We live around the corner from Newfield Pizza. Our preferred pizza has always been Illianos, but they got expensive. Then we'd go to Freddy's on main st in Cromwell. But Newfield Pizza DELIVERS and that's a huge plus. I called for delivery at 812pm. The woman on the phone was very patient and friendly as I had to run out to the car to get my wallet. They said it'd be 45 minutes and I felt bad because they closed at 9pm. They didn't seem bothered though. The guy got to our door at 9:07pm and was really friendly. The pizza was really good - enough cheese and the sauce was flavorful. The crust is thinner which I like. Overall, great experience and I'll be happy to order delivery from here again! read more

The best meatball grinders I've ever had in a very long time reside here. They have a really good menu and good prices . The pizza is delicious, and the salads unique. I haven't seen a mandarin orange chicken salad in a long time , so I was excited to order one today. It has big marinated slices of chicken, red onions, glazed walnuts, cranberries and juicy slices of oranges throughout. They have small and large salads with a few dressings to choose . They have takeout or a nice table area to dine at. read more

Newfield Pizza - Beautiful Mandarin orange chicken salad with walnuts and cranberries.... yummmm - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

They always are friendly and the service is always good . I find the value very good and they always seem appreciative when I come in

This is one of my family's favorite restaurants, in Middletown. The staff is always friendly and quick to seat us. They can accommodate small and large parties. We've been here, more times than I can count. We also order delivery on a regular basis. We've never been disappointed; everything arrives on time, fresh and hot. Their pizza (and sauce) is wonderful, as are the grinders, pasta and salads. My husband is a huge fan of their Cheeseburger Grinder. This was part of today's order (and almost every order). Today, I ordered the Greek Wrap. Unfortunately, it was missing the signature Tzatziki sauce. The apps are standard for a pizza joint. They used to have these crunchy, addictive french fries. They recently changed...hoping they'll go back. Try the mozzarella sticks, they are a favorite of ours. The sticks are decent. But it's all about the marinara that is served on the side. It's so good, that you could drink it. read more

Friendly family restaurant. They have delicious grinders and yummy pasta dishes. Their snowball pizza is a customer favorite. I also love their penne all vodka. Quick delivery. Great service. read more

My husband and I went in for dinner. We ordered a lemonade and milk "they don't have milk" We asked for a large pepperoni pizza with a 1/3 mushroom rather than a half and they refused to do it! We paid for the drinks we didn't drink and left. How are you going to tell a customer they can't have what they ask for? read more

I love this place. They have really good food for a decent price. Pizza is always my go to but the other half likes the grinders as well. Not a huge fan of the chicken parm grinder but I'm really picky with that so I can't count it against them. Would absolutely recommend to people! Plus everyone has always been kind and friendly when I go pick food up!! read more

More like 3.5 stars, Newfield pizza is a nice local option that provides delivery. The pizza is always fresh and not too greasy. I typically go with a pepperoni/sausage combo and the prices are reasonable. I recently tried the Winger pizza which has chicken, wing sauce, blue cheese and mozzarella and it was great. Not everyone does a good buffalo chicken pizza so I was pleasantly surprised. Overall, while there are some better places in Middletown like Mondo and Illianos, if you're looking for a pretty good deal or delivery, try Newfield. read more

Newfield Pizza - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

I'm on a salad kick right now. A lot of places don't post pics of their salads so when I got this one from Newfield pizza, I had to post! It was such a great salad!!! Very good portion of delicious grilled chicken. I ordered it with a vinaigrette and it was all so yummy! I will definitely order again. For me, this was two lunch servings. read more

Newfield Pizza - Grilled chicken mandarin orange salad - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

My order was wrong. When I called the store manager he said I ordered plain wings. I said I ordered buffalo wings. He was very unhelpful and very dude. The pizza was mediocre at best and was delivered cold, which seems to be a common consensus. Not recommended. read more

Newfield Pizza - Receipt - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

This the worst pizza I have ever had. I am a pizza snob but this was the equivalent of a frozen pizza. Crust is bad, sauce tasted jarred and the cheese/toppings were artificial tasting. read more

After the great no Anchovies closed down I decided to try another pizza restaurant. My first time I ordered the Chicken parmesan dinner. It was ok and price similar to others. My second visit I ordered a sausage with pineapple pizza and was money shocked that they considered this to be a speciality pizza and it cost 33% more for what is a standard topping-(pineapple) EVERYWHERE else. I'd still go back maybe but when someone calls in with a order they should be giving the price over the phone so not to get shocked embarrassed that they didn't bring enough money in to pay bill. read more

2.5 stars + benefit of the doubt. The organizer of my Thursday night pickup hockey group takes us all out for pizza and beer at the end of the season, and does it here. I can only assume the primary reason is price... The pizza here is every bit as good as what you can find in the freezer case at your local supermarket [that's not a compliment]. The chicken wings are clearly a pre-fabricated product that they just dump in the deep fryer. Perhaps the best part of the meal was the fried calamari, but judging by what goes on around here, that probably came pre-fab from Sysco too... The waitresseses doted on us very nicely, always making the rounds to get us more beer when needed. I guess that's what makes me want to give them the benefit of the doubt. But let's just say there's no reason to return here solo. It's an almost deliberate exercise in mediocrity. read more

