Ordeed the Cromwell specialty pizza. Delivery was quick. But just seems to be missing something. Believe it needs more sauce or a more flavorful sauce. I did like the crust and the toppings are fine. read more

We ate inside for lunch. Customer service was very good. The food arrived at a decent time. The food was delicious. I recommend and I will be returning! Great atmosphere. read more

See all

This is our go to for pizza in Cromwell. We ordered an extra large pizza with eggplant, black olives and red peppers. It was perfectly baked and absolutely delicious. read more

Family-friendly and welcoming atmosphere. Best pizza in town! Highly recommended. Attentive and respectful staff read more

Great hand made pizza, along with friendly service. Pizza great pricing is extremely reasonable. Stop in and try a great pizza or any of their other meals. read more

The pizza looked great, but first bite was a heavy layer of cheese. I do not prefer a lot of cheese and something tasted different about this one. Pepperoni was inconsistent and not much of it on the pizza. The undercarriage and crust saved this pizza for me as that was definitely the best part. I got this for takeout, but the service was quick to get the pizza up. read more

Cromwell Pizza & Pasta - Pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Beautiful meal on the patio. Great service. Their house dressing is fantastic. Great salad, reasonably priced.

I've had several items on their menu at several different times. I feel like it is hit or miss with them. The last 2 times I got food delivered the teenage drivers forgot something or delivered the wrong order. In person I have also had some mix-ups. I recently ordered a large pizza - half cheese, half mushrooms. My pizza (see picture) barely had any mushrooms on it. It was also cut awkwardly so less than half of pizza had the few mushrooms on it. It's just really frustrating especially when you have to pay extra for toppings. I don't think I will be dining here anymore, there are lots of other local pizzerias to choose from. read more

Cromwell Pizza & Pasta - Less than half the pizza has mushrooms on it, and it is sparse on the one topping I asked for. - Italian Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Great stuff. Love having such a great place within walking distance! Pizza, sandwiches, wings...everything for these game day weekends. Looking forward to getting back there. Hopefully someday very soon! read more

I am a pizza snob from New Jersey and to tell you the truth it's very hard to find good pizza in Connecticut even though the governor put a big sign as you enter the state that states it is the Pizza capital country. In all honesty, again it's hard to find pizza in Connecticut that is a Greek style. This place is very very good! Highly recommend. Especially if you're a jersey person and you know what I'm talking about. read more

This place is consistently on the money with the best calzones in CT, hands down! The dough is super thin, light, and tasty. They don't use a heavy, thick dough. It's just perfect. The fillings are delicious I really like their sausage. The pizza is similar in taste and flavor with nice thin pizza crust and yummy sauce, ooey gooey melty mozz, and toppings. My go-to pizza spot from now on. After living in NYC for years, I've been searching for that authentic taste in CT, and I finally found it. read more

Beautiful sunny day when we started so sat under a big red umbrella for lunch at Cromwell Pizza and Pasta. Ordered a Katie's Favorite Panini to share and have had this one before with its grilled chicken, provolone, roasted red peppers with pesto and mayo. This is the best! Hungry so we also ordered a Margherita with its usual fresh basil, plum tomato and mozzarella...so good. By the time we finished, the rain had started and we were ready to go with full stomachs and happy earts! read more

See all

New favorite pizza delivery option!! Closest thing to New Haven style I've had (that is available for delivery) in the area. Awesome crust, great flavor, right amount of toppings, good prices. So glad they could deliver over to my far west corner of Middletown. We will definitely order again in the future! read more

I used to love going to CPP, however, last night we ordered a lg cheese pizza and a lasagna. The pizza was cold and slimy and the lasagna was a thin slice, basically four bites. Which is disappointing because their lasagna would last me dinner and lunch the next day. Basically its gone down hill over the past year or so. very disappointing. read more

Imagine a pizza place closed on Sundays during football season. They must be loaded. They must be rolling in the dough.

