I have been wanting to try this pizza place for a while. Upon entering, we were greeted by a very friendly cashier. She was so warm and inviting. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place was very clean and calm.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We ordered a large cheese pizza and a steak and cheese. The steak and cheese was good, all of the cheese was at the bottom of the bun in the crack. The meat needed some flavoring. More salt and pepper on the meat and it would've been perfect. It was kind of flavorless. The bun was nice and soft. The cheese pizza the cheese was toasted to perfection. It was good. It won't be replacing my favorite pizza joint. But I was not disappointed in our lunch choice. read more

See all

Very good, food hot and fresh. Can't wait to go back. Pizza calzone sub was amazing. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Place is very very clean[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]], [[HIGHLIGHT]]I do wish a little background music was playing.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

For an early dinner a friend and I decided on pizza here. Since it was 4 PM, the establishment was almost empty. I made my order at the counter and took a seat. The order (for a party of 2) for was for 2 small pizzas (forgot the exact price, was about $16 ea.) - the loaded and the chicken artichoke. These were made to order, so it took 30 minutes to arrive. These were piping hot and with slightly crisped crusts. Imagine Pizza Hut's pan pizza, but local and with much more passion and care. Otherwise, tasted like the decent local pizza place that's your default if you live around here. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Decor looks like 90s pizza hut minus the kale (yeah, kale used to be decoration) in a positive, family-restaurant-oriented sense.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

New England Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

See all

Best pizza in Exeter! Pricey, yes but worth it every once in a while Great location, easy in and out

Just ate a yummy steak and cheese calzone! The Steak was great quality!Fresh and Hot!

Visited the coast and had to stop at New England pizza on our way home. We lived in Exeter for years and then moved away so it was a nice opportunity to visit our old stomping grounds and enjoy one of our favorite restaurants. Their pizzas a huge with lots of toppings, their calzones are equally delicious. Meatballs are my favorite! The staff is always friendly and helpful. I have a restricted diet and they are always willing to customize to my needs. Give New England puzza a try when you are in the area. read more

Great place, great food, great service!! The employees are very friendly. Haven't had a disappointing order.

New England Pizza Restaurant I placed an online order for takeout large Buffalo chicken pizza. Arrived at the restaurant with my 8yr old and we decided to eat there. We sat down and ate and the pizza was pretty good. It had a nice crunchy crust. It was LOADED with cheese. And LOADED with crunchy large-cut chicken tenders. The cheese had a nice golden glow to it and the pizza was a pleasure to eat. Each time I got a bite of chicken I had a really nice crunch. I've said crunch like 5 times now and it's the theme here. It wasn't delivered to us with blue cheese but I asked and the girl delivered one to us. The blue cheese side was huge, and had monster chunks of blue cheese in it. I would assume being this large it should have been an extra charge but she handed it over for free. (Just an assumption....it's 2023 people, nothing is free anymore) The girl at the register was awesome. I went up and asked to purchase two drinks and she was able to add them to my order without taking my card again. More about her...she was AWESOME. She seemed to know everyone who came through the door. The "how's your family" type. She came out to the dining area (often) and checked on everyone including us, made sure everyone had what they needed, checked on the timing of numerous orders for incoming customers. From the dining area, she's the only one I hear. Thanking every customer, managing the register. Smiling at everyone. And hustling around soliciting everyone's needs, and meeting them with a smile. If I were in charge of that place reading this I would sit her down and commend her for incredible service. I wish I got her name but I hope if her boss reads this he knows who I'm talking about. 4 stars not 5 because it was good, but 5 stars is reserved for those special places I go outta my way for when I need that specific fix. read more

See all

Everything is excellent here. I love the cheesy garlic bread. I love the pizza. I love the chicken Parm dinner. The subs are great. Always very nice people. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place is exceptionally clean.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

My go-to spot for pizza! I love and appreciate that the food is always consistently good.

While my truck was being serviced i walked up the street and found new england pizza and im glad i did. Everyone that was working where super nice, i ordered ziti w meatballs and it was very good came out fast also [[HIGHLIGHT]]nice clean atmosphere![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] i'll be back next time im in exeter. read more

Very good. Highly recommend getting pineapple pizza with bacon. The service is wonderful and the boss is great. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambiance is very throwback![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

They have awesome chicken fingers (my favorite), with the sweet and sour dipping sauce! The pizza is good as well. Not exceptional, but good. I go there for those dang chicken fingers but when I am there, I will pick up a pie as well. read more

The chicken tender sub is the way to go. The service is fantastic and quick, even on a Friday night. Worth every dollar going to this place! read more

i've been coming to this place for over 10 years. The pizza is always delicious. Always. If you love Greek style pizza this is the place for you. Their salads are fresh and delicious as well. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Their dining room is spacious and clean.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The young folks who work there are very professional and do a good job. I highly recommend this place if you are in Exeter. I'll be back. read more

As a newcomer to Exeter I was looking for a moderately priced Italian eatery. There are a couple upscale places but New England Pizza seemed like a good option for an informal outing. Do not like the service set up. No waiters; a post-Covid thing?. Ordering at counter off a menu wall makes it less appealing. With takeout customers lining up the situation prompts an almost hasty selection. Thankfully, They bring the food to table. The server was good and overall the staff was helpful and friendly. [[HIGHLIGHT]]There are plenty of tables but the focus appears to be on takeout, again a Covid aftermath?[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Did not try pizza but maybe next time. Thought spaghetti would provide a good barometer of quality. Rate it as B minus. A bit gummy and like what appears to be typical in the Exeter area, the sauce lacked nuance. This could be a very nice restaurant if it had a wait staff, something to consider in a town with an older population that prefers to be seated. read more

We order from New England pizza at work. So far I have loved anything I have ordered. The eggplant calzone (I add ricotta) is excellent. Cooked to perfection!! Thanks for great lunches!! read more

Sometimes you're just too tired to go back out of the hotel. After reading the reviews in which so many yelpers talked about delivery, I decided this would be the way to go for dinner as we'd had a big lunch -- even though this place was only down the road a bit. We ordered online using their app and it was pretty easy putting in all our choices -- salad dressings, pizza size, special toppings, adding in a drink, etc. The app said it would be about 45 minutes to arrive, but they also provided a tracking chart. Immediately after we ordered, the app told us they were starting our order. It seemed only 10 minutes later that a truck picture appeared saying our order was on the way. We had advised the front desk to call us when they arrived and they were there pdq. The order was exactly as we'd placed it -- a small cheese pizza with added sausage and mushrooms. It was cut into 8 small slices. And perfect for two people to share. The pizza was t the best I'd ever had, but way better than dominos. The mushrooms were fresh and the sausage was cut into thin slices. Actually liked the toppings better than the crust, but still decent. We also had ordered an antipasto salad for one -- way too large for two people even when it arrived. A mix of romaine and iceberg lettuces, celery, green peppers, grape tomatoes topped with rolls of ham, capicola, salami, and cheese on top. We had gotten both creamy Italian and regular Italian dressing. Both were good. So next time you're in the area and or feeling lazy, this may be your answer. read more

New England Pizza Restaurant - Small sausage & mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

See all

New England Pizza is the Gold Standard in Exeter area. The subs are humungous and the pizza thin and hot always. I work at an auto dealer down the street and they deliver super fast and are always friendly. They are our only choice. read more

​ if I could give less than one star I would the price and the quality of food has gone down drastically since the pandemic I've lived in Exeter for 18 years just went back for the first time in three the meatballs taste like uncooked rubber the pizza was horrible and I paid $25 for a small pizza and a crappy meatball sub I don't know if the same owner still owns the place he was a good guy but his food and staff are horrible now the place took a total nose dive read more

Great pizza place. I stopped in on a Sunday, early afternoon. There weren't that many people there so I didn't know what to expect. I ordered the their signature pizza and fried mushrooms. The fried mushrooms were "meh" but the pizza was excellent. The staff was very friendly. I'll definitely eat there again when I'm out that way again. read more

New England Pizza Restaurant - Fried mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

See all

High ratings on here,are why we stopped in for dinner. Friend ordered a pizza, I ordered the Chinese chicken salad and a side of sweet potato fries. I didn't see a water option on the fountain machine, so we also purchased bottles of water. The salad arrived with a container of refrigerated salad dressing, no chicken. So I mentioned to the man it was meant to have chicken, he seemed confused. He took it back, about five minutes later brought out one with chicken, but didn't bring the dressing this time, so a third return...he brought it. Which had to be warmed in my hands a bit, since it was to thick in the container to pour on. I am guessing this might be a great pizza place, and to order take out, however I wouldn't take anyone here for a sit down meal. Other options in the area. read more

I absolutely love this restaurant! I have been going here for many years, always top notch. What stands out to me the most is the costumer service. The staff are truly amazing. I want to recognize Pam. She greets you with a big smile and goes far beyond her role to satisfy everyone's needs. She is always running around, working hard. She makes my day!!! Thank you Pam for being so great and always making our trips to New England pizza amazing! read more

Always fresh, always delicious and always friendly - this is not a pizza joint, this is a family restaurant with wonderful homemade food - one of the best places to eat in Exeter by a mile. read more

