The BEST Italian sub! Just had the "Special" again. Yumm! Loaded with freshly cut everything! Absolutely delicious. And delicious on day 2, as well (got the large ). Of course excellent pizza, as well. Love this place! read more

This place sells very good pizza. Very nice guys. Good food. All support the locals especially Italian owned pizzeria . Pride and tradition is a beautiful thing. read more

Newton Pizza - Newton pizza really impressive. - Pizza Near Me - Newton, New Jersey

Came up to buy something from Marketplace and not familiar with the area, But past reviews urged my intuition and the review from 13 days ago really sold me. First, the place is spotless Clean! Impressive, it smells like my Dad's pizzeria, the faint smell of Dough rising and clean counters From the moment that I bit into the crust of their Plain Slice, I Could Tell. My Dad had his own pizza place many moons ago and I'm sort of "picky" with how the crust and the sauce Melds into one another. The crust is almost Buttery and airy where you're in heaven for a Brief second as you bite in and Close your eyes to Savor the moment. We ordered a regular cheesesteak hoagie fried onions, lettuce, tomato and pepperoncini on the Side! Also, an order of pizza fries, light in the sauce! This meal totally Hit the Spot! My Mom took the road trip with me and Trust me.... She is Picky but also gives her Honest opinion. She is My Treasure and I value her input. Especially when it comes to Food. Lol. When we arrived at the counter, practically everyone greeted us and was Super nice. The food is delicious and we Left happy and with Full Bellies! Definitely MUST come back and try more items on their menu! Ciao for Now! read more

See all

This has to be the worst pizza I've ever had. Doughy the cheese tasteless. Not sure what those other folks were eating and reviewed but it wasn't what I had. Just can't get Brooklyn style pizza in Newton. Not likely to return. Sorry wish I could share with you what I had just had, it was disgusting. No other way to describe it.. sorry Newton pizza. read more

I've been going here since I was a little kid when they were in their old location. Best hoagie in the area - great pizza. Love it!

Best ingredients, great service. Always consistent. This is THE PLACE for good Italian. read more

Best pizza in town! Classic, fresh and if you leave hungry it is your own fault! Generous options and very friendly staff. Family friendly unlike others around read more

Just stumbled upon this restaurant on my way back to Pennsylvania. Thought it was going to be a regular pizzeria, turned out to be a nice restaurant. I enjoyed the pizza, better than any I've had in the Poconos. Nice waiters , nice place , nice variety on the menu . If I'm in the area I would stop by again . read more

Best pizza in Sussex County . Pizza crust is the best around ! Never disappoints, always great !

Deliciousness - 2/5 Happiness - 4/5 The staff here is very nice and welcoming. We enjoyed hearing them talk to locals by first name and they were very attentive in re-fills of our drinks and boxing up our leftovers to go. But the pizza just wasn't all that good. We ordered a pizza with eggplant, chicken and peppers. While I liked that there was a mountain of toppings on it, they simply lacked flavor. Every topping tasted exactly the same. And the cheese also overwhelmed everything. It's not something I say often, but the pizza definitely could've used more grease. The cheese was so overpowering that it needed something, anything to cut the flavor. The crust, however, was excellent. It held together and was nice and crispy. read more

Good local pizza. We were able to sit at the one table they had. The owner is very accommodating and will make the pizza anyway you like including thick, thin, well-done, etc.. read more

I have been eating at this place since I was little. I haven't been to the new spot yet but I am sure it's just as great as the last. Their menu is your typical pizzeria and super simple. Easy to just pop in with friends or even children to grab a quick slice of pizza to eat. Hands down this place has the absolute best subs, best baked ziti and best pizza in the area by far. Friendly people work there who always remember you when you walk in which creates a nice environment. Their tomato sauce is to so sweet which makes anything with sauce on it great. The prices are extremely decent for the amount of food you get and every time I have gone their my order was exactly as ordered. Only downside is there is no delivery but it's worth the drive for sure. Will continue eating here for many more years to come! read more

Not my favorite pizza in town, but been around for a long time. Everyone has different tastes in pizza and Italian. Try it, you may like it but it's not my #1 read more

