have purchased fifty more. The staff maintains the store very clean, wear plastic gloves when selecting your choices, and the prices are reasonable. Don't hesitate to visit Meyer's and I'll hedge, that you won't leave the store without a sweet purchase.

I accidentally found this spot while dropping off packages to UPS. I thought why not go in and…read morecheck it out. They have so many options once you walk into the store you smell chocolate everywhere. It's like chocolate overload absolutely smells delicious. They have chocolate pretzels and chocolate bars chocolate shaped, so many different ways the pictures don't do it justice. The staff extremely friendly helpful, answered all the questions that I had. It's a great place to get gifts for all kind of occasions the birth of a new baby a new job. They also have other types of candy like jellybeans, large assortment of those they have gummy's. They even have popcorn, which I think you see in of my pictures just lots of choices and options. I got chocolate clusters andchocolate covered toffee absolutely delicious and I would definitely be going back.

THE GOOD ----------------…read more+ Lots of variety and delicious homemade chocolates to choose from behind the counter - too many to mention - but there's a hugeeeeee assortment of milk, white and dark chocolates. + Approximately $27/lb (as of February 2026) depending on the size of assorted chocolates box you want to purchase. 1lb is about 30+ pieces of chocolate, which is PLENTY to enjoy!! + There are plenty of prepackaged chocolate boxes/packs to choose from too. + Chocolate sampling seems to be allowed here, if you choose to do so. + Private parking lot to the side, which is greatly appreciated in this busy area of River Edge. THE NOT SO GOOD ---------------------------- - Nada. MIXED THOUGHTS --------------------------- = Nada. RANDOM OBSERVATIONS -------------------------------------- = Was preeeetttty busy the day before Valentine's Day 2026. Parking lot was packed, but there were still plenty of chocolates to add to a box from behind the counter. Prepackaged items were running low though.

I've shopped at Critchley's several times since moving to Oradell and have always loved supporting…read morewhat I believed was a local, homemade chocolate shop. That's why I recently spent nearly $70 on chocolate roses to give as gifts. When I got home, I realized they were actually made by Madelaine Chocolate Company -- a brand sold on Amazon -- not made in-house. Even more disappointing, a Critchley's sticker had been placed over the original branding, which made it appear they were their own product. After tasting one, it definitely didn't resemble the quality of their homemade chocolate. It tasted like a mass-produced bar. Had I known they weren't made by Critchley's, I would not have purchased them -- especially in that quantity. Transparency matters, especially when customers are intentionally choosing to support local. Gave two stars because the chocolates that they DO make are good. Really disappointing experience. Hoping they address this.

Great hidden gem of a chocolate shop. Prices are good. More importantly the chocolate was…read morefantastic. The chocolate covered strawberries were my favorite as well. The staff is very friendly

I'm beyond happy with the Chocolate Box's services and I strongly encourage everyone to buy froM…read morethem! I called from California asking if they can send my sister an arrangement for her birthday in New Jersey. Mary answered my call and was so helpful. She went back and forth with the calls to ensure my order was placed properly. My sister received her surprise and even mentioned how nice the person who delivered was. They are so great to work with and fulfilled my request seamlessly. Thank you so much!

The staff are all very nice and willing to help. Always knows the answer to my questions.read more

Kate is wonderful! Her chocolates are amazing! She is…read morealways cheerful, happy to help and always supports the community whenever I ask her for a chocolate basket for an event! Thank you so much!

First time trying out this sweet chocolate shop. It's small once you go inside but it's filled…read morewith a great variety of chocolates. Lady at the counter was very nice. We bought a box of chocolate milk cashew turtles and wow they were amazing. The box was gone in two days- they were so delicious. The turtles were made to perfection. It was the perfect combination of chewy , sweet, nuts and caramel! The chocolate turtle boxes already came prepackaged. At the counter there were other chocolate fruit options available. I can't wait to try out their chocolate covered strawberries.

amazing chocolate selection it tastes so good me want chocolate its a world of chocolate the…read moreservice is great

My husband (Lodi, NJ native) grew up eating Genevieve's chocolates for 50+years... this "talented"…read morefamily-owned, third-generation CHOCOLATIERS have created so many childhood memories & traditions by mastering their OWN handmade AUTHENTIC style chocolates ... what more can we say, THESE chocolates are made with LOVE ... THANK YOU~ THANK YOU~ THANK YOU~!!!

This is a family favorite dating back many decades. They have managed to stay consistent over all…read morethose years and we are never disappointed. The quality remains high, the service is good and they continue to be one of my favorite chocolate shops.

Candy shop in the Garden State Plaza - they have a store and also a little kiosk in the middle of…read moreone of the lower walkways. Lots of gummy and sour candy flavors, and some interesting items like an edible flower. Candy you can pick by the pound, easy to get mixed up and seeing people with tongs across candy types worries me as a parent with a child with allergies.