We did delivery as we were just passing through town on a road trip so I have no idea what the storefront looks like. We just ordered some basics, a cobb salad and an antipasto salad and a thin sausage and mushroom pizza. The salads were great and they did not skimp on the toppings. All the ingredients were fresh and didn't taste like they had been sitting all prepared in the fridge. The antipasto had tons of meat, which I would have preferred less of only for dietary reasons. Pepperoni, prosciutto and ham all made appearances along with olives and pepperoncini. It would have been nice to have some more veggies, but again, just a preference. The pizza was not my definition of thin crust and that is why I gave this place a lower rating. It was more of a "boli" style with thick puffy end crusts that I ended up cutting away only to make a sizeable slice shrink to an appetizer portion. The sausage was pellet like, a major no no for this pizza lover. I figured Pittsburgh would know how to make some great sausage. Maybe they do and Monte Cello's should look into a different supplier. At least the mushrooms were fresh. They have a huge menu that includes soups. "pressure fried chicken", calzones, strombolis, sandwiches, hot hoagies, and pasta. Some of the other stuff might have been tasty, but after sampling the pizza, I think we will scout out another place on our next journey through Cranberry. read more

Forget this place. Don't do it . Delivery orders wrong. Very late. Half the order missing. Dining in a different story. Bad food. No care in cooking or prep. Pizza is ok number 2 in the area. Best item pressured cook chicken with mash potatoes. If they closed, they wouldn't be missed read more

I stopped by here today with 4 other coworkers for lunch. We arrived at the restaurant shortly after noon and were immediately seated at a table big enough for us. On the short trip to our table I was not able to see too much of the restaurant but it appeared to be clean, they had some 6 pack coolers (weirdly some Labatt's Light was in a Bud Light 6 pack container but post-it marked as Labatt's Light which was the same with some other beers) and they also had two large flat screens that we were able to see in the dining room. This was especially welcome since it's March Madness time and so we were easily able to watch the games while eating. For my entree I decided to have the 2 pieces of pizza and side salad. The salad came out first and was your normal starter iceberg lettuce salad with some onions, 2 olives, a single tomato wedge and a very small cup of dressing. It wasn't bad overall although I could have used a bit more dressing which I am sure that I could have asked for. Our pizza was brought out next and I was surprised to see that it was square slices instead of normal slices but the menu did mention a certain kind of pizza which I did not really pay attention to. As with most pizzas, it came be talked about in its three parts: crust, sauce and cheese. The crust on this pizza was thick, had a crunchy outside and soft inside and reminded me of pan pizza which while not healthy certainly tastes good. It's tomato sauce was decent and I could taste some spices while the cheese was just average and nothing to write home about. The bottom line is that I would probably head back to Monte Cello's in the future although I am not sure that I would head there on my own. While I didn't really have a great sample size of the food, I did think that it tasted decently and I also loved that it was cheap ($3.50 for lunch after my $1 off coupon). read more

Pretty good pizza. I always get the buffalo chicken pizza, which is my favorite. I feel like you get a good deal on your pizza but the other menu items seem a bit high. The staff is usually nice too! read more

Ok ok this is THE LAST time I'll review this dump! How it stays open is beyond me, ok the pizza is good but everything else is GARBAGE. I'm a local in cranberry so we literally live 3 mins from here and of course EVERYTHING is cold, I had ordered food to be delivered after a rough day, I don't expect gourmet food from this place AT ALL just simple food. Well they took it beyond the point of freaking foul! The "buffalo chicken strips" were soggy flat pieces of crap and the first time I cut into on it had a pinky wide strand of cartilage going the whole length through it(barf) The provolone sticks were rock hard and wrapped in aluminum foil with the marinara which is in a little dish which is by now melted into the sauce cause it was hot when they poured it in so it melted the container and was soaking the aluminum foil wrapped hard pieces of cheese sticks I got Alfredo for my two year old son and was wondering why he didn't want to eat it, he loves Alfredo, we'll after he ate all my fries I tasted his Alfredo and instantly got freaked out, it tasted like a cleaner of some sort, maybe dish soap like they soaked the noodles in it??? My son ate that!!!! So I instantly called montecellos to talk to the manager, explained it to him, he offered me a store credit for just the Alfredo, I declined as I just wanted to warn them of the garbage they are serving Over all I'm still hangry and now $35 dollars more regretful of my initial decision to not make dinner read more

Great pizza in several crusts; delicious calzone with flaky, buttery crust. Very busy with attentive staff. We will be back here for sure!

