Molokai Pizza Café is the kind of spot hungry travelers dream about and hungry mainlanders book return flights for. The pizza? Exceptional--hands down the best I've had in many moons. And the service? Phenomenal, with a smile that makes you feel instantly at home. These gals went above and beyond for me and my coworkers, turning a simple meal into a standout memory. If your stomach is rumbling and your standards are high, this is your spot. Highly recommended. Jordan read more

See all

Had the best ribs!!! I know, feels weird for ribs at a pizza place. We were the only people who ordered ribs. Everyone else coming in ordered pizza and chicken wings. But I was craving for ribs! Our server Jayman was very convincing. He said it was his favorite too! Did not disappoint! Rumor has it that there's limited places to eat here on Moloka'i. So far, so good!!! Will come back here to try the pizza maybe tomorrow.... Oh, you get a 10% discount if you have AARP membership!!! read more

See all

A long-time family place to hang out and chow down in Molokai. Bigger than it looks outside. Lots of both take-out and dine-in. There are some old-timey arcade machines by the counter and a change machine. Parking is in the lot in front or just off the road. The menu includes breakfast, pizza, burgers, pasta, and desserts (mostly ice cream). I had the mushroom burger and fries. Everything was pretty good and the staff are nice. It should continue to be a cornerstone of Molokai. read more

See all

I wasn't sure to expect when I wandered over to this place. There really aren't that many options on Molokai and definitely not many that are open late. I was quite surprised at how tasty the food was! This was a very good pizza. I did a build my own because I like strange things on my pizza like pineapple and garlic rather than some of the pre-existing options. I was pleased. Excellent minced garlic mixed in, loads of cheese and of course tasty pineapple. There was a bit of sweetness to the sauce and the crust was a tiny bit thicker than I would have liked, but still done to perfection. The wait staff was great and very attentive. The small sized pizza was pretty good size and could have easily been shared. As far as the place itself goes it's right next to the only other open late place in the town. Everything here is very laid back and great for relaxing. If you're hunting for a pizza you don't have to make yourself, definitely give it a try you won't be disappointed! read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Build your own pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

The pepperoni pizza braids were so soft and garlic buttery I kept eating them! We had a Big Island pizza which is equivalent to a supreme pizza with everything on it. The dough was light and not greasy and the cheese just made everything taste so good! service was impeccable and our waitstaff was attentive and kind and looks like he enjoys his work. The cafe is rather large and accomodating for a party of 5-30. I'm going back again to try the chicken alfredo! Mahalo MOLOKAI. read more

Great pizza parlor that offers more than just pizza. Went with the Big Island pizza, cheesy bread with garlic butter sauce. There are generous amounts of toppings for whatever size of pie you choose; S, M, L, or XL. The crust and cheesy bread were cooked perfectly, crispy and chewy. They offer buckets of chicken either 24 or 48 pieces to feed an entire extended family. The service is extremely friendly, wait time is very reasonable, and it is one of the few places open on Sundays. read more

Solid pizza options on the island! Ordered a large pepperoni and pineapple and hot wings. Both items were good and pro tip order ahead to save some time. The island is small with only one pizza place, the crust could be a little more authentic but overall tasty. The restaurant does have other dinner options and Wednesday night is Mexican themed food read more

See all

Molokai Pizza defies the odds of staying alive after all these years. Located at the end of the Kaunakakai Wharf and the main crossroad, right next to Moloka'i Burger, it offers plenty of parking. The menu is inexpensive, simple, concise and matches what residents need: hand-fabricated pizzas, basic salads, entrees, sandwiches, burgers, a "canned" fountain of soft drinks, and daily specials. The overall ambiance is very clean, hung with decorative Hawaiian themed pictures and artifacts, with both sit down full service, and a take out counter for pick ups. It fills up quickly after 6pm with groups of families and deuces. Service is friendly, quick and polite. Between the two of us we ordered a large simple salad and medium "Molokai" pizza. The basic salad included roughly chopped iceberg lettuce with a smattering of thin-cut halved tomato slices, fat pieces of cucumber, and thick sliced onion pieces. The dressing we selected was individual packs of Kraft Ranch. Being some of the first customers on a Saturday night the freshly made pepperoni and cheese pizza came out fast, piping hot and very attractive delivered on a stand. The medium sized pizza hit the spot and was more than enough for two with breakfast leftovers. If you are seeking simple, quick, tasty and healthier food options this is a place to consider. Yes, sometimes menu items run out, but due to limited barge deliveries, inclement weather, and lack of consistent staffing, it is fortunate that the few remaining Molokai restaurants survive and flourish. read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Med Molokai Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

