Welcoming with a warm atmosphere. Attentive professional and friendly service. The grouper bouillabaisse was delicious but most of all the absolute best tiramisu's I've ever had! Two other families were celebrating birthdays. A great celebration restaurant read more

My family and I had an amazingly delicious Easter dinner at Il posto Di Joey! The lamb was cooked to perfection as were the sides; delicious mashed potatoes and veggies. We started with baked clams and fried calamari, always so good at Il Posto! The zabione dessert was ordered early because it was made fresh with berries. After a delightful dinner zabione was served topping off an excellent dinner. The ambiance and service is top notch! I love this iconic restaurant in Huntington! Joey always makes sure his guests are satisfied and happy and we were! read more

We had a group of 8 people for a celebration dinner at Posto Pazzo, and it was an outstanding experience! Our waiter, Mario, provided attentive and excellent service throughout the meal. The homemade pasta dishes were exceptional, as were the meat dishes. All in all an excellent meal. The plus for us was that even though the restaurant was busy, we could have a conversation. read more

We love this place, Cozy and very attentive staff. The food is consistently good, highly recommended as the most delicious and happy place for an Italian meal! read more

This was my first visit to Il Posto di Joey since the restaurant replaced its previous establishment Tuttp Pazzo. The new business has an updated contemporary cozy ambience with a scenic view of the bay located across the street. The menu had creative specials along with their similar menu has noted as Tutto Pazzo. The restaurant provides a breadbasket with freshly made bread along with rice balls once seated. The staff is attentive, friendly, and accommodating. We enjoyed immensely the stuffed artichokes as an appetizer along with the shrimp parmigiana and Veal Milanese. Our dishes were delicious. Overall, we enjoyed our dining experience, and we will be visiting this restaurant often. read more

See all

First time here for a birthday celebration with some friends. Everyone liked their food and was happy with their meals. I had the Sole francese which was very tasty. The martini pours were great you are getting two cocktails for the price of one. The bread basket bread was very soft and tasty. They also start you off with complimentary rice balls too. We did the Caesar salad and fried zucchini starters. The fried zucchini came with bacon and Gorgonzola cheese. It was amazing! Salad was tasty too. Nice place with good service. read more

Il Posto Di Joey - Bar area - Italian Near Me - Huntington, New York

Our 1st visit to Il Posto Di Joey. When we arrived we realized that it is located where Tutto Pazzo was originally. We arrived we were seated promptly at a table with an amazing water view.(across the street from the Harbor Club/photo is below ). No need to worry because Parking is available! We were greeted promptly by a very friendly waiter name Lenyn. They dropped off a warm & fresh baked bread basket with focaccia that was delicious. For appetizers: We ordered the crab cakes, which definitely shouldn't have been served. Sorry, it didn't meet my standards. It had so much breading then they burnt the bottoms of the crab cake. Cocktails: Homemade Sangria was not my best the apples had a alcohol after taste & water down. Dinners: Highly recommend the two veal dishes below. Veal Francese & Milanese it was such a tender piece of meat which was perfectly prepared & delicious with just the right amount of veggies and delicious mashed potatoes. Our overall dinner & dining experience was wonderful and I definitely recommend this place. read more

See all

This restaurant was absolutely outstanding, what a delicious meal for my first time trying some things on the menu. We were able to get some dinner choices pretty early, they said they could cook it up and we'd pick it up in 20 minutes. Got to the spot and it was ready when I got there. 1) Caesar Salad- Huge portion, delicious, very flavorful, perfectly dressed, great starter. 2) Goat Cheese Artichokes- Very heavily filled, cheesy, and the sauce is perfect for bread dipping. 3) Soul Francese- Buttery, Smooth, Eggy, and the vegetables with potatoes were hot and tasty. 4) Soul Oreganata- Also very delicious, same with the vegetables and potatoes. This spot deserves way more love then Yelp gives it, we will definitely return! read more