The pizza was the best thing we got tonight. I loved the charred crust and the taste of the sauce. I got the Capri panini with grilled chicken and pesto, it was pretty dry. The grilled chicken didn't have a lot of taste. I would definitely come back just for the pizza. We also got a side of curly fries and they were delicious, they had a little kick to it. We ordered it for pick up and it was on time right when they said it would be. The price was also so reasonable! read more

Cromwell Pizza & Pasta - Large cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

See all

Ordered food online, never delivered. Of course, they were closed, with no mention on the website or message on their phone. I would not waste your valuable time trying to get food from this place. Zero consideration for customers and zero ability to understand what they do is screwed up. Poor management not present to refund the transaction, poor customer service from the terrible explanation I received from the staff. No apologies. read more

It's... okay. Not good, not bad, just average. Before I launch into the review, I will preface this by saying I have never had the pasta or sandwiches from this place. Therefore, this review is focused entirely on their pizza, salads, garlic knots, etc. Moving on... There are lots of pizza places to choose from in the Cromwell area, and there is nothing really about this place that stands out above the rest. Nothing wrong with the food persay... it just doesn't really stand out as a particularly excellent (or bad) choice. The biggest selling point for Cromwell Pizza & Pasta is they are open 7 days a week and they also deliver. Many of the better pizza places in Cromwell are only open 5-6 days a week, and most do not deliver. Which means that while it is never my first choice, it has it's place when the better options aren't available. read more

Great chicken parm and penne alla vodka. Not a fan of the meatballs, would skip those.

Cannot express the appreciation for this business during a critical time for our company. They worked hard to complete orders, they went above and beyond expectations to make sure we had enough food to keep the crew going. Sometimes multiple large orders a day, never an issue, food was always amazing. The staff was extremely accommodating and helpful in making sure we had what we needed. read more

If you're in the mood for some Italian cuisine, this is the place to go. I ordered their margarita pizza with mozzarella sticks and a house salad. Mozzarella sticks stood out amongst the rest and I was shocked because I'm quite particular about how I like them. The margarita pizza was pretty good as well. Topped off with the correct amount of basil so that the conjoining flavors were not overpowering. If you're in the area, I would definitely recommend it! read more

Concerning the pizza... Crust and cheese are good. Sauce is not my style. I'd say average overall. Portions are weak. Menu says medium serves two. I got the medium and, unless two 6 year olds are eating the pizza, it does not serve two. I'd hate to see what the small looks like. read more

Cromwell Pizza & Pasta - Italian Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

A pathetically tasteless undercooked experience do not patronize. The takeout was cold, undercooked under seasoned, and we ordered three toppings on half the pizza and got them on 3/8 of a pizza total rip off. read more

What happened to the pasta fagioli? Used to be the best in town, I would go out of my way for a quart or two regularly. But now it's flavorless, the color & consistency are off and it's rarely hot. Used to be served with a couple pieces of bread for dunking, now there is no bread and the soup is lukewarm. Was my go-to for a long time, I don't think I will ever order it again. Disappointed but hopeful the old recipe will return. read more

