I thought long and hard about taking a star away and how to explain my reasoning. We've enjoyed meals and service here, both in-house and takeout, on numerous occasions and we've always walked away feeling it was a five star experience. But on this occasion the walk away feeling was that the meal and experience did not seem exceptional.
Reservations were made a week ahead of time to ensure that we would leave in time to attend an event in Saratoga. The suggested time we were given was perfect (keep the 5).
We were seated in the "new room" and when my wife felt a very cold draft coming from an air vent behind her chair, our server was quick to provide a cover for the vent. Obviously, a problem they've dealt with before (keep the 5).
Along with the menus we were promptly served an amuse-bouche of cucumber and sesame seed, and some house-made herbed focaccia with a white bean spread. Both were excellent (keep the 5).
The draft beer selection was a nice cross section of a handful of styles, not dominated by IPAs, from mostly smaller NY breweries (keep the 5). I chose to try for the first time a beer from Schilling Beer Co. in Littleton NH, Alexandr Pilsner ($8). It was clean, refreshing, and light flavored.
Upon hearing the daily specials from our server, we chose to share the Braised Calamari ($19) as an appetizer and my wife ordered the Pan Roasted Halibut ($46). I stayed with the regular menu and selected The Best Fried Chicken ($34).
The Braised Calamari was outstanding (keep the 5). The non-breaded squid was perfectly cooked with pozole verde, zucchini, avocado, crispy tortilla strips, and cilantro. And I got to enjoy all the heads.
The Pan Roasted Halibut was beautifully plated with smoked corn cream, fingerling potatoes, chorizo, roasted fennel, a piquillo vinaigrette, and fresh cilantro. The halibut may have been just the slightest bit overcooked, but was still moist, and the flavors of the other ingredients seemed somewhat disjointed. The Spanish style chorizo slices seemed too large for their flavor and texture to be melded with the other ingredients (not a 5 dish).
It's been a long time since I've had fried chicken. Maybe I'm not being fair; maybe I don't expect a comfort dish to be outstanding. But I did enjoy it and it satisfied that craving I had. The chicken was lightly breaded and the meat from a wing, a thigh, and breast was supper moist. The apple butter was tasty on both the buttermilk biscuit and the chicken, the bacon braised greens were flavorful, and the pimiento mac & cheese were a reasonable alternative to the normal ooey-gooey variety served elsewhere (I just don't see it as a 5 dish).
Finally, service was excellent. Young staff assigned to refill water glasses and buss the tables remained unobtrusive throughout dinner but presented themselves professionally at the appropriate times (keep the 5). The only distraction was the friendly bartender, who in conversation with a couple dining at the bar, spoke so loudly that he almost overpowered the excellent background music being piped in (drop the 5).
Can't give a 4.5, so it gets rounded up. Looking forward to another 5 in the original dining room on our next visit. read more