I really like this place, but I always forget about it when thinking about dining options. The wedding soup is good, the chicken parm is fantastic, and the pizza's even better. My only quibble is that sometimes things are in the food but aren't mentioned on the menu; for example, their sausage casserole (if I'm recalling the name of the dish correctly, it's a couple of lengths of Italian sausage on top of sauce and pasta) has green peppers in the sauce. Had I known this, I probably wouldn't have ordered it because I have a bad reaction to green peppers. If not for that, 5 stars *easily*. There's also a bar on the "other side" from the restaurant. I've never been in that half of the building, so I don't know what it's like. read more

Pleasantly surprised to find this place on a recent trip. We were hangry and looking for a quick meal in the early afternoon. We placed an order for carryout and the service was pretty quick - food was ready in about 15 minutes. My chicken parm sandwich was serviceable but nothing special. Stuffed banana peppers were a total hit - beef and cheese and marinara all mixed for something totally delicious. The real slam dunk was the stromboli. It tasted like a delicious Italian sub, except rolled up inside a perfect pizza dough crust. The prices for carry-out six packs seemed pretty high ($13 and up for mixed six packs), but I assume those are just convenience prices and that it would be cheaper to drink in the restaurant or bar on-site. Food prices were really reasonable and I'd definitely come here again. read more

Food is good. Better than any Monte Cellos around. Management of my time of interaction was great. However, I do not approve of the way the Owner treats people. He definitely knows how to run a business behind closed doors, but it is no wonder he needs Managers to be the front face representation of his company. read more

Monte Cello's is a neat sports/yinzer bar located off 19 in Cranberry. They are in a great location and easy to find and I go here often for lunch. They have some flat screen TVs and a separate bar area so a great place to go if you're looking to watch some sports. Their lunch specials are fantastic! They have a consistent menu of good pasta/pizza on special every day, and then have a rotating menu for the month. The Sicilian pizza is nice and filing and the side salads are a great compliment to some of their meals. It's relatively cheap and the food is consistent. The staff is for the most part friendly, and I can say I've never had a bad experience going here. Would strongly recommend salad/soups and Sicilian pizza here. If you have a chance stop in for lunch and check it out! Cheap good food with some flat screen TVs and in a nice part of Cranberry. read more

$10.00 for a chef salad that used to be $5.25 . No better just more lettuce. Did you have to double the price to pay for your remodeling? bye Monticello's Maybe you can put another Monticello's in Arizona because I won't be ordering from you anymore. Former weekly customer! read more

Hands down the best pizza in Cranberry! We love the Chicago deep dish. We order Monte Cellos at home and when I'm at work it is always the go to. We have had several items from the menu and are big fans! read more

This place is great. Very good authentic Italian (note: NOT AMERICANIZED) pizza, good appetizers. Service and whatnot are not exceptional, but they certainly don't detract from it in the least. Still very good. The price is more than fair for the quality of food. I've yet to try something on this menu that I don't like. Highly recommended for a good night out when you want good Italian food, particularly pizza. read more

Oh monte cellos, you have the most amazing Sicilian cut pizza that ever lived.... I've been living in the south for 6 years and I literally dream about monte cellos pizza - it's that good. I make it a point to stop by for my 2 cut and salad lunch special (only $5 little dollars btw) at least once while I am in town. I've never been disappointed. I'm not a heavy eater either but I stuff myself full like an unchaperoned child at a birthday party and I don't feel any remorse after I finish the whole 2 slices. Monte Cellos is consistent at what they do and they have been around for a long time. The place is always packed, prices are reasonable, service is pretty ok mostly, location is convenient. They also have a separate bar area that makes me feel at home. Great selection of crafts and seasonals, too. Try the pie! read more

Love the pizza's. Mainly the tomato basil -delicious. Whenever we go there they are always busy and they are one of the few places in town that deliverer . They don't have many healthy options on the menu -would be nice if they could add some. The décor is quite dated and could stand to be freshen up. I will continue to get pizza's from there. read more

