As soon as me and my son walked in we got greeted and let us know where the menu was. There was a few slices they had sold per slice in the case but everything else is made to order. The wait wasn't long at all. The design of the restaurant my son likes. We order a 18" cheese pizza; came with 8 slices, cheese slice with house salad and drink combo, fried cheese and slice of BBQ chicken pizza. Everything was fresh and the bbq chicken pizza was my favorite. I got 2 bites and my youngest son took it cause it was so good. The fried cheese are triangle shape and way better than any I have had before. read more

New York Pizza - Quick to go dinner - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

Always, good, always hot!! Best Pizza on the Island! My only wish is that there was a bigger place to sit down And eat. read more

The New York Pizza in Fleming Island, FL makes claim to having the most authentic NY style pizza in a North Florida. And let me tell you, the pizza is massive, like its flavors. The sauce is impeccable, the cheese is just enough but not overpowering, and the light fluffy dough makes you able to enjoy multiple slices without feeling like a blob. Truly a masterclass of pieology. Shoutout to New York Pizza! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

I want to say that as much as the pizza has great flavor and my husband and son's 18" pepperoni pizza was tasty, these two slices of mushroom pizza are the tiniest slices I have ever received from a pizza place that you can get slices from. I put my hand next to the box so you can see how small these slices are. I have ordered slices for my son previously in the pizza place and his slices have been a little bigger than this. Plus the mushrooms look like the thinnest shreds or minced pieces. To charge $3.49 a slice plus $.40 a topping is not worth it! Most places when you order slices the slices come off of a large to extra large pizza not a medium. Very sad that this is my first time eating the pizza and this is what I have to eat. My son loves the pizza so I guess since this place is close to home he will enjoy it in the future. read more

New York Pizza - 2 slices of pizza with mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

Love this place. Some of the best pizza in town. I would drive half an hour to get it instead of ordering delivery from a chain pizza place.

The New York pizza was not good, taste sauce and crust .........I don't recommend this pizza. The owner can contact me and I can help them get their product right! read more

They get zero stars not only because of their pizza and wings but because the person answering the phone couldn't even apologize for the food being cold! She actually was arguing with the customer. I'm from NY! That is definitely not even close to NY pizza! The name is deceptive!!! Obviously, the person who makes the pizza has never been to NY!! A large NY pizza has 8 slices not 6!! The wings were suppose to have BBQ sauce it looked and tastes like ketchup! The "BBQ" says was dumped on top! That's is not how wings are flavored! The food was disgusting and definitely not NY anything!! Please change your name to something not deceptive to those of us from NY!! read more

Food great service great We were traveling and after a long day of driving this was perfect. read more

I love coming here after my hair appointments! Pizza is always so good, they have an awesome deal: 2 slices and a drink for under $9. Slices are huge, and they sell by the slice. It's consistently good, and definitely NY style! Place is clean and they have outdoor seating too. My favorite pizza on the Island. read more

Excellent thin crisp pizza and well-made Grandma Pie as well. We just called it Sicilian growing up in NYC. Definitely the best in Clay County. read more

Nice place, a little off the main drag. Pepperoni pizza was cooked perfect with nice crust. Garlic cheesy bread was a good appetizer choice. Italian sub was very fresh and can feed two people. Antipasti salad was great. Service is fast casual, so you order at the counter and do the rest yourself. Restaurant was very clean and has seating outside as well. No complaints about anything. read more

See all

Just better pizza, it reminds me of a place I used to frequent back in upstate New York.

Excellent pizza!!!! Worth the money! Highly recommend for anyone craving an authentic New York style pizza! read more

New York Pizza - Excellent pizza!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

These pies are giant. The dough is light and fluffy and the cheese is top notch. We tried the chick fila style pizza and I would pass on this as it leaves something to be desired. Not sure if it's the soggy fries on top or what but definitely won't order that one again. Our basics pepperoni mushroom was . The service was great. The super adorable whole family working was heart warming. The side salads are huge and the dressing was fantastic. We opted for the antipasto salad and it was great. We had also ordered the mozzarella sticks- lovely block cut and perfect breading. read more

If the people in The Fleming Island area around this restaurant think that this is great NY style? You have lived a sheltered life. People believe this great pizza is because this place is closest to where they live and convenient. I can come with 2 maybe 3 other very good options within a 20 minute drive if that long. Greasy film due to cheap pepperoni and flimsy cardboard crust. When folded NY style, standby for the grease bath. Last resort stop read more

New York Pizza - Pepperoni & Mushrooms 18" - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

I'm originally from Brooklyn NY. Just moved close by and had to give it a try. DEFINITELY worth it ! Feels like Brooklyn read more

Let me start by saying if you're looking for a pizza place that will exceed your expectations in terms of pizza this is the place. Dave Portnoy approved 7.6/10. By far the best pizza place located in Fleming Island. Their sandwich "the works" is on-par with other sub places such as Jimmy Johns. For ordering during Memorial Day prior to their closing I found the delivery to be extremely fast and was very thankful for that. This place has always been consistently a great pizza place and will continue to get my business when I'm in the mood for some. read more

New York Pizza - The works sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

See all

I really loved this place but lately it has been eh. Sometimes you can't even get the online ordering to work. The workers are friendly and the food is good so I have it 4 stars. read more

The atmosphere is informal. Delicious pizza and their garlic knots were delicious. Incredible. This is the best NY style pizza in Clay County without a doubt. read more

Have been going to this establishment for over a year and is worth every dime! They have the best quality, excellent customer service and the food is delicious!! Whatever they have going on, it's unique. The portions are Generous and many things seem to be made from scratch. The crust on the pizza is the kind you eat every bite of! I've tried other places around here and I'm sold on this restaurant. Nothing else compares!! read more

This is good pizza. Everytime I am coming in people are carrying 3 or 4 out the door. The only people that don't like this place are people that like pizza hut pizzas, and pizza hut is not pizza. read more

poor customer service taking to long to get my pizza i have been waiting for a hour this is very making me mad i am tired of the wait and they are going to see from my lawyer.!!!! read more

I might sound critical because I used to run a pizza shop myself. To their credit, they have improved their technique since I've first tried their pizza. They were baking on pans, and now use screens -- yielding better crust texture. Our philosophy was to use the very finest ingredients from the flour to the homemade sauce cooked with frozen basil to the artisanal pepperoni. Starting with the pepperoni, I'd work on improving ingredients read more

We loved this place, we did take out all the time as did our friends. I would had given them 5 stars hands down. The last 6 months not so good ! We talked with friends and they agree. They have skimped on the crust big time. It's limp. Not New at all! Not good ! What happened? Please fix it! Bring back your New York Pizza! read more

After seeing many good reviews about this place we decided to give a try today. What a waste of a good pizza Sunday tradition!! Not only was the pizza cold ( really? It is only about an 8 minute drive to Eagle Harbor),The crust tasted like burnt cardboard, I even ordered it with extra pizza sauce and still it was hard as plywood . I would definitely not be ordering from this place again. I know many people like it but that is not my case. read more

I agree that this is probably the best pizza in Clay, but the bar is pretty low here. The pizza is close to NY, the sauce is a little off from the tri state area flavor profile, the crust is missing the flavor from up there, but for being 1100 miles south, it's the best substitute I've found in Clay. The wings are OK, not anything special, but the pizza make up for it. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Clay. Probably Jax. Always hot and fresh, even when ordering delivery. The prices are fair and the portions are huge. Cheesy garlic bread is so dang good too! We got chicken wings for the first time last week and they are bigger than most wing places around. The staff is friendly as well. They have become a staple for our house and will be getting them again this week probably! read more

Wanted NY style Thin crust cheese. It was amazing. The owner made my pizza she was super nice and the place was very clean which is very important to me!! Got the large cheese 8 slices 19.00. Was great for a pick up during covid!!! read more

I have to hand it to New York Pizza, their slice is VERY close to a slice from the Big Apple! It's thin with a distinctive crust (eat it immediately for the best experience as this type of crush gets chewier with time), flavorful cheese, and delicious toppings. My only qualm (and thus only 4 stars) is the price. I wish a slice was just a tad cheaper. Other than that though, this is the "real deal" and worth coming back to again and again. read more

Outstanding Customer Service!!! They make sure your order is correct and looks fabulous !! Tried Everything on menu can't go wrong with anything. They make you feel like Family!!!! read more

Great pizza. We got their biggest one for a party and I waited about 15 minutes for it but everyone ate it up :)

In the mood for a large slice of thin crust pizza at a great price? This is the place. The service is quick and friendly. If you are just looking for something to grab for a speedy lunch and pizza sounds good, this is your place. It's recently remodeled and looks great inside. read more

Best pizza and wings we've had in Fleming Island. Everything we have ordered from here has been outstanding. The staff are always nice and polite.. our go to pizza and wing place! read more

Not impressed. $40+ for two small pizzas and an "appetizer" sampler. Pizza crust was not good. Cardboard texture that reminded me of frozen. Toppings were acceptable, even though most were unidentifiable. The $10 appetizer sampler was inedible. Fried from frozen, over cooked and greasy. Service, even for takeout, was severely lacking. Waited at the counter to be acknowledged by the termite-boppers that were socializing. Had to ask for the appetizers that I ordered. There is good pizza in the greater Jacksonville area. This isn't it. read more

New York Pizza - Yuck! - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

Just ate here for the first time and will definitely be back. We had the garlic knots and a pizza, both were amazing. The owners are very friendly, the food was quick the music selection was great. read more

New York Pizza - HALF a calzone! - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

This place is great and they deliver. Tried the wings a thick crust pizza and cheese sticks. They were all delish. Plan for an hour on delivery. read more

New York Pizza - Pepperoni mushroom and banana pepper pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

See all

y'all.... I STILL love this place. and i finally tried the CFA pizza that was all the talk at this place and it's AMAZING. it's my favorite pizza, probably ever. something about it just... is so good like i already want it again. i love places that sell such unique foods and this is deff one of them, deff a place to try out if you're in the area and want some pizza. will continue being a consistent customer! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

See all

First time at the restaurant. Great pizza, pepperoni is deli style not those little pieces you normally get. Guys behind the counter where very nice. Large, full of ingredients and very good!! read more

I'm a pizza snob and I'm particular about how it should be made. I have a simple test to judge pizzas by seeing how good their beef and jalepeno pizza is. The best one for me is in SF at a mom and pops Italian pizzeria called Victor's. I have to say that this one comes very close to it. The tomato sauce is delicious and the toppings are great quality. The pizza has just the right amount of dough. I've ordered it several times over the past few months and it's always perfect. read more

Upon setting up for a live shot with my reporter, I came across this pizza shop and surprisingly, I was craving pizza. The staff was super friendly and pizza per slice is set an amazing price. In the future, if we're ever in Fleming Island for a story, I'm definitely stopping by again. read more