After reading all the rave reviews I went into this reservation with high expectations. Overall a bit disappointing. They advertise live jazz music. When I reserved, I confirmed there would be live music. I got a call last minute that they cancelled the music. We had plans with friends and went anyway. The entrance portrays a speakeasy vibe which is done very nicely. The bartender was friendly, and overall service was solid 4. Appetizers were good. We had a special tasty empanada, fresh corn salad, crab cake and fried calamari. The corn salad had fresh greens and was tasty. It had a nice flavor and definitely refreshing. The crab cake was delicious. The calamari was ok. Restaurant has a limited menu, but enough selection in the few menu choices. When it came to main entrees sadly, they were out of lobster ravioli and lobster mac & cheese. The beef Wellington was a bit dry and overcooked (not medium rare as ordered) and plain-looking as it was sitting alone on the large plate. Desserts were excellent. We had homemade Oreo cake with fresh whipped cream and a very delicious creamy cheesecake. Absolute a five star for desserts. Overall: 3.5. Great atmosphere and desserts, but the rest was a bit disappointing. read more

Well, we are here again and for a reason. The food and service simply do not disappoint here. From the second we walk in, we were greeted with several people knowing our names. It's a feel good type of place that we truly enjoy. Service again, top notch and you can tell this team knows customer service. We will continue to come back and enjoy this establishment! You should read more

Barrotta's Supper Club - Supper Clubs Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

I celebrated my birthday here with my husband and best friends. The entrance has a speakeasy feel, and once you walk past the curtain, the space is cozy and charming. Since it wasn't overly crowded on a Thursday night we were able to really enjoy the atmosphere. The food was excellent. They gave us a complimentary bite size hotdog with special mayo that opened up our apetite. We started with the burrata, and the cheese was absolutely spectacular. My husband and I shared the cacio e pepe with truffles and the chicken cordon bleu--a combination I never would have thought of, but it worked perfectly. The truffle cacio e pepe was honestly one of the best I've ever had. Our friends enjoyed the pork chop and lobster ravioli also. The waiter was attentive all night and even comped our olive oil cake for my birthday, which was such a thoughtful gesture. The desserts were delicious, and the live music throughout the evening made it feel extra special. They even sang Happy Birthday live, which was the icing on the cake. The only downside was that it was a bit cold inside, and after asking to lower the AC, it was turned back up by the bartender who said verbatim - I don't care what they say I'm sweating. read more

See all

I had my wife's 31st birthday dinner here this past weekend, and I could not recommend it enough. The vibes were amazing. Our waitress, Riley was absolutely amazing. She was so on point and fun. The event coordinator, Sarah was incredible. She made custom menus for me and asked to use decor she had to make the space look even nicer. Both of them made the dinner feel so special. We got compliments all night on the planning and how fun it was. The food was good, the jacked up burgers were a favorite. The drinks were good. Absolutely amazing! seriously have your next event here. read more

Barrotta's Supper Club - Supper Clubs Near Me - Huntington, New York

Such a beautiful ambience with live jazz music. Our server was attentive, courteous and knowledgeable ( especially to 2 of us who are gluten sensitive). The truffle Cacio e Pepe with gf pasta was amazing! My husband loved the beef Wellington. Fantastic dining experience. Loved the weekend pre-fix menu. Perfect for a date night! Great cocktails. read more