So I no longer live in Cranberry Twp PA anymore, however I visited this place many many many times. I've visited every state except Hawaii and Alaska and eaten at many Ma Pa pizza joints. This still remains on my Top 5 of all-time. Love the pizza. That is all I'm commenting on, I haven't had the other menu items in so longer I can't comment on them. Whenever I go back home to visit friends I stop here for pizza. The atmosphere is good. It's two places in one. Full restaurant and Full bar side by side separate from each other. The bar even has it's own entrance, you do not need to go through the restaurant to get in the bar. Good amount of draft beers, all liquors. Service is always great, and friendly. So of the waitress's in the restaurant are young and can be flirty with the other kitchen staff. I think there is high turnover as far as the high school kids. But overall it's good. You could do a lot worse. read more

The pizza is good. We have ordered delivery from them a few times and the food is always good quality and the service is fast, and friendly. Prices are good for what you get. read more

Food is usually good. Service is so-so. The interior needs a drastic makeover and the booths need to be bigger. God help you if you have anything bigger than a 30" waist because you can barely breath once you get in. The only person comfortable was my 6 year old nephew. Insist on a table if you're a normal adult. The place seems run by 16 year olds who really don't give a crap about you or your experience. Feels like I'm in high school when I go there. read more

Must say I was disappointed with the pizza I picked up yesterday. Got a pan pizza and it was like a big piece of dough and soggy. Italian hoagie was ok. I get my za here a lot and hope it was just an off night. read more

One of my favorite pizza and wing places in Cranberry! Definitely worth the little bit extra in price. You get what you pay for!

Local eatery. Famous here. Really not any different from a fast food place. Staff... well, I should have just seated myself and let them figure it out. Will go back to see if this experience was aberrant but I am moving away from Pizza places as they see to be benign in taste and presentation. read more

Monte Cellos is the manilla envelope of cranberry twp dining. The food is ok, the people are ok (sometimes), and the restaurant itself has looked the same for 20 years. God bless America. read more

Got halfway through my meal before I noticed a piece of metal in the middle of my plate. read more

Monte Cello's - Got a free side of fryer metal with the special for lunch today. Look before you bite. - Pizza Near Me - Cranberry Township, Pennsylvania

This used to be my favorite pizza place. Started going here about 2 years ago and looked forward to the 45 minute drive to eat there. Recently the Pizza has gone down hill but tonight's pizza was absolutely terrible. Our server was a sweet girl so I didn't have the heart to complain to her but the pizza was the worst I've ever had. Barely any sauce . Minimal toppings just plain awful. Don't think I'll be making the trek again in the near future. read more

Best pizza around!! Wings are great too!!! The special ranch dressing is my absolute favorite! Fun family place too!! They have the balloon man on Friday nights. My entire family loves Monte Cello's Cranberry! read more

My girlfriend had told me that this place was really good, so I decided one night that I would treat my friend to it. We didn't want to eat there, we just wanted to take out and go back home. I called 30 minutes in advance just so that I wouldn't have to sit around and wait. I had driven past it before I knew that it was always slammed. Whenever we went, it of course was slammed. You couldn't even find a parking spot. I ordered a calzone and so did my friend. I looked at them before I left and they looked great. They were very expensive but I don't mind paying a lot of the food is good. After we left and went back home, I was not impressed at all. It didn't even seem to be cooked all the way. It had a funky taste and it just wasn't what I expected at all. My friend's was the same way. I called to complain but all they said was that they would make me another one but I didn't want to go back out so I didn't bother with it. I would probably go back again but I would order something else. The employees are extremely rude as well and are more worried about talking to each other and joking around than actually helping their customers. I think the next time I go, I'll order something different and see how that tastes. read more

Monte Cello's is one of my favorite places to hangout when I'm around town. They have a very large menu, and incredible service. Although, my last visit was good, but the margarita pizza (at least that's what I customized it to be) was bland. My grandmother thought that they needed to add fresh basil, instead of dried. I agree that Monte Cello's needs to add fresh toppings to the pizza, or at least say that the basil is dried. Overall, I love Monte Cello's and I definitely recommend going there for a nice lunch or dinner! read more

Passing through from Michigan to Virginia; happened upon this gem!!! Excellent pizza!!!