Really nice place, probably the best Pasta fagioli around. The homemade pasta is worth the visit alone ! Lasagna and the cauliflower risotto both fantastic dishes. The perfect end to the meal was the banana gelato and cappuccino. Looking forward to going back for sure. read more

Was there a few years ago. Will never go back. The waiter was rude. We were told the only menu was online and we would have to download it ourselves. The noise level was unbearable !! The prices we not worth the food and the service. There are a lot better choices for dinner in Huntington. read more

Had a lovely dinner at Il Posto Di Joey on a Saturday night. The restaurant is very large and spacious so it can easily accommodate larger parties. I was disappointed with their appetizer choices, we got the Gnocchi egg rolled which weren't too exciting and the special cheese board was just OK. The highlight of my meal was the blackened salmon on my Caesar salad - great portion and beautifully seasoned. Their chocolate martini was also a hit. There are better Italian spots out there, but this is a cute spot for a large, last minute gathering! read more

Came here with 2 of my adult children and my husband for Valentines Day. Did not know what to expect as my son made the reservations. I have to say- we were pleasantly surprised! Joey was wonderful and the food was excellent. We look forward to coming back soon. Thanks for a wonderful evening. read more

Il Posto Di Joey - Zucchini pasta - Italian Near Me - Huntington, New York

Great place and excellent food! I appreciated the customer service and the atmosphere read more

Il Posto Di Joey - New York strip steak - Italian Near Me - Huntington, New York

Well it may look nice but looks are certainly deceiving 1. Waiters are not attentive at all 2. You get bread and mini rice balls. Nice touch until you try them. Rice balls are more or less tasteless. The bread was stale 3. I had linguine with white clam sauce. This is always my litmus test when I try a new Italian restaurant. It was horrible. Literally no taste. I added grated cheese. I added red pepper. Didn't help. Needed more garlic. Parsley. Just a dozen very small clams. Cost them at best $1 to make. Charge me close to $30 4 cannoli for dessert. Most disgusting rancid taste forgive shell 5 two of us were sick the next day read more

Everyone enjoyed their dinners. Hot food is always makes the food taste better. Service was very good. We will be back.

Dirty masks on floor and not The same since name change. Some waitstaff are arrogant, will go Back hoping it will get better. Food was average. read more

Great food always fresh a lot of homemade pastas and fresh seafood good New Haven pizza as well always I love the tomahawk it's enough for three people with delicious sides that come with it and the desserts are always new ideas that are really good I like the Al Capone desserts when he has them read more

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED 4.5 STARS On Friday, February 21st, I attended a group dinner at Tutto Pazzo, a venerable Italian restaurant in the Halesite section of Huntington. Use Prime as a landmark. Tutto Pazzo is just a little north on the opposite side of the street. Parking is valet and the young attendant was very pleasant. Upon arrival, the young female bartender made me a terrific GG Vodka Martini. The restaurant seated us promptly when our group arrived. I started with the Baked Clams.They were moist, whole, delicious and well seasoned, with a perfect breading to clam ratio.I sampled some of the meats and cheeses on the Tease Plate and some Bacon Wedge Salad.Both were very good. The Wedge was particularly excellent.It was loaded with perfectly cooked bacon. Onto the entrees....I had the freshly made Lasagna Bolognese. It was fabulous.The sauce was rich and meaty.There was no doubt that the pasta was made fresh that day. My tip is to take advantage of the many fresh pastas offered here. My companions loved their dishes.Standout dishes were too many to mention.You cannot go wrong with any of the Parm dishes. I'll cite the excellence of the Raviolis, the Goat Cheese Stuffed Artichoke Bottoms and the Angel Hair with Pomodoro Sauce.The Meatballs here are superb.The texture was perfect and the seasoning was on point. I concluded with the Chocolate Brownie, served with Whipped Cream and Ice Cream.It was fabulous and one of my companions said the Tiramisu was as well. Service was polite though a bit inattentive.Our group was extremely pleased with this restaurant. BOTTOM LINE: In a town with several fine Italian restaurants, Tutto Pazzo stands out. read more

See all

A bit disappointed with this place. Maybe it was the great reviews that I had such high expectations?? I don't know. Was it my choice of hot antipasto?? I don't know. We went Saturday night with no reservations and wow it was packed!!! It was really beautiful inside felt very upscale. We were told wait time would be anywhere from 30mins to an HR. We were okay with that since we weren't too hungry. We snagged the comfy couch seats in the waiting area. They give you complimentary chips as you wait. We ended up being seated about after a 20min wait. Our waiter was great and attentive considering how many tables he was attending to. They serve you upon sitting a bread basket. I read about it in other reviews and many stated the bread was nice and hot. We did not get hot bread but it was still very good. You also get 4 rice balls in there I didn't like it but it was a nice touch. Now onto to the food. Food: My fiancé ordered 1/2 clams and I ordered the chefs choice hot antipasto for one. My fiancée said his raw clams were good. The hot antipasto I did not like one thing on there! Goat cheese and artichoke ugh a no go for me! Stuffed mushroom another no! Eggplant a no! Fried calamari a no! Baked clams also a no!! The only thing good I mean amazingly good was the marinara sauce that came with it. For our entree we decided to share papadelle with pomodora sauce. This dish was a winner! It was delicious! After we had their Nutella bread pudding dessert and cappuccino very delicious! The prices are definitely expensive I don't mind an expensive meal as long as it's delicious. The price tag definitely doesn't the match the food here. I rather go to portofino also in Huntington. It isn't upscale but the food is delicious and half the price tag of Tutto. read more

See all

We decided to give this place a try to mix things up a bit. It's a fairly big restaurant with a casual vibe. The bread basket they brought out was stale and had rice balls which were super bland and dry. Our waiter was fine but not very helpful when it came to making recommendations or answering questions about the menu. We ordered the eggplant rollatini, the ravioli twisters with pesto, the taglierini pasta with vodka sauce, and the gnocchi with truffle cream. The eggplant was good (7/10). The ravioli twisters with pesto were good but a little too dense and heavy (7/10). The taglierini was a really delicious unique pasta but the vodka sauce was very bland and watery (7/10). The gnocchi with truffle cream was definitely the stand out. It was delicious with just the right amount of truffle (10/10). This is a fine restaurant but the prices are definitely too high for what the ambiance, service, and food quality is. read more

See all

Simply one of Long Islands best Italian/ Mediterranean restaurants!. Fun atmosphere, combined with owners who really care about their customers!. Sensational Italian salads, fish, beef and pasta. This unique seaside gem offers elaborate business lunches, Romantic dinners?, and extraordinary home style catering. We loved the Caesar salad, extra large shrimps cocktails, lasagna , and bronzino! For dessert Sorbet! Kudos to Joey for having been awarded the Excellence medallion for superior food , ambiance and service! Barry Kay, President , The Association for Excellence in Hospitality read more

I love this place, not only do they have amazingly fresh delicious creative dishes, the owner and staff are amazing. I came in for some brunch and had delicious lobster Benedict and the best sangria in town. I love coming here, and will continue to come here read more

See all

Wow pow chow! Yeah I went there. I can't lie, I wasn't ecstatic about the lasagna bolognese. Though the flavor was good enough to finish my plate, I was just expecting it to be meatier. The portion was big enough that I didn't need dessert with my sambuca and espresso. (They had a selection of desert cocktails) Everyone I was with was happy, and you know I ate other people's food. Everyone ate like they were fed by an Italian grandma. My table mate to my right let me try some of his chicken francese. It was absolutely delicious and I may get that as my meal next time. Notice I said next time. The first thing I noticed when I walked in was a tomahawk steak and a selection of charcuterie. I look forward to my next visit read more

Il Posto Di Joey - Lasagna Bolognese - Italian Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Typical Italian fare you can make at home. Nothing special to say about this place. Service this weekend was atrocious which make the food seem worse. Asked twice to order, got ignored, asked for help, only to have some say they are sending someone but no one ever came. The even managed to not bring us an order of baked clams which we ordered, but they did remember to bill me! I'd go elsewhere for better food. read more

My in-laws dined here and had a very disappointing experience. The owner was rude and unwelcoming. They came here for lunch and were handed a menu. They looked at the menu, ordered a salad, and then noticed that the other folks dining at the restaurant ordered options that were not listed on their menus. After asking the fellow diners where they ordered their food from, they were told this was part of the lunch menu. My mother-in-law then asked the waiter why they were not given a lunch menu and he directed her to owner. She then approached the owner with the same question and he answered "oh sorry" with no remorse. They ended up getting the lunch menu but it was clear that the owners intention was to dupe them into ordering from the dinner menu to up-charge them. When their food arrived, my mother-in-laws shrimp wrap had a huge clump of human hair on the plate. After sending it back, the waiter brought back out in about 60 secs, clearly not remaking a new dish. Really unfortunate experience here, please be advised. read more

This was my first time here. It's a large pace with a view of the water and marina across the street. The rice balls given with the bread basket were delicious and held me over for dinner! I had veal saltimbocca. The sauce was different than I expected, but the whole meal was amazing. I also tried the shrimp risotto dish (gluten free!!) that was delicious, and the pesto gnocchi which were creamy and tasty! I had the cannoli for desert. The cream is the usual cream, a lot thicker but very good! Only reason I didn't give it 5 stars was the menu was a little overwhelming, and a little bit pricy. I would like to go back if I am in the area again! read more

Il Posto Di Joey - Italian Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

The food is incredible !!!!!! They make homemade pasta ! And in the summer fresh veggies and herbs from the garden , can't wait to come back in 2 weeks ! My fav is the 4 cheese pasta read more

a quick review. FANTASTIC service, awesome interior. We had a great romantic table by the fireplace. I got a gluten free zucchini spaghetti with saute vegetables that was suburb and well cooked and fantastic. My wife got a salmon that she said was also very good. We will definitely be back. I will say a little more expensive then usual per entree. read more

See all

We walked through the fire How did we ever survive this? We tangled the wire And hid behind what's emptiness But No one can love you No one can love you the same I'll always want you I'll always you this way We'll learn to outgrow The thorns on the rose Thorns on the rose Thorns on the rose We tripped through time but, we were only children then So we couldn't find That we'd hold on beginning to end No one can love you No one can love you the same I'll always want you I'll always want you this way We'll learn to outgrow The thorns on the rose Thorns on the rose read more

Il Posto Di Joey - Italian Near Me - Huntington, New York

I was really excited to try this place since they have homemade pasta. Unfortunately, it was a bit of a mix bag with the food. We started with hot anti pasta, which came with stuffed mushrooms, stuffed eggplant, fried calamari, artichoke heart with goat cheese and baked clams. First sign was that the calamari was tough, batter was light and sort of crispy but the squid was rubbery. I was really surprised because as you walk in, they have a Seafood case like at a fish market. All Italians will tell you, if the calamari is bad- the rest of the food will be. The stuffed mushroom was bland, baked clams was decent and I did like the artichoke with goat cheese. Eggplant was ask OK. One item we did like was the marinara sauce. So we ordered pasta with marinara - it was good, but my over all food experience will not bring me back here anytime soon. I think the food is way better at Portofino and they also have homemade pasta. Anyways, the place was packed and the atmosphere was up beat, service was great, but very inconsistent with the food. We skipped the protein and went for desert and had the bread pudding which was good along with a Cappuccino. To recap, my experience was impacted by the inconsistency of the food, but service and ambiance was cool. The place is price and I don't mind paying for the food needs to up-to-par. read more

See all

Food was good and the atmosphere was nice but you certainly do not get your money's worth.

Great , everything is wonderful, they grow their own tomatoes and onions in the back , great view of Huntington harbor , food delicious read more

See all

BEST SANGRIA I'VE EVER HAD! I've bartended for years and I order a margarita or sangria wherever I go, this is my favorite! Rice balls in the bread basket, great touch and yummy! Margarita pizza was delicious, not the best but, very good! For dinner we got gnocchi with pesto, the gnocchi was perfect! My boyfriend referred to them as "little potato clouds" We also requested a pink sauce with taglierine (not on the menu) they made it for us and it was SO GOOD! We weren't impressed with the dessert menu & we were super full so we did not get dessert but my boyfriend got a cappuccino and said it tasted burnt. Service was good, he seemed busy but still provided us with good service. read more

Il Posto Di Joey - Margarita pizza & red sangria - Italian Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Over priced, over rated and Im over it. I keep trying to give this place a chance, it just never happens, maybe the good reviews are from customers that don't know real authentic italian, or maybe just locals being loyal. If youre a foodie don't do it read more

So I did it- tried this place again... Absolutely horrible service, SAME WAITER was so rude, seemed like he was drunk or something and absolutely no attention at all... Went here for a small bachelorette dinner for my friends mom.. just the 5 of us. Her daughters hung up cute balloons on wall ( after asking and calling ahead to see if it was ok ) .. well the RACIST owner, who very much still works/ owns this place came over and started taking the balloons off the wall, and got angry and asked if the tape we used was the kind that peeled off the paint, ummm sir your restaurant gave us this tape and how could you be so rude in the middle of our dinner? ... MAKING US FEEL SO AWKWARD. I can't believe this guy is even showing his face around.. and also acting this way towards his customers. Terrible overpriced sangria .. $16 a glass for a tiny water down cup that's filled half with fruit and whole thing with ice meaning it's 4 sips. Officially WILL NEVER BE BACK read more

Everything was perfect I had the raviolis and they were cooked perfectly the decor is gorgeous and there is indoor and outdoor seating along with a bar area So many choices on the menu and fresh made pasta!! Definitely will be coming back read more

See all

Friendly, good service, lots of choices on the menu great food the only disappointment was the steak save that for when you go to prime across the street otherwise plan on over eating read more

Went in yesterday (Thursday) afternoon around 4:00 pm with my friend. No one in the place except all the staff sitting around a table behind the bar. A female host maybe walking around like an expected father waiting to hear about his wife giving birth. Walked in asked can we sit and eat at the bar, "yeah" no welcome no hello felt like bad vibes! I asked how is your day going "good" the guy left after throwing 2 menus in front of each of us. He returned to the table where everyone of the staff people sat totally ignoring us. Sat there almost 15 minutes. No cocktail, nothing! Trashy place and after reading the other reviews I do not feel bad leaving this honest review. Something is wrong here. Save your money and go elsewhere. Came 10 miles to try this place but I am glad we walked out from being disrespected & ignored. Reading about racist reviews? Well I get annoyed and being of Italian decent there were no Italians in the place. Cold hearted people. Shame on this place. The department of health should also take a walk through as the place had a foul odor and dirty restrooms. There's many other places to dine at in Huntington village and the surrounding area and for these fancy prices stay away and go eat like a king and be welcomed elsewhere. Place sucks! and wow pow chow man or something like that as the old place tutto pazzo would say. Never again! I'll say Chow! read more

The zucchini flower era were delicious Mozzarella with tomatoes and sweet onions were extremely tasty Papadelle with meatball and sausage was really on of the best I've tasted around town!! read more

Il Posto Di Joey - Italian Near Me - Huntington, New York

I have been to this restaurant multiple times and each time, my experience has been nothing short of amazing! I have tried so many different dishes here and I have loved them all. The last time I went, my girlfriend and I got the cold seafood tower, tomato salad (grown from fresh from their garden), and eggplant meatballs which were on special. All the food was fabulous, but the eggplant meatballs are my favorite!! Not only is the food always very fresh and delicious, but the restaurant is beautiful, the staff is extremely friendly and Joey, the owner, is such a great host and always makes sure we have a wonderful experience. I don't think I will ever stop going to this restaurant! read more