Updating my review 2.5 years later because we decided to give them another chance. Everything we ordered this time was pretty fantastic. The stuffed cheese pizza was hot and melty and the crust was crispy and buttery. So yummy. The spaghetti with meatballs and marinara was excellent as well. We also ordered the loaded Parmesan pesto waffle fries. They looked like a hot mess that tasted great. Happy to see this location caring about what they are sending out to their customers. Thank you! read more

See all

I can't justify $31 for a small 10" thin crust with 2 meat toppings and 3 veggies toppings. I was driving so I wasn't thinking when I ordered thinking 10" was a typical size pizza but it is slightly larger than a personal pizza. We rarely eat pizza so this took us by surprise. I think we remembered having a large full topping pizzas for $25 was normal. But this is a small 10". The pizza was okay, nothing spectacular, slightly better than your typical pizza chain. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - $31 for 10" small classic thin custom 2 meats 3 veggies. - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

I wanted pizza, and I had Nancy's at an event not too long ago and it was good, so I decided to give it a try... I know things aren't as cheap as they used to be, but there's no way to justify a medium pizza being $40! Like, never. I guess I'll start on the hunt to find something reasonably priced. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Pricing - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

I'm FROM Chicago and this pizza is truly overrated, overpriced and flavorless. Ordered the classic thin crust pizza. The crust and edges weren't at all crispy and flakey as classic Chicago tavern-style pizza SHOULD be. Ingredients, dough and sauce were all super bland, and FLAVOR is what makes true Chicago-style pizza. Not to mention I called to place an order and was put on hold for over 15 min. Overheard the kid on the other end chit chatting with a customer for 10 min AND taking another order before mine. When he picked up the phone again, I simply told him that I will place my order inside instead. I was driving when I initially called and was on hold so long that I had arrived there before he picked back up again. I then told the kid respectfully that a 15 min hold to place an order is unacceptable, especially when I heard him socializing and taking another order before mine. There was only one person in the store when I walked in as well, so it wasn't as if they were slammed. No apology, no remorse, nothing. Not the absolute end of the world, but I hate how often people these days don't seem to know to apologize for inconveniencing customers. I would've let all that slide. But, once I got home and tasted this insult to Chicago pizza, I had to give fair warning to potential future patrons. Take it from this Chicagoan. This place does NOT do justice to great Chicago Tavern-style pizza. Save your money. read more

We ordered the small 9in stuffed pizza pie with mushrooms, onions, green bell peppers. This is def Chicago style deep dish pizza. I'm pretty picky with cheese because sometimes there's a borderline of milk mold type smell like a bad Swiss and I just hate that :( but this place does not have that, they have a high quality cheese, a crafted sauce that's not sour/tangy it's just savory and a tad sweet perfected. The toppings are there they didn't skimp. This could feed 4-5 people with normal appetites it's pretty rich and full. If you're not a cheese lover I'd say go with the normal style pizza because this is wayyyy too much cheese for me I ordered this via a delivery service so can't attest to customer service Since we don't specialize or have a lot of Chicago style pizza places I'd rate this place 5 stars read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - 9" Small Original Stuffed Pizza, can feed 4-5 people - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

The pizza was delicious. Reminds me of true authentic Chicago style pizza. Will most definitely be ordering from them soon. I just want to try their Italian beef sandwich next time read more

I saw recommendations for this Pizzaria in a FB group i follow. I was sort of in the area and decided to place an order since I was in mood for pizza. I have to say, i was disappointed. I ordered a small thin crust cheese. The cheese was the best part of the pizza to me. It didn't have enough sauce for my taste but the crust tasted really odd. I can't place It. Really different than typical pizza crust ... I would not return read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

See all

Some of the best pizza I've ever eaten. If you get the pie one slice is more than enough to fill you up.

