Stopped in here with the family - we ordered large calzones, one was a buffalo chicken and the other a eggplant parmesan. They were both good, the family thought the eggplant was better than the buffalo chicken. The complaint was the buffalo chicken became "one note". In all honesty it was just okay. It was not great it was not bad..... read more

Absolutely love this place. My dad and I meet here at least once a week for lunch. Always greeted with friendly faces and wonderful food. What a great place to spend time with my dad and very convenient location. Always fast service as well. read more

I have thoroughly enjoyed every pizza off of their menu. Specifically love the buff chicken (no red onions :)). Pastas are great, hit the spot immediately. Always get chicken alfredo or meatballs, tastes fresh every time. Harry, the owner, is such a nice man - him and his team have done an awesome job creating relationships with their customers and generating loyal/repeat business. I order for my job all of the time, and everyone always gets excited when they see those boxes come through. Thank you everyone for constantly giving us everything we ask for - definitely happy I came across your restaurant! read more

I was pleasantly surprised by this place. My co-workers and I went here after a late night of work. I was expecting a crappy pizza place. It looks like a crappy pizza place but it was actually really good. I got the chicken parm and was very happy with it. The decor/atmosphere leaves a lot to be desired but if the food is good then I am not that concerned. read more

We are in town for the weekend and your restaurant was recommended. I have to say that this pizza and calzone is among the best Italian I have ever eaten (including when we went to Rome)! The sauce was especially wonderful. I so wished we had you at home in Virginia!! Thanks for the great meal! :) read more

The hamburger sub is excellent! Fries, fingers all terrific. Even the fried chicken was good. My wife loves the calzones! Can't miss there! read more

I always get the Buffalo chicken calzone. I get it with red onion and it is so delicious! Highly recommend :)

Good food, but driver wearing mask with his nose uncovered. Grossed me out. Will not order again.

Short version - excellent veggie pizza and Greek salad. Long version- we aren't local but we were staying one night in a nearby hotel. Chose pizza for dinner as they did delivery, had a cool online ordering app and the reviews were quite good. Used the online ordering app. Ordered large veggie pizza with the addition of onions on half and spinach on the other half. Large Greek salad light on onions, extra feta, and Greek dressing on the side. The app was great to use with lots of modifications available. Even how many slices you wanted the pizza in! Delivery said 50 mins, 7pm on a Saturday night I thought it would be busy. However it arrived in literally 10 mins. !!! Via friendly delivery man. Veggie pizza was delicious. Great mix of veg all cooked well, perfect cheese proportion, base and crust quite light and crispy. Not greasy at all. Veg all tasty and fresh. Greek salad very fresh lettuce. Tasty dressing. All my modifications were done accurately. I should've asked for plates and knives and forks as no plates were provided and just one knife and fork. This is a place that obviously cares about the quality of its food. Yum. Wish it was local to me! read more

Sunday afternoon we ordered 3 large pizzas after waiting 40 minutes for our pizza to be delivered I called. The you lady that answered the phone assured me our pizza was out for delivery. We waited 20 more minutes making the wait time a full hour. We then called and cancelled the order. No apology. No explanation...nothing...not exactly making loyal customers stay loyal. read more

Very floppy, very greasy and no crunch at all, the crust is incredible terrible, y'all gotta fix yo shit if u want me to come back no cap

Several styles of pizza in exeter. This is my favorite. Great crust, better cheese mix, abundant toppings. Fast to deliver. Better in store like all pizza. Salad's will please. Do not be afraid to ask for something you want or do not want, they work hard to please. They have happily sautéed garlic for my pizza over the years. read more

Best pizza in Exeter. Staff is very friendly and they are always quick. They get it right every time!

Being from out of town,we decided to order in at our hotel. We ordered a pepperoni pizza, greek salad and fettuccine with chicken. The portions were more that plenty with a lot of chicken. It all was great!the delivery was fast and courteous. If we visit again we will definitely order from New England Pizza again. read more

I totally love New England Pizza!!! They not only have the best pizza going, but the staff is friendly and fast. My daughter wanted a little pizza party there with her friends and they accommodated us- even opened a bit early so we could set up a bit. The girls loved it!!!! It was a hit. Family friendly for sure!!!! read more

NE pizza isn't the best place in the world, it's the best pizza place in the entire universe!! They have a polite staff and I would definitely recommend this place to parents who have trouble finding a new place to eat. The pepperoni is excellent and I am not sure how they do it. NE Pizza is one of the most delicious pizza place I have ever encountered read more

The pizza is actually not good. Stick to the other stuff. We both had subs and really liked them. The prices are fantastic for the most part. You can get 2 small subs and fries for under $20. It is close to Exeter Hospital so it's a goof local takeout option if you're stuck there. read more

I ordered an Italian sub. Bread, cold cuts and veggies all very fresh and tasty. Long line but the staff was very efficient and friendly. Did not have to wait long for them to deliver it to my table. Appears to be very well managed. read more

I had read reviews about this place stating not to eat the pizza etc at this place...blah blah blah...today my family and I ate at this restaurant and it was fantastic! From the gentleman that took our order that was extremely polite and helpful, the restaurant dining area is spotless, and most importantly our food was fantastic! I highly recommended New England Pizza, the food was great! read more

My kids and I stopped here on our way home from the beach. Everything was excellent! The staff was friendly and the food was served hot, fast and it was delicious! We tried the sandwiches, pasta and pizza along with some fries and all of it was great! read more

Nothing too special here but a pretty decent joint for pizza considering they aren't too many pizza joints in Exeter.

