OK there's nothing fancy about this place, could use to freshen up it's look but if you want a good pizza while in Malden this is the place. I'm a HUGE fan of their buffalo chicken pizza to me it's the right blend of hot chicken, cheese and blue cheese dressing on an Italian style crust. I haven't had a better buffalo pizza in this area. read more

Ol' reliable! I stand by this place. It is hot. It is cheap. It is true New York pizza or as close as you'll get in Boston area (alongside the other location in theater district-are they the same owners/biz? Same name and also very good). I like their seating option inside it reminds me of my childhood and sitting in for dinner. If it's under $5 you need cash so I usually have to add a sodacan when I get a few cheese slices. But that's fine! No frills but who needs em. So many spots in the city with meh pizza are out here charging $7-8 for a painful slice here they aren't small and they are good!! read more

New York Pizza - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

Always great but needs cosmetic upgrades to the pizza parlor.zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

" Pizza is huge , cheap and delicious " The pizza is huge. It's a bargain for the size. It tastes delicious. At this location parking is not bad at all . The vibe is welcoming. The service is good , very friendly. read more

This pizza spot has the best Mamma Mia pizza!!!! No other pizza spot makes it the way they do.

Literally one of the best buffalo chicken pizzas I've had in a while. Their phone is always ringing when I'm picking up my pizza which is how I know this place is popping. I usually call ahead and the pizza is ready within 20 minutes. The lady who works at the front is always slammed with calls but makes time to serve the people at the restaurant as well. Sometimes, it's a little chaotic, but I promise you it's worth it. The pizza itself is thin, crispy and soft. The dressing on top makes it all come together. The chopping chicken pieces in every bite and the perfect amount of sauce make this pizza a must try! read more

I can't even give them a star. Had to give a star to post The pizza is horrible. The cheese they put it has a weird taste . The pizza was undercooked. It's the worst pizza I ever had in my life.. read more

Okay services, nasty environment and fair foods. Nothing delicious at all, But all the pizzas are yummy.

I sometimes go here with some of my friends in the area and overall, I think this a great place if you're looking for some good food. The quality of it is excellent in all honesty. I usually get Chicken and Fries and they are outstanding. However there are a few issues. Mainly small ones. The guy is usually takes the orders is sometimes hard to understand and sometimes he gets confused on what your saying, which happened to me last time. My other issue is the fact that the text on the tvs showing the menu are kind of small and compressed, making it a bit hard to read. Despite all that I do think this a pretty solid place read more

This is my go to spot for some good pizza and fries in Malden specifically. My go to is their mamma mia buffalo chicken pizza (never disappoints)!! This is cheap and delicious. Normally no more than $20 for a medium size pizza and a large fry for my boyfriend and I to share-plus we always have left overs for lunch the next day. This is a good spot if you're looking to stay in the area. However their service is terrible. It's normally the same girl at the front/cashier and she is always disgustingly rude. To be honest, she shouldn't be working in a place like this or at any place that requires to work with human beings/customer service because she sure as hell sucks at it. It's always a mad house any time from 3-10pm since this is in the heart of Malden also really close to the high school. If you're looking for a place to sit, I would recommend you taking your food home if you're in the area because you'll be annoyed with screaming- out of controlled high schoolers. read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

This place is simply amazing. I saw the reviews for the Buffalo chicken pizza and had to try. We've lived in Malden for 3 years and am so disappointed we didn't try earlier! By far favorite Buffalo chicken pizza. Pics are from two different times. Each time the pizza is the same quality which is rare for some places to do. Pieces of chicken are small but distribution is even and not sparse. Great sauce on top, not too spicy with the Buffalo, nice tang. Highly recommend these guys! read more

New York Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Large 16" - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

See all

Their customer service is very bad. I always have an unpleasant experience due to the cashier. She is very rude to customers..I placed an order online and arrived five minutes earlier than the estimated pick up time. She told me it would take another 30 minutes. Shows that they do not have good time management. They need to do a better job keeping up with their orders and updating the estimated time if there is a delay. However, aside from their service, the mamma mia buffalo chicken pizza is fairly good. I usually order a medium pizza and my boyfriend and I are always stuffed. I also tried their steak and cheese sub and it was very dry, bland and lack of cheese. I would recommend avoid visiting on weekdays around 2-3pm because high school students tend to hang out there after school. read more

