This place is dangerous! I went in for four muffins for the fam and left with a half dozen and an iced coffee. I ate the Boston cream on my way home. It was exactly what it sounds like it should have been. The young lady behind the counter was friendly and courteous. I will definitely return for more, but I will need to space out my visits before I end up becoming a muffin myself. read more

We used this store to cater a large district-wide event, and it was a huge hit! It was very easy to work with the catering department. They have great prices, everything was delivered as ordered, and the participant feedback has been very positive. Looking forward to working with them in the future! read more

Amazing variety of unique muffins. I love the minis at great price so you can try different flavors. Bagels like jalapenos and spinach are awesome. You cant find anything like this around here and definitely not at the Einsteins. I like to stop by for a quick bite on Sunday mornings around 10. The crews are friendly, helpful. Few Sunday's ago to my surprise, I saw the owner at the store. I have never seen him during the weekends. I figure things were lot better that day but nope. All of the tables were dirty as usual, napkins on the floor and things were in need of cleaning. We had to clean our own table to sit down. I wonder what the hecks going on here lately. This place could use wipe down more often. Its the best muffin/bagel place I can find around here. I would have given 5 stars but one is taken off for the dirtiness of the table. read more

See all

The muffins have been a family favorite for over 20 years. My kids loved them as toddlers and now as adults when in town they still want a box! read more

Well I have driven by MFM for a few years now driving to work. I received a coupon in the mail for a BOGO on a muffin. When I walked in the store looked very clean and organized. The person behind the counter seemed a little bored as I was not greeted, and no attempt was made to upsell me. I purchased 2 muffins but was not asked if I wanted a coffee or anything to drink? I ordered a blueberry muffin and a chocolate cheesecake. The size of the muffins are average which is kind of dissapointing given the 2.50 each price tag. The muffin itself was ok but seemed a bit dense and lacked any real blueberry flavor. It did not seem as though whole blueberries were used in the muffins. The chocolate cheesecake muffin was ok. I have a coupon for a BOGO for a sandwich with a drink purchase I will probably not bother to use it or the buy 2 get 2 bagels. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Blueberry muffin without much blueberry flavor. Average size too. Not my favorite muffin. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

Very generic and basic. One of the worst breakfast sandwiches I have EVER had! As a restaurant that emphasizes "'muffin" you would think this IS their staple......nope! Tasted like a 4 pack of Muffins at your local supermarket. Walking into an empty room, at lunchtime, should have been a clear sign to about face. I won't be back read more

This place rocks!! The bagels and muffins are fresh daily and their breakfast sandwiches are delicious and made fresh in front of you. You should also grab lunch here, their deli sandwiches are the bomb as well. we made the mistake of trying another bagel joint down the street... whooops big mistake. We won't be stepping out on My Fav Muffin again lesson learned Tehe!! :) read more

Every time I drove down Arapahoe, I would drive by the sign that reads "My Favorite Muffin" and be so irrationally intrigued. Muffins are fine and all, never really put much thought into them. But something about this place called for me and one day I finally answered. It looks like they have some sandwiches and bagels available as well, but I was on a mission. I grabbed a box of 4 of what looked like the most delicious. muffins, at least to me. We are chocolate lovers in this house so I chose 1 double chocolate, 1 chocolate chip and 2 chocolate cheesecakes. I'm gonna have to agree with the store name: these ARE my favorite muffins. You kinda think you're eating a cupcake because they are moist and fluffy and so delicious. My favorite FAVORITE muffin out of the bunch we tried was definitely the chocolate cheesecake. Did I say moist? Well these were extra. If that sign keeps calling you like it did me, stop fighting it. Come on in and meet your favorite muffin. read more

My husband loves My Favorite Muffin so we decided to take my parents to this location last Saturday for our farewell before they headed back home. We walked in and the place was completely empty other than staff so we took our time checking out the menu. I was pretty disappointed that they couldn't make a single drink with decaf coffee. The woman I spoke to said everything is made with a powder, so decaf was not possible. The muffins looked great, as usual! As we were deciding on them, the young girl running the register walked over to ask if it was for there or to go. We told her we were eating there, as we were planning to eat outside. She then decided to mention that they were closing soon, at 2. That irritated both my husband and I because it was only 1:30. Clearly, it left a sour taste for us. We just don't believe that is excellent customer service. read more

