So disappointed after a reading recent great review! The Roast Beef Panini was served lukewarm with congealed cheese and very dry, missing the horseradish cream (stated in the menu). When I requested the cream the waitress returned 10 minutes later to inform me they didn't have any, they were out. Seriously?! It was dry, concealed and inedible. I ordered the Seafood Penne Vodka, they apparently don't use Vodka or red pepper, neither could be tasted in the "Vodka" Sauce. My friend also complained the Vodka Sauce was extremely bland. read more

I have been wanting to come to this place ever since I moved to Newton when my neighbor told me this is the spot to visit if you want dine in pizza. Finally paid a visit after some family members stayed over for the weekend. Stopped by around 2pm on Saturday. Once we entered we were greeted and seated promptly. The place had a lot of natural light and did not have music playing in the background. Started off with complimentary breadsticks (free), fried calamari ($13.95) and jalapeño poppers ($8.95) which were both solid. For our main we got the Dominick's special ($19.95) which is a supreme pie and was good and filling. We also got the margherita pizza pie ($17.95) which seemed like a regular pie sprinkled with shredded basil leaves, solid but def not the margherita pizza I was expecting (check out pic and determine for yourself). Overall it was a good experience. Solid food and reasonable pricing. * Parking lot on premise * Good service * Credit card fee: 3.25% read more

See all

Great place always clean prices aren't insane i enjoy the meatlovers so delicious and good customer service

Excellent variety of food and I've never ordered something I didn't love. Cozy dining room and service that makes you feel right at home. I go there often and always love it. Plus...some of the best pizza in the area! read more

Went here for dinner. Service was fast. Our server Morgan was very friendly and personable. Ordered Drunken seafood in vodka sauce with penne . Also Drunken stuffed eggplant with vodka sauce. Portions are nice size and prices reasonable. Food was very good. Excellent service, prices and food. Will be back when in the area. read more

See all

Enjoyed dinner w/2 other couples. This is a BYO w/an inviting dining room. Waitress promptly opened our wine & brought us waters & bread to start. Two couples ordered a large Caesar to share - it was very good although the croutons were extremely large so we just pushed them away. One person's eggplant rollatini was supposed to come with a starter salad but that never showed up. Two couples ordered pizza - Grandma's pie & Brooklyn. We liked the Brooklyn better due to it being more thin crust. Grandma's was very good but more "bready" for our liking. The eggplant rollatini came out which was excellent & waitress had thought the salad for that meal had come out so she brought it with the dinner; hence the 1 star off the review. One other person got a large house salad & liked it. All in all we really liked our meals & the price! Parking was OK; a little tight but we managed to find spots. Would go back again for sure! read more

See all

Great food and service! Everyone in our party enjoyed the food and experience. Tasty casual spot.

Food service and ambiance is outstanding the owners Pete and Sal couldn't be more accommodating it's aa perfect choice for dates or to meet friends read more

Sunday night dinner at Dominick's what treat! Excellent staff, although they were very busy. Our party of three was seated in a reasonable amount of time. Food was great, we tried the chicken marsalla. Scallops and shrimp with spinach and a personal size pizza. Plenty left over for dinner tomorrow night. Also, plenty of off the street parking. Anxious to try other items on the menu, they also offer gluten free dishes. read more

See all

My wife and I had our child's birthday party catered by Dominick's. Being that it was our first time hosting such a big event, we weren't quite sure how much food to order. Both Pete and Sal couldn't have been more helpful in guiding us on what to order and how much of each item would suffice a party of our size. They were super friendly, patient, and knowledgeable. We received calls from guests raving about how good every thing came out even days after the party. The delivery was on time and the food was ready to be served upon arrival. I would highly recommend anyone looking to cater a party to give these guys a call! read more

Thanks to Dominick's, I threw a nice surprise 60th birthday party for my sister today for 50 people! Sal was awesome and helped me pick out pizza types that folks just loved. Nice salad too. Price was reasonable. Sal is a kind man and really took all the stress out of throwing a surprise birthday party (in Newton NJ from Hawai'i)! I can't thank Sal and his team enough - good people! Much aloha to all of you! read more

The best pizza my family has had in a long while. I work in Wayne, NJ and live in Bushkill, Pa. I go out of my way to pick up pies for my family on my way home. Originally from NYC. This is some good pizza., read more

Pizza was phenomenal and huge! The atmosphere is very pleasant and the server we had was awesome! Great place to eat, prices are reasonable for the serving size! Highly recommend, New Jersey has some of the best pizza around! read more

Excellent food. Great service. Never disappointed with anything. We order frequently from the hospital and always great.