New York Pizza - Steak and Cheese Sub - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

Waited an hour and a half and food never arrived called them 5 times and no response. Called them when they opened the next day and said it's not there problem and we're very disrespectful. Worst service I've ever seen in a pizza place. read more

Needed to try some new delivery in the area as am just about sick of everything. Got a steak tip salad - just blah, the steak really had no flavor and the salad was just plain. Shrimp Broccoli Ziti, had good flavor & was a decent portion Cheeseburger was good (claimed the BF) and he is super picky... Everything was good, I would go back to try some other things. read more

See all

If you want a quick slice of pizza it isn't my number one place to go the pizza is dry. But great customer service. read more

Nyc pizza is a hit or a miss. For me personally, the pizza is great. Haven't tried anything thing else on the menu, but it does get packed sometimes, and I see other ppl grabbing other items. The place is not your high class artisanal pizza but hey if your down to earth and want a decent slice come check it out. The buffulo chicken and cheese pizza are on point, and what I usually get on the run read more

The pizza is great if you get it hot which only happened once since we started ordering from this place they have messed up every single order. Between being 2 hours till we get it ice cold and being told it was my fault for not calling when I called several times. they said they would make good of the next order and they didn't then they went to the wrong location and by time we got it it was cold never made good of it. this time they didn't send all 3 pizzas which i repeated twice and they claim its my fault just to be told by the jerk on the phone every time they come to this address there is a problem YES because every time we order you screw it up. We no delivery to your address no more that's fine your not the only pizza place in Malden. Pizza is great service is trash. read more

Cheese pizza is oily, tastes like cardboard! Cheap prices though. Customer service is average

This is my go to pizza place in Malden because the Buffalo chicken pizza is one of the best I've ever had. I also frequently get their wings, steak and cheese calzone and onion rings which are all great. I feel like compared to a lot of places their food isn't overly greasy which I appreciate. The prices are reasonable and ordering online is easy. Their takeout service is always super quick and the pizzas are just coming out of the ovens when I get there so I know everything I'm picking up is fresh. I always suggest ordering from here when friends come to visit and will continue to order from here often! read more

15 minutes estimated time ended up being one hour when i finished eating and went home i ended up sick threw up they changed this place so much pizza different fries chicken they changed alot and taste so bad read more

I usually like this place a lot, but after the delivery service they don't even deserve a star, i ordered a buffalo french fries and a cheese pizza in which they usually have them ready and just put them in the oven, i live 2 blocks away, the food took more than an hour and a half and when i called they said he will leave in 5 minutes? And he took half an hour? The food was very cold and soggy... read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

With a name like New York Pizza, there are certain expectations. And I'm satisfied that the slices of pie they're slinging out meet that. Pretty good slice, nothing to complain about. Get a slice, fold it, and walk out the door and eat it while walking down the street. Just like the City. (Missing star is because a pepperoni slice costs a whole dollar more than a cheese slice.) read more

This place has no AC. So it is hot, humid, and stinky inside. This review is to remind myself not to come here in the summer time. Pizza quality has gone down compared to 10 years ago. read more

If you're from Malden then you definitely know about this pizza spot and what they're known for. During my whole high school time, my friends and I would always walk over here to grab pizza. They are known for their buffalo chicken pizza and you will not be disappointed. I've tried buffalo chicken pizza from different places but no place can compare to the one here. I recently moved to Randolph and drove all the way back to Malden just because I was craving pizza from here. read more

New York Pizza - Mamma Mia Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

Anyone who could give this pizza a negative review doesn't know good pizza! The best pizza around! FLAWLESS! Always fresh, hot & FLOWING WITH CHESSE! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

Just got slices of buffalo style pizza and bit into a large piece of bone right into my tooth and gums ... won't eat here again this is the third time this had happened in the last few weeks ... gave them chances not again I'm not read more

New York Pizza - Bone from slice of buffalo style pizza - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

Costumer service is very bad.. the food is mediocre, the owner is rude and the employees too. I have lived in malden for 5 years now and this is my local pizzeria.. unfortunately there is no love in this business, very sad. read more

This isn't my favorite pizza place in malden, but it does the job if you're hungry. $5 minimum if you're using card. The slices are a little dry, but the staff members are hilarious ! read more

