What a great restaurant, that continues to be one of my faves on Island. Again, you stepping…read moredownstairs, into this cavernousesque restaurant you can imagine salty whaling captains, peglegs and all, ordering up their ales and bowls of chowder. The staff from the maitre d who has been there for ever to the bartenders and servers, all top notch and friendly. I've dined with reservations for more of the fine dining feel, but also have casually rolled up to the bar and enjoyed the more relaxed vibe, but still great food. Again, Nantucket is expensive, but I find that the meal, service and ambiance warrants the price for a fun and memorable night out. Enjoy the walk back into town and soak in the fresh air!

We stayed here on the 4th and 5th of October, 2025. We booked in June '25 during our annual week…read morevacation on island. The rate was spectacular, and the inn was even better, but the restaurant and bar is to die for! 5-star. Where to start? The staff is excellent, professional, exceptionally pleasant, and very accommodating. Our room was huge! Clean. Well stocked. Nice clean bathroom. We had tea in the common room in the afternoon; able to chat with other visitors - relaxing and quite pleasant. The restaurant was to die for. We made our reservation on Resy a week before. Everything was just incredible, starting with a mussel appetizer, cod and polenta/spinach dish, to the chocolate soufflé. The next morning we crossed the street to attend services at Saint Paul's Episcopal. Came back for a quick breakfast down stairs; the coffee was top-shelf, eggs perfectly made, and fresh fruit - can't beat any of that. We left our bag at the Inn, and went in town to shop, sip coffee, and take it all in. Picked up our bag and dropped it off at the Hyline building. Had lunch with local friends at Brant Point. The day, hotel, dinner, church, and lunch was all serendipitous. No negatives. Ship's Inn is one of the absolute best and well known inn and restaurant on the island.

Staff was great. We had a mishap in our room and they moved us to a new room and were so…read moreapologetic. Both Rooms and updated bathrooms were beautiful. Giving 4 vs 5 stars because I Wish there was some wiggle room in the 30 day cancellation policy. We happened to be on island during a huge rainstorm and the forecast was bad when we took the ferry over and went to worse after we arrived and there were no ferries leaving with wind gusts at 40-50 mph. We would have preferred to postpone our trip but would have lost a significant amount of money. We tried to make the best of it but we were quite miserable and drenched much of the time. I would stay here again.

Unfortunately did not have a good second experience with the Nantucket Resort Collection Hotel. I…read morebooked a two night stay on Hotels Tonight, and 24 hours before check in tested positive for Covid. Not wanting to possibly infect the entire hotel. Immediately called the Hotel and Hotels Tonight to cancel the reservation, impossible to get anyone on the phone at the front desk to answer (you can only reach the reservation line which is off site), finally got a text from the manager Kara the day of the check in asking what time I was planning to check in. When I informed Kara that I was not coming to Nantucket that weekend she agreed to cancel my reservation but not refund my money back to me. I called Hotel's tonight and they agreed to the refund only to find out that the hotel refused to refund the money back. I called Kara back and she said she refused to refund the money back to Hotels tonight and said "we are a small business and we need to make our money", after arguing for hours back and forth with her she then told me I needed to speak to her General Manager Alicia Hehir. I called her multiple times and she refused to call me back. Finally I had American Express Centurion call them to dispute the charge and they agreed. This hotel lacks compassion for their guests and needs to be run much better. Their management is not responsive to their hotel guests and lacks sympathy for people who have Covid.

I am 42 years old and have never written a review (I had to create an account), but this trip…read morewarranted a write up. Upon arrival, after Angel handles everything from the ferry, you are greeted by Fulya who is maybe the sweetest woman you will ever meet. Unfortunately you cant take her home with you, but she will make your stay as easy and convenient as possible. Unfortunately, my wife got a stomach bug on our trip, and because the concierge car was unavailable, Kate insisted that I use her PERSONAL vehicle to run to the pharmacy. If all of that isn't enough you have John, the head bartender, who not only makes one heck of an espresso martini, he works the bar like an ace! Again, 42 and I have been lucky enough to travel quite a bit, but the level of service that we received at the Nantucket Hotel, not only rivals, but surpasses any 5-star resort that we've ever stayed at. I have been coming to the Island since I was in the 6th grade and I will never go back without staying here. Angel, Kate, Fulya, and everyone else, thank you so much for the level of service and passion for your craft. We cannot wait to come back and really appreciate everything. REALLY SHOULD BE 30 STARS. Simply the best experience.

