The food was bomb! A pleasant surprise for somewhere I did not originally have any intention of stopping by! The service was great and really patient as we decided what we wanted! The sandwiches were delicious and the fries were so fresh! The ambiance was very chill and relaxing! Yeah, so I will be back read more

See all

Door dashed a pizza and it had no sauce and full of grease. Never again! It's just poor quality and doesn't taste good at all

Very recommended italian style pizza and salads, food is always flavorful made with fresh ingredients, pricing is affordable with a great customer service, ambience is good for families. Must try. read more

See all

This place use to be the truth, but not anymore. We dropped by to get a couple of cheese slices and was utterly disappointed, my slice was flavorless and so old that the sauce had dried up on it. NEVER AGAIN! read more

The service is always awesome! The staff is always friendly! I make an order by phone, then pick it up. I ordered 1 Veggie Pie. Sometimes I order wings. Their wings are pretty salty but you can ask them to add less seasoning. Mondays and Tuesdays have a special deal where you can get a large 2 topping pizza for $18.99. Veggie Pie (18 inches) - $23.99 $25.43 (with tax) The pizzas usually take 15-20 minutes, if they're not busy. If you're going to get wings, I would recommend getting the Lemon Pepper or Garlic parmesan flavors. So I hope everyone gives this place a try! read more

See all

I ordered the pizza slices and was very impressed. Seems like they're bigger than before. They were all very good! This location is definitely better than others. read more

Italian Pie - Garlic and mushrooms on one slice, bacon on another slice, and then the classic pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

I love reading reviews saying the pizza was overcooked on the bottom (clearly don't know how italian pizza is supposed to be cooked). Great flavors, authentic and very flexible on the toppings. They have larger pizza's for families so it is actually a better bargain for a good pizza. Please do not compare Little Caesar's and Domino's to this. The owner is there some of the time and can help make anything you want. Alcohol can also be served with your meal which is a nice touch. Definitely recommend! read more

It was burnt and no flavor at all worst experience ever cause I live 20 minutes away from there. I asked for a refund they said no I had to get a new one but am busy working read more

Italian Pie - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

Had a great experience dining here. I got the fish and wings combo, everything was CRISPY! The fries and fish were so fresh and crunchy. Enjoyed all of the flavors without needing any sauce. The owner created us as we came in and was so nice. All of interactions we had were perfect! Enjoyed the cozy ambience as well, it was a cool place to hang out with friends and have a great meal. This is my new favorite spot! read more

I ordered the shrimp Alfredo for delivery & received chicken/beef Alfredo. Unfortunately the restaurant & delivery service refuse to rectify the clear incompetence. Uploaded photos along with the receipt & nothing this experience was a total waste of money. Over ambience completely awful. read more

See all

My momma and me were trying to get some quick lunch and we didn't feel like going to any of the usuals fast food restaurants. Checking on the GPS and Yelp what was close to us we found this place. They have good lunch options, mostly pizzas slices, wings and subs. We decided to go with the 1 Slice 2 Toppings & 6 Wings for $8.99. The pizza was good. I like how fresh the ingredients were and it was very tasty too. The wings were okay. Nothing special and the lemon pepper sauce was too salty. The place was pretty clean in general and the staff was nice. Nothing fancy, in fact very casual and not expensive at all. Might come back for lunch sometime in the future. ESPAÑOL Mi mamá y yo estábamos tratando de conseguir un almuerzo rápido y no teníamos ganas de ir a ninguno de los restaurantes de comida rápida habituales. Comprobando el GPS y Yelp lo que estaba cerca de nosotros encontramos este lugar. Tienen buenas opciones de almuerzo, en su mayoría pizzas, alas y subs. Decidimos ir con los 1 rebanada de 2 ingredientes y 6 alas por $ 8.99. La pizza estaba buena. Me gusta lo frescos que estaban los ingredientes y era muy sabroso también. Las alas estaban bien. Nada especial y la salsa de pimienta limón era demasiado salada. El lugar estaba bastante limpio en general y el personal era agradable. Nada lujoso, de hecho, muy casual y nada caro. Podría volver para el almuerzo en el futuro. read more

See all

New favorite spot! The pizza is incredible and the service was super friendly and attentive.

I've been here several times in the past and really loved their pizza! Our family loves Pizza, and i would pick up a pie occasionally when visiting this area. Due to the pandemic, its been about 1.5 years since I've eaten here. We recently had lunch there, it was just ok this time. Unfortunately the pizza was overcooked on the bottom (i should have returned it, the bottom was very dark). We also had a chicken philly and some pasta. The staff i had was friendly but new, i had some questions that she wasn't sure about, then an experienced employee came along and helped out. Will try again but will definitely look at my pizza crust before i leave. read more

See all

Everything was delicious and exactly as ordered. We got shrimp pasta and meat lovers pizza. It was all great!!

Have only ordered the basic Italian Pizza Pie each time so I can only speak to that, and not the place itself. But it is a very good pizza, and really excellent for the price (around 20 for a large). Thin crust, good ingredients, delivered promptly every one or my four or five orders. Highly recommended. read more

Small local pizza place that does mostly takeout. First time trying it and very pleased with the quality of the pizza! Tried the white pizza and veggie pizza. Came out hot and very fresh. Delicious crust. We will definitely be back! read more

The memory of authentic Italian pizza in Rome may be too recent for me to give all 5 stars to Italian pie in Lawrenceville. My experience was to go so I can't really comment on their customer service or the inside of the place but it seems pretty casual. I ordered a slice of pizza which is such a great deal. Two bucks will get you a slice as big as your face and every topping is $.60 on top of that. I added pepperoni bacon and onions to mine. The crust is on the thinner side and pretty crispy so I wouldn't necessarily call it Italian style, but delicious nonetheless. They were generous with the toppings although next time I might ask for a little more sauce. The real showstopper is the garlic knots. You can get eight for $4! They are wonderful doughy little balls--not really knotty but totally naughty. They sit in a pool of garlic, butter and olive oil and are served with a side of marinara. Gosh, it feels so good to be bad. Holy yum, I could've eaten all 8 I think! Better knot. Due to the value and oh-so-tasty appetizer, I'll be eating Italian Pie again for sure. read more

Italian Pie - Garlic knots. 8 for $4 - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

See all

So, I saw the OTP newsletter about pizza and I had been craving it since the weekend - this place was number 1, my boyfriend was down so - we ended up here! The pizzeria is located on the edge of a shopping mall. This makes it convenient to enter from the surrounding streets depending on which area you're coming from. The restaurant is perfectly lit so you're able to see if they're open or not from the street. When you walk in, there are booths to the left and right of you and you pass a few tables as you walk to the counter. You get to the counter to order and there's a HUGE menu awaiting your arrival so you can order whatever you'd like. This place has everything! They have an array of tacos, pizza, pasta, wings, wine, beer and the list goes on and on. I decided to get what I know I like - sausage and extra cheese or meat lovers. I didn't realize the slices were so large so I ordered a regular meat lovers slice and a Sicilian slice w/ extra cheese and sausage. Once you order, you'll get a number and they will bring the pizza out to your table. On the table they have crushed red pepper, parmesan cheese, salt and pepper. Being from Jersey, I had to bump the rating down from 5 to 4 stars because they didn't have garlic powder on the table. There are 3 big tvs in the dining area for your viewing pleasure. In the direction I was facing I was able to watch ET (Entertainment Tonight) & in the direction of my boyfriend's view he was able to watch UFC's Ultimate Knockouts. Perfection! The pizza was pretty tasty! I loved how big the slices were. Nice and cheesy, fresh and hot! The meat lovers has sausage, ground beef, pepperoni & ham. The slice had just the right amount of cheese under all the different meet. Just delish! The Sicilian slice was nice and thick. The extra cheese was a nice touch! Not disappointed in the least. My boyfriend also got 2 slices and our dinner was about $13! (Sometimes, I can be a cheap date lol) It's fairly close to my house so I don't doubt that I will return.. sooner rather than later. Do yourself a favor and grab a slice if you're ever in the area! read more

Italian Pie - Extra cheese/sausage Sicilian and a meat lovers slice. - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

The pies are fresh and tasty. Will cook to your preference. Prices well. Service only at eat in. Clean decent read more

Italian Pie for me says Delicious! I have had several things on the menu and everything has been sooo good. From what I remember, a while back this location had pizza/italian on one side and Mexican food on the other. They have merged together and have become one FABULOUS place to eat! I came alone the first time. After that I bragged with some leftovers taken home to my family about how good everything was. Now they always want to come along with me! (I should have kept it a secret) My favorites are the pasta dishes (Alfredo :) it comes with a chilled glass of wine if you check in on yelp! I also really like the Italian sub, The Mexican pie with sour cream on the side add jalapenos and its a GO! The sicilian pizza is my families favorite, it's HUGE and we always have extra to take home. If your anywhere near Bethesda rd, and hwy 29 in Lawrenceville give them a try. read more

See all

My friend said she heard this place was really good, so we decided to come here on a lunch date! There are plenty of parking around this area and enough seating for about 15 tables! I originally was going to order pizza because it is a pizza joint, but the Philly cheesesteak caught my eyes. So that's what I got! The Philly was huge, like woaaaah. Very meaty, which I love! The Philly was very flavorful, cheesy, and juicy. Like, I was amazed on how great it was! The only thing is I wish their bread was a little better. I think it was on the verge of going old because it was just a tiny bit stale. The fries were delicious! It already comes seasoned!!! I didn't need any salt or ketchup. The pizza that my friend got looked really delicious! It looks like they cook it in a fire oven because of the charring. Next time, I definitely will try that out! read more

Italian Pie - Philly Steak And Cheese Sub - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

I'm a Bronx native so it really is a difficult task to find pizza on the same playing field up north. This place is nice. Very family oriented shop including goodies for the kids. My godson enjoyed himself. He's 4. He's excited to be out anywhere! Lol. When it comes down to the pie, it was not what i expected from a store titled ITALIAN PIE. The pizza was bland & lacked authentic Italian flavors. I could have made better pizza at home. The pizza failed to impress me even with the table spices & garlic. They gave it a good shot just didn't make the cut. read more

See all

I was jonesing for a pie. Read some reviews and thought I would give Italian Pizza Pie. Went with Pepperoni, Sausage, fresh tomato and Garlic. Crust and sauce was real good. Then they hammered it with cheese, very light on the pepperoni and sausage. Way heavy on the fresh garlic in clumps that over powered the pie. Yes I know garlic is strong, I use a lot. I just spread evenly. All in all it was pizza, just a bit un balanced. read more

My friend and I were in Lawrenceville so we decided to grab some pizza/pasta. I ordered a small pizza, he ordered baked zetti, and we split it 50/50. This turned out to be a great idea. The zetti was great, cheesy, saucey, and satisfied me 100%. The pizza was decent, kind of soggy, but overall not bad. Plenty of toppings and seasoning, they did a good job. The only thing that would have put this place over the top into the 5-star stratosphere would have been some bread and butter at the table. I know it's hard to ask from a place like this for lunch, but that would have done it for me. But overall it was a great experience. read more

Italian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

Everyone knows they have a good thing going on! The pizza, the salads and the Stromboli(s) are soooooo Good!!!!!!

We ordered pasta for delivery by UberEats. Came early and the food was nice and hot. The lasagna was good but looked like a burrito. I didn't taste any ricotta nor did it have layers between pasta. Still, it was okay. My friend had the spaghetti and meatball (just one large one). He said the sauce tasted too sweet. So they make sweet sauce. (I prefer savory, but to each his own.) The bread sticks were good and still warm too. Overall I wasn't grossed out or hated it. The flavors we're good. And a plethora of black olives on the garden salad, YUM! read more

See all

Save your money and go somewhere else!!!!!! My first time trying this place out due to the positive reviews. Well I'm guessing there's like a new management/owner or something. Anyways, I ordered a Togo pineapple pizza here, and as I was checking out, I notice there was a little girl in the back climbing on top of a step stool, and the man who was making pizza had no gloves on, he carried the little girl down and move the step stool and continue making the pizza without gloves. Very very unsanitary. Disappointing. Technically my pizza was a pre-made cheese pizza and they just threw pineapple on and put it in the oven. Unlike Pizza Man on Indian trial, it's actually freshly made. But however, I would go here just for their tiramisu! It's so BOMB!!!!! It also comes in a glass cup!!! $4? Can't beat that! read more

Italian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

We went when we were starving so we ordered a bit too much but everything was great! They used to have a restaurant next door named Mexican Pie which unfortunately closed but they kept some of the menu and though we didn't try it then, it looks delicious. The staff is a bit off but not rude and the prices are good. read more

See all

It is a same that sombody who menu base is so good bit there costomer service is appalling that this is back to back orders that i have ordered salads and no utensils ....i have ordered many time from this small town owner to support everything that is going on. But both times i have called to express my concerns on the quality of service provided is garbage, for emplys lie and not knowing what is going on.....maybe the owners should be more hands on to make sure that his resturant emplus know how to do there jobs.....for a costomer to call and not know who is incharge is unacceptable. I take pride in my 20 plus years in the industy and know how inportant it is to support small biz, unfortunatly they do not have the knowledge to even unstand a complaint......so world we are living in.... The only reason they are getiing 1 star is cause i have too.... read more

I love their pies but when I ordered pizza the person on the phone was crunching ice into the phone and I could barely understand him. The pizza is great and I highly recommend it! Just need to work on customer service. read more

My family ordered a small Greek salad without onions and Italian dressing and a meat lovers pizza. I received my delivery on time. The pizza was ok, but the salad was messed up. I received a house salad without onions and ranch dressing. Although disappointed in the mix up, I attempted to still eat the salad. After a few bites I realized the salad had onions on it and they took them off. I'm allergic to onions and had a reaction. read more

I used Uber Eats to pickup my order from Italian Pie. I ordered a Margarita Pizza, Ginger Ale, and a piece of tiramisu. When the driver stopped at my house he brought out the pizza... and that was all he had. The Uber driver blamed Italian Pie for the missing items, stating the restaurant had the order info and he does not. Thank God the Uber Eats app was easy to find order help and refunded the two missing items instantly. In the last 6 weeks I've ordered 5 times and 2 of the 5, Italian Pie screwed up the order. This was the biggest screw up and the end of me ordering from them. 40% of my orders were incorrect or missing items ordered. That's way too high for me to trust they'll get my order right! read more

My taste tester approves of the calzone and pizza slices. After she ate a whole huge slice and 4 bites of calzone, it deserves 4+ stars. Calzone is my favorite from anywhere so i give it 5 stars. Unlimited toppings, yummy bread & a slightly sweet marinara makes their calzones the best around. Garlic is a must topping. Meatballs, salami, veggies like artichoke, mushrooms, onions, and fresh GARLIC is amazing. Regular ($8ish) is pretty big, like a loaded 12" pizza. Large ($15ish) is like an XL 18" pizza that could feed 2-3 people. NY Pizza slice - thin & crispy and the cheese and sauce are quite tasty and perfect texture where cheese wasn't sliding off and making a mess. Easily the best slice I've had in Gwinnett. this slice was HUGE like 1/6 of a 24" pizza. I like the crispyness - even my lil girl can handle the slice without making a mess and didn't need to fold it like typical huge NY style slices. read more

Italian Pie - Huge slices, foldable yet balance-able - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

The customer service was horrible. I called for an order one hour ahead of time. But when I came, it was not ready. I had to wait for another 45 minutes. While I was waiting, the two young ladies were very rude and disrespectful. They didn't explain why it wasn't ready, just keep ignoring me. Extremely BAD EXPERIENCE!!! read more

I ordered $35 worth of food and it all went in the trash. The large order was intentional to try a little bit of everything. My large pepperoni pizza had very sparse toppings and was bland at best. I didn't taste a better motz or any hint of spice to the sauce, frankly it was on par with Dominos or Marcos. One notch above Papa Johns maybe. The spaghetti and meatballs were well... dry like the Mojave. Hardly any sauce at all and the meatballs were equally dry without any sauce on top of them. The meatball sandwich bread was charred on top and the rest was soaked and soggy and just fell apart. Repeat performance on the dry meatball. The best item sadly was a small greek salad. Extremely disappointing. As others mentioned they clearly have a ventilation issue with the oven, the AC doesn't pull its weight and the portable AC unit was just blowing hot air. It was miserable in there. The two teenage girls working up front need to polish their poor customer service skills and spit out their gum. read more

I really enjoyed this place. It's an Italian owned restaurant and you can definitively tell by the food. It was my first time there but my bf had been before since it's near his house. You order at the counter and they bring the food to you. You make your own drinks at the soda fountain. They have a nice size menu with many options. I had a calzone and he had penne pasta with meatballs. This food was delicious! The family who owns it was in there with their kids eating, it was a holiday. They were nice and talked to the patrons and played with the kids. They also opened Mexican Pie (I think that's the name... or it's Taco Pie) directly next door. read more

Italian Pie - Calzone and Meatball pasta - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

Ordered Chicken Alfredo and garden salad and other things. Opened salad out came a huge what look like a knat. 20.00 has gone down the drained because I will not eat anything else I ordered. read more

Italian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

After reading the strong reviews and seeing it is so close to our place out here, I had to stop by. That said it was good, like 4-4.5 stars. Had a lunch special two, 2 topping slices with sausage and roasted pepper. Very large slices, great char and crisp in the crust. Sauce was good, cheese was OK. Toppings were NYC style, very thin cut sausage, and loads of roasted rad and green peppers. This with a drink for $4.50. Can't beat that! I showed the workers the yelp App as I do not think they had heard of yelp. This is a very well priced joint where pizza is good and reasonably priced. I also noted that draft beers at $1.50 here. I will be back again soon. read more

"Perfect, casual, affordable" are some of the adjectives my family used as we ate here for the first time. The pizza can be ordered by the slice. We love that because we can get exactly what we want. Thin crust, just the right amount of sauce. Really good! Order at the back counter, get your drink, then sit yourself at an open red and white check covered table. The back ground music ranges from classical jazz, to opera, to Tony Bennett. Speaking of drink, they offer something called Horchata, which is kind of like cinnamon flavored milk. Try it! My daughter loved it, I liked it, my wife did not like it. Oh! No light beer option on draft. That's weird. The three of us were completely satisfied, and we only spent $19.00. But then we went back to the counter and spent another $6.00 on Chocolate Cannoli and were Super Satisfied! We will be back FOR SURE! read more

Italian Pie - Vespa! - Pizza Near Me - Lawrenceville, Georgia

Food - Delicious! This place has a lot of interesting specialty pizzas. It also has a Mexican menu too (that was surprising)! Italian and Mexican under one roof -- yesssss! I had the firecracker chicken pizza. It's legit! It's also spicy!! (I actually had them use the marinara, instead of the Buffalo sauce though). Prices - Reasonable Atmosphere - A bit outdated , but those "hole-in-the-wall" places always have the best food, right!? Service - Friendly :) Overall: I'd recommend it. I can't wait to try the fish tacos. read more