Positive Yelp reviews lead us to this place. The feel of the restaurant is a bit dated, however clean and well kept. My husband ordered a calzone full of ricotta, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms and jalapeños. He said it was the best Calzone he's ever had! I ordered a small buffalo chicken pizza (no red onions, had leftovers) and it was super yummy. Clean white chicken, great sauce, I ordered it extra crispy. We definitely recommend dining here, service was great, staff was friendly, good was great! read more

New England Pizza Restaurant - Calzone and Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

I ordered a small meat lovers pizza, onion rings, 1 beer and 2 waters. How can you get this order wrong? The pizza tasted like store bought frozen pizza (Totinos type) cheese didn't even melt. They didn't even make the onions rings. I brought it up to the cashier and all she said was "oh, you still want them?!" I also got charged for 2 tap waters in the plastic courtesy cups! Brought this up to them and was told they would refund this back to my card... I'm sure this is not going to happen! Just as we were leaving, the girl shows up with the onion rings and then rolls her eyes at us when we tell her we're leaving. I don't think this will be refunded either. I can see why this place was fairly empty on a Friday night. They really don't care . read more

One of the best pizza/sub shops in the Seacoast. Food is always very consistent and delicious. Staff is super friendly and they take great care with covid precautions in terms of cleaning and food handling. Owning a restaurant I know when one another is on top of their game and NE pizza is. Go to lunch there on a regular basis. read more

It was ok, it's not a hand stretched dough which is a disappointment and the garden salad was over priced for a bunch of lettuce. Took home some baklava it was horrible stale and soggy. We tried the place but not sure we'll be back for the pizza. read more

Good pizza, nice people. Was in town for work and this place was the highest reviewed. It did not disappoint. read more

This Is my favorite nearby pizza. It has a not-thin crust with a good sauce and great selection of toppings. I love the fresh tomatoes. The sliced garlic is sharp -watch out! The pepperoni is not too spicy but flavorable. You enter and order at the counter. Lines, even when busy, move quickly and everyone who works here is so nice. After you order (and they have subs and some pasta dishes, too), you chose a clean and comfortable table or booth in the dining area and they will deliver it to your table when ready. There is also a bench for waiting if you are getting takeout. I'm a big fan of their New England style Greek pizza. To me, this is my go-to pizza when pizza is what I crave. read more

New England Pizza Restaurant - the logo of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

Order was ready to go when I arrived to pickup. Pizza and calzone were hot and delicious. Salads were nice and cold and fresh lettuce. My husband appreciated the bite size cut on lettuce for his Ceaser salad. read more

Stopped in for a quick meal. I was very hungry so I ordered a salad and a sandwich. Every thing was fresh and delicious. The host was exceptionally pleasant. Would order again if they were nearby! read more

See all

I just moved to the neighborhood and was looking for a pizza place. I found New England Pizza on Yelp and absolutely loved the food. The staff also are very friendly. I will definitely buy from them again. read more

I have ordered take out twice. It's what you expect from a pizza joint however the pizza and food are very well made and the staff are very nice . Their online ordering is seamless and perfect for people who have to know where everything and anything is. Very efficient. read more

Clean!! It's never too crowded and they serve you fast. The pizza is really saucy and is definitely different than dominoes or mama lena's. I'd recommend eating in here. read more

We were staying at a hotel nearby and ordered delivery from here! The food was shockingly amazing!! Usually I don't love delivery from pizza places, but this place amazed me! The food arrived quick and hot! We ordered a bunch of random things but there were two standouts. 1. The cheese pizza was delicious!! We got extra cheese and it was one of the best pizzas I've ever had! 2. The wings! My boyfriend loved them! They weren't soggy like most wings, they were crunchy and packed with flavor! Highly recommend this place! read more

I ordered a simple meatballs and pasta not only was the pasta cold the meat balls looked like they had been froze. and reheated GROSS dry garlic It's like they put zero effort into making a 11.00 dollar plate that I could make for about 6 dollar at home so the fact that people do this to the public is sick so if you want cold meat balls and dry bread go here if i could give it zero stars i would By the way flat soda as well the one time that I do drink it its flat! read more

NH pizza is typically very bad. Front Row is greasy, and Mama Lenas is cardboard. Then, I found NE Pizza, It has a great crust, good sauce and consistent. Staff is super friendly too. They are the closest thing to good New York pizza I have found. read more

Friendly and excellent service! Great food, large portions and reasonable prices. Would definitely recommend.

Shitty customer service. I ordered two small pizzas over the phone and when I came to pick it up one of them was a large even though I know for a fact I order two small. When I got to the counter to pay I told the guyAnd I ordered a small and not a large kind of expecting him so at least offer to correct it or just charging for the small like they would have at any place with good customer service would have. Instead he just kind of give me a blank stare and was silent indicating that I need to pay for the large even though I know I did not order it. Are the customer why should I have to pay for something I didn't order makes no sense read more