Great sandwiches. Lately it's been hit or miss depending on which "staff" is on shift. They can be a bit forgetful but when they have it right it's worth the prices. It's still hard to believe a deli sandwich that used to be 4.99-ish is now 15.00+ Oh well , it's a treat to get a deli sandwich nowadays isn't it! read more

For some reason, I craved a sub for dinner & so I got the CJ's Pastrami on Dutch Crunch and it was really good! The bread was great and full of flavor, everything tasted fresh, and all the flavors went really well together. They also gave a good amount of pastrami, which I appreciate because it contrasts other sandwich places where you get minimal meat. The only real negative about this place is pricing for a sub.. but what can I say, it's 2026. Definitely would get this again. read more

Two people working during lunch hour? You can tell they are stressed and feel bad. The place is packed of customers standing waiting. Ordering is done on a kiosk. I'm not sure it's any faster. read more

Left without food. Too busy working with Grubhub or waiting on you to use some silly ordering machine to actually help customers. Pretty easy to make a wrap at home so you lost my business. read more

The signature "Mr. Pickle" sandwich was piled high with premium meats and served on a beautifully soft, Dutch crunch roll. I loved that they included a complimentary whole dill pickle and a sweet cookie on the side. read more

My husband went there and had to wait until they were done with online orders until they helped him. He was there for 30 mins and 2 sandwiches ONLY cost $35 dollars....only to get home and the sandwiches were made wrong and bread on both sandwiches were stale. Thanks so much read more

Just went to this location and cannot say that I had the best experience. I ordered over the phone and that was easy, and they were very nice. But when I got there in person and tried to use this coupon, they looked at me like I was stupid and the person in charge said they never accept coupons. I showed him the book and the address on the coupon, and even one of the other Employees mentioned that they did see the coupon accepted the other day. The person assisting me Insisted that I was not correct and that they do not accept any coupons whatsoever. Very, very sad to be handled in such a manner. I used to like going here too :( read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Oakley, California

the gentleman who took my order and made my sandwich was very sweet and kind, and the food hit the spot :)

Ordered a sandwich. Took 25 minutes. The girl at the front was rude about my order. Somebody else came after me and got their order first I believe she was a manager too. She could be a lot kinder to people. She had an attitude slick back hair in a bun with glasses . I've never had a problem till today. read more

Never gets online/app orders right! Truly frustrating when you're spending over $10 for a sandwich

My poorly made half sandwich not with $10 Compared to my library card for laughs. Lack of toppings & just made with no care. read more

See all

My wife ordered lunch for us to pick up and take home on my break from work. I really wanted to try this sandwich but sadly I am unable to as they only got the mayo part right. Highly disappointed and do not think I will want to eat here again. Update: they have refunded what we paid due to the error they made. I also raised it to three because I am having a bad day and was upset I wasn't able to have lunch today. But everybody makes mistakes. We are only human. I feel bad about the one star review - that was my mistake. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Got Beef without veggies - Sandwiches Near Me - Oakley, California

One of my family's favorite go-to spots. I adore their salads! Especially the tri-tip salad. The young people working here are always friendly and quick-working. The establishment is also always spotlessly clean. Highly recommend for a quick, healthy lunch. read more

Great sandwiches! Also, we appreciate the professionalism and work the young staff provided with our order last night - great job! One suggestion, don't put all the chairs up until you actually close at 8pm. We were forced to eat outside which we don't always like to do. If you're open until 8pm, customers should be able to sit inside and eat. read more

Ordered on line, got to the store- no order. Although my computer said order went thru. Came home and found I had been charged for the online order and the in-store order. Always a wait. Short staffed on several occasions. read more

I walked in and everything looked nice and clean. It was a very short wait -- under 5 minutes to get my sandwiches. The location had plenty of parking. Overall a good experience. read more

This is my final update, still no word from corporate. It's very unfortunate that this company doesn't care about their customers.

The service here is great and the staff is very kind. I quickly walked in to get a sandwich and when I returned home I discovered my sandwich was made completely opposite of what I ordered. Unfortunately I was in a time crunch and had to get home for a meeting so I couldn't return it back to the store. Called the store and right away they were apologetic and provided me with several options to fix my order and ended up delivery a brand new sandwich. Thank you! read more

First time trying this place. I gotta say, I really like it!! I ordered the Big Easy and Mr. Pickles. This is in downtown Oakley. A cute little town that has a few shopping stores and some restaurants. I recommend this place for lunch. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Storefront - Sandwiches Near Me - Oakley, California

See all

I am posting this review for the lady who helped me out around 9:30-9:45am today. She was incredibly friendly, fast and helpful. 5 stars for her. Only three stars because the sandwich is good but man your prices are utterly insane. Update. Christy your hollow words mean nothing. Obviously a lot of people are over your 17 dollar sandwiches. read more

Expensive sandwiches and there was a small fly/bug in our sandwich so we showed the cashier and they offered to make another one for us but we were already full by then. A refund would've been more appropriate but we left. The service was good and we had no problems with the team but the bug in our sandwich turned us off. This place was really busy with a constant pace of customers coming in. If it wasn't for the bug I would give a higher rating but the prices are still high. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Oakley, California

See all

Every place deserves a second chance- I'm glad I took a chance again here. Place was nice and clean. Ordered a tri tip sandwich, l must saw YUM! The meat was a little chewy but it had great flavors. Menu is large, a lot of different selections. Just be careful and check the birds as many items online are not available in the store. My kids still idolize the dancing pickle guy. read more

Haven't ordered from here in a while but the Reuben used to be stacked with meat, sauerkraut, and thousand island soaking the rye. They're looking like a poor man's sandwich now. Dry and thin. Price is up, quality is down. Last good sandwich shop in town is gone. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - A dry boring sandwich. - Sandwiches Near Me - Oakley, California

Mr. Pickles, how hard is it to follow the online order and put the correct ingredients on each sandwich? Our family has tried to order from a local business but this is about the 15th wrong order. I've called management and they really don't seem to care. So disappointing since we really need a good sandwich shop and I love this chain in other areas. I hope the owners read this and turn things around. Please just follow the sandwich order! I have attached a photo of my sandwich that should have pesto and lettuce, instead they added tons of peppercinis and pickles not ordered. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Missing lettuce with a pile of peppercinis and pickles were added in its place?? - Sandwiches Near Me - Oakley, California

See all

We arrived here around 10:30am on a Saturday to get lunch for on the boat. The help behind the counter was very friendly and welcoming. I ordered the BLT and got it on Marble Rye bread (Yippee for them to carry that flavor). Someone commented that the BLT had very little lettuce - but mine was perfect, lots of bacon and everything else in nice balance - looking back I kinda wish I had added pickles - but next time is fine. My hubby got the Santa Fe salad which looked awesome with big hunks of freshly chopped chicken in it. He really enjoyed it - It came with a huge roll. Each order comes with a ("baked daily") chocolate chip cookie which was pretty decent. Better than subway cookies or those Pillsbury Slice and bake cookies. We will be back. read more

French dip is amazing. Cookies are not as good as they used to be...must be saving money lol They load the meat in and the sourdough bread is awesome with the perfect balance of crusty crunch and softness. I like how they send large bags of chips along with single sizes. They are quick and friendly and don't mind explaining things for those with questions. read more

I ordered a deli box for a work meeting and got myself a tri tip salad. I was pleasantly surprised by how good it was. The tri tip was nice and tender with a good smoky flavor. Will for sure go back for that. read more

We've tried this place several times since moving to Oakley and we continue to be disappointed. Today I ordered a BLT which was so flat it could have doubled as a pancake. 1 slice of tomato, a light sprinkling of lettuce. These are two of the main ingredients. On the other sandwich, I asked for extra lettuce and to add avocado (I paid extra for the avocado). I got what looked like the last scrapings of lettuce from the bottom of the container, not even enough for a half serving of lettuce, and no avocado. This is certainly not the first time something like this has happened. Additionally some of the staff come across as very rude, barking commands at the customer, and other staff simply need to write down your order rather than asking 20 questions about the ingredients "wait did you say wheat roll?" No I said sourdough. "You said no mayo right?" No I said no mustard. Overall not impressed. Better sandwiches can be found elsewhere. read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - BLT with barely any lettuce. A pretty pathetic sandwich if you ask me. - Sandwiches Near Me - Oakley, California

See all

Good sandwiches & chocolate chip cookies, not good macaroni salad it's pre made not homemade, girl taking my order corrected me twice when I was placing my order by telling me the names of the sandwiches I was ordering... I didn't have their menu in front of me at the time, I just felt like... really. it's kinda expensive almost $25 for two sandwiches but they are good.. read more

Great Sandwiches with lots of meat. My favorite is Turkey with Avocado. Staff is very friendly and helpful with good service. Very relaxing to eat inside. read more

My wife and I have eaten here several times but our last visit didn't provide the quality we are used to. I asked for no mayo on my sandwich, which the server did, but then it was drowned yellow mustard - couldn't taste much else on the sandwich. Sourdough bread was really good though. Also, the Staff seemed somewhat disinterested during our visit. Even with the 2 for 1 sandwich coupon, don't think I'll be going back; not a fan of yellow mustard and the overall experience was a little disappointing this time. read more

This place used to be great. The staff used to be friendly, food good value for your money. Lately, not so much. Last 3 times I've been there the staff is rude and the sandwiches are lacking. Yesterday, my son and daughter went to get lunch for us (5 sandwiches). A man made 3 and a girl made 2. The 3 from the man were as expected. The girl's not so much. The had 1/2 a Big Easy. There was hardly any meat on there and what was there was dry. Had 1/2 avocado slice, hardly any veggies, and bread was falling apart. My husband had turkey and only 3 slices. They were saying she was rude and acted like they were an inconvenience to her. I wasn't going to say anything, but based upon a post and comments on the Oakley Around the Block FB page this has become the norm there. They're even talking about if come in 30 minutes before closing you're told they're closed and not making any more sandwiches. I love Mr Pickles and the convenience of the location. I just am not sure about going back if the food and service continues to be what it is. I hope something change before enough people stop going and the owner, who is great, loses the place. read more

I was skeptical at first but It was Delicious, Moms lives super close so I'll probably be back read more

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - super delicious , Thanks - Sandwiches Near Me - Oakley, California

Since moving to California we have been looking for a good sub. We found one at Mr. Pickle. They are relatively good prices for a yummy sandwich. You can also get a salad if you are trying to go low carb. I usually get the "Big Jake" filled with turkey, cheese, avocado, cream cheese and all the fixings. My husband gets the "Tom Turkey" which has turkey, cheese and bacon. You can order your sandwich with everything which includes: lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, pepperoncinis, mayo, mustard, and garlic sauce. With every sandwich you can make it a combo by adding chips and a drink. The best part is with every sandwich you get a free chocolate chip cookie! My husband did order the tri tip sandwich one time and it was not good. The meat had a rainbow tinge to it like it was undercooked. So beware of that! read more

Very rude to out of town guests!! Complete attitudes with No accommodations for anyone who left their mask at home! Refused to give the phone order of 3 sandwiches and even yelled! read more

My roast beef and ham sandwich was excellent. Pickup was ready on time and easy to grab and go.

I made the common mistake that mom's make thinking they have more time than they actually do. I ordered lunch for our daughter and I before hopping in the shower and head to work, and then I realized if I went to go pick it up, I would be running late for work. Unfortunately I didn't choose the delivery option. I chose to pick up the option I called the store and spoke to the manager Cynthia and explained to her the pickle I was in. Cynthia went out of her way to drop off our lunches so I wouldn't be late for work not only did she do that but she didn't charge me a dime I offered to get her Starbucks gift card or something for her compensation and she said no worries! I am still in shock at how great she overexceeded customer service; this is what we need more than the world customer service going above and beyond to make the customers happy. Because of Cynthia, I will make sure I only support this location. Thank you so much, Cynthia. You're an amazing manager. read more

I frequent a lot of different Mr. Pickels sandwich shops around the area. The staff in the Oakley location are rude. I'll never patronize the Oakley location again when I can go elsewhere. read more

I hadn't been to Mr Pickles for awhile as it wasn't great last time but I thought I'd give it another chance as I like to support local businesses. I won't be going back again, the sourdough roll was stale at the ends, the sandwiches were tasteless and had so much dressing on them they were slimey and very little meat. Guess I'll be driving a little further to get an edible sandwich. read more

On more than one occasion they are Out of items, giving people hard ends of bread and assembling messy sandwiches. It's unfortunate that this place is lacking...guess i'll make the drive to Antioch. read more