I visited the Oakleaf location and thought it was the perfect stop for me and my son to grab a quick and delicious bite! Tons of options, friendly staff, and a great location. We always love our visits here. read more

See all

Insane experience. They absolutely do not seem to care about pickup orders. When I arrived, I was told my order wasn't ready, even though I noticed several to-go bags sitting on a table. I waited about 30 minutes because I didn't want to be impatient or keep bothering the staff. After checking back, I found out those bags had actually been the orders I was waiting for the entire time. Not only was my order apparently sitting there the whole time, but there was no apology or sense of urgency. The only response I got was, "I didn't know." Very disappointing customer service and a complete lack of attention to pickup customers. I wasted 30 minutes waiting for an order that was already prepared. read more

We did take away from Jersey Slice and ate in our holiday home. The staff was very nice and offered a free drink while we were waiting. We had Margarita and Veggie Pizza in Large size for 4 adults and couldn't finish it up. Both pizzas tasted very well. read more

Jersey Slice - Pizza Veggie - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I hate to write a review on anything but we ordered jersey slice tonight via takeout. I ordered a chicken parm sub. Taking a bite the chicken fell out of the sub and out of the breading. The chicken had grill marks? Looks like pre cooked Perdue chicken, breaded and fried. I'm confused, and it didn't taste good or fresh. Bad texture. I ate most of it because I was hungry and pregnant. My husband loved his steak and cheese though. We usually get pizza and wings and always good. Won't be getting the chicken parm again. read more

Jersey Slice - Precooked Perdue chicken for chicken cutlet? - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Horrible food and staff the food looks you get at grocery store it is never clean or organized and so gross and disgusting

Pretty damn good pizza! Thin and crispy just how I like it!!!!! Will definitely return and recommend! read more

Jersey Slice - Chicken bacon ranch & pepperoni slices! - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This place has a great lunch special and the food is delicious. I like all the Jersey references.

Super yummy! We have been looking for a good pizza place and this is our new go to! The garlic knots are so fluffy! read more

Jersey Slice - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Very very good! With steady traffic in and out on a Friday night you know it's got to be good. The pizzas are huge and made just like at the Jersey Shore! I also had a Greek Salad which was huge. I boxed up 1/2 of It before I even started eating. I also ordered 2 of the amazing pepperoni rolls, which come with sauce for dipping. But......don't get me started on the truly most special of all food there.....THE GARLIC KNOT! So good we ordered 6 for the table! read more

The wings were great but the gluten free pizza... $20 and the pizza was hard as a rock. You could lift up one slice, connected to 5 others, shake it and it wouldn't move, split since it was pre cut. Even steaming it over water didn't soften it at all. Not sure what cauliflower crust it was but do not eat it! read more

Jersey Slice - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Garlic knots were a soggy mess from sitting in too much butter, they were inedible, they were left in the oven too long and the bottom of the aluminum pan was burnt, rolls were black on the bottom read more

I guess Instagram advertising works. Honestly, anything involving pickles is gonna catch my eye and require investigation. I'm glad I saw this ad. I love the White Pickle Ranch pizza. As the name implies, this is a white pizza. The twist is that it has pickles on it, again, as the name implies. It lives up to that name very well with plenty of dill pickle chips sitting on the right amount of mozzarella, covered in ranch. The crust is good, thin and a little chewy. The slices are big. It's simple, and simply good. The rest of the menu looks very good, ranging from salad and wings (with a wide variety of sauces), to calzones, strombolis, and a nice selection of specialty pizzas. I don't live up this way anymore, but if I did, this would be my pizza place. It is recommended read more

Jersey Slice - Two White Pickler Ranch slices and a drink for less than $10 on this Monday. If you like pickles, this is your pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Favorite pizza shop, and they deliver in nocatee. You can't go wrong, placed an order online on a Sunday and pizza was delivered on time and perfect! read more

See all

We stopped in and got a chicken Parm sub, and pizza. Wow, the bread was soft, and the sauce was soooooo tasty!! One of the better parm subs I've had. My husband got 2 slices of pepperoni and sausage and he said they were great. Small place but on a nice day, you could also sit outside. Well def go back for other intriguing menu items!! read more

Jersey Slice - Pepperoni and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

