Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mystic Lobster Roll

    4.0 (51 reviews)
    Closed 8:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Updated 1 month ago

    Order Mystic Lobster Roll Takeout or Delivery

    Mystic Lobster Roll Photos

    MYSTIC LOBSTER ROLL ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Mystic Lobster Roll

    Recommended Reviews - Mystic Lobster Roll

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Audra D.

    I know the price of a lobster roll in LBI is $30 a roll. But, I got a very small amount of lobster for $30. Sorry, that's a rip off.

    Cassy B.

    I absolutely recommend Mystic for all your lobster roll needs while in LBI. I placed an order from Mystic around 6 PM and my boyfriend went to go pick it up right before they closed. He said everyone was so friendly and that it had died down by the time he got there since they were closing up. we got three lobster rolls to try. One was the surf and turf, one was a Connecticut, and lastly a main lobster roll. All of them were absolutely delicious. I went for the Maine lobster roll even though there were so many tempting other options. I wanted to try a normal roll first to see the quality and it did not disappoint. The huge chunks of fresh lobster tasted so perfect with the buttery potato roll. On their menu they have a huge lobster roll list, some look super fun. I believe they have one other a Chipotle aioli and candied jalepenos! I think that's my next go-to. We also got the lobster bisque and the shrimp and corn chowder to try. The woman recommended warming it up on the stove but you can easily also do it on the microwave. We went for the lobster bisque first and it was absolutely delicious. The shrimp and corn chowder was even better in my opinion. Lots of shrimp and with the perfect amount of heat and sweetness to it. This place is definitely quality ingredients and guarantees freshness. They're right off the main Boulevard and have a nice size parking lot. They are also famous for their breakfast sandwiches which I definitely have to try one day. Their regular sandwich menu is incredibly extensive as well and I want to try out one of those two for the beach one day. All around a very solid lobster roll. I was craving one and this was absolutely delicious.

    Big Blue Building on the West side of the Blvd
    Cayla J.

    Went here for dinner on a Sunday night. The restaurant was clean with plenty of seating indoors (a few spots to eat outside!) Went shopping at Farias across the street while we waited for the food- ordered fries, a lobster roll, and two tacos (~$50) that were ready within 10 minutes! The lobster was fresh and buttered generously with a good meat to bread ratio. Chicken tacos were light and satisfying- loaded with avocado and spring lettuce. Bonus points kickin coleslaw & juicy pickles that come with the meals. Looking forward to my next dining experience there

    Maine Lobster Roll
    Gillian D.

    Still a fan favorite in our family for lobster rolls on the island. We called in our order, and this was a great way to save some time on waiting! They told us our order of 5 sandwiches would take about 20 minutes. I tried the BLT Lobster Roll today, looking for something more complex in flavor than your standard Maine roll. The bacon/lobster combo was delicious, but I wished there was a bit more lettuce - and I wished the tomato had a bit more flavor to it. Despite those notes, I'd definitely still order it again. Also ordered in our group today, we had some standard Maine rolls, and even a surf & turf roll, all containing the generous portions of lobster served up Mystic Meats style. I've posted their 2022 Season Menu here, I noticed the one on their webpage loads too blurry to read. Hope this is helpful!

    Menu 2/2
    Alyona Z.

    5/5/20 Driving through town for work, I got the sudden urge for some seafood, especially since I'm near the sea. I called over 10 restaurants only to get no answers. I was giving up and leaving this town, when upon departing, I drive by this location, only to do a u-turn and come back here. Boy! I am beyond thrilled to have came here! I ordered the lobster roll and had the lobster warmed up, as I prefer it warm vs cold. The staff was super friendly and welcoming and even helped me figure out what to order. The food was so delicious! Honestly, it was the BEST lobster roll I've had so far! I would highly recommend ordering the Maine lobster roll with the warm buttery bun. It was so delicious! You won't be disappointed.

    Lobster to go!
    Mort C.

    Nice little deli spot for ginormous sandwiches and freshly made lobster rolls. Not the greatest one I've had(sorry Quincys still takes it!) but very tasty and clean lobster flavor!! Worth a visit....

    Italian Chicken Cutlet 20" sub

    All summer we enjoyed fresh fish from Mystic. Our older boys and friends talked about the subs and said they are the best. Amongst our favorite is the Italian cutlet - chicken cutlets, tomatoes , roasted red pepper & fresh mozzarella with a balsamic glaze. Operated by very nice people & they are open year round, definitely try!

    Nadia C.

    excellent lobster roll! the bread really makes the roll. it's perfectly crisp with good amount of butter. they don't skimp out on the lobster chunks and meat either. definitely going back!

    Our Famous Italian, 20 inches!!! THIS SANDWICH IS HUGE!!!!!!
    Donna D.

    This is truly an amazing sandwich shop! We got the Our Famous Italian 20" sub and holy cow!!! It's huuuuuuge! I love spots that have crazy food items! I know some of you are gonna be like that's too big, but lets be honest, this is awesome, and your really buying 2 sandwiches in one! Finally a place worthy of 5 stars! And yes, the sandwich was delicious! Definitely coming back because of this!

    Surf and turf lobster roll

    See all

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of E K.
    0
    8
    0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    the lobster rolls were awesome and the staff is very nice and helpful. definitely check this place out!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Loved there Lobster roll it's warm lobster on a toasted long bun.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Mystic Lobster Roll Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Mystic Lobster Roll

    Are they open through October?

    Hello, yes we are open until New Years Eve - we are open every day 9a-5p except Wednesday we are closed.… 

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Howard's Seafood Restaurant

    Howard's Seafood Restaurant

    3.8
    (198 reviews)
    4.2 mi
    $$$

    Definitely won't be going back. Both the Lobster bisque & NE clam chowder were excellent with loads…read moreof lobster/clams in each serving. The salads should have been served chilled , not room temperature. Fried lobster dish was average and pricey. Would be better if broiled. My flounder w/crabmeat was burned on the bottom & dry. Also, a fly in the milk for my coffee. Overall, very disappointing. Service , by Maura , was efficient and attentive. Ambience was poor - very loud from patron's conversations. Decor is stark wood walls with local historical photos. Should have curtains/drapes or acoustic panels to absorb the noise.

    Howard's is an LBI classic for a reason. It's a calm, refined space for a family dinner, and the…read morefood is solid. The French fried lobster and the crab cakes are delicious, but my personal favorite is the blackened tuna steak. The apps and sides (calamari, clams scampi, etc.) are also tasty. Portions and sides are generous. You will not leave Howard's hungry! The servers are friendly, and not overly attentive. Just right. My one suggestion: Freshen it up a bit! Would love to see more nightly specials, some new sauces, and vegetable options beyond broccoli.

    Photos
    Howard's Seafood Restaurant
    Blackened Tuna topped with chilled citrus butter & diced tomato vinaigrette
    Blackened Tuna topped with chilled citrus butter & diced tomato vinaigrette
    Pan-fried swordfish fillet with golden breadcrumb crust,topped with arugula, tomato, cucumber, Kalamata olives, red onion &zesty vinaigrette

    See all

    Pan-fried swordfish fillet with golden breadcrumb crust,topped with arugula, tomato, cucumber, Kalamata olives, red onion &zesty vinaigrette

    Mystic Lobster Roll - sandwiches - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...