I ordered a turkey sandwich, mostly bread and lettuce, little turkey. NO french fries or something to go with it. My friend ordered a wrap served with some potatoes chips, which were awful. The waitress had an attitude like she didn't want to be there. Didn't give any alternatives for bread, something different then the roll, No thank you or smile. Just grabbed the menus and left. The busboy was good, maybe he should be the server. read more

This is our favorite place for authentic Italian cuisine. My boyfriend and I come here a few times a month, and always have excellent service and get treated like we're family. We love everything we have tried here. Of course, their pizza is amazing, but our other favorites include: baked ziti, chicken Parmesan, and make your own pasta dishes. I have created my own pasta dish that they always make just right: angel hair pasta with fresh diced tomatoes and a garlic/butter sauce. For dessert, I always get the limoncello flute (which is not on the menu--so you have to ask for it), which is nice and light. Also, Dominick's is a BYOB, so don't forget to bring your favorite bottle. Kudos to the amazing service from Meagan tonight, she was a rockstar and was there any time we needed anything. We will be back again and again!! read more

See all

Order here EVERY WEEK! Their food is so tasty and fresh! Excellent service and quick! Nice ambiance to go out on a Friday night! Salads are delicious btw! read more

We go to this restaurant every year when we are in town from California. The food is excellent! The staff is efficient, courteous and knowledgeable about the the various dishes. (They have so much more than just pizza!) We have never had anything but excellent service & delicious food in all the times we have come. We highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a great meal at a reasonable price and excellent customer service! read more

Great food and the staff is always accommodating. Byob perfect for dinner. Eat in or take out.

Best pizza in Newton and the other Italian food is wonderful as well! Family oriented and delicious!

Fantastic service. Excellent food. We go there often for take out and eat in. The grilled shrimp salad is awesome. Creamy balsamic dressing is home made and so good. Chicken areabiata so good. read more

Amazing pizza and great service. I Dec omens going before 6pm, it'll be packed by then.

Moved here from San Francisco and the restaurant was highly recommend. Ordered a pizza half cheese half meatball along with a Caesar salad to be delivered. What a disappointment. Nothing like what an east coast pizza should be. The salad was just lettuce and croutons, not as described on the menu. read more

Good spot for consistently solid meals. The pizza / calzones / garlic knots are always great, and my family loves the penne arrabiata. Their sandwiches are good too, and I've really enjoyed the chipotle chicken one they have. They recently changed the type of Cesar dressing they use, and I will be honest that I'm a bit disappointed! The new dressing just isn't as good, but previously, I used to love the chicken Cesar wraps. read more

Had a chicken parmigiana sandwich and a personal size margherita pie. Both excellent. Service was great. Prices are very reasonable. read more

See all

Current 3 stars is vastly under-rating this busy, family friendly, warm-hearted Italian restaurant. It's also a pizzeria. My wife and I and my teenage daughter were promptly seated and quickly given drinks. Warm delicious tomato garlic bread was put on the table while we considered our options. I'd been out of state for 2 weeks and wanted some NJ Italian. Veal Saltimbocca for me, eggplant rollatini with penne vodka for the missus and a cheese pizza for the girl ( she's easy to please). Perfectly cooked spinach under tender veal with a perfectly tasty gravy. The spouse gave the thumbs up to eggplant and the girl rated her pizza 5/5. Total bill was very reasonable especially as the main dishes came with a salad. The Caesar dressing was top notch. Lots of people were also doing takeout so that's another option if you want your Italian "a casa" read more

My family and I go to Dominicks a dozen or more times a summer as we have a summer lake house in the area. We are from NYC and are pretty picky about pizza let alone Italian food. We really love the Dominicks. We haven't really explored the menu but the pizza is a GREAT rustic crust pizza with nicely seasoned sauce and the topping have always been very fresh. We have their heroes frequently - chicken, veal, meatball and eggplant - and have found them to be consistently be top quality with plenty of cheese and meat (or eggplant). Also their stromboli is to die for. We have had a couple of the pasta dishes and found them to be better than normal NY pizza place quality. In reference to other reviews - In all the times there we have never experience any issue with the staff or owner (Sal). Several years ago when we had just discovered them, we spent a half hour talking with the crew about the Newton area and all the changes and felt very comfortable there and we have become regulars. We have just been there twice in the last week during the Corona crisis and found them hard working, gracious and accommodating (even after having called back to change the order 15 minutes after we called it in). This is especially notable considering they are doing curbside pickup with a parking lot full of people who usually would be eating in the restaurant. All in all I highly recommend Dominicks to anyone looking for a ready comfort food meal. PS THERE CANNOLIS ARE EXCELLENT. Always fresh filled crispy cookie with rich filling. read more