You can't go wrong with Nancy's Pizza. It's so good. I usually order for delivery but a few times I have decide to drive and pick it up. I have to say I'm from Chicago and Nancy is very popular there for great pizza. I was very happy to see that they opened up a location close to my home. Everything is good. I have tried the pizza, thin, stuffed, all of the salads the Italian beef sandwiches. It's a small location so it's carry out only. The staff is very friendly, when you walk in they always greet you. I also love that if they make a mistake they work to make it right. I love this place. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

See all

The food is outstanding. The best deep dish pizza in the south I do believe. They also serve traditional Chicago thin pizza. Overall A++ on the food. This is a new franchise location for Nancy's and they literally opened about two weeks ago. As such, they have a lot of customer service kinks to work out. I placed a $40 order online for pickup and when I arrived I learned their printer was out of ink and hadn't printed any online orders out, so my pizzas weren't even started yet. They went ahead and made the pizzas while I waited and comped my whole order which was awesome. Give them some time to work out the kinks and this is going to be one of the best pizza places around! read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Founders of Nancy's - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

This place is take out only. I've had Gino's East, Giordano's, Uno's, Lou Malnati's and many other excellent deep dish Chicago pizzas. Nancy's is every bit as good.if not better. I've been disappointed with some deep dish pizzas in the South before, but this IS the real deal. read more

Mainly rated this poorly because they placed foil on top of our to go pizza, which made the cheese get stuck on the foil. Ruined a good chunk of the pizza. The taste was ok. The breadsticks were better. We will not be ordering again even though it was ready earlier than their estimate. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

The only real Chicago deep dish pizza chain we have near ATL. This one is a small location by the highway off Suwanee/Lawrenceville. Be warned there is no indoor seating, so if it rains it's pretty much just takeout! The cashier was really friendly and funny. Purely food based review; Medium ($36) - We got one of the premade ones that had a variety of stuff in it. Took about 30 minutes to make but it was piping hot. Each slice is definitely deserving of its own small meal. You'll be satisfied. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

NANCYYYYYY!!! Girl! You put yo FOOT in this dang pizza! Easily , the best pizza I've had in my 33 years of life. My small 9" in stuffed pizza with pepperoni and mushroom was amazing. It was hot and fresh , the sauce was delicious and just a little sweet, but the cheese, it was the cheese for me. They also were not stingy with the toppings. This size pizza could easily feed 2 - 4. It was absolutely worth every penny. I thoroughly enjoyed this pizza , I will be back! read more

See all

Great Chicago Pizza!!!!!!!!! You will enjoy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Good customer service!!! read more

Best Chicago style pizza in town!! I was skeptical to try this pizza place since it is a franchise, didn't expect the best. But wow, now Georgia has the best Chicago style pizza place in Gwinnett county. One slice of stuffed pizza can get you very full but doesn't feel too greasy. The place has a welcoming atmosphere and workers have great services. You are missing out if you haven't checked this one place yet. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - a person taking a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

See all

Lawrenceville has a Nancy's and I'm excited about it! Yes, the pizzas are stuffed and heavy, loaded down with yummy goodness. I ordered and stuffed cheese pizza and a Uncle Tony's stuffed pizza and they did not disappoint, could only get down 1 slice -lol. The crust is soooo good and the cheese is Thick! Prepare to pay around $30 for a small specialty pizza. (Prices are up, but still worth it).5 stars all the way! read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

Great pizza consistently! Being from Chicago and being used to Chicago deep dish, I was Leary of trying this place but now it's the only place my husband and I will eat pizza from. We love it! read more