See all

We're from Chicago and absolutely loved this pizza. Order the thick crust -- it was fabulous. We're already planning to go back one more time before we leave the island! read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe offers a delightful dining experience with a range of mouthwatering pizzas that capture the essence of island-inspired flavors. Nestled in a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere, the cafe prides itself on fresh ingredients and a creative twist on classic pies. The crust is perfectly thick yet satisfying, with a slight crispness that provides a great foundation for the toppings. Their pizza, topped with pepperoni, bacon and mushroom is a standout--perfectly balanced. Overall, Molokai Pizza Cafe impresses with its attention to detail, quality ingredients, and ability to create pizzas that are both satisfying and unique. Whether you're a local or just visiting, this cafe is a must-try for pizza lovers who appreciate a bit of island flair. Their customer service is very friendly and makes you feel welcoming. read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

See all

My pizza was good. Service was okay. The menu has a nice variety of choices. Ambience was comfortable.

Come hungry, but be prepared to relax and not be in a hurry, remember, this is Molokai (which is great)! The pizza was delicious, with a sauce that was a bit sweet, not greasy and cooked just right. Our waitress really hustled to take care of everyone and was really pleasant as she worked hard to serve us all. A real treasure of a location! read more

See all

Super friendly service for us visitors to the island. Our pizza was delicious and we were happy we could get a side of fresh brocolli to go with! Thanks for a great welcome to the island! read more

We always stop here when we come to town Yumm. It's open later most other places here. read more

Pizza was fine. The crust was a little soft. If I order SHEIN I will ask for a crispier crust. read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Half ham and pineapple and half big island - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

Solid pizza on Moloka'i! Comes out piping hot, and has a family-friendly atmosphere. My main regret is that they don't serve beer. A pie without a pilsner is like a Hawaii without a waterfall, or a dozen. read more

The best part about this place is the team. They do a phenomenal job and make you feel right at home. Pizza is good. I wish the crust had a little more "umph" Hit it when you are on island! read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Three pies - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

We had a consistently positive experience here, trying several different items from the menu, and everything was delicious. Pizza - yum! The salads were my favorite. Beyond the great food, the staff truly made the experience special. The cashiers were always friendly, helpful, and seemed genuinely happy to be there. The restaurant itself was spotless, with employees constantly cleaning and maintaining a tidy environment. It's worth noting that no alcohol is served here, but the overall quality of the food and service more than makes up for it. read more

See all

Great pizza. Had the Big Island. Exceptional ingredients. Fast and friendly service.

Molokai Pizza Cafe really improved their food this year 2025! Amazing Service and Having more options on the menu is great!!

My boyfriend and I shared a whole pie and ate the whole thing in one night. I don't know what it is, but everything tastes better on Molokai!!! read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

See all

Super friendly Nice pie with generous toppings Prices are fair on a very expensive food landscape read more

Really good pizza and friendly people. We got the Big Island Pizza. We like that they slice in small slices. read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

Friendly staff, very tasty pepperoni pizza. The bottom crust could have been crispier. It was perfect when reheated in the oven. read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

Ate there today, we were thought the pizza was delicious and a very good price for what we got! Being on Molokai we expect to pay more but this was a really good pizza, we got a medium and the price was no more than at home. two of us ate half and brought the other half home for dinner. Had to get a side of Mac salad, for $3 it was so good, you can tell it was home made, yum! read more

Don't let the name fool you - they serve much more than pizza. They have good chicken dishes and salad. There are daily specials. We went twice during our week in Molokai and enjoyed everything we had. The service was good and friendly. read more