See all

A great experience overall! Mileage may vary with the food value on weekends. The outside is a bit beat-up but the inside is gorgeous. It gives a real speak-easy vibe. The live jazz music, dim lighting and red velvet looking booths add to the ambiance. It's honestly perfect in that sense. Waitstaff is superb. They were among the best I've ever seen. Fabio was our waiter and I couldn't imagine better service. The guy was so friendly and had a ton of charisma. He was the highlight. The weekend offers a fixed menu for $90. It's hard to argue if the price is justified. It includes one starter, one main, one dessert and a champagne toast. Getting the Beef Wellington or Porter house does incur an additional charge. The latter does include 2 sides though. The starters include a good selection but it does make you wonder if the corn salad costs them as much as the crab cakes, for example. So the fixed price can leave you feeling like you have to pick an elevated option to get your money's worth. And there aren't many options to feel like the $90 is in your favor. I started with the meatballs. A great appetizer but also hard to justify on a $90 fixed price. There should have been something to elevate the dish. It was very good but probably a $12-15 appetizer in most places. The lobster ravioli I ordered was not up to what i was expecting. These must be pre-made because any place that makes them in house will include lobster pieces to garnish the dish. Not bad, but a $30 dish probably. It was heavily coated with a sauce that I didn't care for and topped with diced shrimp. For $90 I would have expected in- house pasta made fresh and stuffed with real lobster pieces. This dish was disappointing. I regret not getting the Wellington after my ravioli arrived. Dessert was a highlight. The apple tart with vanilla Gelato was perfect i loved it. But still... maybe a $14 dessert at a nice place. So the total for the things individually felt like it was $60. Keep in mind that tip is not included in the price. I know the band is expensive but I felt like dishes are normally marked up a bit, as they should be to cover the restaurant expenses. This was marked up plus about $30 per person on top of that before you tip. The menu also includes dishes like rigatoni in tomato sauce. That's an $18 dish in most places, so your total meal would be about half of the $90 you paid here. The Porter house ends up being $225 for 2 people. That was the best dish but you're paying $112.50 instead of the $90 per person. My favorite steak place does a larger tomahawk for $140 and 2 sides will not set you back $85 to make up the difference. So many things to love about this place. I really did enjoy the visit. Staff is awesome. Interior is cool. The food is good but I would have loved an ala carte menu and imagine we would have a reduced the $400+ bill by 30%. I'm fine with slightly elevated menu prices to support the band also. That was a cool part. Please do visit this place. It's awesome. read more

See all

Our first time at Burrata's Supper Club was a memorable one. As you walk in, you're greeted by the sound of a live jazz band, setting the tone for a quaint, romantic evening. The atmosphere is cozy and intimate, with attentive quick service and incredible food. I personally would of loved a little more time in between meals. We opted for the three-course dinner and started with the crab cake and fried calamari--both delicious. For our mains, we enjoyed the perfect beef Wellington and the salmon, each perfectly cooked and flavorful. We finished with the apple crumble and the chocolate cake, and both desserts were outstanding. Complimentary champagne with dessert. The music is at a perfect volume--not too loud--and the overall noise level in the restaurant is calm and pleasant. We highly recommend Burrata's Supper Club and look forward to returning. Let me know if you'd like a shorter version for a quick online review or if you'd like to add a photo caption. read more

See all

We spent a romantic night out in Huntington on an October Friday. It's a small corner place tucked behind Ivy Kitchen and Bar. Speakeasy vibe. There was 3 people playing- bass, piano, and guitar. Quiet jazz. There was only a few tables, less than 10. We had reservations at 8pm but waited around an hour to be seated so the manager gave us free drinks at the bar. The citrus & bloom and Annemarie were great cocktails. Our server Fabio was very nice and personable, but the service was a bit slow, which was okay since there was jazz to be enjoyed. We started off with a free amuse bouche: mini wagyu hot dog. We liked our appetizers: crab cake (just one, hope there could be 2) and the fritto misto (portion was large and generous). The entrees were good too, salmon and chicken cordon bleu. We also got two sides: the lobster Mac and cheese and zucchini fries. Overall those were good. I enjoyed the caviar on the salmon and the potatoes. Chicken cordon bleu was nice and moist. Lobster mac could be an entree by itself. The zucchini fries were good too. Came with a nice whipped ricotta and honey dressing. For dessert we tried to get the apple tart and strawberry shortcake but they were gone, so we opted for the flourless chocolate cake which came hot and with vanilla ice cream - so delicious! and the chocolate mousse which was beautiful but a little dry. The bill came out to be close to $300 for two people with tax and tip. It was definitely splurge but fun. Things to improve on are the waiting times, the inconsistent size of the appetizers - frito misto was a lot bigger than crab cake, having more dessert options than chocolate towards the end of the night, and the bathrooms-need a hanger for jackets or bags and the towels were strewn about in the sink-maybe get a dispenser? Also spotted a little poo stain on the toilet rim. Overall though it was nice but definitely a splurge. Edit: also we weren't offered complimentary champagne.. which was listed in the menu. I forgot to ask but looking at other reviews realized that was omitted. I would have liked to have tried that. Or maybe we could have gotten that taken off the bill. read more

See all

The service was divine and our service by Fabio was with such warmth and welcome! The pre fixed menu was delicious however some of the items were a little bland for our taste, notably the cordon bleu. The atmosphere and musicians were a really nice vibe and very romantic. I would recommend again and hope they give consideration to expanding their pre set menu. read more

See all

Tried this place for the first time because I love a restaurant that has live music. The place is well decorated in a quaint space. We ate downstairs as upstairs they had a pop up event going on. The wine and food were delicious. We had the chicken cordon bleu which was perfectly cooked. The chicken was cooked to perfection tender inside and crunchy on the outside. We also had the cacio Pepe which adds truffle, amazing. The meatballs were one of my favorites around. And trust me I know my meatballs my husband literally orders meatballs wherever we go. Would def go back read more

Barrotta's Supper Club - Decor leading to the upstairs - Supper Clubs Near Me - Huntington, New York

Cute spot. Had a different expectation in terms of jazz but we found out that during holidays, the 3 piece jazz isn't always there. So I would only come back when they are here. The keyboard player was ok but it wasn't what I was expecting. Went for a friend's bday. Food was absolutely delicious. The crab cake and meatballs were delicious. Some friends said the citrus drink was watered down or something felt missing. So they brought a different drink on the house to compensate. Service was amazing. Consistently checking to see if we needed anything. Very prompt with food. Made very good recommendations. Will be back ONLY when the 3 piece jazz will be there. Probably for a date night or a simple dinner. read more

Barrotta's Supper Club - Supper Clubs Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

We attended Frank Sinatra night -which happened to be our second visit to the supper club. It was $115 per person including entertainment and you got a 1 appetizer and 1 main entree and 1 desert and 1 champagne drink. All in all -a home run night with both food and entertainment knocking it out of the park. Service was attentive and the place felt like a small night club out of a movie. Food was fresh -served hot and delicious. Applause for a job well done. read more

See all

Fantastic new restaurant bringing the supper club vibe of Manhattan to Huntington with live soulful jazz and a delicious food menu. Atmosphere it intimate and elegant and a great place for date night or getting together with a small group of friends. Foods is Italian/American and doesn't disappoint. Everything is fresh and served in large portions and the Beef Wellington is not to be missed. The Arancini, fried butternut squash risotto served with lobster sauce and herbs is uniquely fabulous and I highly recommend. Great waitstaff, knowledgeable and professional. Barrotta's is a great addition to the Huntington restaurant scene and definitely what was missing. Highly recommend and definitely make reservations weeks ahead... the word has gotten out since they opened it's a Hit ARANCINI - FRIED BUTTERNUT SQUASH RISOTTO, LOBSTER SAUCE, HERBS read more

See all

Good good, good service. Meatballs and crab cakes were delicious. Portions are very generous. read more

See all

We came here on a sunday night, the day after Valentine's (which prob saved us a fortune lol). They had the jazz singer rather than the entire band, but we didn't have to do the prix-fixe menu and just ordered a la carte. The singer with dim lighting with the red couches/decor made for a very intimate vibe, especially that there were under 10 tables dining there. I loved my tuna dish which had so much flavor and pretty presentation. We also got lobster mac+cheese which was delicious just always wish there was more lobster. On our way out, they let us peak at the upstairs which was their private room.. I would hope at some point they figure out a way to be serving up there and have more tables rather than just open it for private. We discussed how it was an enjoyable enough experience we'd come back on Fri/Sat where it was prix-fixe and full band just to check it out, but it was nice experiencing the quieter more intimate night too. We definitely hope to go back soon. read more

Barrotta's Supper Club Huntington, NY @barrottasupperclub Barrotta's Supper Club is one of our favorite intimate restaurants for date night! It is truly a special spot, and a must visit location when in the Huntington area!. The ambiance is cozy and sophisticated, giving it a perfect exclusive feel to it, and the live jazz performance adds the perfect touch. Everything on this menu is executed amazingly from their top tier crab cakes, lobster ravioli, and beef Wellington. Even down to their sides that are prepared deliciously, assuring that every bite here is as good as the last. The cocktails are fresh and full of flavor. The service professional and helpful with recommendations. We love it here and we know you will to! Follow us on Instagram at @drinklongislandny for the full video and much more reviews of spots all over Long Island! read more

See all

Lovely place. Food was fantastic and service was top notch. Attentive but not intrusive. And the bartender knows what she's doing! I hesitate with live music because it's usually overwhelming but the jazz trio was beautiful and you could easily carry a conversation. Acoustics were perfect considering it was packed! Will definitely be back again. Highly recommend. read more

See all

I was so happy to see "live Jazz music" in the email from this supper club. I am in Manhattan quite a bit, and am always searching for a Long Island place with music and a vibe. My son came along, and we had a pleasant Sunday evening here. The waiter was super nice and attentive. It wasn't crowded as it was Sunday before New Year's Eve. There was a single musician playing lovely music. The food was top notch and the waiter was very helpful in directing us to various choices. We had the meatballs, my husband and son had the beef Wellington. I had the pasta with shrimp and crabmeat. Truffle fries too! Nice portions and all delicious. They ended with the apple crumble dessert, I stole a spoonful. YUM. Drinks were yummy too. It's small, so make a reservation. They told us they will be having a piano bar upstairs which I am excited about. If I had to make a recommendation, please add the times of the music on your website and I would love a list of who is playing if possible. Of course I needed pics on the beautiful steps! Top tier place!! read more

See all

Went on a Friday, had a very nice experience. Great vibe, excellent food. Had 3 course meal, portions are large and choices are great. Three piece Jazz was a great vibe and at a perfect volume to be able to have conversation. Will be back! read more

Food and drinks were great, and the staff was very pleasant. Love that they play live music. Will definitely return. read more

Barrotta's Supper Club - Supper Clubs Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

The food was outstanding and the service was excellent. The tuna was the best I ever had. read more

Barrotta's Supper Club - Supper Clubs Near Me - Huntington, New York

First off this is such an beautiful spot. They had live jazzy type music while we were eating which was wonderful. Our waiter Fabio was AMAZING. And of course the four course meal was delicious. I definitely recommend for an elegant and fancy dinner. read more

Barrotta's Supper Club - Burrata appetizer - Supper Clubs Near Me - Huntington, New York

This place is amazing. I was looking for a place that has live jazz, and Barrotta's sure didn't disappoint. The food was delicious with generous portions and the service was impeccable. I will definitely be back. Thank you for making our night one to remember! read more

Phenomenal dining experience! The most gorgeous upstairs great for small parties and the like. Beef Wellington was superb and can confidently say best glass of Prosecco I've ever had. Service was fantastic and attentive and the live jazz can't be beat! Loved it! read more

Barrotta's Supper Club - Beef Wellington - Supper Clubs Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Good service Price fix menu $90 per person W/o drinks Deserts were nothing special. Considerably Over priced in general. read more

Absolutely loved my experience at Barrotta's Supper Club! Not only is the food amazing (What! Those meatballs!), but the atmosphere is old school Italian - the owner Zack Barrotta wants you to feel like part of the family. We will definitely be back and soon! read more

went a few months ago but never clicked post... mediocre at best. forced to eat the weekend menu. they advertise 4 courses, but include the amuse-bouche, which by definition is supposed to be complimentary - tiny rice ball with no flavor. average food overall - severely overpriced for what it is. the crab cake i ordered was a thin hockey puck of mostly breadcrumbs. the tuna was the smallest piece of fish i could imagine. sauces of both dishes were tasty though. just trying way too hard to be a hip NYC spot so they feel justified in charging the prices they do. 2 stars instead of 1 because it was still a nice ambiance, service was solid, and always love live music. unfortunately, music and ambiance aren't enough to make anyone in our party ever want to go back read more

We had a lovely dinner at Barrottas this evening. The staff was lovely and helpful. The food was very good. The calamari and the beef Wellington were stand outs. They had a jazz guitarist which adds to the ambience. read more

See all

Food was excellent so much better than the photos. Perhaps new photos would do good service is also excellent. Friendly wait staff and receptionist. Manager came to check on us which was very mice. Live music was amazing. Good use of smaller space and make it intimate. Pricy though but big portion read more

I so wanted to love this place. The town needs a good dinner and music venue. Just couldn't when the two best thing are the meatball appetizer and French fry side. New and needs to work out kinks. Figure 22 dollars a drink, that high. Ahi tuna was ok. Didn't have much taste and bland. Same with the 70 Dollar Wellington, bland and chewy. Bland was a common theme. 17 dollars for fries as a side, bit over the top. Got 3 stars for atmosphere and music. read more

I can't rave about this place enough! The food was AMAZING! The chicken was full of flavor, the tortellini was delicious and the meatballs were a table favorite! Loved the family style dinning. We were upstairs for a surprise birthday and the decorations felt like you were walking through a secret garden. We will definitely be coming back for date night. read more

Our first time dining at Barrotta's was a great experience. From the moment you walk in, it feels like stepping into a speakeasy. We arrived about 30 minutes before our reservation to enjoy the bar, and the drinks were excellent. The music set the perfect mood, and the service was outstanding. The staff was attentive, friendly, and made sure all of our needs were met. You can dress up or be dressy casual. Highly recommend this restaurant read more

Fabio truly made sure we had a great time. Hes service is top shelf . The music is just right makes you want to stay. The food was truly cooked to perfection. Had a great time will be back for sure. read more

I hosted my 30th birthday in the upstairs private room and I couldn't be more happier! I want to thank Paulie, Olivia, and the owner Zack for being there throughout the night making sure the party ran smoothly. I want to thank the servers and bartenders as well Food was excellent and drinks were awesome!! read more

Barrotta's Supper Club - Supper Clubs Near Me - Huntington, New York

Definitely a hidden gem and I'm so happy my husband and I came to this place for a date night!!! The ambiance and live jazz music was perfect, exactly what we needed! The service was and food was phenomenal. Def the best beef Wellington I've ever had. Zack the owner came over to apologize to us w the reservation that YELP messed up but he made up for it and put us at the best table in the house. Simply AMAZING! read more

I very rarely review, how many places can actually meet my standard in every way being an eight or nine out of 10, if not a 10 out of 10, but this place does it. Staff was amazing. Everybody was happy. The music from the three-piece jazz ensemble was amazing, had dinner at the bar because there were no reservations when I called, everything I had for dinner, which was the blue cheese wedge salad, the calamari, the porterhouse for two, the vegetables, it was all a 10 out of 10, and when something that good occurs, I have to speak out about it. Just had leftovers for breakfast, it was terrific too. read more

Such a great night at Barrotta's Supper Club in Huntington Delicious food, amazing vibe, live jazz band, and truly top-notch service. Well done! . We all enjoyed ourselves! We will be back. read more

Food! Delicious! Service. Exceptional! Ambiance.., ok. So it's my anniversary although I've been here before. I love this place. Never disappoints. Live music, mellow. Highly recommend! read more

Five stars is not enough! Great food, cocktails and music! You don't even feel like you are on Long Island haha.

Had dinner reservations for 4 on a Friday . The weekend menu was in my opinion very limited...not too many choices. It offered a 4 course for $89 plus pp. Beginning with a chefs choice ( I called it a teaser) taste...which actually was a cocktail frank on a mini bun with some type of mayo dressing..it was tough..as if sitting on a grill an entire day . Then your choice of appetizer...I got the calamari fritti..it was tasty..my husband got the crab cake..also good. For entrées mine was the Lobster ravioli with chopped shimp & bits of lobster claw in a cream sauce..I found this dish too salty. My husband had the Beef Wellington, somehow says the liver..but he enjoyed his..the other male in our party had the same& was happy. The other female in our party had the Rigatoni & short rib. She & I both thought our dishes were OK but , nothing to write home about. Dessert was good though. I had the Limoncello cake ( delicious)..there were 2 N.Y. cheesecake's..just OK.. and 1 red velvet cake , also OK. So here's the ticket...after 2 glasses of wine each , 1 side of Brussels & 1 st. Corn salad..we get a check for $800 ! WHAT ?! If addition is correct the check should've been $400. So what is this extra. My uncle ( the other male in our party) promptly called the waiter over to find out wassup ?! After some embarrassment & apologies the total got pretty much corrected. OH ! I forgot to mention how they asked my uncle to move out of the way ( while we were still seated) so they could get a table through & how they asked us to leave because they wanted to seat a new party...mind you the restaurant wasn't filled & there were other tables. In short..the food wasn't that good especially for the price...the staff was rude & we all left saying NEVER AGAIN ! Upscale looking dinner club but small . Enjoyable live music. IMHO that's about it . read more