I don't have any good photos because we order NY panini for takeout and the second I get home I eat the entire thing without pause. This place is so insanely good. Not only are they able to pull up your last order on their end (perfect for the custom sandwich that you just can remember what you got). TONS of options-from the classic to the outlandish. Lots of vegetarian options, and the most insanely delicious fries in the area. Portions are HUGE and reheat well. Great service and convenient location. Will be back a million more times. read more

a really nice place to get a great panini! i love the options they have & the staff were very kind. would definitely come here again! the 631 sampler was great !! & I couldn't stop eating the fries. They were delicious. The Flex Wrap was amazing & big portion too. The Nashville Panini is more of a sweet flavor than your typical Nashville so it was a bit of a surprise, but great chicken & cheese. read more

See all

Great place for gluten free sandwiches. I've been coming here for over 15 years and always stop by when I'm in Huntington

Amazing sandwiches! My partner and I come every time we visit from the city. So consistently good

Pincetta was excellent, perfect amount of sauce, greens, and delicious chicken cutlet. 10/10 will return. Thanks for dinner!

New York Panini is one of my go to places in Huntington for take out. After partnering with the Mets and Coca Cola they've really ramped up the decorations inside and their own personal branding, which is really good to see! For the most part, their sandwiches are great, and there are so many options to choose from. My all time favorite used to be the Massimo, which was a panini with deli ham, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, romaine, balsamic and herb mayo on ciabatta. While this is no longer on the menu, you can still get it through their BYO panini option, and that's what I do every time! Something about the salty ham and cheese with fresh greens and tangy balsamic really just satisfies every food craving I can think of. If you haven't already, do yourself a favor and order this!!! read more

New York Panini - The Massimo, no longer on the menu, but I got it as a BYO panini! - Salad Near Me - Huntington, New York

Very pleasant staff that make up some delicious paninis that are large enough to bring leftovers home to enjoy the next time you have a hankering for some great tastes. Located just steps from the Christmas tree set up for the holidays, we came in for hot chocolate for the kids and we noticed some different beer from a local brewery for purchase in the cooler. The nice man behind the counter informed us that they were buy 3 get one free. A good deal for some local flavor Although the dining area was on the smaller side, it would be a good spot for 2-3 guests to eat together. A few high top tables were available for small groups. Well worth the stop in. read more

New York Panini - a woman and a child in a store - Salad Near Me - Huntington, New York

Always amazing. Must admit both my son and I always order the same thing. They have what we normally order saved by our phone number. I can just say the usual please. Always fresh, always delicious. read more

Great food & great service . Two fellas , an older gentleman & a younger guy. Both were Super friendly & helpful. I was unsure of what to get ... they made suggestions. We shared a huge portion of Tuscan fries - delicious! We both got a panini ( could only eat 1/2) big portions . . The bread really makes a big difference & the sandwiches were amazing)! I would definitely go back AND I would highly recommend this particular spot. You will not be disappointed . read more

Such delicious paninis. Sooo many options, literally something for everyone. The friessss are to die for!! If you like the battered type fry (almost like double fried?) this is your spot. Omg drool worth. Couple seats inside where you can sit and eat. read more

Very good place. Lots of food options and service is fast. Would definitely go back again

Called and ordered a chicken parm panini for pick up. The panini was awesome and huge, was able to feed two of us for lunch. Will definitely go back can't wait to try all of their different fun paninis! read more

