The food here is delicious! Lasagna and the sauce is so good! Kim our waitress took very good care of Alice on her 96th birthday. You can tell the food is made with love. Support local family restaurants and especially Montemaggiore Italian Restaurant . read more

Montemaggiore Italian Restaurant - Lasagna! - Italian Near Me - Elma, New York

Amazing food!!! My family has been on a mission for over ten years to find a sauce and veal margarita like we loved at la Casta Lana and we found it!!! Absolutely awesome!! Three of us got it and absolutely fell back in love with it! The quest is over!!! The veal was very tender, the eggplant and ham were great and the wine sauce topped it off perfectly! Great portions and ratios ! The red sauce was a sweet stick to the ziti and was delectable!! The wife got the eggplant rollitini also amazing. It had Rivera and mozzarella cheese inside and out. Perfectly broiled' Good size too! [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a modern bright large windows comfortable and relaxing![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Friendly relaxed service . We will be returning very very soon I have edit me review we loved it so much we when back and brought more family TWO days later !! ya that good! read more

See all

My husband and two son's favorite dish has always been veal margherita but their favorite restaurant to get this dish closed years ago. Well...... we have found their new favorite place and my son says he hopes they are open for the rest of his life! Even better than they remembered. I had eggplant rolatini which was perfect. We all agreed their sauce was perfect, just a little sweet but not too much. The meatballs are gigantic and very tasty. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The building was completely remodeled and is very modern Italian with nice touches like big windows and a cozy fireplace.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]There is a very large patio but it was too muggy to sit out.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Of course we were all to full for dessert so got it to go. Peanut butter pie and tiramisu were incredible! Our wait staff were very pleasant and friendly. We definitely will be back many times! Highly recommended. Would give more stars if I could! read more

For my second experience here, I drove from the city of Buffalo to here in Elma and ordered my tripe dinner --and it was so fantastic. Anybody who is a tripe lover should come here. The sauce is slightly sweet with peppers. It's wonderful. read more

Wanted to say this restaurant s the best Italian restaurant in WNY ... great food and service was awesome Restaurant is clean , and in a perfect location We had server Adriana great service the owner Michelle came out and asked if we needed anything which was very good Customers service with her customers love this restaurant read more

Chicken cacciatore with GF pasta was great. The sauce is good a little acidic. I would recommend them putting a little baking soda in to cook off the acid, but other than that tasty. Everyone was happy with the food. Would also recommend Romain or mixed greens for salad not just iceberg. I can't stand that. read more

Fairly new restaurant probably still working out the kinks. Only 4 stars mainly because of personal preference. Portions were generous with the main meals. The bread offered is simply a toasted sub roll. The side salad is only iceberg lettuce with tomatoes, onions and green olives. The homemade sauce is a sweet sauce if that's your preference you'll love it. One of the pieces of Chicken Francese was tough and the sauce was a bit too lemony for my taste. Chicken Parmigiana was delicious! Our server was friendly but didn't seem to come around as often as you expect. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant is clean and well lit but a warmer color on the walls or maybe a dark accent wall would be a nice touch.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Good food, huge portions , would recommend splitting Only beer and wine [[HIGHLIGHT]]Clean but a bit noisy[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Stopped for a late lunch and so glad I did. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Lovely atmosphere with Deano playing softly[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]], wonderful waitress and delicious meal. read more

This was really 3 1/2 stars and could have been 4 ... Chicken parm, and eggplant parm was ordered. The eggplant was the best (by far) chicken was good - but lacked seasoning and should have been pounded thin. Comes with a salad (which is a mandatory for old school spaghetti house) and bread. To really get me to 4 stars ... the bread needs to be home made (ours was Costanza sub rolls warmed up). All in all this will be a regular rotation for a quick dinner. As an FYI - they serve a sweet sauce, which is different, but very good. read more

Montemaggiore Italian Restaurant - chicken parm - Italian Near Me - Elma, New York

Service was terrible. They had a young kid as a waitress need to be trained the tripe meal came out there was very few pieces of tribe said on a big mound of linguine, and I didn't ask for a linguine I asked for a rigatoni, and it was disguised with peppers and onions terrible meal almost $30 without tip go somewhere else not doing a good job here! if I could give it no stars, I would read more

went to this restaurant today did brunch was a great experience and the food was delicious took my mom for Mother's Day workers were helpful owner Michelle came out and asked if we needed anything we gas a great experience at this restaurant today read more