Ordered the Teriyaki Wings and a Turkey and cheese pita. The wings were a solid 2.5 out of 5, tasted kinda old! The pita was good, not the best but not bad, solid 4. Service was great, our waitress was very friendly and accommodating. read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe Opened in 1992 Featuring: Molokai Fresh Dough Pizzas Incredible Bread Stix Cool Crisp Salads Popular Pasta Dishes Barbecue Baby Back Ribs Chicken Dinners Kids Meals Daily Specials *Molokai's original pizzeria My best friend and I ordered the 10" Big Island pizza: Pepperoni, ham, bacon, mushrooms, olives, bell peppers, and onions. We also ordered the 12 piece Hot Buffalo Wings. My friend says, "the pizza & wings satisfied her hunger." I enjoyed the retro theme atmosphere & overall deliciousness of the food. I highly recommend eating here. P.s. There's an old school PAC Man Arcade Machine. 50 ¢ per game read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Big Island Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

See all

I hate to give a bad review. This place, the pizza looked amazing but sadly we didn't try it. I got the wings, they were horrendous. I wish I got a picture, because even the look was quite displeasing... probably my fault for not getting pizza at a pizza place. Just warning people not to get the wings. The service is great and the staff is SUPER friendly. Would be happy to go back and try the pizza. read more

The food was great and customer service is always pretty good, but they need to separate their orders because my cheesy bread always gets stuck to the parchment paper. read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Cheesy bread - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

I still eat here when I'm short on time. Takes about 25 minutes to get your order. When your order linguine they give you a pretty good size portion. It can make 2 meals. read more

See all

When we went to Molokai pizza cafe we ordered at the counter and got our pizza brought to our car about 10 minutes later. It was a super quick process and very minimal contact. Very clean too! We ordered the Maui pizza which is a veggie pizza. It was absolutely delicious! We brought it to the beach near our hotel and ate it there. It was a very nice experience! read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Maui pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

Overall, not great but only option on a Sunday when everything closed. Food: pizza was not the worst I have had. One step above Totino's frozen pizza. Service: bad. Waited an hour for one 10" pizza. We were initially told to sit down for dine-in service but no one came to help us so we ordered at counter and after 50 min of waiting someone came to tell us to get out of the table if we were not dining in. I don't understand why we had to leave table. The place was empty and we had initially been instructed to sit there. Ambiance: meh. Nothing special. read more

Good choice of pizza, burgers, salads, pastas or diner plates. We ordered pizza, pasta and ribs for take out. Service is around 20 min. There are games for kids and Molokaï´s souvenirs to buy. Tables for eating inside and food is very good. read more

I always get takeout so I can't comment on the dine in service. You have to put into context that this restaurant is in Molokai and you don't have any other options for Pizza. We always get the large Maui pizza which gives you 16 slices which is good to feed to adults and two small kids. Easy to call in the order and the workers are always friendly. Look for coupons in the dispatch (newspaper) for some discounts but other than that food is well priced and tastes pretty good after a day at the beach. read more

I'm from Oahu but was craving pizza and ordered a medium pepperoni mushroom. The cheese hits different. not bad for the price! read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

We are here twice on our recent visit to Molokai. Pizza was very good as were the wings. The next night we returned and had hamburgers. We waited an hour for our order of 3 burgers. Burgers were not worth the wait. Buns were dry. No sauce of any kind. I ordered a teriyaki burger with sautéed onions. I finally found 2 or 3 pieces of onion. Definitely pizza is the star here. Our servers both nights were charming which was a plus. read more

Discreet little pizza place with very good pizza. The one we tried, Big Island, was like the works. Pepperoni, ham, bacon, mushrooms, olives, bell peppers, onions, Italian sausage and ground beef. I'd rank it above average fast food variety. The Teriyaki wings were also good, tasty and not dry. We also had fresh made lemonade that was super refreshing and finished with soft serve ice cream. read more

Molokai Pizza Cafe - Big Island Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kaunakakai, Hawaii

We went there yesterday for lunch while we were on Moloka'i for work. One of our Moloka'i office's ladies took us there and it was awesome. Two of us shared their seafood alfredo pizza and our other coworker had their meatball sub. We also ordered their breadsticks. Everything was so 'ono and their customer service was excellent. I will be definitely be eating there again the next time I go to Moloka'i for business or pleasure. Oh by the way, they accept CASH only but they have an ATM in there. read more

See all

Enjoyed the Oahu pizza and some buffalo wings before heading home. A nice little place to eat with your Ohana. Clean and spacious. read more

See all