I really wanted to try this place. Heard wonderful things about the deserts and bagel sandwiches. I am new to the Denver area. This particular place is next door to where I am currently living. However, from the time I walked in the door, I did not feel welcomed. It took 10 minutes for the guy staff to even say I will be right with you. I said no problem. As I am standing in line someone else walks in, instead of saying "How could I help you" or taking my order. The other cashier immediately took this guy's order. I politely walked out the door. I refuse to patronize this business. It is apparent customer service is not My Favorite Muffin's thing. read more

Stopped in for a dozen mini's to take to an appointment. I decided to also have a quick lunch sandwich. Turkey, Bacon and Cheese on an Everything bagel. WOW, that was a great idea. I wolfed that down before I even got out of the parking lot. I was on the run and had only about 5 mins to spare to be on time for an appointment a few miles away. I was all about that sandwich and my appointment was all about the muffins I brought along. Shame they aren't open earlier and a little later. read more

It's Sunday. I tried this place again. They can't get orders straight, no coffee in any of the carafes and people don't get it. Why did I bother read more

I love this place. They introduced me to the breakfast blt and it is delicious. This is an amazing local place. Every time I enter I see locals sitting and enjoying their morning. Kind of a bagel version of CHEERS. Love love it here! read more

Excellent customer service, I wasn't sure what to get and the man helped me get an Assortment of the most popular muffins. The interaction made my entire day, thank you! read more

Take a word of advice. Break up with that dough! Do you want a nice side piece? Then you need to come to My Favorite Muffin to get that bread! Delicious breakfast sandwiches and cherry cheesecake muffin made me believe in side pieces! Spend that check and get it right back!! read more

Hands down the best bagels ever!! Always are so fresh and not hard. Love the Salsa Jalapeno cream cheese... mmmmmm

Muffins here are miles and miles away from normal! There's a huge selection and I haven't had a bad one yet. The Georgia Peach is amazing...tastes like a crumb peach cobbler. Even had big slices of real peaches in it! The deep dish apple is another amazing one! Love this place!!! read more

Sensational experience, I am so ecstatic that the Glen Allen area, welcomes My Favorite Muffin to the area, I love the selection of delicious epicurean bagels and Muffins offered by this establishment. So many delicious options to choose from that are freshly prepared !!!! read more

I have gone here regularly since it is on my way to the office-and their food is really good- - unfortunately I've alwsys felt the counter staff has consistently been abrupt and unwelcoming. I have to be in a tolerant state of mind to deal with the negativity and "forced" customer service smiles which I get every time. I've worked in customer facing service positions a lot ~on the OTHER side if the counter...so I always just hope they are having an off day and it will be better the next time...not the case. My daughter was in ftom TX visiting and went there for a Breakfast sandwich on her own... Came home asking me what was up with the place I had recommended... she said they seemed annoyed with her and abrupt. When she got home she realized that her breakfast sandwich did not have the egg on it to top off her experience. Thinking I'm done at this point. Customer service is a huge part of any establishment no matter how good the food is. Sad...because I like the place read more

Not sure what's going on with this place anymore... We order the Southern Tradition bacon, egg, and cheese, with cream cheese breakfast bagels and they have been wrong the last 3 times we've been there!! My personal favorite was when the egg was missing from all our sandwiches. I called to complain, no one answered the phone, I left a message and did not receive any call back. Hence this crappy public review, as they could not remedy it with an apology and a fix. Please note, the owner is present and at times making our incorrect sandwiches. read more

I love My Favorite Muffin. I was introduced to MFM about two years ago when my wife (die hard sweet tooth and muffin lover) told me we needed to try a new spot for Sunday morning breakfast. I'm thinking, "Honey, I'm a dude...man needs more than muffins alone to survive until my next feeding." Needless to say I was pleasantly surprise by the numerous options made available to a MFM customer. From your typical bagels and cream cheese to your not so typical sandwiches, breakfast eats and smoothies this place seems to have a little something for everyone. Here we are two years later and I'm still hitting MFM for breakfast on Sundays. Not only on Sunday mornings, but often treat my office to a box of muffins, mini-muffins or bagels from this spot at least once a week. The great thing about MFM is the staff. From the moment you walk in these folks actually care about you being at their counter and do their absolute best to be sure you're getting what you want. Breakfast made your way. Hot, fresh and minus the spread, add bacon, cut in half diagonally...whatever, these guys want to make your morning. Great job honey...I guess I really can survive on muffins alone. read more

Very disappointed in the muffins I received. The muffin I got was undercooked and it was like eating undercooked bread dough. For the price I could have gotten double the quantity at Walmart and they would have tasted better. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