We're just in town for a few days and googled restaurants and Newton Pizza popped up and I am SO GLAD that it did. We're from the DC area and I've never had such wonderful service. Miss Denise was so good with my 2 year old. We felt so cared for and a part of a family! Like, where else do you feel like that for a 15 minute meal?? On top of that, the pizza is EXCELLENT. The bottom is nice and crisp (no soggy bottoms here!) and the toppings are fresh, bright and so so good. You would be doing yourself a disservice if you did not stop by Newton Pizza. What are you waiting for? Go! read more

Good food, but terrible Covid precautions. Everyone wears a mask EXCEPT the person making the pizza uses the mask as a chin diaper. When asked why the person handling the food didn't have his mask over his nose and mouth, I was told he doesn't wear it up because he opens the hot oven... he wasn't in front of the oven - he was making a pizza. Not worth the risk. read more

When I am In the mood for pizza locally, this is my go to spot. The pizza is never overcooked or undercooked. The sauce to cheese to dough ratios are perfect and the recipe works. The quality of ingredients are high, and you can tell that ownership has been making pizza for a long time. Not only has he mastered his craft, but all his employees have been trained properly as well. But pizza is not the only thing he does well here. His chicken parmigiana sandwich is spot on, his salads are generous and always fresh! The place is always clean, the staff are super friendly and polite, and prices are more than fair! Been coming to Newton pizza for a long time and I love their food! read more

The best pizza I've found in Sussex County since 1996. The staff is super nice and personable. YUMMMM read more

I was in the area and told that this is a great pizza place -for sure it is! I got a cheese pizza, and it was some of the best classic pizza I have ever had. The prices were so reasonable for good quality pizza, about $12 for a normal sized cheese pizza. The tomato sauce and cheese were on par, and the dough was so tasty -none of that thick or super thin crust pizza. It was soft and doughy and delicious. They have a few tables inside for dining in, but it seems like most people order take out. When you're at the cash register, you can see them making the pizza behind the counter. I saw my pizza come straight out of the oven and into the box -hot and fresh out of the oven! Newton Pizza is a local and family-owned place where the staff know their frequent customers by name. Their menu seemed pretty extensive; besides pizza, they also have subs, pasta, and other Italian dishes. There is a small town, friendly feel of the atmosphere here. Definitely recommend stopping by here for pizza if you are ever passing by! read more

Newton Pizza - Classic cheese pizza fresh out of the oven! - Pizza Near Me - Newton, New Jersey

This place is consistently good. The staff is great. This is a go to pizza place if you are in the Newton area.

Cowabunga, dude!! Newton Pizza is the best 'za in town (i.e. best in a 25-minute radius). They do a mean onion pie, and a meaner classic. I don't like to use the word "plain" because it's a disservice. Classic. Newton Pizza is a cozy little place with ample parking and friendly owners/staff. Really enjoy the taste of their sauce. Some pizza places add sugar, which I do not think tastes good at all. Runners up are A&G Pizza and Villa Capri. read more

Really is the best pizza in Newton! And the wings are fantastic!! as well as the sandwiches

Great pizza. Real polite staff. They don't deliver, but it's cool since the food is worth the trip. Didn't go there much at the old location. New location is smaller, but much more pleasant. Brighter. read more

Newton Pizza is under new management. Because I have loved this pizzeria for a long time (and it's close to my house), I have been back a few times, and will probably give it a least a couple more tries. However, it looks suspiciously like the magic is gone. There's nothing wrong with Newton Pizza nowadays. It's perfectly serviceable pizzeria, and the new folks running the place seem perfectly nice. But the crusts are a little thicker and a little tougher, and the pies just don't bring the same magic to your mouth. read more

Gotta love a nice ol cheese pizza with bacon on top. Man is it nice to have a place that's good so close.

Very under estimated pizza shop in that it have very few selections and a small shop, however their food is awesome especially the sausage and paper parmigiana sandwich! Very pleasant staff, too. read more

Best local pizza joint ever. Been coming to this place since I was a kid. Family owned and operated.

Newton pizza has got to be the best pizza in Not only Newton but possibly all of Sussex county. The people behind the counter of this establishment have pride in their food and their store. Much of the kitchen is within view when you step up to the counter, and it is always spotless. That always resonates with me. I don't live in Newton but will go the extra 5 mins to actually enjoy my dinner. Keep up the great work. read more

Today i went to newton pizza for a quick impromptu lunch between jobs. I don't know the area but I wanted a quick grilled chicken salad. The owner was super nice. Explained what they put on their salads, and added extra red peppers and green and Black olives and shredded mozzarella cheese , just like I asked for. When I requested bread , I got an entire large roll , sliced , with butter squares , too. All this for $10. Amazing in these times. It was a huge salad. And absolutely delicious. I ate outside on a cute little table and chairs And they even brought me extra tomatos. This is a really nice place !!! Thanks for my relaxing lunch on this beautiful August day !!! read more

In Newton for a show at the theater. Read the rave reviews and decided to try them out. My wife and I opted for a couple slices of their belly buster pizza and a Pepperoni roll. Pizza was top notch and watched as the pick up pizza was flying out the door. Pepperoni roll was amazing stuffed to the gills with Mozz and Pepperoni and a lovely red sauce. While eating. We were able to watch them create the most amazing looking Italian. Sub. I told my wife there was no way I could walk away from a sub like that.So I ordered one to go.They individually sliced the meat and cheese for each one. Best thing is, I'm from Maryland . The young lady remembered me calling to inquire and said she was expecting me. Could not have been friendlier. Hey folks. Its a couple minute walk from the theater and you pass a bunch of places you pass to eat. Its worth the walk! PS. They have plenty parking too :) read more

Very friendly people and awesome pizza!!!!!!! I will definitely be back next time I'm in town and look forward to it!! Great sauce, high quality cheese and toppings!! read more

Every time I go there the food is excellent ! No matter if is a slice of pizza ,assortment of pies , appetizers or dinners. Fast and friendly service. The place is super clean and inviting. read more

This is hands down the best pizza ever. I make it a point eat here as often as possible whenever I'm in town. Great people service and the food is absolutely amazing. read more

The best pizza in town hands down and the subs are insanely big. Haven't tried the dinners but with pizza and subs like that I can only imagine they are also delicious read more

All the food is amazing but I travel from NYC just for the subs!!! Amazing!! Great and friendly service.

Okay...So I'm extremely passionate about pizza and let me tell you...Newton Pizza is AWESOME! The crust was perfect, not too soft not too crunchy. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio. I would definitely recommend giving Newton Pizza a try! Oh! And the service was unbelievable...so accommodating. 10 out of 10 would go back every time. read more

Mom & pop pizza joint. Pizza is great. been here a couple times and tried a bunch of different pies and all were good. Crust was thin and crisp, sauce is simple. Friendly workers. I did t try a hoagie yet but I saw one being made that looked thick. Gonna try one next time. read more

Great pizza and quick pick up service! I'm a huge fan of buffalo chicken pizza, especially when it's done right and Newton Pizza does it right! ( in my opinion) I live 35 minutes away or I would order from them more often but every time I am passing through the area I always call an order in. There is not many places in Sussex County that has good quality pizza, but this place def does! Two thumbs up to Newton Pizza! read more

first time me and my son went there for dinner. The service was awesome and the food was great IT was the first time my calzone was made perfect everywhere I went I had to always tell them to put it back in because it was doughy . def coming back read more

Best pizza in Newton and in Northwestern New Jersey! Family owned, longtime presence in the town and great friend to the community. I've been going here all my life, there's no one better in the area. read more

The pizza was delicious! To be honest, a star should be knocked off because we ordered a mushroom pie, and the mushrooms were pickled. That's a huge no-no for pizza. If you don't have fresh mushrooms, don't offer mushrooms as a topping. The pickling gives the pizza an off flavor, but even with that, it was delicious. They redeemed themselves with the calzone. It's the best calzone we've tried since moving to New Jersey. When we picked up the food, I noticed that the restaurant is super CLEAN. This is so important to me. A woman was cleaning up the place the whole time while we waited, even though it already looked clean and tidy. It was an off hour, so the place was empty and she wasn't getting in the way. It's a cozy, local joint, so I imagine it's nice to eat in, too. Also, it's family owned. I got the impression that everyone working there was part of the family, so they really care about their food and service. They were very friendly. If we lived closer, we would be regulars. I highly recommend this place!!:) read more