FINALLY!! A true authentic Chicago pizza joint here in Lawrenceville!! On numerous occasions I have shelled out hundreds of bucks to have Giordanos Pizza packed in dry ice and shipped in all the way from the Chi. So when I heard of this new spot opening up down the street I was more than skeptical. But let me tell you... not only is it as authentic as it comes- but in my opinion, it outshines Giordano's by a landslide! CRUST - The outer crust has a crispy sturdiness that holds the integrity of the pie together, but still manages to maintain buttery flaky texture that melts in your mouth. This is a hard find in a lot of Chicago deep-dish pizzas in my opinion! SAUCE - Secondly, the vine-ripened tomato sauce has a fresh sweet flavor that's good enough to be tossed in pasta, coupled w/ some Italian sausage, and served as an entree! *note The sauce MAY be too thick & chunky to some people's liking. My daughter loved the flavor, but thought it was a little too chunky. ‍ but to each his own... CHEESE - The mozzarella was high grade, thick, full of flavor, and not lacking in quantity. The video I posted with this review showcases the beautiful cheese pull! AND that slice was cut after a 25 minute "TO-GO" drive home! TOPPINGS - The pepperoni and Italian sausage were high grade and very robust in flavor. The sausage was not cut into the commercialized "mini nuggets" like you'll find at the 30-min delivery spots. Instead, the pizza was stacked with what seemed to be a LAYER of ground Italian sausage; so almost every bite contained a chunk of that delicious "sage-y" flavor. GLUTEN-FREE CRUST - My wife hailed her GF pizza as the best she's ever had. I personally do not prefer GF crust, but after having a bite of hers, I must agree! They somehow managed to capture the crispy , yet flaky texture that is prevalent in the deep dish crust. WELL DONE!! PRICE - Let's be clear. This isn't a Little Caesar's $5 Hot N Ready party... We paid $70 for a medium deep dish (fed 5), a medium gluten free pizza (fed 3), and a box of cannolis (fed ME ). But in terms of quality, exclusivity, & experience... it's worth EVERY SINGLE dime. It's a GREAT choice if you're entertaining guests, especially if they've never had true Chicago Deep Dish! STAFF - They've only been open a couple weeks, and I'm not gonna lie, Nancy's is in HIGH-demand, but they are GREATLY under-staffed. Team-spirit and team-morale are high, but you can feel the tension and pressure to perform as soon as you walk into the place. I witnessed 2 customers complaining about the wait during the 15 minutes I was there, but the staff was super sweet, apologetic, and honestly were doing their best. My order came out right on time, so I had no complaints at all ‍ All in all, this is a GREAT spot that I will be frequenting in the days to come! They only offer TO-GO tho!! read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Medium Gluten-Free Thin Crust Half - Pepperoni Half - Pepperoni, Sausage, & mushroom's Best GF pizza we've ever had!! - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

See all

Nothing less than orgasmic! Thank you!! This was the best pizza delivery I've had in my 50 years on this rock! Worth every cent!

So-so pizza, crust was kind of tough/stale. Pretty expensive & not the best I've had. Probably won't go back

Great food service was great The cleanliness of the restaurant is very good I will be back soon read more

The pizza is Bomb!!!!! The best I ever had in Atlanta. Great service as well. The Midwest party cuts allow you to get more slices and they have a family size which is bigger than an XL 18 in pie. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

See all

Pizza was ok. Very odd pricing. they offer "favorites" that have names but you have to pay for each topping separately. On the stuffed pizza, there was more undercooked dough than toppings and cheese. And the bbq pizza with pineapple had entirely too much pineapple. I won't go back read more

The best Chicago deep dish pizza in Atlanta. Good tavern style too (thin). Deep dish is not hand held.

Pizzas were pretty good (extra crispy sausage). Price should have been a little less. The girls at the counter could have displayed a little more enthusiasm for your business. I'll likely go back to the thin crust at Fini's. Better staff at the front door. read more

Hiding in a quiet shopping center. Place is kinda blowing up and saw a lot of foot traffic going in and out. Mostly a carry out spot. Pizza was fantastic!! The pepperoni was under the cheese. It was about a 20 inch pie. A little pricey for my taste it was about $25 bucks, but I'd check them out again. Trying the deep dish next. Oh! had an order of meat balls too about $6 bucks for two. They were great as well. Ate them too quick and didn't get to snap a pic. Worth a try. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Xtra large pepperoni. The pepperoni is placed under the cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

See all

I've been here once before the pizza was good and well made. The second time i was highly disappointed. The pizza was sloppily made, part of the pizza had little or no crust on bottom, the rest had thick crust, sauce was sparse very little, lots of cheese though. We went on 1/28/25 and ate it since we didn't see it until we returned home. I will not be back. I must say the cashier was very nice. read more

This is takeout only but authentic Chicago pizza - both the thin and stuffed. I have to Come back to try the Italian beef. They have coupons now if you sign up via app or email, but do know this is not cheap pizza like other chains around here. For 3 of us it's about $40 for dinner. We will keep coming back when we need the Chicago fill. read more

Outrageously good! The pizza, the sandwiches, the salads...everything! Don't miss this place and for proper Chicago style (which is very scarce around here) this is the place! P.S. the youngsters behind the counter are polite and friendly. Great customer service. That's lacking at most every other place I visit. read more