What a great meal! From start to finish, I was thoroughly impressed. We got off to a shaky start, when we weren't seated right away. We stood at the hostess station for about five minutes. When I realized there were only two waitresses, I relaxed a little. One of the women greeted us, and we told her that we preferred to eat outside. We grabbed a corner table, closer to the road. We were promptly brought a basket of bread & butter, our silverware and napkins. Drinks were ordered and delivered within minutes. There is a children's menu, but we decided to order a side of meatballs for my son. My husband and I shared and Antipasto salad and the Caboose pizza. The salad was large and had crispy lettuce, salty prosciutto, firm roasted red peppers, delicious Kalamata olives (I normally hate this variety), black olives, artichoke hearts, mozzarella, shreds of carrot, tomatoes and cucumber. We chose the lemon vinaigrette, which complemented it perfectly. It is now my favorite salad! My three year old son, who doesn't normally eat a lot of meat, devoured almost an entire meatball (about 3" in diameter). Of course I had to try it for myself. The texture and density were perfect. There was a slight cheese flavor, but it wasn't overpowering. It was also cooked just right, not too greasy. I'll definitely be ordering a side the next time we visit. Our pizza was served piping hot. It was the picture of beauty, covered in; chicken, bacon, red onion and BBQ sauce. The sauce was a little sweet for me, but a sprinkle of pepper remedied that. I savored the pizza, but couldn't wait to get to the crust. Slightly burnt and crunchy, just the way I like it. I'm slightly regretting it now (son is wide awake), but we couldn't leave without trying the cannoli. We ordered two, one for my husband and the other for my me and my son to share. They were served on one dish and plated beautifully. The filling was a little looser and smoother than I am used to, but it tasted awesome! I may be wrong, but I think that I might've picked up on a little lemon flavor. The shell was fresh and crunchy. I couldn't have been more excited, when I found out that they deliver to Middletown! read more

See all

Delicious pizza! The crust and sauce are fantastic. My favorite is the Sophia Loren. Highly recommend this place!

This was my first takeout experience and it is now my new favorite pizza place in the area. I ordered a small garden salad and it was a huge portion, very fresh and the house dressing which is a creamy balsamic is delicious. They also threw in a couple rolls. The pepperoni sausage pizza was thin, crisp and cooked to perfection. The buffalo wings were crispy and everything just tasted super fresh! When I arrived, although getting takeout, there was outside seating with live music. This is a quaint little place that's definitely worth visiting! read more

See all

First time visit. Other than the very loud teenage birthday party (9-10 teenage girls), the place was great. The garlic knots were amazing as was the pizza. Server (Mimi) could've been a little friendlier but she was efficient. The little girl customer who was in there (possibly Leela Grace) was cute but she kept bothering her mom (a waitress) while she was trying to wait on guests. She also kept interrupting our server (who may have been her grandmother "Mimi"). The little girl was sitting with her dad but she wouldn't listen to him....kept getting up, running around, interrupting her mom and grandma while they worked. She threw a tantrum once when she got in trouble for something and then threw a piece of pizza on the floor. I get it, it's a small town, family-owned place but a 3-4 year-old running around bothering other customers isn't cute! read more

Cromwell Pizza & Pasta - Garlic knots - Italian Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

See all

Sub par grinder and Greek salad if you want to call it that. Very disappointing and now I won't go back even though it's the closest pizza place read more

Veal parm. It came back quick and so good, so good. Mushroom and pepperoni pizza is as good as it gets anywhere including Wooster Street. Katie the bomb as usual. Pizza thin crusted and absolutely perfect. Just ordered the chicken cacciatore with the gnocchi. Blew me away. And Courtney being there a little over four months was awesome delivery was the bomb! read more

Great pizza! And the delivery was easy they came right to the door on time and were super nice

We've been trying many different pizza places trying to find one we like. Well our search can finally stop. We found it. We ordered a large all mozzarella with eggplant on one half and bacon, pepperoni and sausage on the other half. It was delicious! The crust is thin and not over cooked and the toppings were plentiful. We don't like a ton of sauce on our pizza and this was just right, not to mention quite tasty. My husband and I were both very pleased. The only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 is because it arrived warm, not hot. The driver was given the wrong address. This was our first time ordering so I won't really hold that against them. We will order again. I'm sure they will learn our address and th be an issue going forward. Need to update...we ordered again this week. The order arrived right on time and food was hot. We had Pasta Fagioli, chicken wings and a pizza with all mozzarella, sausage and bacon...one half had pepperoni and the other half had meatball. Everything was delicious. I'm so happy we found a place near us to irde Another update 02/14/2020 - I just can't say enough how much we love this place. The food is always delicious. We ordered twice from them this week. On 02/11 we ordered a pepperoni and bacon pizza, garlic knots and a version of their Spaghetti Connecticut River. I asked them to change the spaghetti to fettuccine and the marinara to garlic and oil. They had no issue making those changes. OMG!!! I am so glad they did. Out of this world delicious. Then today we wanted to order out and, of course, this is the first place we thought of. We had their Buffalo wings which are amazing. We love that they put the sauce in the side. Also had their pasta Fagioli which I've already raves about. We had an eggplant parmigiana grinder. I have trouble finding eggplant I like because I like it cut very thin and not drowning in sauce. Just enough to know it's there. Well, let me tell ya, this was amazing. Soooo delicious. I am hard-presses to find a food item we don't like. This has become our "Go to" place. Never disappointed in the food. Sometimes the delivery takes longer than they tell me. It annoys us because then the food is cold. This is consistently the only issue we have. But the food is so good I can't let that stand in the way. I just wish that was dialed in as nicely as the food. But do yourself a favor and give them a call. You won't be disappointed in the food. read more

See all

My usual go to place for tasty pizza. Great staff. Best fresh made chicken tenders around. Good steak subs.

Stopped by here for lunch on a Monday. Takeout. My father got a hot ham and cheese and myself the Italian combo. Took these to visit my grandmother. We had a nice lunch together and Cromwell grinder got to help me bring it together. read more

Cromwell Pizza & Pasta - Italian Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

Delicious calzone, salad and gluten-free pizza! Service was friendly and when we ordered delivery it was fresh and prompt. Would definitely order again! read more

Best Pizza in Cromwell, quickly with delivery (typically comes before the estimated delivery time), friendly and clean! Can't wait for my next pizza urge!! read more

My first two experiences were just okay, but I gave this a third try to be sure. I ordered and paid for (delivery) pizza two hours ago; it was charged to the card, it didn't come, and no one answers at the restaurant because they closed 20 minutes ago. Order for convenience and hope for the best I guess. read more

Located in the heart of Cromwell, on Main Street, this little gem is a must try. They offer great pizza and pasta. We were greeted by a friendly staff member. We ordered the spaghetti/meat balls and the baked gnocchi. Both had great flavors and tasted delicious. The side salads were well portioned. They have both inside and outside dining. Also Friday night's they have live music. Don't forget they offer BYOB. The local Clippers Magazine has a variety of coupons, but if you forget your coupon don't worry their prices are reasonable. Highly RECOMMEND Cromwell Pizza and Pasta!! read more

Enjoyed this local spot. Stopped in late on a Friday night and there was only one other couple but I think that this is more of a family spot. Chicken Parmesan came with two pieces - one was really tender, one was a little tough so we would definitively order again to see what the norm is. I ordered something "arrabiatta" and was surprised that it didn't come out with a red sauce - it came with a wine sauce that was jazzed up. No problem with that but I thought it was worth mentioning for others since I've never seen that before. Some Dinners come with EITHER salad or pasta so I would suggest pasta and then ordering a large salad for multiple people to share - seems it would be the better deal. Also - house bread is yummy so don't pass up. BYOB read more

Cromwell Pizza & Pasta - Salad that comes with some entrees - Italian Near Me - Cromwell, Connecticut

The food is delicious here. Only one time they burned the garlic knots but i didn't care because everything is so good. Besides the garlic knots, we ordered the vegetable pizza. They have the best pizza dough around - it is on the par with Brooklyn, NY pizza - which says a lot! The only negative i can think of it they don't cut the veggies smaller. The kitchen prep people could just be busy but it's one thing i think they can improve on. The same for the salad, the tomatoes are huge, and other items in the salad as well - too big, lol. But it's really a minor flaw considering how yummy everything on the menu is. And their desserts are excellent too. Service is fast and if you order on the phone they are always so friendly. Great place! read more