If you are looking for fantastic Italian food then don't miss Dominicks. Always fresh, hot and delicious. It doesn't matter whether it's lunch or dinner from sandwiches, pizza or full entrees this place is right on point. Never disappointed. Pete and Sal do it right! read more

Outstanding food. I have been there quite a few times and have ordered different things from Pizza to Panni's. Everything is outstanding. Pete, Sal and the staff are great people, very friendly and carring. read more

Great Italian restaurant. Pizza is very good and place is very big and comfortable. Lunch specials are huge and reasonably priced. Service is always great. Salads are fresh and the pasta is delicious. Super clean. Great place. read more

Best casual dining in the area!!! Bar none! It's BYOB which in my opinion means better food! Great personal service (Margo is the best) The fried calamari is Amazing! And then look at this impromptu birthday "cake" read more

Dominick's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Newton, New Jersey

Best chicken rolls & calzones in the county! Definitely Brooklyn style! & to my surprise, the owners are indeed from BROOKLYN!! Woohoo!! read more

Dominick's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Newton, New Jersey

Plain pizza overall: 3/5 Cheese: 4/5 Crust: 3/5 Sauce: 2/5 Buffalo pizza: 3/5 Wings: 3/5 Had something odd happen. I ordered two plain slices, one buffalo, and a bottle of water to go. Was charged for 3 gourmet slices (only one was gourmet), a water and an iced tea which I didn't even order. Owner seemed puzzled at his mistake when I brought back the receipt, but to make it easy I just grabbed an iced tea and said not to worry about the over-charge on the two plain slices. Hopefully it was just an honest mistake, but keep an eye on your receipts. read more

It's the age of stay at home so having fled NYC for my home town (and not entering stores for 3 weeks) I tried Dominick's tonight for delivery. Pizza is excellent as was the eggplant dinner. Looking forward to trying more of NJ's best dishes in the 07860 and thankful for Dominick's during this time. read more

My family wanted to pre test their food ahead of a family gathering so we ordered a takeout of some items. Fried calamari was over battered and salty. Chicken tenders were OK, fries that came with them were soft and tasted like the oil used was also used for other items. Eggplant Rolentine was more like Eggplant Parm. Eggplant was overwhelmed by sauce and mozzarella, salty. Penne, garlic broccoli w/oil overcooked (it was takeout...) salty and small for $14.70. Chicken Piccata was terrible, the liquid was almost white from the amount of flour they used to thicken, chicken was overcooked and over salted. Broccoli Rabe.. How do you screw this up? Too salty to eat! My wife and I eat out a often. I like salt, a lot. Worst meal(s) that we've had out in years! Won't be using them for catering or anything else. read more

The most AMAZING Italian food I have ever had! Order the meatballs, any parm, pizza, salads, and have to order a side of sautéed spinach! They give you amazing bread to nosh on too. We usually order delivery and the order always comes correct! Why they only have 3 stars is beyond me!! Must order!!! A+++ tomatoe sauce it isnso simple but soooooo good!!! read more

Been there several times service was ok lots of food choices But, food prep needs improvement,pizza not great other meals prepared by folks who don't understand Italian cooking. I realize this is Sussex County and some folks might not know what good Italian food should taste like no insult intended. In my opinion I would only order the Pizza. Try their food an make your own decision. read more

We had Brittany and she was incredible! The service was impeccable, the food delicious and served quickly. Everything was amazing and we cannot recommend this lovely business enough. read more

I have to say Dominicks positively slammed a very big order for delivery last night! Starting from the lovely lady who answered the phone. She was courteous,informed of the menu and accommodated every request by my hungry and somewhat picky group! Thank you for your patience on such a busy holiday prime-time night. Food arrived HOT with perfectly prepared salads,delicious entrees,and our fantastic pizza which was cooked to our preference.All was fresh and so good. The broiled flounder with spinach was a little on the garlicky side,but good.Excellent bread too!!! I haven't eaten so much without a tummy ache for a long time-no greasy food here.Fresh,clean,excellent value. My compliments to all involved at the restaurant.Delivery person was a doll too,thank you. Mrs.A. read more

My in laws orders from here often, they always get this tray of focaccia bread and it's the best damn bread.