I decided I was in the mood for an Italian hero and checked Yelp and decided on New York Super Subs. The location is not much to speak of one small table basically only take out. I ordered an Italian sandwich regular size. The service was excellent and the gentleman behind the counter was very friendly and very helpful. As far as Italian sandwich's go it was just ok nothing special. I did not care for the bread that much and the meat was just ok. I probably would not go again at least not for an Italian hero. The food would get 2 stars in my opinion but the service was 5 stars all the way. Overall I have to give it 3 stars as the food itself was just ok. read more

New York Super Subs - the outside of a restaurant - Delis Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

The food was amazing. I ordered a meatball sandwich and it was totally worth it. The ambiance of the place is up to par with sufficient seating capacity. read more

The smallest and most depressing cheesesteak I've been served, and it was almost $15. There's also no place to wash your hands and there's only two tables (no wonder why). I rarely leave reviews but had to do one for this read more

Good place to get a quality satisfying sandwich. I believe there was a location in Fox Chapel, but when I visited, it was closed. The Squirrel Hill location has many of the classic sandwiches, like Ruebens, Cheese, chicken Florentine, meatball, among others. I decided to try their cheesesteak sandwich (not the sub), their eclair, and the cannoli. I thought the sandwich was good, but a bit pricy. Their cheesesteak sub is probably a better deal, and you can get in a 1 ft or 2 ft (super) size. The meat was a good texture, but I would have liked a bit more cheese. The bun was nice and fluffy, soaked with steak juice on the bottom. Good amount of tasty mushrooms. You can also get the sandwich on a croissant. It was served with a tiny portion of coleslaw, which was tasty but way too minuscule. I also ordered a pickle wedge as one of my sides, but did not receive it. They have an in-house bakery from what I am aware of. They pride themselves on their cannolis, but I found the vanilla to be very average. It was not a very crispy shell. The filling was bland and just vaguely sweet. It tasted almost like whipped cream. Nothing special. The eclair was similarly only okay. The filling on the inside (custard) was very good. But, the chocolate topping was not thick enough. And, the eclair dough was standard, almost cakey. Probably not worth $4; I've had better at the Oakmont Bakery. This place also makes cookies, brownies, shortcakes, and other desserts. All in all, New York Super Subs probably can't compare to the New York delis. They make fairly good sandwiches, and they may be a good food stop if you like big sandwich (and are willing to pay the price). Their baked goods aren't anything special. read more

See all

If you're looking for tasty sandwiches, this is a good spot. They have a pretty classic selection -- Italian hoagies, ruebens, turkey clubs, meatball subs, BLTs, everything you would expect -- plus a few interesting offerings like the buffalo chicken sandwich. Everything was good. If you're sticker shocked when you look at the prices, don't worry -- you do get plenty of sub for the cost. Their "whole" hoagies are two foot longs, and their "half" is a regular footlong. So keep that in mind when ordering! read more

Best meatball sub I've had in years, you can tell they're made in house. Go with a friend and split the two footer... Wish I lived closer

New York Super Subs was good. The quality of the pastrami doesn't compare to the kosher cuts you can get in the New York area, but I still really enjoyed my sandwich. The pickle was good, and the coleslaw was a generic, mayonnaise based slaw. I will eat at New York Super Subs again! Head over for solid sandwich options. read more

New York Super Subs - Pastrami with swiss - Delis Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

A little pricey, but a great quick takeout lunch option. Service is usually pretty good. They have a place you can sit inside or outside, but definitely prefer takeout here. 2 foot long sandwich??? Wild! read more

I ordered a burger with sides of potato salad and a pickle wedge. The cook who made my meal said he "made it with love" and I felt it haha. Just a really good, cheap, late lunch. read more

Only stopped in briefly to pick up food for a friend. While I waited the cheesecake caught my eye as it's one of my wife's personal favorites. Slice of cheesecake will set you back about $4 bucks, but texture and taste were spot on! Not too heavy and they were generous with the strawberries in syrup. Plenty more on the menu that I'd like to try. read more

This place is pretty new to Squirrel Hill I think. Uncle Sam's Subs has been an institution in the neighborhood for so long but New York Super Subs is a great option! We got take out from here recently and enjoyed our subs. My wife got the chicken salad, which was very dense and tasty (though not much lettuce). I got the buffalo chicken sub, which was less dense but also had a nice zingy flavor. The subs were both 12 inches and reasonable prices but they were very thin so in the end it didn't feel like a ton of sub. They do offer 24-inch versions of all subs so maybe I will try that next time. Take out was very quick too - our order was ready by the time we got to the store in just about 10 minutes. read more