New York Pizza - HUGE slice of cheese - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

The place was very small and tight (the establishment is only doing takeout right now) and as it got busy, I felt as if the customer service got worse. It looked the like the workers in the back was lost (maybe he was new), as two other customers next to me had gotten the same pizza as I did. Otherwise, the taste of the pizza was great as expected. Buffalo chicken is the way to go for sure! read more

Visited one random day because Sweet Kingdom next door was closed. Not the fanciest place but...that Buffalo chicken pizza was really a work of art. The staff were super nice. Can't wait to try their other offerings! read more

New York Pizza - Who is she - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

Okay, so we just ordered a large cheese pizza and a chicken broccoli & ziti with alfredo for delivery. The delivery driver arrives and DROPS the CBZ right in front of me as he is handing the food over--- Me: Oh whoa, that's not good. Him: Oh no, I think it's okay. Me: Can we check it first? *He opens the bag and pulls out the container to reveal that it's DRIPPING in it's own sauce. Him: It's okay. You see? Sauce outside, but inside okay. Me: Uhhhhhh, it just exploded open, it is NOT okay. *we go back and forth about who's right and finally he agrees to take it back to replace it... (no apology was given) -Moments later, I decide to call the restaurant to inform someone about what just happened. And IMMEDIATELY after I mentioned that the driver dropped the food, the guy interrupted me and said, and here's the icing on the cake: IT'S OKAY. THE CONTAINER IS TIGHT. IT DOESN'T OPEN IF IT'S DROPPED. I continued to tell the guy that it DID open, and there was sauce leaking through the bag, but the guy KEPT interrupting me and getting short with me shouting---- Him: You want a new one?! You have to give it back to the driver so we can show our boss. His only defense was, "he is human, we make mistakes." TRUE. But don't pretend like everything is OKAY when you messed up! I lost my temper and what followed wasn't nice. I asked for a manager and he told me that he was the manager on duty. That says A LOT about this place. read more

I drive by this place in Malden, MA often so decided to give it a try. If you're looking for good New York style pizza, look elsewhere. The pizza is mediocre at best. However, I also got the steak bomb sub with peppers, onions, and extra cheese and it was fantastic. Will be back next time i need a Philly cheesesteak fix. Come here for the subs, not the pizza! read more

found a nail in my buffalo pizza. Traumatized never again, they don't wear gloves while cooking.

I love the place and the food. I think they should be more clean and hygienic, but besides that i love the food, and also the people are very nice. read more

If you live in Malden and have never tried the buffalo chicken pizza here, you're missing out. The service is always quick and kind. They're doing a great job at limiting exchange of contact during the pandemic as well. read more

Ordered Shrimp and Calamari, Calzone and Salad w/fries The shrimp was ok and the calamari was sub par. Big salad which was decent and reasonably priced. The Calzone, Spinach, Feta and Olive was tasty. Fries were eh. Would not try again. read more

New York Pizza - Calamari - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts

See all

This is probably the BEST pizza I have ever had... their chicken pizza is EPIC... only 3 dollars for a huge slice

Native New Yorker here. I wanted to like this place, but wasn't a big fan of this pizza. The cheese to sauce ratio is off w/ way too much sauce. read more

Three stars because I don't exactly have much to base it on. I've fallen in love with their cheese calzone and that's ALL I ever get here. It's $7, large and friggin delicious. I usually order a second marinara sauce for dipping because one isn't enough for how big it is. I love arriving a few minutes early, watching it come out of the oven and them spreading a layer of melted butter over the top to make it glisten. They take credit cards so that's a plus.....and the seating area has like six booths which is plenty since they aren't usually overly busy. I usually get take out and your food is always ready within 15 minutes of ordering. I agree, not the best name for the restaurant but the foreign owners probably wanted to try something with a little pizzazz without knowing what entails a typical NY pizza. I'd love to go back and try a few other things but it's pretty hard to pull myself away from something so cheap and good that becomes your staple. read more

I just order a steak and cheese with mayo and hots. No mayo no hots. -_- 3 starts because the place is still good. I will give it another chance then final review. read more

New York Pizza - No mayo no hots... - Pizza Near Me - Malden, Massachusetts