Cheesy bread is ok. It's just missing some sort of herb, more butter or something to tie it together. And they kinda skimp on the side sauces. Don't know about the other appetizers. We went with the BBQ chicken pizza this time around and I've had way better BBQ chicken pizza elsewhere. Like the garlic cheese bread, it's just missing some sort of garnish/topping to tie it all together. For example, Mary's in Sonoma adds crispy onions and the added texture and taste make it an absolute favorite. The signature combo pizza however is pretty good. Overall we've have good experiences here. It's really cool to have a pizza place serving the Olivehurst area. read more

Update: The owner reached out and advised we'll be getting refunded that additional fee that was charged, which we really appreciate. Because the owner made this right, I have updated my rating from 1 to 3. Because of yesterday's service, I did not change my rating to higher than 3. Also, we will give them another chance. Our son's birthday is next month and he really wants to get some Alaskan size pizzas for it from them and again, because the owner made this right, we will be placing these pizza orders for his birthday through them. Hoping for better service next time we go. Original review: I've ordered the same pizza over the years from this place. I literally got charged $8.27 plus tax for them inputting a note that I have a tomato allergy (Misc Open). I've never paid this fee for this same exact pizza order. That's about $9 more than was I've previously paid for this same order before. I brought this to their attention and the girl at the register (different than the gals I've picked pizza up from before) was very unhelpful and unwilling to correct. I did not want to cause a scene so I paid it especially since she refused to correct it. But due to how I was treated and what they did, they have lost my business. Please note that we called the order in versus doing it in the app but we should have ordered from the app because it would have been cheaper especially since they tacked on an additional fee and I brought that up when we picked up the order. The girl did nothing to resolve this and refused to. Extremely poor service which we never had in the past. Anyway, my husband was upset and advised them that we will no longer get pizza there for ourselves because of this. Our son's birthday is coming up in a month and he wanted to order some pizza for his party from them, but after this, we will take our business elsewhere. Additional context: Charged $74.40 yesterday for the Alaskan size pizza (white sauce, pepperoni, garlic, and basil). I'm allergic to tomatoes so I'm forced to pay for substituting it with white sauce. If they had extra olive oil as an alternative, I would have picked that. The sauce options that are available, the ones that don't cost extra to substitute, I cannot have. I remember when this same pizza was fifty some dollars a few years ago but we've been paying about $65 for this same exact pizza size with the same exact toppings the last couple years for myself. The only time it was less is when it's a smaller size pizza order. Anyway, I was going in expecting to pay this and it was a sticker stock when I was told I had to pay that much for this pizza. I was only expecting to pay about $65 for the order. read more

10/10!!! They were incredible and fast! The owner is so sweet! We order from them all the time and never have any issues! Thank you again for the amazing service! read more

Neighbors Pizza - Amazing! Always delicious - Pizza Near Me - Olivehurst, California

We have tried this place a few times and we love it! We usually get thin crust pepperoni! The pizza tastes soooo good. We always get delivery service and they are on it! This pizza place has become our favorite in the area. read more

We came in from Texas, staying at a nearby hotel. Found Neighbors Pizza. The place is small but the taste is huge. Loved the crispy thin crust. The owner and employees are super friendly. Definitely recommend this place and we'll be back. read more

I've been ordering from neighbors on average, once a month. I love their pizzas. Everybody who comes over always asks where I got it from. When I do have time to go pick it up, they are also super nice to my kids and I. My favorite is the New York with thin crust. read more

Ordered a large combination pizza and it was still hot when we got it and was very delicious best pizza by far great job neighbors pizza I would order again from them and recommend them to others read more

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza with spinach and it was delivered. Wonderful delicious pizza fantastic people running the register.!

This pizza is shockingly good. It is simple but the flavors are right and it's a great go to for us now!

I live close. The pizza is always delicious. Hot fresh ready. They've never messed up my order really great place for a quick go to lunch or dinner. One thing I can say that might need some improvement when walking in. I seen three employees wearing pajamas, and crocs would just recommend a little bit more professionalism When getting dressed for work. But still love the pizza. read more

The pizza was not hot, not did it seem very fresh. It also was small in size for the price. If I'm going to pay pizza prices, I would rather go to many other places. The only reason I ordered from here is because it was close by. read more

Pizza was amazing!! The cashier was very welcoming and friendly . I highly recommend!

If you're ever out and about around Olivehurst California, be sure to stop by Neighbors Pizza. If you're looking for a delicious pizza and great service you're at the right place. It's not very big but it's cozy for sure. read more

Neighbors Pizza - Store front - Pizza Near Me - Olivehurst, California

See all

I placed an order for takeout last week. It was awful. My mother ordered wings and they were so greasy it was dripping off and stained her clothes. I ordered pasta substituting pesto and cheesy garlic bread. The pasta was awful. It all clumped together and the taste was not good. Half of the garlic bread was burnt and had no cheese. I did try to contact the manager the next day but I never received a response. So I decided to warn everyone of the bad food and non responsive management that you will be dealing with read more

I go here a lot and it's really great the pizzas always tasting great and they've never disappointed me so far

There's nothing to rave about here. Wings were not good, at all. Pizza was very mediocre overall, but did have a lot of toppings and the crust was tasty. Prices are pretty reasonable given the food quality. read more

See all

My order was miscommunicated causing a wrong order. It can be frustrating when buying a 50 dollar pizza especially when the part that was messed up was the wife's. This local business went way out of their way to make it right. They have awesome customer service and you can tell they care about the quality coming out of their place. All un all happy wife happy life this is definitely our go to pizza place on game day. Thank you so much... read more

Coulda, shoulda, woulda.... Been in the area for 7 years. Finally decided to support this local place, let them win me over. Well....dissapointing is the word to describe my order. Ordered online, arrived to pick up and was told still cooking, ok no problem there. 15 min later i was told they were still working on my potato skins. Ok, no problem again. Upon getting my order and walking out i could feel the bottom of the XL pizza box did not feel warm. Hmmm, my thought was they forgot the potato skins and quickly made those while my pizza sat. Got it home in 5 min and immediately had to start my oven to reheat. Meanwhile the toaster oven was fired up in order to cook further the quickly cooked potato skins. Even after some warming in the oven the pizza remained cool. Not to meantion the skimpy toppings i added for $5 each. Overall the pizza lacked enough cheese and sauce. Sauce was flavored similiar to Costco pizza. I tried. I will stick with Primetime pizza for my local needs. They have an actual doughy crust you can taste. Not charging extra money to have a nice crust. Neighbors pizza is just ok. A step above little ceasers. read more

Just tried Neighbor's Pizza on McGowan. Delicious! I have a gluten allergy & they offer gluten-free crust. Just amazing!

Good pizza. Excellent Mediterranean Salad. Eat in or carry out this a good place to go in Olivehurst CA. I'll be going again.

We were staying at Lake Minden RV Resort in Nicolaus and decided we wanted pizza. Barbecue is great, but at some point in the week everyone is ready for pizza! Well... Nicolaus is kinda in between everything. Between Highway 99 and Highway 70, between Lincoln and Yuba City, and just about halfway between pizza joints in Olivehurst or Wheatland. This trip we decided to give Olivehurst a try. I'm glad we did. The pizza and cheesy garlic bread were very good. What wasn't so good was the wait! I called the order in from the campground, that is about 20-25 minutes away. The girl taking my order said it would be about 25 minutes. I arrived to pick up my order 25 minutes after calling it in, paid, and waited anxiously to get my food and make the short trek back to camp so we could all eat. Well, I waited, and waited some more, and finally after being inside waiting for another 25 minutes, I asked the manager (I think) if my order was almost ready. She said "Let me check," and the next thing I new another girl appeared with my pizza and bread. I got my cheese and peppers and hurried home. The food was good and the staff were friendly. Time just passes a little slower here, I guess. The 25 minutes quoted turned into 50 minutes without a second thought. The menu offers a lot more than what I found in the reviews. I will likely pay Neighbors another visit next time I'm staying at Lake Minden, and very well may try some pasta. read more

Good pizza bad location but nice restaurant good prices recommend if you're in town in area

This is a great little pizza joint. The pizza is always very good and I like that it's not greasy. They do have a gluten free crust available that does not have dairy as my daughter can't eat dairy. They also have a veggie pizza. read more

Called 30mins ahead to place order and once arrived, they haven't even started on my order yet. Continue to pay for my pizza and left a $2 tip for the service which I shouldn't have. They end up giving me a second class treatment. After 15mins of waiting, Customers that came in after me start receiving their pizzas before me. Had to approach the cashier and ask several times before my pizza done. This pizza business is going down hill for sure. This will be my last time we order pizza from this place. read more

So good!!! Thank you Really fresh and hot....came pretty fast also.... Our favorites are chicken with bbq sauce, Canadian bacon and pineapple, Oregon , Italian sausage, black olives and mushrooms Order at least once a month for past 6 years read more

I love their pizza! I love their Alfredo sauce and chicken !! It's delicious I highly recommend them!!