New York Super Subs - Buffalo Chicken - Delis Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Huge portions, fresh ingredients, and friendly services veggie and cheesesteak subs are great read more

On Sunday night, after a long day of driving, my family was hungry for some cheesesteaks. Normally, Uncle Sam's is our go-to, but they were already closed when we called at 6:15, so we decided to try New York Super Subs again. Our first experience had been tasty, but not quite enough to take on Uncle Sam's spot in our takeout rotation. We ordered a super cheesesteak sub and a small cheesesteak with just beef and cheese for our picky eating 6 year old. We also grabbed cannoli for dessert. The sub was delicious, and the baguette style bread is a bit of an elevated element. The cheesy beefy mushroomy pepper and onion sub definitely hit the spot, and helped counteract the car-tired hangriness that was hitting us all hard. The kiddo enjoyed his sub as well, which was a relief. The cannoli went over well too. In fact, we were asked why we only got the kiddo one cannoli and no fries. Welp, they don't have fries! But still, it was a tasty meal, and I'm glad to know that we have options for the next time Sunday evening rolls around and we didn't plan dinner. (I blame so many of those occasions on the Steelers! LOL) read more

Always fast and good. Their Hot Sausage sub is fantastic.

My boyfriend and I just popped in for the first time. Pleasantly pleased at the friendliness from the man behind the counter, he helped suggest popular items on the menu. We ended up sharing a Philly Cheesesteak without mushrooms and it was absolutely amazing! We got a full size which was more than enough to split with each other and it traveled well home, still warm, juicy, and delicious! read more

New York Super Subs - Mmmmm - Delis Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Lobster roll Looking forward to trying everything else. Great bread and fresh ingredients go a long way. read more

Never misses on making you one of the best subs you will have in your lifetime. Choose your typical go to choice of sub and enjoy! Sizes are crazy big so prepare to share or finish at another point in the day. read more

Terrific addition to the neighborhood. Fresh and flavorful. Mildly spicy dressing is perfect--they import it from Brooklyn. The "small" Italian sub is a full meal. Recommended highly! read more

New York Super Subs - "Small" Italian sub. - Delis Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Yikes! I paid $44 for two sandwiches (DoorDash fees and forced tip) and the corned beef sandwich arrived with no meat, no Swiss cheese, no Thousand Island dressing---just coleslaw on the bread!!!! i called to complain and he said "that's how you ordered it." liar! i said, "if that was the case, why didn't you call?" no response. Also, I paid for a pickle ("it's in the box---no it was not). i paid for a "special mayo" and that was not included!!!!!!!! Truly terrible service. must be run by idiots. disputed the charges with my credit card and Door Dash. I will never will step foot in this filthy vortex of stupidity and illiterate workers. UPDATE: DoorDash emailed and called me to apologize for the "sloppy and unprofessional treatment" I received. They refunded the money for DoorDash and the food. Still, NEVER AGAIN! read more

Great. Tasty fresh food. Friendly people work here. Fresh ingredients We tried Italian was way better than other places in squirrel Hill read more

I decided to stop in this place when they had a sign out advertising a "Boston lobster roll." It was a huge mistake. Maybe their other food is good but I do not recommend the lobster rolls. When I walked in the first red flag was the long list of options for sauces and toppings. I said I wanted whatever was the most traditional or authentic version of the Boston lobster roll. The person making the sandwiches responded in an annoyed and exasperated tone that how would he know what an authentic Boston lobster roll is? It's literally how it's advertised on their menu. Call it a Pittsburgh lobster roll if you want to do your own thing. I asked for the mayo based sauce as that sounded the most authentic. They then decided to use hot butter instead and cook it on the grill and insisted this would be better and gave me the mayo based sauce on the side. I was not really given a choice in the manner and it was too late to protest. As a result the lobster was over cooked and to my horror I realized it was mixed in with imitation crabmeat! Given the price of around $20 this was not what I expected. They also added lettuce and tomato, which was another surprise. It came with a "side" of potato salad which you can see from the photo was the size of a condiment sauce rather than an actual side dish. read more

New York Super Subs - "Boston lobster roll" - Delis Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

So many places to eat in this part of Squirrel Hill, I feel like I'm always discovering something new, and this awesome little deli is no exception! Their subs are ENORMOUS, and you will definitely not be short-changed on delicious toppings. My chicken cacciatore was juicy and well seasoned, with tender grilled mushrooms, peppers, and onions. It's not fancy, but it's delicious. Keep in mind that there us not a lot of seating-- could be a great place to grab food before a picnic in Schenley or Frick Park. Will be back! read more

LOVE their subs. We found it by accident one day. Not because we walked by it 100 times and just didn't notice it-but, because we wanted to try something new and local is always the way to go! They have, hands down, the BEST meatball sub. And the chicken Florentine is excellent as well. We order it often and it is just amazing!!!! read more

Don't order online because if they can even find your order, they don't fill it correctly even when you're the only customer in the store.