We have eaten here several times and we have always had a wonderful meal. The sauce is delicious! I've had stuffed shells, lasagna, chicken Parmesan and my husband has had chicken cacciatore. Every meal has been delicious. The service is great. The staff is friendly and attentive. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant is tastefully decorated and they had special decorations for Valentines Day.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

See all

The food is amazing! The best eggplant parmesan I've ever had. Great canoles. Nice wines. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very comfortable inside.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Staff is very nice. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Can get noisy if crowded.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Food was great with big portions. If you like a sweeter sauce you will enjoy. Service was fast and very nice and conscientious. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Was a little loud but we were in the back room which was a little quieter.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I would go back again. read more

Montemaggiore Italian Restaurant - Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti - Italian Near Me - Elma, New York

The food is delicious! We've ordered takeout from them several times and have not been disappointed a single time!

It was our first time here and we will be back. There were 5 of us and we all loved what we ordered and we all had left overs our waiter Nathan was great! read more

See all

This place has the best Italian food! The price is amazing for the amount of food you get and the service is incredible. A family owned business doing it right! read more

I was there for dinner last night and really liked the my dinner and the service The meatballs are very good, just like Gramma used to make. Italian sausage was very good ** The sauce is too sweet for me read more

Is that a constanzo sub roll for bread hmm. If that is true WOW an Italian restaurant who serves bread out of a bag DOUBLE WOW!!! That is so sad :( shameful!!! What a scam these people are not Italian and if they are TRIPLE WOW!!! If an Italian restaurant can't make fresh bread ( flour and water) if you can't mix water and flour together you won't be open for long.I would go down the block either way and get real warm homemade bread. I'm a real Italian what else is isn't homemade.SO SAD read more

Our first time here. Food and service were superb! I had the red clam sauce and it may have been the best I have had in years. The portions are large and the prices are reasonable. [[HIGHLIGHT]]A very nice atmosphere also.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We will be back. read more

Good plentiful food. [[HIGHLIGHT]]A comfortable dining area[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Customer Service, waitstaff is fabulous. Would recommend.

I generally will not write a bad review on here. I just won't review it at all. However our experience today at this "newer" restaurant was a total disaster. I cannot remember another dining experience quite this bad. We were really excited to try it and can't see us ever giving them another chance. Comfortable dining area and expansive menu gave us high hopes. It all went up in smoke after that. We ordered the small antipasto for an appetizer and it came out well after our meals did. Instead of watching our baked ziti and lasagna get cold waiting for it we started eating. I was over half way done with my meal when it finally came to the table. I had to ask for the bread and butter that came with our orders when the antipasto was delivered and over half my meal was gone. The antipasto had absolutely zero dressing on it. We asked for a soda refill three times and twice she told us she'd be right back with our refills and never did even once with a refill. Another table had to ask for their bread after hearing me do the same, and the table next to us got a cold cup of soup delivered. The elderly couple seated at the next table over ordered a sub to split before we ordered and got their food as we were finishing. She asked for a plate for her half of their sub and I am not sure she ever got one. The food was good but not great. Portions were decent. Maybe a bit spoiled as a loyal LaBella Sicilia customer but this place can't compare to say the least. Hope they can turn it around, I hate to see restaurants fail. I think every table in the restaurant was visibly dissatisfied. read more

See all

Sauce is way too sweet for my liking. Pizza was too doughy and thick despite ordering "NY Style". Veal parm was decent but came out pipping hot we couldn't enjoy it. Service was good. Everything was just "blah", nothing that would make us return. read more

Went for dinner and although there were many empty tables the hostess had to see if a server was available. The server said she would be available in five minutes. So rather than letting us sit at a table and wait for the waitress, they had us wait in the entryway, so we left. read more

Since there were 5 of us we were able to get a reservation and we all enjoyed this newer Italian restaurant. We loved the mozzarella sticks and freshly baked bread. The appetizer calamari was perfect for its price point. The 2 children has an order of spaghetti and meatballs and lasagna. The veal cacciatore was a hit, with very tender veal. The chicken parmigiana platter was also a hit with a side of lasagna and 2 stuffed shells. The one disappointment was the veal francese. It was too salty and the lemon too strong which took away from the tender veal. It was our first time there and we will be back. All 5 of us came home with boxes for the next day. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I must add the ambience was much better than the photos portrayed.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Our server was attentive and ready to answer any questions we had about the menu. read more

Been wanting to try it for awhile now and so glad we finally did. Friday night and it was pretty busy, but we walked in and were seated right away. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant is very clean, open and well decorated.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Our server Adrianna was amazing! Very attentive, friendly and knowledgeable about all the menu items. Had the lasagna and stuffed shells. The wine and meals came out quick and were absolutely delicious, the red sauce was slightly sweet and had great flavor. the portions are big and we took left overs home. We also ordered desserts to take home (cannoli and lemon cake) both were fantastic. We highly recommend, and will be going back and will be asking for Adrianna. 5 stars all the way. read more

Montemaggiore Italian Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Elma, New York

Excellent food and service! The menu offers a wide variety of Italian favorites. We've also ordered pizza for pick-up several times, and it's just as wonderful as the dine-in meals. read more

Fastly becoming my favorite local Italian food. The vodka sauce is fantastic and I decided to try the Sicilian style pizza and I was shocked by how good it was. Portions were huge so I left full and with plenty of leftovers for a fantastic lunch the next day. read more

Love, love, love Montemaggiore's! The food is delicious (the red sauce is amazing!), the service is top notch (Jackson is super friendly and always on the ball), and [[HIGHLIGHT]]it just has a great atmosphere[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. I'm there at least twice a month, and I've never had a bad experience. I highly recommend trying it out! read more

Just had leftovers from here and they were absolutely delicious. Will be going there very soon!

We were looking for good Italian near West Seneca and we finally found it. Huge portions, everything is fresh and tastes great. The red sauce is a tad sweet, my wife loved it. I had the vodka sauce on rigatoni and added mushrooms and it was fantastic! We can't wait to go back. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]First and foremost the place is VERY CLEAN! (a real plus for me )[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Been here a few times since they opened and all my experiences were excellent. Had the opportunity to have both Adrianna and Jackson be my servers. Both were very observant ,kind and did not rush you . (good for the business) The food was excellent. Had Lasagna, stuffed shells,eggplant parm and Spaghetti and meatballs .Each time NO complaints very good and so much I had dinner the following day. Salad was good but could use some tweeking maybe a little tomato, spring mix instead of iceburg lettuce. The bread was a heated sub roll with butter but they did bring me some oil and herbs for dipping (thank you). My over all eat in experience was AWESOME! However going forward I ordered a pizza from takeout. It was good but NOT what I expected . I ordered mushrooms, onions, and pepperoni extra $6.00 for 8 tiny pieces of soggy fried onion that belong on the Eppie Roll , 8 pieces of mushrooms I could barely find. I learned my lesson to either just order cheese and pep them add other stuff at home OR just stay at my favorite Bocce Pizza place. Very happy to have a GOOD ITALIAN restaurant close by I shall return! read more

Excellent customer service and the food is delicious !!! I ordered the eggplant parm and it was so tasty ! Love their sweet spaghetti sauce ! read more

Food was delicious ! Service good [[HIGHLIGHT]]The noise level was out of control[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We will give it another chance..... read more

We had a group of 20+ and handled it well. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Loved the way the changed the look and feel from the previous business.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] From someone with a latex allergy they are safe and do not use latex gloves. Food is safe! read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]The interior is very bland and the decor is minimal. Not a "cozy" place to dine.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] They serve beer, but it's not listed on the menu. We started with the meatballs as an appetizer. They were on the dry side, but the flavor was decent. The salad that came prior to the meal was unappetizing. White iceberg lettuce with a few tomatoes and green olives. Green olives and onions were optional. I got the chicken francese. It was very tasty with light breading. The spaghetti I chose as a side was not palatable. Reminded me of cafeteria spaghetti. I think this place is ok. Not sure I would return. read more

Was there for lunch for noon and they don't open until 4pm. They still served us lunch. The food was outstanding. I can't wait to go back.

Heard some awesome reviews so decided to try takeout Saturday afternoon. We decided to try a half of a Sicilian pizza , an order of sausage and meatballs. I usually get pictures but we dove right in. The meatballs and sausage was covered in a delicious red sauce. Both very tender and delicious. The Sicilian pizza was also good. Nice crisp crust and plenty of cheese. Order was ready when they stated. Once they get everything ironed out of opening a new restaurant we will definitely be dining in. Congratulations on your new restaurant. Everything we had was very good ! read more

The waitstaff are very attentive. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The atmosphere is great.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The portions were so big. The prices don't break your wallet either. We ordered veal parmigiana, chicken parmigiana, chicken alfredo and baked ziti with meatballs. Everything was hot and delicious. We will return for sure. read more