Meh. It was mediocre. I ordered 2 GF pizzas for my husband but at 11.99 each these far from exceeded expectation. The toppings were wimpy. Like one of the slices didnt even have any chicken. He also was bummed the crust was chewy and corn mealy tasting. For the $24 I could have almost got 6 GF pizzas from Costco that are far larger and tasty. I ordered the "family special" for my kids and I to eat. Large pepperoni and olive. It was ok, glad I got thin crust as it seemed thick enough as "thin" crust goes. Sauce was rather bland though, crust too though. Sadly the pizza at winco tastes better .... It also came with garlic cheese bread that was super mediocre. And I got the Honey wings. Those were actually tasty! idk. I would love to support small business but it's not worth almost $60 to have bleh food. I could go to a nice restaurant and spend the same.... read more

Neighbors Pizza - Gluten free georgia chicken - Pizza Near Me - Olivehurst, California

See all

Their pizza tastes like it has fresh ingredients. Service has always been friendly. Pricing feels high for the area. Personally I prefer Round Table. read more

It was the first time to ordered a pizza from neighborhood pizza back in June the Order person took my order said it would be 45-60 minutes before your pizza arrive I ordered a combination So in 19 minutes it came and it was lukewarm the driver said he rushed over Yea felt sorry for this kid So never ordered again!! Just be careful pictures always look good not the same in real life!!! read more

Their pizza is really good, had it during Sunday Football. Good size, good price, and gave us chips towards next time we get a pizza with them. This place is great in the Olivehurst Area. read more

If I could get zero I would but 1 star is the lowest... My husband and I would order from here all the time for the past 4 years. First thing is their prices are through the roof I understand inflation and things are expensive nowadays but the prices are a bit insane especially when using credit cards. This was the 3rd time messing up our pizza. First time got the wrong pizza and didn't get our salad. Second time forgot our soda and a poker chip. This last time the pizza was too undercooked,super greasy and there was barely any sauce on our wings. Don't get me wrong amazing food and I understand mistakes happen which is okay. The staff was amazing and very kind but after this last time I ordered not so much... on busy days i understand the staff is under pressure and everyone gets frustrated sometimes but the girl who took our order thought she put me on hold but actually didn't and I heard their whole conversation about me. Not sure who exactly was talking but it sounded like the owner's wife and I heard her complaining about how annoying it is when people call to complain and want compensation just for free food. The amount of times I've let wrong orders slide because I understand how draining it can be working food service just for them to complain at me complaining on the mistake THEY made and assuming I want free/discounted food is ridiculous. ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS!!! This is not the first time I've heard the staff complain about customers. There's this couple that I see dining in a couple times when we order to go. The guy sometimes has a puppet with him and likes to talk to people with it (including me) which I know can be a bit odd. I seen the owner's wife go to the back and overheard her say "I hate him and he's so weird" which is honestly pretty sad. We are not all the same please treat your customers with respect. Imagine if the poor guy heard her. That's absolutely so unprofessional. I'm never ordering food from here ever again. PLEASE DO BETTER NEIGHBORS PIZZA !! read more

Being new to the area I love doing business with small businesses. I had a deep craving for quality pizza so I ordered a medium "everything " pizza and mozzarella sticks. I had to order the mozzarella sticks to get my order delivered! I ended up paying $6.75 for delivery. The cost of my order was $34.97! My pizza came rather quickly and was delivered by a sweet young gal. I was so excited to try this pizza! I first sampled the mozzarella stick and was vastly disappointed! They weren't fried but instead soggy, limp and cold. Yuk! Then I opened up my pizza box and at first glimpse I noticed that the toppings were pretty sparse. And since the pizza was cold I had to zap my slice. I took my first bite so badly wanting to love it.....however, it was quite the opposite. The pizza lacked flavor, cheese and was pretty awful. Such a huge $34 dollar disappointment! I mean a frozen pizza would of tasted better. I called the next morning to explain my disappointment and a nice lady who said she was the manager said she'd reimburse me but I never got it! All in all this pizza was pretty bad! I can't recommend it by any stretch of the imagination! read more

Pizza has always been great. Delivery on a Saturday is definitely going to run behind time but that's to be expected. Staff was super friendly as well. read more

Ordered online and it was delivered before the texted delivery time, but the pizza was overcooked and crust inedible. The salad was a pleasant surprise though. read more

Neighbors Pizza - Salad and Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Olivehurst, California

Do not order the wings here. Just awful! We ordered the lemon pepper wings 4 wings for $6. They were so oily and soggy; the chicken skin was flappy and overall had no flavor. The wings came sitting in a pool of OIL. Never seen anything like this before. We had to throw them out. Do not order them! read more

See all

I lived in AZ and was visiting my Son and his family in Olivehurst, Ca. Ordered their special for $30.95 included large pizza with two toppings, bread sticks, 8 buffalo wings, and 2 litter soda. It was delivered to me within 35 minutes! The manager took my order and she was exceptionally professional and helpful. Oh did I mention that the food (all of the orders) was DELICIOUS! I will definitely order this special again when I come to visit my Son and his family! read more

Pretty good pizza will defiantly eat here more often glad we have a local joint here in olivehurst

Really good pizza and appetizers! If you're in a pinch neighbors is always a good option. Great customer service.

good Pizza and great customer service. The owners know how much my daughter likes certain things and has her back every time. Thank you for being great. read more

The best pizza around, almost 30 minutes late is not ok, I order thin crust so it's a soggy mess when it's delivered almost 30 minutes after the scheduled delivery time , you get one star for a soggy pizza read more