Off-season at The Curst Pizza is so weird. You just walk in and get a table. I am exaggerating…read moreslightly, but there were more helpers than customers. I ordered the 13-inch pizza with sausage and pepperoni. They have a meat-lovers pizza that I have wanted to try. Their pepperoni is slightly spicy, which I like. Not a big fan of tiny crumbles of sausage, wish the sausage were bigger. There is just something about seeing a picture of the Beatles hanging on the wall, eating pizza, that always brings a smile. Obviously fake, but nice seeing John, Paul, Ringo, and George.

Updating my review due to the recent price increases. The food is still great and I love the BBQ…read moreChicken pizza. But $30 for a 13" pizza and $18 for a house salad ... is just a bit too much for me. It was over $80 for my wife and I to have dinner. I didn't even have a drink -- just tap water. The price increases are excessive, IMHO.

My brother-in-law has been dying to get us to Peppi's, and we finally made it! Being from NY, we're…read moretotal pizza connoisseurs, so our expectations were high. We were a party of eight and sat outside--absolutely gorgeous night for dining al fresco. There was only one waitress, but she was completely on point the entire time. We started with the mozzarella sticks and meatballs, both hot, fresh, and delicious. We were told we had to try the Cadillac pizza, and wow--definitely a must-try! I love a good white pizza, and this one was full of flavor. We also ordered a pepperoni pizza, a Margherita pizza, and the eggplant parm platter. The crust was nice and thin, and the sauces were super flavorful--honestly on par with NY pizza. If you're craving a taste of home, give Peppi's a try!

Went here for lunch recommendation from a friend and it didn't disappoint. We split a pizza and…read moreeggplant parmigiana sandwich both excellent one of the best pizzas I've had in Florida it's NY style crispy crust with great flavor I would recommend to everyone

Outstanding little Italian restaurant. Great service. Great food. Great prices. Their…read moremarinara sauce is perfect. Their home made desserts are excellent. Their pizza is terrific.

Quality food, great service, nice environment all around. I came in on a Wednesday night out of…read moreseason in Naples and the place was packed. Great job!

I ordered pizza from this restaurant. Reading the reviews why not try it! The place was bursting at…read morethe walls with customers to dine in and take out! The pizza I ordered was mushroom and sausage pizza! ordered on line and told them i will be there at a certain time. You can actually track your order ! It was ready on time, paid on line and was out the door back to the house and eating a piping hot pizza! Large menu plenty of choices!! Price $$ Have to go back and try other foods!

This local pizza restaurant is one of my favorites, and the food is delicious. However, the past…read moretwo times I've gone out for date night, I've had the same waitress. She was honestly quite rude. I gave her the benefit of the doubt and thought maybe she had a bad day, but when I returned a couple of weeks later for dinner, she acted the same way.

The food was fantastic. The service from Maria was even better. It was my first time and it will…read morenot be my last. The value was unbelievable

So my gym is next to this location and they have a sign NY pizza, so let's check it out. Indoors…read morevery deceiving from outside, it's actually pretty roomy and clean. The pizza display was ok, there were some slices that should not have been displayed, other items looked pretty good. So my order consisted of a med pie with peppers and onions and sausage and mushrooms, garlic knots and a house salad. Sooo, the pizza was better than what I expected, the pizza maker was a nice lady and made it with live, the salad was ok the tomatoes were to ripe but the rest was ok, the garlic knots were ok just to thick and doughy. But one thing I need to point out that Isabel provided great customer service. I will return to try some of the other items on the menu.

New to the area, living close by. We decided to stop in on a weekday night for dinner. 6 PM in…read moreseason, it was busy, but we were able to get a seat for two. Some of the tables are very close to where patrons walk by, so that was a little awkward. Ambience is nice. Better than we expected. It's deceiving from the outside. Nice decor. Bar looks like a good spot. Started with a regular side salad, which was very good, tried out a small cheese pizza, which was pretty good. Very crunchy with minimal flop. Chicken Alfredo was delicious as was the marsala! Big portions, so I was able to take some home. Our only complaint was the service. They were all over the place. Rolling silverware for the first 5-10 min when we were ready to order pretty quickly was frustrating. We asked for extra plates for the pizza and he said he would get them and then never came back. They seemed a bit understaffed/not assigned to specific tables? Hard to put my finger on it, but would definitely try coming back at a slower time. Also, bread service - even if on menu to purchase, would have been great, especially ordering pasta dishes.

Got takeout pizza and stomboli. It was OK but short on sauce. I don't know, maybe this is NY…read morepizza but I will tell you, it does not hold a candle to New Jersey Stromboli!! Discussion among the family says Crust pizza is better.

Unparalleled experience! This is the real deal. It's consistently out of this world. We came back…read moreto try the house special, Grandma's pizza this time and it's EXCELLENT. Thin crust, amazing flavors of garlic tomato and the perfect amount of cheese. You feel like family the moment you walk in the door. I can't believe how friendly they are- it's seriously remarkable. We will certainly be back- again and again!

Disappointed…read more Called ahead because I was 45 minutes away and asked them to time the pizza to be ready at that time. They guy who was on phine said it would be ready in about 45 minutes. When I arrived the man suspiciously announced "perfect timing right out of the oven!" I drove 15 minutes to my destination with the pizza that was "right out of the oven" to find totally overcooked pizza nearly burnt and the cheese had already solidified. Top of pizza totally dry. Crust was dry and overcooked. Two of the worse pizzas I have had in a long time. My family agreed and a sibling actually made fun of the leftover slices the next day. I suspect the pizza boxes were sitting on top of the stove for about 30 minutes and they immediately cooked the pizza as soon as I called. It was not busy this was 4pm and no other orders being cooked and underway. No phones ringing. Just me and my $40 waste of money.

I've been back two times since my initial visit two weeks ago and continue to be impressed by the…read moreamazing flavors of all their slices. In my last two visits I tried the meat lovers, vodka grandma, supreme, and chicken bacon ranch. The quantity of food (loaded with toppings? is impressive and the vodka pizza was the best vodka pizza I've ever tried, no doubt about it. On top of the amazing flavor, texture, and quality of the pizza, the owner and other workers recognized us and treated us like family. Such an incredible place to relax and enjoy quickly served slices. Beyond friendly and humorous gentlemen working at this establishment who truly seem to love what they do. I'm sure I'll be back again soon!

We heard good things about this restaurant and wanted to stop by. This is a small restaurant, you…read morehave to look to see it between other buildings. Although the restaurant is small, the flavor is big! The menu has a good variety of pizza, calzone, salads and even a few subs. The pizza with the cauliflower crust was interesting and so was the Sicilian, but we decided on the usual pepperoni. This was a great choice, the flavors were balanced and the crust is true New York style, both crusty and chewy. It's one of the best pizza crusts I've found in Naples, IMO New York crusts make the best pizza. Service was fast and the staff is great, it's obvious they make a lot of pizzas here and know their stuff. If you like New York style pizza, this is a place to check out.