Kate and the crew always make you feel at home with their unsurpassed hospitality. My wife and I…read morealways come to Nantucket in April before it gets busy and could not stay anywhere else than the Nantucket. Beautiful rooms and great location but it's relaxed welcoming atmosphere that goes way beyond our expectations!! We'll be back soon

I highly recommend the Barnacle Inn. A friend and I stayed there June 2023 for 5 days. Inn, staff…read moreso inviting. This Inn and the rooms are very clean, historical, charming. Breakfasts are delicious, plenty to eat with unending coffee and tea available as well. We really lucked out with the Barnacle Inn and will be back. The location is a half block from Main St. ideal.

Great cozy inn with fantastic service and ultra clean accommodations. Walking distance to downtown…read moreand properly priced. Suzie and Sumaya exceed all expectations. I'll be staying there every time I return to the island.

We stayed there last autumn (sorry for the late review!). It was excellent. The house was quaint,…read moreclean, and lovely. Also lovely was the hostess, who took such great care of us. Definitely recommend.

Lovely stay:) quality beds and accommodations:) friendly staff and quiet rooms. Loved the morning…read morescones and evening cookies!

Well, we stayed here for 3 days initially in '24 and liked it so much in '25 we stayed for a week…read more Great, great, GREAT B&B! Wonderful host; and fantastic cookies, drinks, and breakfast. Parking is available. Near town and near some great venues: such as the Brant Point Light, Whaling Museum, Children's Beach, and I can go on. Seven Seas... priced perfectly. Very clean rooms. Nice amenities too. No negatives whatsoever!!

Location, staff,room and overall Nantucket experience highly recommend! Especially Loved the…read morerooftop and new shower!!! And fireplace courtyard walkable and bike to everything !

Go back in…read moretime A gorgeously restored Victorian carriage house, this B&B is without question one of the nicest places we have stayed on the island. The location is on a very quiet little side street that feels isolated even in the midst of the summer chaos. The great part is that the Carriage House is still only a short walk to the center of Nantucket. The rooms aren't large but extremely nice and furnished in period style. They serve a pleasant breakfast in the morning and we had some of the best blueberry muffins ever. Perhaps the nicest part of our stay was getting to met the proprietors Haziel and his wife Tomomi. They were incredibly gracious and friendly and not only willing to take the time to give us directions to anything we wanted but also seemed to enjoy discussing environmental issues on the island or aspects of Nantucket history, politics, or just about anything else. This is an absolutely gorgeous place to stay but it was the hospitality of Haziel and Tomomi that made it very special.

I've had two wonderful stays at the Carriage House, the most recent over Labor Day 2018. Haziel…read moreand Tomomi are very warm and friendly, and more than willing to help you with any questions you have about the island - restaurants, sightseeing, transportation, and more. The location couldn't be better - a block from the head of Main Street, near Murray's, yet off on a secluded and quiet side street. The bedroom was comfortable and cozy - bonus that the view from my window was of the gold dome of the Unitarian Church. As others have said, this is a great value when compared to other B&B's in the area, which are much more expensive. At Carriage, I stayed in a queen room with a private bath for approximately $50-$75 less than what a single bed with shared bath would have cost me elsewhere. One very small additional convenience that would be nice would be air conditioning, as it can get pretty hot and humid at times on the island. The lack of A/C is actually common on the island however, and I slept comfortably with the ceiling fan.

We absolutely loved our overnight stay at The Cliff Lodge. We were able to access Restaurants…read moreduring a nice walk through the area. Our room was gorgeous! The inside bathroom was stylish and updated beautifully. decor was beautiful gorgeous through the house. Art work hung on the walls, rugs that accentuate the rooms. It was Quiet and welcoming Breakfast was perfect and lovely to not have to worry about. Monique was an absolute pleasure to meet and have if needed. There was a beautiful yard to sit in. We will stay there again and again.

Get ready for steep stairs and funny carpet on those stairs!…read more But we got a cute (tiny) 3rd floor room for a decent price 2nd week of August. On the most expensive vacation island where rooms run $600 and up, our tiny room in this clean B and B served us well. The custodian of the place was nice but had no butter or cream cheese for the breakfast. Otherwise baked goods were fine and coffee good. We braved it and did roof top. Next door neighbor's home and antique car collection so Nantucket! Would stay there again.