The name says it all; this is definitely My Favorite Muffin!! Since my very first bite of the Chocolate Chip muffin I have been hooked. That may sound awfully dramatic, but yes it is that good, and I don't typically like sweets! Strangely my car seems to navigate there on its own without my directive. I know what you're thinking, enough gushing on to the review... - The selection of muffins, bagels, pastries is vast and its fun to try unique combinations. I would also recommend the latte and the drip coffees, great flavors! I highly recommend the Apple Muffin, Chocolate Muffin and Everything Bagel. - They offer indoor and outdoor seating, always a great option on a lazy Sunday morning. I can't say the view is anything special as it looks out to Arapahoe Road but never the less outdoor seating :) -The prices are fairly average for all of the items and well worth it read more

My Favorite Muffin - A Haiku Their Muffin Top is not all that. Too Sweet for me. A Ninja Cupcake This place gets a lot of love. I just dont see it. Its a fine establishment. The people are nice. The service is good. The muffins . . . not so much. . . I just don't get into them like most people do. Too sweet. And if I am in the mood for sweets, I can do much better. A muffin is supposed to be something you can eat at brunch. Most of the muffins here are way closer to the cupcake end of the spectrum. And if I want a cupcake, there are places for that too! All of that said, I go here whenever I have a morning meeting. These things KILL at morning meetings. People flock to them like crack. I will never know why. read more

Of all the local places for some baked goods, this is one of the few worth the trip. They don't have a wide range of cookies and cakes, but they have reeeeeealllly good muffins!! They have big ones and mini ones, mostly in the same flavors.. They have an amazing variety of muffins, chocolate, chocolate chip, pumpkin, fruit - you name it! the kids LOVE the mini ones.. they provide them in great "authentic" white bakery boxes, a nice touch for those from towns where "real" bakeries exist. They also have crepes - I've never had one. They also have bagels.. I really want to love them, but I can only muster a "they're good and suck less than Einstein's." They have too many bagels covered in cheese and other "heretical" varieties, but they do, thankfully, have sesame, poppy, everything, and the good ones. They do, however, have some excellent cream cheeses! Cinnamon/honey is a big favorite of mine. If you're entertaining for breakfast/brunch, grab a big box of muffins - your guests will thank you! read more

This is for the store on Arapahoe Rd. First time I went I got unfriendly service from the lady at the counter. Maybe she was having a bad day though. Since the muffins were really good, and for curiosity, I decided to try again. This time the man helped me. He greeted me with "You ready to order, or what?!" Needless to say, I won't be going back. I ordered the same two flavors, the blueberry muffin and the coconut cream pie muffin. They were both delicious, and the store is very clean. I would have given five stars if it weren't for the service with a scowl. read more

People are right when they say these muffins are more like dessert muffins. I had the Boston creme pie which is really good but a slightly different mix up and it could have been easily a cupcake. So these muffins are like a 1st cousin to a cupcake. Which does not mean they are not good/ delicious. The main reason why I gave them just an a-ok is that I also tried to enjoy one of their bagels but their bagels are not like regular bagels their different. I can defiantly tell their fattier nothing like Einstein's. I don't think I will get their bagels again. Their thinner but, I don't know I just think they have a weird makeup. I prefer other places bagel over theirs. So I think I will stick with the items in the companies name MUFFINS. P.S. Muffins are a bit pricey so be prepared. read more

My kids love the bagels and the muffins. However, the service in the restaurant is consistently and utterly horrendous. The person that greets you takes your bagel order. Inevitably, they walk away from you before you have even finished your order. If you want a muffin too, you then stand in front of the muffin counter for countless minutes before the next person takes your order. For some unknown reason, the person that takes your bagel order can't take your muffin order too. To top it all off, you'll wait 5 minutes at the register for the next employee to acknowledge you so you can pay them. I wish this was a rare experience, but it literally happens every time and I have countless stories to back this up. I wish we had another option. My suggestion: train your employees. It's anarchy in there. read more

I am not big on muffins at all, but a co-worker brought in some cherry cream muffins today and yes, these things are good! Really tasty - even gets five stars for being tasty and me never being in the store. Dang! read more

I don't know. The muffins haven't been all that great to me and they don't have a good selection of beverages. I mean, hell, I can put my own tea bag in water. Only because there is a lack of bakeries in the area, do I see myself returning here unless I stop being lazy all together and just make my own at home. read more

