Let's just say I have been going here since I can remember... 25-30 years. Food is the same (excellent), service is the same (great people), personally my favourite pizza, and has the best bang for your buck! It is great knowing you can go here and get a good meal! We also always use Nickey's for youth sports pizza parties etc! Thanks Nickey's for the great food! read more

This is the best pizza in town. We moved away about 7 years ago and I have been searching for a pie as good ever since . We were in Lynn last week and stopped by for a few pies and it was just as good as I remember.The crust is crisp on the bottom with a great chew, the sauce is amazing with just the right amount of cheese. The pepperoni pizza from Nick's is one of my all time favorites. The pepperoni crisps up and the pie melting in your mouth. read more

This is the best pizza we have had for a long time. We ordered a cheese and a pepperoni. Both were cooked to perfection. The people working there were so nice. This is definitely our new pizza place. read more

Best subs and pizza in the city of Lynn! You can't go wrong with the meatball, the chicken cutlet, or the turkey sub. I love the pizza too!

Classic New England pizza and sub shop run by the same Greek family for only God knows how long. They serve thin crust pizza and good subs. No frills and no credit cards. Worth the ATM fee you pay from the machine right inside the front door. read more

Discovered Nickey's the day we moved to Lynn, and haven't been able to try any other pizza. For $12 bucks or so you can get a fantastic thin crust pizza, with great sauce and three toppings. The place just smells so great when you walk in - you know you are in for a real treat! Only down side is that they are cash only - but it is more than worth the trip to the ATM! read more

Amazing pizza. Low prices. Every time I'm in Lynn I make sure to stop by and get a pizza.

My favorite place in the city to get pizza, I try to get it at least once every three months with my family. We get pepperoni and sausage pizzas, chicken fingers, and fries and it does the trick. It's the only pizza I could literally keep eating even when I am full (probably a problem, but whatever). Highly recommend if you like pizza, only downside is no delivery. read more

Best sub shop in or around Boston. Hands down. I don't think their prices have changed in 15 years. $5.25 for a large steak bomb? C'mon.

Been going there is since 1977. Great Pizza, Great Sandwiches and Great Family run business. Nickey is a long time friend and well known in Lynn, Peabody and the North Shore. The Large Pizza, only nine bucks, is truly large (not like the other places that call a 14 inch pizza large). The small cheese, just six bucks, is the size of most other places large. His Steak fries are the best and they now have an ATM Machine inside for people that travel without cash. Tell them Gary Leavitt sent you. read more

Nicky's makes a great thin crust pizza. Just a normal pizza pie. Decent prices on the pizzas and yes the pepperoni is intense. Have not had the subs yet, but soon will. read more

My only complaint about Nickey's is that they only take cash. Otherwise, for good, basic pizza, they're about as good as it gets. Try the double dough. You won't be disappointed. read more

Nickey's is absolutely fantastic. The prices are cheap but the food is absolutely amazing. Absolutely come here if you're in the area.

I'll drive 8 miles through traffic to get a Nickey's Pizza. The Best !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The homemade Chicken Fingers are OMG awesome, and the subs are top notch. The owner and the staff are wonderful . What more can you ask for ? read more

This place is 100% a hidden gem. I can't believe I've never been to or heard of this place before today. Their prices are unbelievably cheap and their food is delicious. I got the steak bomb w a small fry and was not disappointed. The only thing is that they only take cash but they do have an atm. read more

Best pizza in Lynn by far, especially in the Lynnfield street/Wyoma area, cute family owned place, people in there are always super nice and very very rarely is there a mistake on an order. read more

How have I been living in Lynn for 6 years and totally missed this place?! Excellent food! Steak and cheese sub was cheesy and flavorful! Pizza is great. My husband got an Italian sub and loved it. The only down fall is they don't accept credit cards, but there is an ATM. read more

Nickeys has been around for years. I live on the street it's on and have ordered from there i would say hundreds of times. Great prices pizza is awesume. And if you veal cutlet subs they use real veal not the patties. read more

Give me a double dough pizza some steak fries well done and a veal parm sub and I'll spend my whole weekend loving life on my couch. But seriously the food is fantastic read more

best pizza in the area. thin crust, nice sauce, perfect. they make a mean steak and egg sub as well as a veal cutlet sub that is the real hidden jewel here. read more

Visited this family run pizza place when my family was staying in town for my grandmas funeral. My dad grew join Lynn and raved about this small pizza place. Although from the outside it looks really small but once you enter the place your thoughts change completely. The people/owners are so friendly and the smells are even better. We watched them make the pizza right in front of us, homemade deliciousness. When we got back to the hotel we dug right in. The pizza was delicious! Great crust and sauce and the price made it an even sweeter deal. My dad got the veal cutlet sub which was to die for. We definitely will revisit this small town restaurant again when we come back, hopefully next time on better circumstances. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Lynn!!! The dough has such a great flavor and mixed with their incredible sauce and generous amounts of cheese it's such a great pizza!! read more

Oh man Nicky's Pizza, the best Pizza and Subs in the city. The veal cutlet here is without equal. Keep on doin what your doin Nicky and wife because this place is just as good now as it was when i was only 5 years old. read more

recently found nickeys, best old style subs a+, the way subs used to be when i was a kid. i golf nearby at gannon and now have a sub after. so far italian, meatball and veal subs all great! i plan to try them all in coming weeks. i took a pizza home aand thought so so, but that was after an over hour ride home. but will try it again. overall a big yum! read more

I love Nickey's Pizza. The combination of cheeses that they use on their pizzas is simply delicious! The crust is thin, more like "traditional Italian" pizza as opposed to the thick, airy crust that a lot of places use now. They make a terrific steak bomb and their french fries are the super-thick cut potato fries. YUM! Prices are always reasonable as compared to other places in the area. They're a family-owned an operated biz; multi-generational. They can handle large orders with advanced notice and offer discounts to nonprofits whenever possible. They're closed on Sundays (even God rested, right?) and they always take a week off in the summer and close shop for a vacation. No delivery, but that's ok. They're right on Lynnfield St, Rte 129, so easy to get too and parking isn't too bad on the side street or in back of their building. I've grown-up enjoying many a Nickey's pizza. Good stuff! read more