New York Panini - Chicken parm panini - Salad Near Me - Huntington, New York

I have been a huge fan of NY Panini for almost a dozen years, dating back to when they were still called La Bottega. In all that time, nothing has changed in terms of the excellent quality of their paninis. It's one of my family's go-to delivery meals. Also a tradition for us for picnic dinners in the park, and whenever (pre-pandemic) me and my wife are headed in to NYC for a concert, we get paninis to go (usually the perfect classic eggplant parm) and eat them in the car on the way in. Anyway, you cannot go wrong with their selections. The Norbie Monster is AMAZING, consisting of not one but two burgers, with crispy bacon, peperoncino cheese, hot peppers, red onions, tomatoes, mixed greens and spicy mayo on a round rustic roll. My family dared me to finish it and I have finished it, more than once! Other faves I ALWAYS order: Caltanissetta (hot sopressata, fontina, hot peppers, tomatoes & baby arugula on ciabatta), Foggia (breaded eggplant, smoked mozzarella, olive paste & sun-dried tomatoes on krispina), Ancona (breaded chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, hot peppers, mixed greens & tomatoes on ciabatta), Avellino (sweet sausage, smoked mozzarella, red onions, tomatoes & hot peppers on round rustic roll), Pepe (prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, red onions, olives, hot peppers & spicy mayo on ciabatta), Catania (marinated tuna, fontina, olives, red onions & mixed greens on whole wheat). It isn't just Italian flavors, either. I tried the Pierre Park Po'Boy recently (fried shrimp, iceberg lettuce & homemade creamy remoulade sauce on a round rustic roll) and it rocked. Salads are also wonderful. We love the farro salad (grilled chicken, arugula, barley, grape tomatoes, hot peppers, hearts of palm, gorgonzola, honey mustard) as well as the beet salad. read more

New York Panini - I turn into a food monster when we get NY Panini takeout... - Salad Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Had lunch here today and I have to say this was the best lunch choice for a sandwich! I'm glad I stopped in for lunch here! Nice clean place, the people at the counter were super friendly! I ordered the Tribeca Panini, super fresh, delicious and the bread was so crispy! Big sandwich but so so worth it! I'll definitely be visiting here again read more

Amazing. I wish this place was closer, I'd eat here everyday. My panini was delicious as were the sweet potato fries and just as good the next day!! Also very accommodating for gluten free, with plenty of options for celiacs. read more

New York Panini - Cotoletta - Salad Near Me - Huntington, New York

I haven't been here in a hot minute but we decided to give it a go tonight. My bf is the type that will be exasperated by picking up an item from the store but he'll drive just about anywhere for a good sandwich. I digress. We had the Hulk and the Headbanger. We also tried out their meatballs and the Greek salad. He rated his sandwich an 8.5/10 I would say mine was about a 7/10. He would have liked a little more sauce, as it was a tad dry. The bread on mine was a little funky- while not bad it didn't taste quite fresh but it was still good. The chicken had some leftover grill remnants- parts of it tasted like the it got stuck bottom of the grill but not in a good way. Overall, solid sandwich. Meatballs were a little dry, but tasty. Sauce is slightly bland, could have had some more seasoning. The Greek salad was fresh, but it's a very plain Greek salad no pepperocinis or grape leaves here. The counter people are fast and friendly. You can eat in or take out. The inside is small, you can sit in the front on the shared counter area (kind of like a coffee shop) or at the little barrel tables. The tables are actual barrels. We chose to take out bc what's better than tasty sandwiches and a good movie? They also have a selection of Sand City Beer here which is awesome, because they have great stuff. Nice to see local supporting local. read more

Tried a bunch of different paninis. A chicken one, a steak one, eggplant parm. My favorite was the steak one that had avocados in it. The eggplant one was also pretty good. I didn't get to try the chicken one but my coworkers said it was pretty good. The price is a bit on the high side for the size. read more

Nice panini lot to choose from always enjoy coming here for lunch quality pannini god bless

So nice! Yes it's a chain, dark + not my preferred decor (nor comfortable seating for eating in) but the nicest guys. Panini was out of this world- shared the garlic chicken alfresco. Get a side of marinara. Perfect! read more

I am full. Thank you, New York Panini. I am looking forward to trying every sandwich (and maybe a salad one day if I ever turn my life around) on the menu. read more

