These bagels are so delicious and I love a cafe that serves Peerless coffee (french vanilla - yum!). I tried the Everything bagel with Jalapeno smear and omg, so yummy. The coffee was piping hot and fresh and they had all the fixins there to make it just how you like it. There are a TON of bagel options and I can't wait to go back to try them all. This shop also has sandwiches and great lunch options. Super clean, friendly staff, and parking is plenty out front. Can get busy so just come knowing that. read more

I am a transplanted New Yorker and this place, by far, is the closest thing to actual NY bagels that I have found in the Bay Area, and I've lived here for 15 years. I came upon them almost by accident while stopping to charge my car at the Tesla chargers in Strawberry Village and was surprised and delighted to find that "NY Bagels," isn't just a throwaway name like many places -- they actually will bring you back to the wonderful NY bagel you love. I am an instant fan. Funny, charging my car in Strawberry Village has introduced me to some great businesses -- not just the terrific NY Bagels but also the wonderful Thep Lela Thai restaurant. read more

I was in the area dropping my dog off at the vet and wanted a bagel. My go to order is a pesto bagel double toasted with sun dried tomato cream cheese, but they did not have pesto. I went with a jalapeño bagel and the same cream cheese instead. The woman at the counter was friendly and service was quick. When it came to the bagel itself, it was different from what I expected. The flavor, texture, and bright orange color threw me off. I was expecting a classic bagel with jalapeños and melted cheese on top, but here the dough itself was flavored. The sun dried tomato cream cheese was fine, though it could have used more tomatoes for a stronger taste. read more

New York Bagels - Jalapeño bagel w/sun dried tomato cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Mill Valley, California

See all

Good bagel spot and coffee to have before going to hike around mt tamalpais or marin county etc. luckily this spot was open at 6:30 but officially 7am. The bagels were getting stocked as well as coffee. Bagels were good, they had a different taste to them compared to noahs. Coffee was great. I love the generous amount of shmear per bagel. read more

See all

Got a bagel sandwich which was good, the service was fast and quick! Prices were very reasonable, I will go back. read more

New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Mill Valley, California

They have gotten very stingy with the spread. I mean for almost $5 a bagel, they don't even cover the bagel. This is nothing like a New York style deli. These people are greedy. Won't be coming back. read more

New York Bagels generously donated a huge variety of bagels to our theater group, and we couldn't have been more grateful. They were incredibly kind and even offered to give us more than we could carry. The bagels were still wonderfully fresh, and our entire team was delighted to have them. It meant so much to feel this level of generosity and support for local theater--thank you! read more

New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Mill Valley, California

Wonderful bagels! If you are looking for an alternative to fluffy, steamed bagels and want the New York experience- this is the place!

Such generosity!!! Thank you New York Bagels for donating such a bountiful bag of bagels to our group. It helped keep us energized for an evening of creation, and we are so very grateful. read more

Decent bagels and super quick service. I got a bagel with turkey and cheese and it somehow ended up being $10 which is kinda crazy. Was a solid bagel and I'd come by again if I'm nearby, but def wouldn't go out of my way to come back. read more

New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Mill Valley, California

Excellent service , delicious bagels, many "flavors". Phone order and pick up always works.

I have been coming here for years and this place never disappoints. I always order an everything bagel with butter and strawberry cream cheese, and it is always delicious and reasonably priced. The woman who works here is always incredibly friendly and makes the experience even better. I love the ambiance, but I do wish it were a little faster at times and that there was more seating. read more

Thus little gem was introduced to me. They have the freshest bagels being made. They have selections of what they can make for your breakfast or lunch meal. The service is great, looks like only 2 individuals were working when I went in on Saturday at 130pm. There are seating inside and outside the shop and they can quickly make your order quickly. Clean and ambiance is very casual. read more

Finally found a place with legit egg bagels!!! These bagels rock! Lox is legit as well.

I have been coming here since I was a kid and everything they make is outstanding! They have a great selection of bagels and freshly made cream cheeses all of which are perfect. Can get pretty busy on weekend mornings but even then the wait is hardly ever longer than five minutes. They are a family run business and one of the only places you can find a chocolate chip bagel. Literally everything is worth a try here, and even better they still charge a very reasonable price far below the trendier bagel shops in the bay. read more

Love the place Comfortable , but small 4/5 table, one outdoor Breakfast/ Brunch within Strawberry shopping center in Millvalley. Don't know if anyone can ever beat the level of extraordinary restaurants located in and around NYC. Bagels were first created in lower East Side of Manhattan Cre Orthodox Jewish Hts. Of Brooklyn mell as w Bagels are traditional Jewish favorites here are Onion and the Everything bagel. staple of Brooklyn anytime but definitely for breakfast thru 2:30 is recreated here . Enjoy ! read more

My partner was so excited to find this place. He is from the east coast (NY specially) and so always complains about how the bagels and the pizza are lacking here. But this is the first place where he said the bagels were pretty decent and the best he's found in the area. He said that it doesn't quite meet NY standards but still liked it so much that he bought an extra half dozen bagels during our visit for his work friends from New York who have also missed the bagels. We live kind of far from here but would definitely be back the next time we are in the area. The lines can get pretty long here in the mornings but there's plenty of parking in the lot. There's also little seating in the shop, only about 4-5 small tables. read more

New York Bagels - Everything bagel with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Mill Valley, California

See all

Walking into a warm watering smell of goodness. Ordered the Cheese beagle breakfast with bacon and American cheese. Delicious and my tummy stopped rumbling. Wash it it down with a hot French vanilla cup of fresh made coffee. read more

New York Bagels - Breakfast beagle - Bagels Near Me - Mill Valley, California

Fast, efficient, clean, friendly, and absolutely dependable. These aren't fancy artisan bagels with English lager and lavender infused in the dough. These are basic down-to-earth bagels made for the Everyman and if you judge the product on these terms, no one, absolutely no one does it better! read more

Though the wait was long, the bagels were fluffy and delicious. The bacon egg and cheese sandwiches looked like they were just reheated egg, which is why I ordered a bagel with cream cheese, which was fantastic! They had fun cream cheese flavors, like strawberry and maple walnut which were very sweet. read more

New York Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Mill Valley, California

Finally got to eat a sourdough bagel!!! I'm from NJ on holiday in CA and I was so excited to see this on the menu. It was exactly how I thought it would taste and better. This will be my breakfast book for sure this week! read more

Super expensive $5 for a puffy bagel. $7.50 with cream cheese, ridiculous for mediocre quality

YUMS!!! SO worth it for the price. They were generous w the salmon and it was so good I walked back in to get another bagel the bagel itself was the perfect texture. Solid enough on the outside and soft on the inside but not too soft! The texture where its still kinda hard to chew i guess :p My only wish is that it was closer by to home read more

New York Bagels - Lox sandwich w/ salt bagel, everything bagel, and poppy bagel. - Bagels Near Me - Mill Valley, California

the most real, authentic bagels in the bay area (but the bialy not real, tasty, but unauthentic). very good loX, too. B.XL.

Best bagel sandwich I've ever had, was very delicious, perfectly fresh and creamy and was very well sauced, could eat 3 of their empire bagels. read more

Nice detour from Noah's and other chains, this owner-operated store just off 101 is a reliable spot for a brkfst bagel. I love salt bagels and find NY's to have just the right amount of salt to jump-start me after a run. They make all the bagels on site and will whip up all kinds of eggy sandos. read more

New York Bagels - Love the salty bagel!! - Bagels Near Me - Mill Valley, California

Their bagels are super good and so are their sandwiches. My favorite of each are the three cheese bagel, the cinnamon sugar bagel, and the farmhouse sandwich. I tend to stock up so I love that I can bulk buy and then pop 'em in my freezer to eat over the next little bit. read more

Amazing bagels and so happy they offer vegan cream cheese! Wish every bagel place did!! I always come here when I visit my friend who lives down the street, and the first thing we do is stop here for bagels. Best in Mirin!! read more

Wonderful bagels and very fast service - love their breakfast bagel sandwiches! I would highly recommend!

Delicious breakfast sandwiches! I recommend ordering ahead on the app so that you don't have to wait in line! This place can get busy on weekend mornings! read more

Stopped here on the way up to Nappa. As a former New Yorker and now South Floridian, I was very happy. The bagels were absolutely perfect. Light and just enough salt on the salt bagel . The lox bagel was perfect with red onion and capers.Really really great bagels!! read more

Second time I have gotten a chocolate chip Bagel without 1 single chocolate chip in the Bagel. Wth? Can I get a chocolate chip?

I really enjoyed their bagels. They have the density and flavoring that makes for a great bagel plus lots of different choices. They also let you customize a bakers dozen box on the delivery apps which essentially makes them my go to place . I've been here a number of times years ago and glad they are still a solid bagel choice in Marin after "rediscovering" them recently. read more

I like this place, very friendly staff and the food is good. Just once I got a wrong order, and realized it after I drove home. Would be great if you could improve the phone orders, I never was able to place an order over the phone. read more

We kinda discovered this place during COVID. My hubs is from New Jersey and i lived in NY for 7 years...suffice it to say pizza and bagels are judged harshly in our household. I've come to lower my standards for bagels and breakfast sandwiches, and more often than not just opt for something different given it's so hard to recreate the NY bagel experience outside of the tri state region (I don't understand why and don't buy the water explanation...if you have other theories please enlighten me!) They were fast and efficient (appreciated during the pandemic). The bagels themselves were surprisingly not bad. If I got them in Ny I'd probably say "meh, not the best, not the worst" but getting them in Marin I thought "hey this is pretty good!" We'll definitely make this our go to bagel place, given we're not likely to patronize any of the big chains like Noah's or Posh. The breakfast sandwich was fine. Well probably get it again when the hankering strikes, and I'm looking forward to making our own with their bagels. Overall as a native Californian who misses NY bagels from time to time this place definitely hits the spot. read more

New York Bagels continues to be a solid, affordable breakfast option in Mill Valley. The bagels are always fresh; the service is fast & friendly; and I'm usually in and out in less than 5 minutes for around $5. On my most recent visit, I decided to try one of their classic breakfast sandwiches (with egg, bacon, and melted pepper jack cheese on a sesame seed bagel). It certainly filled me up, though I couldn't help but wonder how much better this sandwich would've been with a fresh tomato and maybe a little aioli and/or hot sauce. I guess I'm a little spoiled these days with all the breakfast sandwich options around town. In any case, I'll just make it a point to request those extra toppings on my next visit. If you need breakfast in a hurry and don't want McDonald's or Starbucks, poke your head into New York Bagels. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised. read more

These are the best bagels ive had so far since moving here. I got the cranberry and my husband got pumpernickel with veggie cream cheese. Service was fast and friendly. There was a huge crowd around 9am when we were there. I wish there was some outdoor seating and a little water pitched for people who just want a cup of water. We will be back. read more

See all

This is a great example of a disappearing species in southern Marin County. It's a local family run business that serves good food with good ingredients and doesn't cut corners, and does so at an economical price. And it has done so for many years. I tend to go here for the bagels with butter or cream cheese, or the breakfast bagel sandwich with eggs and ham or bacon, so nothing too fancy. But I notice that when I do order a true sandwich such as a turkey combo, that's excellent too. So I've done my share of what I thought were well-deserved very critical reviews, but this is a place that I feel totally great about endorsing after visiting there many dozens of times, if not over 100 times, over the years they have been at Strawberry Village. read more

Large selection of bagles and schmers. Delicious and nicely managed bagel shop. If you are looking for a quick tasty bite, this is your place! Pleasant staff. read more

Yum. Quite crowded in the mornings. Highly advised ordering ahead and saving yourself the time.