Great place to eat. Excellent staff, delicious food and reasonable prices. No complaints, very satisfied.

Great place for good Italian food! & Such good samwhiches! I reheated sections of my steak sandwich for multiple meals and it tasted great even after a day or two of being refrigerated. You can tell that they use fresh ingredients and care about the food that they are making. Everything I've tried tastes great :) read more

Can always count on a good meal here! Staff is so nice and place is clean! Excellent service, food, service, and all around restaurant!

I've been to this place so many times they have great food and the employees are so nice and they bring your food out to you and cleaning up after you so you won't have to lift a finger read more

My husband and I enjoy this place. The food is all good. We especially like the pizza. Best in the area.

New England Pizza has a nice selection of food and a friendly staff. The food, itself, was fine. I would go back.

2nd time I've been here and it's just OK....last visit we had the pizza was fairly oily and the service was average, nothing fantastic. The decor takes you back in time a little to a booth style pizza bar. Sorry, but id rather make my own at home. read more

Not sure why people are saying the pizza sucks because it was pretty damn good. The garlic bread was good as well. The place was incredibly clean, the staff was very friendly, the food was prepared quickly, and it tasted great. I will be back around when I'm in town... read more

Our favorite place to eat as a family!! The service is quick and the staff is super friendly. We prefer this pizza to all others in the area hands down. The salads and subs are also really good, and the portions are large. As a kid my grandfather took us here all the time after we went bowling. I always loved it and I love that now that we live in the area we can bring our kids here as well. read more

Ended up here after a not so great experience at Station 19. Glad we ended up here because I had an awesome calzone!! The crust was perfect and it was stuffed full of meat and cheese! The staff was friendly and efficient. read more

Passing through the area I stumbled on to this place. Ordered the Buffalo Chicken pizza and I have say that it was as good or better than anything I had before. Just the right amount of buffalo sauce, a generous amount of chicken, which looked like sliced pieces of fried white meat chicken, and a nice topping of delicious cheese. The restaurant appears very well run and very clean. I'll be back for sure. read more

Good, straight ahead, no gimics pizza parlor. Thin, crispy and just greasy enough. Spacious dining area. They also have dinners, but I've never tried those, and baklavah. All I can think of when I look across the street is I'm glad I'm not at KFC. read more

There are several quality pizza joints in town and while I've had decent experiences here in the past, their toppings tend to be light too often. Tonight might have been the clincher unfortunately when my "large" had about 8 total pieces of mushroom on the entire thing read more

The pizza here is ok, and is about a 2.5. It isn't amazing, but it certainly isn't terrible. As mentioned in the previous post, I would have to disagree that the crust is thin, the crust is kind of thick here but not AS thick as a Chicago style pizza. The menu here is quite large and has all kinds of sandwiches. The dining room is quite large and very clean. They have a TV which usually has the news on, which is nice. The manager is amazing and will even order special food if you request and actually order it, I really wanted salmon on my salad and he placed it back on the menu. If you need a quick lunch and are in Exeter, this place is worth it. read more

I was able to try the food here during a recent trip to Exeter since it is just a short distance from my hotel. I had a calzone with pepperoni and sausage and it was fantastic. It was pretty huge and stuffed with meat, cheese, and sauce. The prices were low and the quality seemed to be pretty high so I will try and stop by here again when I'm in town. read more

Love this place! I can't say anything bad about them, except they aren't close to my house and I have to travel to eat here.

This is truly the best pizza in Exeter . The place is always so clean the salads are great I don't know where they get there turkey from but it's a different kind than I've had at other places it's great. I like this place for the food the cleanliness I tried to speak to the owner last time I went in he was very busy. His names Harry I will personally pay him a compliment some day . Keep up the good work . read more

This place is amazing. Amazing. You need this. Eat in. The smell will have you drooling while waiting for your food. The food you receive may surprise you by being even tastier than the smell you've been drooling over. read more

Went here last week with my family. We are new to the area and wanted to find a family style pizza restaurant. This place is pretty great. Although the food is really only about a 7 out of 10 the atmosphere is perfect for bringing a family with young kids. They could be a little loud without ruining anyone's dinner. Great service and overall a really clean nice family restaurant. We will come back! read more