I ordered 2 sandwiches tonight by delivery. It came right around the time it was supposed to. One sandwich was good but the other had fried chicken. The chicken was severely undercooked. I noticed by the texture when I bit into it. I looked at it and it was still lucite and not white. I called and the person who answered didn't seem to care. He said he'd make another which at this point we waited an hour and we didn't want to wait another hour. He said he'd pass it along to the boss. I didn't get a call back. I know businesses are struggling but he could have offered to refund the one sandwich as it was a $20 sandwich. Not even a store credit to try again. Edit: My girlfriend ate her sandwich. She had food poisoning all night and her chicken was cooked. Really glad I threw mine away. Also still no call from the owner/boss as promised. read more

New York Panini - Undercooked chicken - Salad Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Very disappointed when they went to takeout only. That being said we live the food (and soup). The Tomato and mozzarella (add chicken cutlets) on a krispina is my go to sandwich. Add a tomato & cheddar and I'm done. Delicious read more

Not but I got the salad cause I'm on keto but the bread looked delicious and you get big servings for the spend!

You should be embarrassed to have served the chewy, dried out Verrazano chicken panini at the CitiField Comfort zone last week. I can only asssume you serve a much better version of it at your main site in Huntington. I should have been tipped off by the absence of any line at all 5 minutes before the first pitch. And at $25 a sandwich, I was angry at myself for ordering it. Do better. read more

Very friendly guys. Food was great, came out hot and quick. Very happy with the experience

The place is very dark and has a Met's street theme... I don't know who decided to do this but it really took away from the ambiance. The service was great but the Chicken on the salad was very dry. I'm not sure what direction this store is going, but its not at the same level it used to be. read more

Very good chicken sandwiches, highly recommend this place, Very tasty salads. I personally like both the paninis and the salads.

Came in at 7:45 pm and they told me they were closing. Little rude, menu sounded good and wanted to try. They should update their hours so as not to inconvenience others. read more

Excellent panini selection! I got the Foggia (Breaded eggplant, smoked mozzarella, olive paste & sun-dried tomato on krispina) and my husband got the Bensonhurst (Prosciutto, parma ham, hot sopressata, fress mozzarella, red peppers, red wine vin on ciabatta). A little pricy for the size but delicious sandwiches. read more

We decided to spend Columbus Day in Huntington Village and this is my third or fourth time here. They never disappoint! I had The Hulk (chicken, pesto, mozzarella, and artichoke) and it was terrific. My 8 1/2 year old son had his heart set on grilled cheese which was not on the menu. "No problem," the gentleman working the counter said. "We can do that for him." He loved it! We also got their homemade fries with parmesan cheese on them and they were like nothing else we'd ever had! The fries alone are worth a return trip. I also got butternut squash soup which was delicious. I was told, however, that that's a seasonal item. So get there while you can! Great food, wonderful service, and generous portion sizes. I will definitely be back! read more

I got New York Panini delivery I ordered it earlier in the day to arrive at my house by 4:40. The delivery guy got here at 4:35, perfect timing! My panini was piping hot and delicious. They never disappoint!! read more

New York Panini - Well done grilled chicken and mozzarella!! - Salad Near Me - Huntington, New York

My younger brother actually introduced this spot to me and I can't believe how often I've walked by this spot! It's small but it has enough seating. If you're familiar with Huntington then you can also use one of the back parking lots to get to this spot instead of street parking as they have a back door entrance as well. Their menu has SO many options which I really appreciate- there's something for anyone with any dietary need. I went with their tomato and basil panini just to try them out and I was not disappointed. Bread was perfectly toasted, not too crisp, flavor is great and their tomato cheddar soup made me regret getting a small size! You can also call ahead and pick up your order. staff was also friendly. I'll definitely be coming by here more often to try out their different options. If you're in the village, give them a try! read more

See all

I'm sorry to say this used to be my go to for salads, but the last 3 times I ordered my salad wasn't made correctly. The third time, they didn't include salad dressing. I called and was told they were out of honey mustard, so instead of calling to let me know, they didn't change charge me for the dressing, they just sent a dry salad. Why not call to offer an alternative? They get your phone number when you order, but don't have time to use it? I ended up going to Stop and Shop (which is in walking distance of the restaurant, so if they cared to not run out of dressing, they have options in a pinch) and getting my own dressing. I think they've changed ownership/management because they used to care and I used to order from them a few times a month. No more caring, no more ordering. read more

This place ugh.. more specifically, the owners and their son. I was a customer for many years. Every time I'd call in an order, the owner or his son would be short and rude on the phone- every single time. They are always in a bad mood. The food isn't good enough to be subjected to this. So I posted an honest yet negative review, and that's when I saw the truth. The owner's son sent me harassing and threatening messages telling me to take down my review that said that his parents, the owners, are jerks. He got more and more threatening and angry, losing more and more control of himself, so I took it down. It just wasn't worth being subjected to his abuse. He showed his true colors, that's for sure. I will stay far away from this place; there are so many eateries in Huntington with more honorable people running them. Ps now I just read the review about the roaches- ewww!!! I wish I would have read it sooner. There is nothing good at this place. read more

Great sandwich's can't go wrong. Got the headbanger panini was great. Added a bit of lettuce on it and they charged 2.50!for a pinch of lettuce. Total spent was 19.00 bucks for a panini which is a robbery. Be careful when you add simple ingredients that's where they will get you. Thus the minus star. read more

New York Panini - The pinch of mesclun greens. - Salad Near Me - Huntington, New York

Menu is pretty good here, lots of paninis, salads, pasta dishes, gluten free items and soups. I really like how they write the soups of the day on the chalkboard and write whether they are low fat, vegan, gluten free, etc. I have tried several salads here and have had the shrimp salad twice always subbing in cajun shrimp. The salad is pretty good, weird looking shrimp so don't look to closely at them. What bothers me about this place are the workers. So unfriendly. I believe it was the owners who were working and they just seemed absolutely miserable. No smiles, no hellos, no have a good day, just straight serious faces. I tried being over the top friendly and still nothing. What a depressing atmosphere. I understand having a bad day, but you don't bring that to work with you. Always ask for bread at lunch. They give it to some people but not others, I think you have to request it. This is a good go to for a healthy meal. Not cheap though. read more

Amazing gem, never ever disappoints. Always Consistent, always receive a fresh hot 'nini!!!

I'm seeing all these good reviews and I'm confused. The only reason I didn't complain was because it was a free company lunch (and because it was take out). I ordered fettucine alfredo. I got fettucine. I can see a little bit of the color of alfredo sauce on the bottom of the container. But otherwise, there's just oil smeared all over the noodles. For $16, I expected something better. Something that actually tasted cheesy? Since Alfredo sauce is supposed to be a creamy cheese sauce? One of my co workers got the shrimp salad. Her shrimp was burned. Just not a great experience. I think next company lunch, we will be ordering from somewhere else. read more

New York Panini - All oil :( not the creamy cheesy sauce that Alfredo is supposed to be - Salad Near Me - Huntington, New York

After walking through town my sisters and I all decided we wanted a really good sandwich, and one of my sisters suggested New York panini! Our waitress was super friendly, attentive and fast. Place was clean and had a huge selection of delicious entrees and sandwiches . I ordered the prosciutto mozzarella sweet peppers sundries tomato spicy mayo red onion red chili pepper flake on ciabatta bread and it was really amazing . Bread is made in house and was toasted to perfection. And it holds all the delicious filling inside , that's important for a meaty and hearty sandwich! My other sisters got a huge steak salad with tomatoes smoked mozz shredded mozz onion lettuce and she loved it , great presentation too on their plates and bowls! And my other sister ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich with mozzarella caramalizedd onions and herb mayo on ciabatta! Everyone loved their meal and the atmosphere ! They also have outdoor eating in the front and back of the restaurant which is always a huge plus to me ! Great food great service and next time I want a panini and I'm in the area I'll be sure to stop back in !!! Thank you New York Panini !!! read more

See all

Excellent, fresh ingredients! The breaded eggplant is super thin and crisp, tastes amazing on the paninis. Delicious and fresh salads too. The mac and cheese balls are another great option if you're looking to indulge. My absolute favorite place for lunch (or even dinner). Best panini I've ever had. read more