This pizza restaurant recently opened in the space previously occupied by a different pizza restaurant in Palencia. The new one is a lot better. I placed a to go order and they said it would be a 45 minute wait, but texted me in about 30 minutes and said it was ready. The restaurant is nice and bright with plenty of tables for dining there. They also had a lot of take out orders that night. I ordered a large supreme pizza, which came with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and olives. The slices were pretty large, and very tasty. I would definitely eat here again. read more

See all

We didn't feel like going out, so pizza it was over the weekend! We were going to order from our usual place, but due to it being closed for vacation, we looked for another pizza place in the area and Slice popped up! After looking over their menu, it seemed pretty standard in regards to a pizza place. To keep things simple we ordered a large pepperoni and a side of garlic knots. I know, I know, I'm sure I'm out of touch when it comes to prices (I know I say that often), but for a large pizza and a side of garlic knots that was almost $30, seems a bit steep, but I know it's pretty in line with the prices in the area. I was able to order everything online and do pickup. The online app will give you a window of when your items should be done. When we arrived our items were done yet, but that was OK, we could wait. When our items were ready we picked them up and drove back home. When we got home everything looked correct: pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. I dug into the garlic knots and they were delicious: soft, super buttery, and garlicky. Then it was time for the pizza. The pizza was good, the crust was think, and it had a good ratio of cheese to sauce to meat. read more

Started a new tradition of coming here for lunch I appreciate talking sports with Sam she rocks and the food here is the best! Thanks for being so amazing and actually tasty just like at home! Jersey Slice for the win! read more

Best Service! In that plaza! I love coming here! Pizza is fresh, tasty. The restaurant is clean, spacious. So far I have only tried two types, buffalo chicken was sooo yummy! The ricotta was great also. This is my spot for lunch while in the area, I also love how they have wine selections and such. Will have to come on a non working day to enjoy a glass with my pizza. Oh the bonus is the large pizza slice is $4.95! read more

New little pizza shop in Palencia! We love pizza places where you can get just a quick slice to eat! My son loves Cheese so it's nice to not have to buy a whole pizza! Slices were a pretty good size too! We got garlic knots to share that were so tasty with a lot of flavor! Then we got a Sausage/Pepperoni and Onion Stromboli and a Buffalo Chicken Stromboli! Huge portions so could only make it about half way and boxed up the rest! Service staff were really sweet and attentive! There is plenty of seating for a smaller restaurant and they were pretty busy for a Wednesday! Definitely give it a try! read more

See all

After a day of boating, we wanted to try a local pizza place! Slice Palencia intrigued us with their Buffalo Chicken Pizza! It was a tasty delight! The cheese wasn't the best we have had but the uniqueness of their other offerings will bring us back to try to the White Pickle Ranch Pie & some juicy wings! The service was splendid! read more

See all

We ordered takeout and the pizza was terrific! Just a basic pepperoni pizza and requested double cut for easy eating. We had leftover and finished it for lunch the next day. Definitely will be back either to eat in or do takeout again. read more

This is a nice change from the pizza place that used to occupy this same space. Not quite sure what style of pizza this is, but I'm glad they aren't claiming to be another New York pizza place. That said, if you are looking for a unique pizza place, this is it. However, if you are looking for New York-style pizza, this is not it. The style of the pizza is unique with a firmer, thicker crust and different flavors. Although we favor the New York style the most, this was good. I thought the pickle pizza was yummy too. We are looking forward to coming back to try the wings or hot sandwiches. Yes, yes...they have a few more things on the menu than just pizza. While I'm at it, you can get a whole pie or just a slice from the pies on display that are already made. There is plenty of parking, restrooms, and the staff is friendly. The atmosphere is unlike anything you'd expect for a pizza place...sort of a jungle or tropical feel. You order at the counter and pay upfront. Of course, if you get a drink, there are machines to serve yourself. They have bottled beer as well and they'll pop the top for you. Since you do pay upfront, please know the only service you receive is someone bringing your food to the table...you do everything else yourself. On that note, please be aware you will experience guilt tipping at check out when you pay upfront, so be prepared since this is something different for everyone. If you have read my reviews on pizza places then you know my family and I are self-proclaimed pizza snobs since my husband is a New Yorker and we love New York-style pizza. Although NY pizza is my/our favorite, this is good, unique...and an enjoyable change. read more

Order a large meat pizza tonight for pick up we were quoted 20 minutes. From pick up till we got home it was 10 minutes. I don't know if we received someone else's meat pizza tonight but the pizza was warm at best. It was also so thin the pizza ripped leaving part of the slice in the box. The pizza did have a lot of toppings and "looked good" but all in all disappointing. read more

I wanted so badly to like it. I live so close. The owner and staff are SO NICE. If only it was delicious pizza! But alas. it is not. The tomato sauce and on the pizza is thick and heavy - doesn't taste fresh. Tastes like off the shelf Prego from the supermarket. The crust has an odd flavor. The crust is also weirdly chewy. The edges of the crust are not crisp and delicious with little charred edges from being in an awesome oven for the right amount of time. I have had world-class pizza at Sally's and also Pepe's (New Haven, CT) and in New York. I recently went to Bella Mia in the country of Portugal and had stunningly delicious pizza where I had to stop myself. Sadly, with Slices, I really didn't even enjoy 1 slice. I don't know where the other reviews are coming from, but this is my 3rd time at Slices, and I can tell you it's not great pizza at all. All I can think is that perhaps many reviewers have never had fresh, hot, amazing pizza. I actually posted here 2 photos - One that I just took from tonight's pizza from slices, and one from Bella Mia. You can even see the difference in the color of the tomato sauce, the crust - without even tasting it! Slices, please get better, i'm begging you. I want you to win. But your pizza is expensive, and it needs to be good. I paid $24.99 for a subpar Margherita pizza - which is $26+ with tax! Hope that helps. read more

Jersey Slice - Pizza from Bella Mia in Portugal - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Wanted to try a new pizza, ordered the margarita pie... BEST PIE IN ST AUG 9.8/10 it doesn't get better than this place. Jersey slices worker Sam was out of this world friendly and super professional love the people there and the food, will be back ASAP!!!! read more

Amazing food and service!! Highly recommend. A great option if you want guaranteed scrumptiousness!

We went there for a couple of slices and were pleasantly surprised, the pizza was what we are use too coming from the NY area. We then ordered for dinner and again great food and service. We'll be back when we're in the area again. read more

This location has sold 3X. Every owner has made excellent pizza. I ordered the Buffalo Chicken Pizza that was very good. The crust was perfect! I finished the pizza later after it sat in my car while I was at the Daytona 500. It was still very good! I ordered pickup and the man I spoke to was great to deal with and had it ready when I got there. I will keep going back! read more

Much improved from my last experience. Overall, the taste was good and the crust crispy (have to ask for a crispier crust).

I came here with a friend and his daughter a few days ago. I had the eggplant parm pasta w/spaghetti. It was excellent and very filling; I liked how it came with garlic knots. read more

I ordered a cheese slice to go. When I got home to eat it. I was so disappointed it tasted a day old. Hard to bite. The whole slice was a disappointment. read more

I grew up NJ. This place is legit. It's as close to NJ pizza that you will find in NE Florida. read more

Jersey Slice - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Found this place online, decided to try it. We received the wrong pizza completely on accident. The cashier, Sam, immediately called us apologizing about the mishap and had us come back to get our correct pizza. She had made us a fresh pie that came right out of the oven as we walked through the door, and even offered us sodas to apologize. Sam truly went above and beyond. She made our day! Food was AMAZING I highly recommend, and we will definitely be back! (Thank you Sam!!) read more

We are new to the area and have a hard time finding food we like here. We were surprised when we found this little gem! Friends brought it over the first time and we are so glad they did! The pizza is great. The prices are fair. The staff is friendly. And bonus - it's so cute inside! This is a solid 4.5 star establishment. But since we can't do half stars on here - we rounded up! read more

gave me free food and it is very very good will go again i love this place its also cheap

Great staff, hot pizza and delicious recipe for marinara. No wait time, fresh and varied menu. Everything is delicious! Highly recommend

Delicious food great service and nice family atmosphere. I think the pizza is one of my favorites in the area and the price point isn't bad.

Food was good, I mean Kyle the employee makes it a great restaurant for me and definitely makes this place a spot you want to dine at frequently. read more

I think the best description of this place is average. Average pizza, average wings and average prices. Not great. Not terrible.

Pizza is sub-par. There are a lot better options in the area. Worse... if you order online they require your email address, but if there is a box to click to not receive marketing email it is not obvious. I always click to not receive marketing. Now my inbox is getting spammed by Jersey Slice. No amount of opting out of the emails has worked so far. Bad pizza. Bad business. Avoid. read more