Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    New Columbus Pizza & Catering

    5.0 (1 review)

    New Columbus Pizza & Catering Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - New Columbus Pizza & Catering

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Scott W.
    2
    241
    14

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 927 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Rosetta’s pizza - Buffalo wings

    Rosetta’s pizza

    3.6(29 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $

    (This was from over the summer, so the details are a bit hazy.)…read more Stopped by on a whim after a long day of kayaking looking for something of hearty substance. Enter their homemade lasagna. I chose to eat in which seemed to throw the guy at the counter for a moment but after that brief eyebrow raise, there were no issues. You start with a salad and some "garlicy" bread. The bread was toasted nicely and from what I remember soaked in butter with some type of seasoning applied to the butter. The salad....well....it's a salad. I'm never a fan and it was no different than any salad you would get when ordering from a local red sauce Italian restaurant. The lasagna was a solid portion and there were no issues with that or with how it was constructed. Multiple layers of pasta/sauce/cheese. One oddity was it looked like they attempted to melt a slice of American on top, and it was at best, partially melted. Very odd looking. As a few others have mentioned, it's basically self-serve if you eat in since they seem to be very busy with handling takeout orders. The food was brought to their front counter and then I got the head nod that it was mine to pick up. One plus was the nice delicacy of having Guer's tea in the fridge case. I was looking for a Zimmy since Nesquehoning is certainly close enough to Lehighton, but I don't remember seeing any. Either way, good enough. Overall, as I mentioned prior, this is your classic local jack of all trades red sauce Italian joint that every town has a few of. Very large menu at reasonable pricing and the staff I encountered were decent enough. It's not a go out of your way place, but if I lived in town, I'm sure this would be a go-to spot.

    Food is good and ambiance is quite quiet. Service is a bit slow but otherwise ok and messed up…read moreorder . I like cheese

    Photos
    Rosetta’s pizza - Dining Room

    Dining Room

    Rosetta’s pizza
    Rosetta’s pizza - Our pizzas and Stromboli's

    See all

    Our pizzas and Stromboli's

    Antonios Pizzeria - Menu

    Antonios Pizzeria

    3.1(110 reviews)
    3.9 mi
    $$

    After seeing some negative reviews I was hesitant to visit Antonio's pizzeria but I'm glad I did…read more We stopped by on a Saturday afternoon and ordered a small cheese pizza pie and a chicken parmigiana entree with spaghetti, which came with bread and salad. Everything was tasty and I definitely recommend both. Our waitress was friendly and so was the gentleman by the door, so I need to disagree with the reviews that mentioned bad customer service. My only complaint is that they provide some super cheap paper plates, so when I tried to cut my chicken parmigiana the plate was also cut. If they want to use disposable plates, at least use something heavy duty. Also, note that apparently they do not sell alcohol.

    Places like this can go very, very wrong or very, very right and fortunately = this jaded ex- New…read moreYawker and old-skool middle-aged Karen, knows what to order and do here to get a 5 star experience. 1. Do not order dinners. Order a whole pizza (NOT slices) or a Stromboli or Calzone. Or garlic knots. Always the knots. 2. Are you diabetic? Don't come here. Are you vegan, gluten-free, food snob? Don't come here. 3. Are you in a rush/hurry? Don't come here. Relax - and wait. It's worth the wait. This is not NY pizza - and it's not Scranton pizza and it's not Kingston Pizza - it's Carbon County Pizza and it. is. great. Did you order "chicken alfredo"? If you did and you didn't like this place it's your own fault. Shout out to Riley - our server. (I hope I spelled it right.) Give him a raise!!!!

    Photos
    Antonios Pizzeria - Lots of seating on a Saturday afternoon

    Lots of seating on a Saturday afternoon

    Antonios Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza

    Pepperoni pizza

    Antonios Pizzeria - Front sign

    See all

    Front sign

    New Columbus Pizza & Catering - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...