Best pizza!! Their deep dishes are 10/10 but so are their thin crust pizza. They put the toppings under the cheese, they didn't forget your toppings!! That threw me off the first time haha definitely recommend read more

I never thought I would ever change a review but tonight my husband went back to this place. Of course I said I didn't want anything. So he brought a small salad and small pizza. He asked me to try the salad (Caesar) and it was delicious the salad crisp, with all the right additions, real bacon and buttery light croutons, and the dressing is a flavor explosion celebration! They really should make this & sell it by the gallon. This man hardly ever orders a salad. After this pleasant surprise, I broke on down to "Try" the pizza. To my surprise it was indeed delicious, there were all types of flavors, Italian flavors emerging from somewhere, I don't know if it was in the crust which was chewy cheesy and that nice crisp /slightest crunch on the bottom. My brain is processing the conveyance of flavors some kind of great cheese, good tangy Italian sauce that raises one eyebrow when it hits your pallet, oregano, the hint of basil ...all that . Hell it could have been in the sausage, but it hits you like, "I'm the real deal". It was so good that by my second tiny square I had to call the call the store to complement the chef on what has to be the best pizza I've ever eaten. (I have never done that before) there was no management there to repent to but the woman told me that initially when they opened they experienced some service inconsistencies, but now they have them all worked out. I agree wholeheartedly since the pizza was Good -Good! better than any that I've had in Chicago or New York or anywhere. I can see myself going here on a regular basis and my husband for once has found a salad that he loves and wants to try others Way to go Nancy's. Thank you for operating this business so close to my home. Just after hanging up I remembered I had written this review! Try it! Your gonna love it!!! read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - One really good Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

Key info: this is a To Go location ONLY. There's no dine in option. My small cheese, deep dish (Chicago style) pizza was ordered online with a specific pickup time and was ready when I arrived. I took advantage of the grand opening special and it was an all-timer: $5 for a fantastic pizza that is enough to easily make 3 meals. Normal pricing will definitely be higher. The crust is good, the cheese is thick and gooey. The sauce is slightly sweet and delicious. I look forward to trying any of several specialty pizzas next time. The staff is friendly and young. They were working hard to fill the orders. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

The Chicago deep dish pizza tasted just amazing. I can eat but I was kind of stuffed after one slice of deep dish pizza. I often went to the Nancy's pizza in Atlanta when I worked in the metro areas back in the days. This location is a small take out only place. Recommend ordering online for pick up. Glad to see the Nancy's pizzeria in the Gwinnett. read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Chicago style deep dish with meat ball and pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

See all

We were pleasantly surprised by the quality ingredients and the amount of toppings! It was late and we were craving something that wasn't too heavy, spicy or greasy. Our pizza was perfectly prepared, and it actually looked as good as it tasted! We will definitely order again soon! read more

Great stuffed pizza. Do not follow the directions from yelp it will take you to NE peachtree and it is on nw peachtree 20 miles away read more

Nowhere was it stated that this was take out only. I am sure the pizza is good since it is Nancy's but it is take out only.

Solid Chicago pizza! I have to try the Chicago beef sub next. If it's as good as their deep dish, I have a new Chicago food go to.

What a surprise! Over the holidays our favorite Chicago Pizza restaurant in Buford was closed. I learned through a Yelp search that Nancy's existed. The photos and reviews did not leave me confident, but it's Christmas Eve, and most of us wanted deep dish, so the vote was give it a try! So glad that we did, and if nothing else, I leave this review as a overwhelming recommendation to help you through the same apprehension I had. The Deep Dish - Chicago Style was excellent every bit as good as there north-end competitor. Their meats were far more plentiful and flavorful. We also ordered a thin crust, half Sausage, half Pepperoni. The thin crust was great, however the sausage was outstanding. The very best I've had on a pizza! This is not a fancy sit down experience, it's a walk up to the counter, grab your pie and head home. My only criticism is they cut the thin crust in squares vs. slices. If you dislike squares as much as we do, I'm sure if you ask they cut it in a traditional manner. If all you crave is a great deep dish, try Nancy's. read more

My son and I both agreed that this was the best pizza we have ever had. It was our first time trying Chicago Style. What a treat! The staff was great as well. Super friendly! read more

Nancy's Pizza Lawrenceville - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia