After thinking about coming where to eat, my wife and I finally did. The food was outstanding (one…read moreof the best meals we've had). The waitress was outstanding. She made great recommendations and checked in with us the proper amount of the time. We loved that the place felt intimate, especially for the size of the building. We will definitely come back again.

I love the atmosphere of this place, super nice staff! The menu was interesting and the food was…read moreincredible. Prices were a bit higher than expected, but the quality and attention to detail was definitely there. We will be back for sure!

Excellent food and a wildly large bourbon selection! Impeccable service. Pleasant ambiance; ideal…read morefor relaxing and conversation. I chided our server for the lack of decent cocktail cherries, but for the modest prices of their cocktails, it's a small price to pay. I was amused that they requested to reuse our large spherical ice cubes (a must-have for decent old-fashioned cocktails). But again, worth it for the modest prices they charge.

The surest way to get me into your establishment is to name it The Bourbon Room. Even more so if…read moreyou offer your own barrel-aged old fashioneds! Because we had failed to make a reservation, I had time to try both barrel-aged offerings in the bar prior to being seated. The first featured Elijah Craig Bourbon, orange and Angostura bitters, then aged for two months in oak barrels. The second featured Buffalo Trace Bourbon, orange and Angostura bitters, then aged for six months in oak barrels. After being seated in the dining room, we had one of the best meals during our week in Green Bay. The cheese curds were perfect. At our server's suggestion, I tried the cheddar potato bites as a side and they did not disappoint. Parking is a little tricky; there's a very tight lot immediately behind the restaurant, but otherwise it's street parking.

Went for the entertainment they had today fantastic. Ended…read moreup staying for supper, food was great service was fantastic and the place looked clean.

The food was great, however, when we first arrived the female bartender was dropping more than one…read moreloud f-bomb while chatting with some customers at the bar. Very unprofessional and a total turn off. This was our first time there and very likely will be our only.

I've been to Wisconsin a few times now, but had never experienced a "Supper Club" first hand…read more What a fun experience! You start in the bar area, sitting for a sip of whatever you whistle wetter of choice is. At some point, staff comes by and talks about what you'd like to eat and takes your order. Once they are ready to start serving your first course, they seat you in another room and start the process. Well portioned meals abound, whether you fancy fish, steak or chicken. The food was delicious and plentiful (I ate a 2nd meal at home afterwards) Hours are limited. (Only open 2-3 days a week for limited windows of time, sometimes varying). Also, anticipate that within the first hour they are packed and you'll be waiting, so best to come as soon as they open to get good seating and quicker service.

Wow wow wow... A…read moreMUST for Friday Fish Fry! Incredible food, service, and drinks. Jeff the bartender has been there for over 49 years and makes a Killer Brandy Old Fashioned.

When you go to a supper club, there are certain expectations... you expect great drinks, good food,…read morefriendly staff, and a certain vibe you just can't get at a normal restaurant. Billy's on Main hits the nail on the head in all four of these categories. As for the drinks, the old fashioneds here are top notch, so are the amaretto sours, and their ice cream drinks are to die for. I didn't get a chance for any other drink, but I'll be coming back. The service was by far the best part of the experience. The bartenders were super friendly and extremely nice. Super welcoming and personable, it was a lot of fun chatting with them at the bar. Once seated, I couldn't believe the prices! Ribeye for $31?? Tenderloin in the $20's?! What a treat. And as for the vibe, this was classic supper club. Drinks at the bar while you wait for your table. Supper club drinks as the specials. Just the charm you'd expect from a supper club. I'll be honest, I was a bit skeptical of coming here because they didn't have a website, and only like 3 reviews over the past 2 years, so I felt like I needed to write one. If you're looking for a good and solid supper club, this is your jam.

We recently moved to the area and have been searching for a quality supper club--Billy's on Main…read morehas become a go-to for us. We've eaten here multiple times, and each time the steaks have been cooked and seasoned perfectly. The drinks are made well, and the classic supper club touch of cheese and crackers at the bar while waiting is a nice bonus. The bartenders and wait staff are always friendly and attentive, making for a consistently great experience. If you're looking for a welcoming atmosphere and excellent food, this place is worth a visit.

Our first time here and we came for the fish fry. Everything was so fresh and yummy. We loved the…read moreonion on top of the Rye bread. Our waitress Steph was attentive and helpful. We will be back !

Stopped here for Friday fish fry lunch. First time here but felt very welcomed. Staff were super…read morefriendly and attentive. I had the Alaskan cod plate and my husband had the perch plate. Both were excellent. We also had a cup of the clam chowder. Hands down best ever! Highly recommend this place!

Great night out for the girls and we had the truffle fries and salad and drink special. I would…read moremake a reservation as they filled up pretty quickly Will definitely go again. The restaurant had a cozy and chill vibe

Nice atmosphere. Risotto was salty. Steaks were very nice. Unfortunately Not many vegetarian optionsread more

A few start up hiccups as with any business but it is vastly improved. The service and food has…read morebeen excellent every time we have ordered. We order there often to go as we live close by. I enjoy going there as it is quaint with a friendly crowd. It's the kind of place you would want to hang around any time of the day or evening with friends or family. The owner is an extremely hands on hard working guy and is doing everything to make this a successful place that you keep coming back to. We do!

We always loved the Settlement and we were apprehensive with new owners how it would be. It is…read morehonestly better than before! It is clean and bright inside but the same towny cozy small town bar feel. The food was so good! We always loved the tartar sauce from the Settlement and it is still so good! The fish was fresh tasting, not too greasy and one of the better fish fries in Green Bay! Great job new owners! You nailed it.