Ever since they bolstered their marketing efforts, and redesigned the website and menu, their customer service has gone to s**t. When your customer wants cheese on only 1/2 of something, you do it, without question. Time to find a new local pizza joint without attitude. F**k you. read more

The customer service is what made me drop my rating. If you are going to list something under a section as coming with French fries then it should come with fries or state all come with fries except... When questioned the girl was rude and said "a quesadilla isn't a sandwich" well it's listed under sandwiches. Not the first rude encounter I've had with the young girl. read more

Newfield Pizza - Don't list a quesadilla under sandwich that comes with fries if you don't consider it a sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

newfield is a decent local pizzeria. probably if you live within 5 miles your family would come here once a week and know the waitress and cook by name. we meant to go to aldo's but it was monday and they were closed, so we ended up here and it was pretty good. we were pretty much the only people in the restaurant on a late monday night. newfield pizza is better than a lot of other local pizza, but not a destination pizzeria. good if you're in the hood. read more

See all

Ordered pizza through their website on Monday since their website and yelp app said they were open until 9pm. Well when the pizza never showed up when it said it would we decided to call and no one answered. We drove by and come to find out they weren't even open but the website still charged our credit card! read more

I have been enjoying their food for years. It's basic comfort food, so don't get a 4-star Zagat rating attitude on this little gem. At least they don't 'burn' their food all the time - unlike a very highly rated Middletown famous zagat rated restaurant downtown that I shall NOT name!. I love the crispy pizzas - try them all - they are fabulous!. Their burgers, grinders are great!. And the Italian food specials are always on point. I avoid the wraps. The apps. And THE FRIES.....they changed varieties, and for some reason they just are not as crispy or tasty. But other than that it's great here!!!. BTW: Some people talk about 'attitude' of the staff - but if YOU are pleasant THEY are PLEASANT. A little kindness goes a long way...... read more

Also a great place to order from. Usually does delivery and they are very quick. I've only had the pizza and pasta but they are very good

The first time I ordered from here was on a Tues and I had chicken wings and a cheese pizza which was was pretty good! The wings were crispy and tasted fresh and the cheese pizza tasted fine. I thought finally I found my go-to chicken and wings place! But the second time I went it was closer to the weekend Thurs and I ordered the chicken wings again... They tasted greasy and had a lot of batter on them! Instead of a pizza my son had a hamburger meal and he seemed to enjoy it. But I taksted the fries and they were okay at best and their garlic bread was very mediocre. The 2 stars is really because the first time the chicken wings were really good but this time around I was so disappointed. What does a girl have to do to get decent pizza and chicken wings in the Middletown area! I won't be a returning customer. read more

My friend had informed me about Newfield pizza a while ago, but recently I finally decided to go. The food was suitable, the crust was delightful, and the pizza wasn't too cheesy. They placed a satisfactory amount of sauce on the pizza. I also decided to indulge myself in their buffalo wings. I wasn't the happiest with the lack of sauce they splatter on my wings, so I found myself dipping in the blue ranch a lot to make up for the sauce. Furthermore, the hygiene was first-rate; the tables were cleaned to perfection, and the seats were free of crumbs. Overall the experience was not special, but not the worst. If they decided to use more sauce on their wings, Newfield Pizza will be impeccable. read more

I ordered a chicken polo pizza. I had an allergic reaction because there is pine nuts in the pesto. It's not listed on their menus. Once I realized I was having an allergic reaction I called the restaurant because online I read pesto could be made with walnuts or pine nuts. I asked the girl who originally took my order if my food had nuts in it. She said she didn't know and proceeded to ask someone in the kitchen, he responded yes pesto has nuts but he wasn't sure which nut it was. (I could hear him in the background) then I say to her it states that no where on the menu. She tells me "everyone knows pesto has nuts" with a tone in her voice like she was irritated. I said well I didn't know, I've never had pesto and you didn't know either cause you had to ask. Do everyone a favor and change your menu before you f*cking kill someone." read more

My husband and I I recently went to this resturant as part of a party of 25 - 30 people. The food was good and the waitress did her best based on the fact she was the waitress only one for a party of this size. One of my guest did receive his dinner for 45 to 50 mins later. Other guest that arrived after him had already received their meal. My other guest waited approximately an hour an 20 mins and then the dinner delivered was incorrect. I spoke to the Manager and I was appalled at his reponse. HE WAS SO RUDE!!!! He basically said he did not care and if I did not like it to get of his resturant.. Even if he has apologized I would have excepted it, but to have that attidue was totally unacceptable!! I have never experienced this attitude from Managment from any resturant or in fact anywhere and will never vist that resturant again and recomend that anyone one else does. read more

Worst place ever as far as service. There were only two tables that were occupied while we were there (ours being one of those) and the waitress acted as though she couldn't keep up. She was INCREDINLY rude. Never checked to see if we needed refills. We never got our bread w/our dinner until we asked for it and then she acted as though it was an inconvenience. And when we went to pay and asked for separate checks she about flipped out. She said "next time you come in, tell me before. I can't do it unless you tell me before." I said, "sure you can". RIDICULOUS! Horribly customer service! read more

Food is okay, just don't order anything on the side. For example, if you order a salad and ask for the onions on the side, they charge extra!!! Also, myself and a friend each ordered a meal. We wanted to share our entrees. They charged extra to split the two meals. Absolutely ridiculous!! read more

I been ordering pizza their for a while now. Their pizza used to be pretty decent. But recently, they've been going down hill. Not much I can say, their pizza is very salty and not just not add good... read more

Went there tonight for take out. Called in order for large Hawaiian & small eggplant. Got there to find out the Hawaiian was a large pizza but small eggplant was an 8" grinder. Why a grinder. Family enjoyed pizza; grinder was ok. Disappointed. Last time we went (over a year ago), our order was messed up so took awhile to return. read more

We've been customers forever. We come for the pizza, especially these days we order takeout. They deliver but we've always picked it up. The kids still like their plain cheese pizza, and we generally order one with veggies - onion, roasted pepper, and mushrooms being favorites. Last night's was especially good, the roasted peppers tasted freshly roasted, the crust was perfect, sauce was fresh and not over seasoned, and the whole pizza was not over salted as some can be. To be honest, over the years we've had a few pizzas that were not as good as others, but lately they've been nailing it. We've tried many of the other pizza places around, but we always seem to gravitate back to this one as the most consistent go-to for pizza. They are always friendly when I pick-up, asking how I'm doing. I'm surprised at other reviews of rude service, that's certainly never been my experience. I recommend. read more

Their calzones are delicious! I always get them delivered (which are prompt and within the timeframe told on the phone) the calzones are always hot and fresh from the oven. Very reasonably priced and a nice generous size. What more could you ask for? read more

The pizza left much to be desired. Cheese was over cooked and almost resembled a pizza you'd make at home in your own oven. Can't say much about the staff we did take out. Probably won't be back for pizza, might give it another shot for entrees if we're in the area read more

Ive been going to this pizza place over 1 year. The food is excellent, customer service is unbelievable good. I cant wait to go every time. I recommend this place to everyone to go and check it out. read more

Never actually had their pizza but we order dinners from them often. No complaints. Very good vodka sauce.

This place is a scam please make sure you check the prices I ordered a pizza ,fries and a 2 liter soda the driver tells me it's 37.50 looked it up on the menu couldn't of been more than 28 dollars please check your receipt for the food you get read more

Definitely a hidden gem. Worth taking the time to dine in or take out, they deliver too! Friendly staff is a plus, the restaurant in clean and the atmosphere immediately made me feel comfortable when I walked in. Thin crust pizza and homemade lasagna are delicious! What won me over was that the owner even came to our table and introduced himself, We need more restaurants like this around! read more

Some of the best thin style pizza in Middletown, extremely well priced small plain under 6 dollars. And there is outside seating. Waitresses are easy on the eyes. read more

@@@ Please do not waste your money. Hands down worst experience EVER! The pizza was literally not even worth eating. We were starved and could barely finish one slice. It was greasy and just made with poor quality ingredients. The wings are precooked frozen wings you would get in frozen food section of the grocery store. I have never written a review before nor did I have a yelp account but I had to create one in order to help people and prevent them from wasting their money here. Words can not describe how awful the food here is. Do yourself a favor and go to Jerry's down the street it's worth the extra couple of bucks. read more

We love this little place. If you like thin crust pizza done exactly the way you ask, you'll like it here. It's when you sit down with a menu that this restaurant really amazes. They make their own lobster ravioli - very thin raviolis, big around and stuffed fat with lobster meat, in an excellent sauce. It's worth the trip just for that, but everything we've tried has been wonderful, and the prices are right, especially given the large portions. There is no bar, but they do have a modest selection of decent wines. The service is friendly and efficient. read more

OK so I live right down the street when I go in to eat my food is incredible and fresh but this week I had delivery every single night with a total of $236.73 I have spent there in 8 days including tips no mind you I love there food. But unfortunately at this time I am moving on .I live on the same st 300 Newfield I spend a lot of money and the reasons is I order delivery in the first place be cause I am tired from work before I order I write it down every single order I made this week way something wrong and I give the benefit of doubt by I fiqure after over a week they would fix it well folks tonight I'm hungry tired they fucked it up again shouldn't I get what I ask for tonight was a cold grinder Italian coldcut and a roast beef wrap the should have been called vegetarians awful and I ask every time sauce on side cause I can't eat soggy bread and I hate mayo well guess what I get it soaked with Mayo hey I know about work ethics and holding on to customers but they have made no means to resolve this so time for a change where I can get what I order and that's a lot of loss I work with all the dealer ships read more

Newfield Pizza - a white dog on a red blanket - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

"Inconsistently mediocre" is my best summation. We usually go there after we forgot about our last experience. The price is however consistent with the quality, you get what you pay for. read more

Good food, owner and staff always take care of me, highly recommended. Location is convenient with ample parking. Try em!