Food was unreal, the sandwiches did not disappoint. This is definitely a place you go, grab the food and go. Eating in is ver difficult for more than 2 people. Other than that, we had a great experience! read more

We got this as take out today. Subs were pretty good. Really good size- their "half" was a footlong! I wasn't prepared for that but now I have lunch for tomorrow. We also got one of their sandwiches (the corned beef) and that was pretty good as well. My only complaint is that they forgot some of my toppings on my sub, which I didn't realize until we got home. But everything that did make it on my sub tasted much better than other chain sub shops so I think we'll definitely be coming back! read more

Excellent submarine sandwiches with a deli selection. Owner was very nice , highly recommend read more

Asked for no mayo Sandwich was covered in mayo Called to ask for help to resolve the problem and was told to leave my name and phone number. I'll never go back read more

Really good sandwiches, made carefully with quality ingredients. They take genuine pride in their product and it shows. The cannoli are excellent also. The strawberry cake is awesome. read more

If I was reviewing solely on the meatball sub, this would be a 5 star rating. It's the best meatball sub in the city. Those meatballs were homemade and tasted like Sunday supper. That has been added to my crave list. The Italian was good but not amazing. I asked, and paid for, extra pepper relish and there was barley any. Maybe I was just expecting pepper relish like McCoys had but it wasn't overwhelming. The potato salad was solid. read more

I can not recommend this place enough! Their gluten free buns are the best I have ever tasted! Their meats and cheese are fresh, their sauces are homemade and they take great pride in the food they serve. I get the ham and cheese and it is perfect! My husband loves their veggie hoagie, and my mother in law loves the chicken cheesesteak and the prime rib cheesesteak. This is a new location, and they have been very busy and are still trying to work out the kinks, so there is sometimes a bit of a wait to get your food, but I promise it is so worth it! read more

Nice folks , solid cheesesteak , Italian, just a few seats , I'd visit again if I'm in a sub mood

I don't eat subs often, even though I've lived in Pittsburgh for 20 years and they are the local go-to food. Usually subs aren't anything to write home about: bread, meat, cheese... big deal, right? New York Super Subs has changed this for me. These are awesome sandwiches. Perfect balance of meat, bread and cheese every time. They have premium ingredients for my partner and I (the food snobs), like lobster and filet mignon. They have typical ingredients for the kids. They have amazing soups and desserts.I was blown away by the Greek meatball sub and couldn't stop eating the filet mignon sub, it has mushrooms and spinach! This location is new and a great addition to Squirrel Hill, so check it out. I will post pics next time, we ate everything. read more

My new favorite sandwich shop in Pittsburgh! Super House Italian sub is a must. Will be getting the meatballs on my next visit

Got a cheese steak sub. The bun was so soggy i couldn't even hold it. I threw it out and I won't be back.

Great subs, great service, good value too, had the special Italian, and cannoli. Definitely be back

Average at best. Deli meat you can buy at the grocery! Don't ever order the lobster Roll because it is truly pathetic. Overall average at best......consistency changes depending on who makes it........Owner is pretty content if there's a mistake in doing nothing.....but what you gonna do read more

The Italian hoagies here are absolutely outstanding! Great bread, lots of meat, and that house made dressing - takes it over the top! I'm spoiled, for sure. Won't go elsewhere. read more

I went hungry and my wallet is leaner. Must be that I am spoiled living in a suburb where sub prices are half of what I normally see. The lobster was a disappointment with two chunks the size of half my thumb and some shredded meant (tablespoon or a bit more). Also menu says lemon and butter but it had old bay seasoning which I don't care for, I want to taste the lobster. Oh and the sides that come with? No pickle and salads are served in a tiny condiment cup. Fried had a steak sub that seemed average. read more

The Greek sub was excellent! The deli vs half was a little confusing and a little pricy but worth it. Could use one more table