This restaurant has two listings on Yelp. Check them both. I am so confused as to the great reviews for this place. Monte Cello's Cranberry actually has two separate entries here on Yelp; make sure to check both. I made the mistake of only checking one. We came here looking for some good pizza. Based on some Yelp reviews, we figured this would be worth a shot. We should have known the experience would be less than stellar when it took our waitress a while to show up. We were all right with it, at first, as we were busy settling our daughter in and browsing the menu. Once she finally came and took our drink orders, she disappeared again for about five minutes. I found her socializing on the bar side when I took my daughter to the restroom. They really need to send people in to check the bathrooms occasionally. It was disgusting and rank of cigarette smoke. On the way out, waitress still at bar? Check. When our food finally arrived, it looked like prepackaged food. The pizza was mediocre. There is nothing really else to say about the food. Not memorable. What was memorable about this place is constantly waiting for our waitress to finish socializing and to tend her table. One Table! Plates sat on tables for ten minutes before being clean. This could be because the young staff stood around chatting instead of working. We came in for an early dinner, so this is not based on busy times. Other reviews state that this is authentic Italian...oh goodness, please do not believe that. I lived in Italy for 3 1/2 years and this tastes NOTHING like the food there- even in touristy sections of the cities. read more

I agree with the bad reviews. Delivery use to be good, not anymore. Tried several times, orders screwed up, hair in food, cold. Never again.

Monte Cello's has amazing pizza and other Italian food. They tend to get crowded and do not take reservations so keep that in mind! It's well worth the wait for their food though. It's also a very family friendly restaurant which is not always easy to find. I would always recommend this place for eating in or delivery. 10/10 on the yummy scale. read more

Meh. Ordered the zucchini Parmesan and was not impressed. The zucchini was almost too hard to chew through and the sauce was mediocre. The garlic bread and salad I had were great. Most of the good reviews I have heard/read on here are about the pizza. Perhaps I will go back and give that a shot. Also hear good things about their fettuccini. read more

I will never eat here again. First my wing order was messed up, sent me hot wings instead of bbq. Then i found a LONG HAIR in my buffalo chicken rolls. They blamed it on the butter brush. Please, the hair was 4 inches long. No pastry brush is 4 inches long. The manager said she will credit it on my account. I will not be returning so i will be getting my full refund. read more

Monte Cello's - A HAIR in the buffalo chicken roll that the manager blamed on the brush. This hair was the length of the roll and was blonde. No way a brush - Pizza Near Me - Cranberry Township, Pennsylvania

Good Italian. Can't go wrong w anything on the menu. Pizzas are awesome. Chicken parmesan is outta this world.

Horrible. Got terribly sick twice, thought it was just coincidence. Tried ordering one more time, my infant and toddler both had diarrhea and my husband vomited for 6 hours. I didn't have any and I was the only one not sick. I will never order from Monte Cello's again. read more

The pizza is always good, but last night's service encouraged me to add this restaurant to Yelp so I could give it a review. I was there last night and brought in my baby in his infant seat. I bought a pizza and a beverage. The cashier, seeing that I would not be able to carry my baby, my pizza, and my beverage, asked one of the workers to help me with my food. That was so kind! Keep up the great service! :) read more

Had to try their Buffalo Steak Calzone on national Calzone day. Thanks to Cranberry Patch for the idea. Was not disappointed as it was very good with added sauce. With the name "Buffalo", it could have had just a little more kick for my taste. read more

I don't know why they can't seem to get a chicken bacon ranch pizza right, but the past 2 times I've ordered it from here they have completely messed it up. The first time their was no chicken or bacon and there were onions all over it, and this time their was no bacon and again, onions all over it. It's really a simple order and I'm confused as to how they keep producing it wrong, especially when I even specify in my call for no onions. They gave me the wrong size of ranch too; I asked for a pint and they handed me something probably 1/4 the size. On the off chance they DO get it right, it's my favorite pizza in the world, but having received it wrong two times in a row makes me nervous to ever order it from here again. read more

I didn't like how you could see the guys in the kitchen and none of them wearing gloves or very sanitary. I had an older woman as my waitress and it took her 5 minutes to say hi I'll be right back and another 5 minutes went by before she got our drinks, then another 5-10 minutes to take our order. I have served so I understand servers get busy but come on that's rediculous! Once we got our food the pizza was very good though! read more

Delicious every time. It's all about consistency, and this place has it. I'm drooling right now just thinking about their pizza and buffalo chicken rolls. read more