The name is just what I would have called it if it had been named something else... They have the best stuff here. The blueberry muffin is killer and I'd let it kill me because the chocolate cheesecake ones are to die for... Get an assortment of mini muffins, which pack all the goodness of a large one, but fewer bites. Yum! They have a french toast bagel that is awesome. Take that diet! read more

MFM was a nice treat. A few complaints real quick... not being from the area, it's in a 'funky' location and a bit tricky to find if you don't know where you're going (like me, most of the time), and someone, please keep the coffees full in the morning! This is a quaint place and the selection was awesome. The muffins look yummy and there were plenty to choose from, but I was in the mood for a bagel (I just had a muffin the day before for breakfast). It was good, a little flat, and the cream cheese was light and tasty! One problem I did have was the coffee. They had a great selection but the coffee lacked the flavor I was anticipating, there were 3 caf, and 1 decaf to choose from. They had a pumpkin spice flavor and I went to get some and it was empty, blurg... same with the irish cream... uggh! It's breakfast and certain people require their coffee in order to function. I didn't mention it to the employees, and maybe I should have. I just thought there was more than enough staff to accommodate the coffee levels. My son had a french toast bagel with honey-cinnamon cream cheese, it was awesome, I had the everything bagel with the veggie cream cheese and my wife went with the cheese bagel. All-in-all we all left satisfied and if I'm in the area again in the AM I'm going to go and get my "muffin on"! read more

These aren't muffins... these are giant decadent cakes! I love the desserty muffins because they taste just like the dessert! e.g. Their strawberry cheesecake muffin has cream cheese/strawberry creamy creation in the middle and the muffin is so moist and sweet, i love it. I can never finish a whole one to myself... but all the better to share so I get a nibble/taste of all the wonderful flavors that they have! My favorite so far have been this mixed berry muffin.. it had raspberry, blueberry and I think cranberry (?) with a less cakey texture and more bran muffin texture - so it was a great balance of sweet and normal muffin. Whatever it's made of, it was off the hook and I finished way more than I should have. I am oh so glad (or horrified? cursed?) that this place is so near the office... they tend to come around a lot for these office meetings.... read more

This place was hopping the Sunday morning I stopped by, which mean fresh everything, nothing sitting in the hopper for too long. It's kind of three places in one; a bagel place like Einsteins that serves bagels as well as the breakfast sandwiches, a coffee place that has all your funky drinks both hot and cold, and a muffin store. There were about 16 types of regular sized muffins and 8 mini-muffins to choose from, but for $2.15 per regular sized muffin, I chose a bagel instead. That's a little steep for a relatively small muffin. Think of the ones they serve at King Soopers and take the size down by 30%, and then increase the price 4x. The options on the muffins were very much on the sweet side - nothing in the banana walnut or bran or blueberry area. It was all dessert style muffins. But my bagel was very good as was my chai tea. You can bring some picky eaters here and they'll find something they like, there are a lot of choices. Bonus: They have outdoor seating. read more

Bagels are my weakness, and they have an abundance here! I love the variety of bagels they have and you can tell they are fresh. They also have a good spread of spreads, so it's fun to mix and match flavors. read more

We used to go all the time when kids were younger and muffins were great, now we go when they come home or grandkids are here but every time it seems the muffins are dried out and you have to ask for icing on them and even then they forget to put it on, didn't know until we got home. I don't understand why it went downhill but last few times it was a bad experience and we won't be going again. read more

I first discovered this place in Nevada...so when I was driving through centennial and spotted this little gem, I had to stop in to see if it was the same. It most definitely is the same chain of "my favorite muffins" and I LOVE it here! The breakfast is always fresh and delicious and the staff is very welcoming. I'm very excited to have found this spot, once again! read more

Staff is super friendly, very quiet and relaxed and great assirtiin of muffins, Smoothies,sabdwhiches,a omelette and more. Very clean too. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Nice place, worth a sunday stop - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

We had the chocolate chocolate chip muffin and a loaded bagel. The bagel was recommended to us by a local. It was toasted with jalapeño cheese, turkey, ham, tomato and cream cheese on a onion bagel. It was delicious. The chocolate chocolate chip muffin was rich and very tasty. It tasted more like a soft chewy brownie than a muffin. Well worth trying both. read more

This place as fantastic bagels and muffins! Great breakfast sandwiches! They need honey for their tea, though. Always friendly and helpful! read more

My Favorite Muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado