Joey from New York here. I vouch for this pizzeria. Just look at that crust!!! If you want pizza as good as they make in NYC and Brooklyn, give this spot a try. The staff is great, the ambience of the place is clean and comfortable. And unlike most NYC pizza parlors, you can have a pint of exotic beer with your meal! Great job people! read more

Mediocre, not great. The garlic bread went right into the garbage. There's a barstool right by the register. Don't sit there, because they'll ask to move. If only there was a way to retract the gratuity. Which begs the question, why put a basketball hoop in the middle of the park if you don't want the local kids shooting baskets? read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - El Jebel, Colorado

See all

Less than impressed. Very expensive and not much to write home about. Big slices but the crust and sauce lacked flavor and $7 beer is all too much to get me back. Sorry but love good pizza read more

Nice atmosphere, great Philly and onion rings. Service was quick and cordial! Hit this place up if you want a good slice on the quick, or if you want to hang out and watch a game with a draft. read more

This is the place to come if you are hangry! You will leave full and happy to deal with the world all over again. The staff is extremely friendly! Don't forget that this is CASH ONLY!!! Oh and the slices are HUGE definitely bigger then your face. Great stop for after skiing read more

See all

leave it up to the bespectacled hipster to screw up something reasonably simple. It's a Philly cheesesteak!! NOT chopped mush on a bun. juat make a damm sandwich quit trying to make it something more. read more

We went there after a concert in town and some drunk guy actually came up to the counter and took my slice of pizza. So I waited for another which was dry and the service lacked any compassion towards the situation. read more

I am only in the area part time but this pizza is one of my favorites EVER. They have some pretty good pies like BBQ chicken and white artichoke. So yummy! But can't go wrong with a good ole pepperoni. They are QUICK and have excellent service. Highly recommend! read more

Omg I'm in Heaven! My fellow Shreveport, La, penny loaf wearing, prep school friends know how to do a Philly right!! Stuffed but can't not get the fried dough as you Coloradans call it or baby beignets as we say in the south! Byrd rules! read more

New York Pizza - Philly Bowl omg - Pizza Near Me - El Jebel, Colorado

PSA: Cash or check ONLY. Unfortunately, this place did not live up to the other Yelp reviews - Pretty disappointed overall. The service was okay, the guy at the counter wasn't the greatest. I had to ask the wait time of my pizza as he gave short answers to everything I asked and seemed annoyed. The "cheese sticks" are not good, it's literally bread cooked and chopped up with seasoning and cheese melted in it with charred ends (DO NOT RECOMMEND this item). The marinara sauce is sweet and doesn't taste like marinara. The pizza is a hard 5 out of 10, it's decent but it's not the best pizza out there. read more

I had a mishap happen yesterday but as I know New York pizza they are the best!#yelpelite

DO NOT SUPPORT THIS HORRENDOUS BUSINESS. The worker cussed my daughter out for drinking an outside soda in their restaurant. I understand saying it in a nice way, but they screamed "get the fuck out" infront of about 30 other customers. I don't find this service to be professional and I would not recommend going to this place unless you wanted to be treated horribly. read more

The pizza is amazing, service is very quick. Coming from the east coast and a frequent visitor to the boroughs I am always leary of NY Pizza signs when outside of NY. I have to tell you this pizza is the real deal! Very nice bar diner atmosphere. read more

Michael one of the employees here is the kindest soul. My roommates and I had a horrible day and just needed a pizza. He was so patient and understanding about our requests. He added extra ranch too. Not even gonna start on how yummy the pizza is!!!! Y'all rock. read more

Rude person serving and cooking, not sure what his issue was. We entered and could tell he was upset but we were hungry so decided to stay. The jerk decided to yell at my dad in front of all the customers for getting some sauce that was on the counter. My dad has better manners than he did and apologized but the guy continued to be a jerk! read more

Best pizza in the valley! Excellent service. Everything we have ordered has been delicious. Their salads are awesome and super fresh. The fried dough is incredible. read more

Great food and good atmosphere. We keep coming back for more. Purchase by the slice (huge) or get a whole pie. Plenty of good toppings to choose from. Also a selection of sandwiches and salads. The beer on tap is always rotating, so there are always some good choices. read more

Amazing pizza with awesome service from Jeri :) So delicious, fast and GREAR service! We got the BBQ chicken and it was a huge slice, I spit it with my boyfriend. If you like pizza it's a must on your way through Basalt. read more

New York Pizza - Ready and they toast it up nice for ya! - Pizza Near Me - El Jebel, Colorado

This was our favorite spot to have some pizza and wings. Pizza slice is huge and the wings were tasty. Service was friendly & very polite. When we come to Colorado again we will be sure to stop by and eat here again. read more

Pizza is good, wings are only ok. However charging 2$ per wing is criminal for what you get. The wing are not huge (like what you get at Duffs in Buffalo) so why rip off your customers. Shame on you for overcharging on wings. read more

From a New Yorker, this place has good pizza. The slices are huge, the staff is so friendly, and the pizza is solid. Would definitely recommend and it's a real plus when staff members are so open and kind. Love to see it read more

I love the pizza every time I go, it is the best place to get a slice (or a whole pie) in Basalt. The only issue I have had is the fact that they do not answer the phone around 9:30PM. It says they close at 10:00PM, not sure why they would not answer when they still have 30 minutes or more left until close. If they are cleaning up and all of that stuff they should say they are closed at 9 or 9:30 then. read more

Ok I have lived in Colorado for almost 14 years now and this pizza defiantly takes the cake for one of the best I've had here. Big Enough to have one slice for lunch and greasy enough to make you droll. 5 stars read more

Ever slice from Basalt to Aspen ... dead on delicious!

Local -Fun- best part...GREAT PIZZA & WINGS!! Best value in town and you can tell the lines are clean on the drafts! Love this place for family meet-ups! read more

Very good super fast, not a lot of.drink selection ie:brewed ice tea but the pizza is really good. Close to our house so we come here often. read more

Pizza is amazing! The crust is crispy and it was hot and not cold! They were very nice and took less than 10 minutes to go in and order and get out which is very impressive service especially for warm pizza and they also have a nice variety in food if you don't want pizza. read more

Local gem! We get pizza here weekly and everything is always fantastic. Our children love it and of course we look forward to going in and most likely running into a few familiar faces. Make sure to order the Philly! Best one in town! read more

Same great slice that you get in Aspen. Great place to belly up and have a pint and a slice. I can't get enough of this place.

Always my go to choice for good food and good atmosphere. Staff is real friendly. Slice and a beer always goes well but recommend a calzone. Also the pizza is real good too. Even got my leftovers to go wrapped as a swan. If that doesn't say class I don't know what does. read more

I called to order a sandwich and a salad for delivery and they said it would take 45 minutes. After I waited TWO hours for my food I called and asked where it was and they said they tried calling me because they couldn't find my house. Turns out, they wrote my address and phone number down wrong. The guy who answered the phone said he talked to the manager and they would have my food over right away. After another 40 minutes my food arrived and it was burnt to a crisp from reheating and the fries were soggy. The least they could have done was made new food or offered a refund after I waited 2 1/2 hours. BOGUS.. won't be going back any time soon... read more

Incredibly disappointed in the management of this restaurant. My husband and I ordered a pizza 15 minutes after the rest of my family and got our 35 minutes before them. They waited over an hour for pizza and when I asked if we could get a discount or refund for the wait the manager (with a multi-colored headband) was incredibly rude and snapped back at me. The ONLY good thing about this place was the cook named Chad. He was incredibly gracious and kind throughout the whole ordeal and should be the manager because he carries himself with a level headed maturity unlike the manager and even rushed to assure us he would personally bring the pizzas over. He acknowledged the mistake when the manager completely lied about it. read more

I had the pleasure of eating here several times recently for both dinner and lunch and enjoyed each of the menu items that I tried on each occasion. I am a foodie and particular even about pizza but the quality of the cheeses, toppings, sauce and crust were excellent. The camaraderie enjoyed by the employees made it an enjoyable experience to come in, sit at the bar and watch them prepare my meals. Service was efficient and the restaurant is clean. I have eaten at the second New York Pizza in Aspen many times over the years and there is no longer any reason to schlepp into Aspen for pizza, calzone or a great sandwich when I'm in town. read more

Good place to get a pizza. The staff have always been cool. The pies are good, and the prices are a-ok. Have frequently stopped here for a slice & a beer after backpacking trips in the valley & it's always been solid. read more

If I could go here everyday, I would. The pizza in NYC doesn't quite level up to this place. They have a restaurant in Aspen as well, but as a local, I hate putting up with the Aspen employee's entitled behavior. I've met many friends here... It's the perfect place to get social. The staff is professional while still being fun. They have a certain air in their relationships with their co-workers and customers that is enjoyable to watch. Quite a lot like going to a very good comedic show. The pizza has the PERFECT proportion of bread:sauce:cheese that you will just have to try for yourself. read more

Three massive 2 topping pieces of awesome pie and two bottomless fountain drinks for 11 bucks. Most affordable lunch in the valley. The cheesesteak is cooked right in front of you and is off the chain. Cash only, FYI. Cash machine is three stores to the left. read more

The first time I ordered a pizza from here they burned it. To make up for it they made another one for me and gave me back 1/2 my money! They were so gracious and generous about it how could I be mad? In addition, they remember and call me by name every time I go in; which is almost every week now because it is a pleasure to do business with such nice people. They have a loyal customer for life read more

Great pizza place. We were in the area for a week, enjoying the scenery, hiking and fly fishing, and we ended up eating at this place a few times. The pizza was very good each time and the staff is also very cool. Nothing fancy but the (thin) crust is good, the ingredients seem fresh, and the toppings all were tasty. Everyone in our party agreed the pizza was darn tasty. As a bonus the dude up-sized our pies for no extra charge. Folks working there were all very nice and they had good beer on tap, including some very nice local craft brews. The sandwiches they make also looked very good, although we didn't get a chance to try any. Definitely recommended. read more

This place has THE best pizza. The sauce and the crust is on point. We also got the grilled veg sandwich and it was so amazing. Very impressed. Bring your cash or check book no credit cards are accepted. read more

*First and for most I want to thank everyone at NY Pizza who is working and serving us food during this difficult and challenging time.* On that note, I am a permanent resident of Basalt that encourages the patronage of our local food establishments, regardless of the circumstances, because I understand how negative economic situations can ruin a small business. I am very disappointed by my most recent visit. My girlfriend, preordered a pizza for pickup at 17:15 tonight, my order was not completed until 17:55. In addition to this, I was rudely advised to wait in my car until my order was completed and that my order would be hand delivered to my vehicle. Unfortunately, the server forgot and the pizza waited on top of the oven until I went in to inquire the status of my order. Take it for what it's worth it's seem that the night time staff is just rude and doesn't want to be there. I'm sure hope the ownership doesn't condone this kind of inter action with the customer. read more