I walked by this restaurant many times and I decided to give it a try. The place has a casual atmosphere. Nice bar and dining room. The restaurant serves pizza and Italian cuisine. The service was excellent. The night we were there they had a singer singing old school Sinatra and Dean Martin classics. The food was bland. I ordered the Italian style wings and they were dry and had no taste. My gal pal ordered the stuff mushrooms. They were average. Stuff with breadcrumbs. Then we decided to order a large pizza. We topped it with garlic, onion, sausage and mushrooms. The crust was nice and thin. The center of the pizza was soft. I asked for red peppers flakes and salt. Very bland food. The place was hopping but I think the place was hopping for the singer and not the food. It was an older crowd maybe it was also a low sodium crowd. The staff were excellent. read more

See all

Service is always amazing! I have been going here for years and I can say the pricing, service, and the quality of food has never changed. Always top tier. It is a great spot to go if you like authentic Italian food. Super authentic ambiance as well. read more

Nick's - Eggplant - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

We had a great dining experience here last night..nice bar and restaurant. The chicken Francais was amazing--very tender & flavorful, broccoli rabe was perfectly cooked. Great service too! read more

One of the best pizza in Long Island, fresh basil on every pie, the service is fast and always polite. The ambience is a family oriented, restaurant, multiple groups, children, and people of all ages. Just enjoying good Italian food. Everything from their salads to their pasta to their pizzas is top notch. Great selection behind The bar. Nick is a great place for any occasion read more

Nick's - Half white and marg - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

Food is good. But the place is very understaffed. Busy Friday night and no where near enough servers. Very rushed. Please hire more people. read more

Best, most consistent pizza on Long Island! Have been going here for over 15 years and every time the quality is 10/10.

Nick's pizza...a destination. Great food, friendly staff, nice atmosphere. Sal is super-friendly, greeted us warmly, has a lovely smile (and the dimples don't hurt either ;) Will return! read more

While feeling defeated after no Italian restaurants were open around 2PM for lunch. My cousin and I decided on Nick's pizza not expecting it to be so great! What seemed like a regular pizza spot was a very nice restaurant with a great size bar. We were immediately greeted and sat. We got a bottle of Riesling which was reasonable. The bread was divine!! We then had Mozzarella and tomato as an appetizer that was okay. For dinner we got a family size Gnocchi with shrimp that was really good and enough for a large family, but again for a great price for the size of the food. read more

Nick's - Shrimp Gnocci - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Just left had to post review Delicious! Everything we had-the pie was perfect we has a regular extra sauce I sampled the rest orrechette with sausage and the tomato gnocchi perfectly seasoned huge portions! Gail our server was super nice to top off a perfect meal. First time but we will be back read more

Im impressed with everything so far the food was really good they price was amazing The server was really coool made sure we had everything we needed I would definitely come back read more

Nick's - Apps - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

It is sometimes embarrassing to say that you've known about a place for a long time and never found the opportunity to try it out. Unfortunately, this is the case for me with Nick's pizza. when I first moved to Rockville Center, a Neighbor recommended Nicks to me and Recently, a friend had mentioned that his wife absolutely loved the pizza and I suggested that the three of us get together finally so I could see what everyone raves about. First of all I want to comment the staff absolutely beautiful, lovely efficient, friendly, funny, accommodating, every single possible thing you could say about, someone in a positive manner here. The menu of course, has pizza options,red, or white, in addition to that, appetizers, entrées, selection of wine by the bottle or glass. I did notice that there was a small bar on the other side of the dining area. We ordered a red pie half sausage and peppers and half like margarita style and we also ordered a white pie which is the arugula prosciutto which is my absolute all-time fave. because it's my all time I wound up having two or three slices of that and never had the opportunity to try the red pie, so you know that I am determined to return so I can expand my selection of their delicious pizza. read more

Nick's - Red pie - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

Pizza really was delicious and came out fast. Thought it was going to be super expensive but the price was totally fair! Server was a sweetheart and on point with the order. My husband said the Peroni was great and we had a nice little lunch. Caesar salad was okay, might try a different app next time. read more

Nick's - Large pie Half Pepperoni, Onions - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Here's the problem with Nick's..... the prices are too low. And this makes the place too crowded. I took a date here early on Saturday. The service was perfect, food incredible, and the check was not bad on the wallet. Service is done with teams, the food is super good for Italian fare, for a party of two, you're great with a salad and a pasta. For a bigger party, I would do an entree too. read more

Nick's - Bread is incredible, needs a touch of salt in the oil - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

This was a spot on the Food Done It? Tour. Everything was delicious! From the bread when we sat down, to the salad, to the pizza at the end. Everything was full of flavor! The bread at the start of the meal was seasoned well, and paired very nicely with the seasoned oil for dipping. I would have been satisfied with just having that as my meal. Nick's house salad isn't your typical house salad. It had sundried tomatoes, peppers and a spring mix for greens. It was tossed in a slightly sweet, but not overpowering dressing. It was nice and refreshing. Now the pizza.... What a delicious margarita pizza. Flavors were fresh and yummy. It was however slightly underdone, but that didn't take away from the flavors. Service was great. Our waitress continued to come over to us to see if we needed anything. I will definitely return to try something else, and especially for that bread and oil! read more

See all

Wowww, I can't believe the interaction I had with staff/OWNER at this restaurant. We came here for a celebration, and I was quickly disgusted with the way the staff treated patrons. First they tried to seat our group at a table that was too small and said that they will swap us once this other table left. That was fine. We could wait the extra five minutes to be comfortably seated. The problem arose when one of the servers started setting up the table we were currently seated at. Trying to be nice and assist the server so they didn't waste their time as it was very busy, I informed them that there was a possible swap of tables happening since we did not fit our current table. Out of nowhere this guy starts to berate me in front of everyone asking me if I worked there... saying there was no way they were "swapping" us as the other server had stated and continued haphazardly throwing drinking glasses at us like we were some form of peasant and not paying customers. He then continued and said "if you did work here, you'd be fired in a day" ???? First of all, no one here is looking to work for someone with no self respect or common human decency. Not interested in making whatever slimeball of a deal you have with your employees, seeing as you lack any sense of respect. I probably make more than your entire waitstaff combined. Second, you need to check your attitude at the door. I don't care if you own the establishment. What business do you have running a place that is there primarily there to serve the community. You lack all sense of rationality and the clear disregard to societal norms made my experience probably one of the worst I've ever had. LASTLY IF YOU'RE TOO PROUD TO SERVE CUSTOMERS CORRECTLY MAYBE YOU SHOULD STAY IN THE BACK ROOM BEFORE YOUR BUSINESS SHUTS ITS DOORS BECAUSE YOU HAVE NO CONTROL OVER YOUR MOUTH. read more

My go to pizza spot. I only eat pizza from here or grandpa Tony's. Try it out! I've also tried their calzones. They were huge and tasty also. read more

I stood in the front for 10 mins waiting for someone to even acknowledge me. 2 workers looked at me and continued talking before another waitress asked has anyone helped me yet. My break was only 10 mins all in which was wasted. read more

Nick doesn't like to pay his employees even when the courts say that he should be paying them. He owes hundreds of thousands of dollars in back debt because he just wouldn't pay his employees a fair price and paid them on salary and then overworked them which is in violation of New York state laws. Nick needs to pay his bills because while he's making money off of the sweat of the employees that are in his place, he doesn't want to pay them fairly. read more

Nick's - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Wow. New spot I love! The pizza was amazing!! I love thin crust pizzas that come out fresh. We got half plain with basil and Half pepperoni. Really delicious. The bread they give to start is also great with the oil but I wish the bread was warm. We also had pasta with red sauce, wish It had a little more flavor. Also had the special of thin chicken breasts with broccoli and cheese, real good. Can't wait to go back. Great service, good atmosphere. I'd like to go back soon! read more

Nick's - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Such a great spot in RVC! We recently moved into town and are enjoying exploring all the wonderful eating spots it has to offer. For my hubbies bday we decided to hop into Nicks and give it a go with my parents. We're all about family style, so it was the perfect thing. We started with fried calamari and baked clams. The fried calamari could have been a bit more flavorful, but overall were well cooked and not chewy. Baked clams were one of the better ones I have had, so very pleased with them. For dinner we split chicken parm, broccoli rabe and spaghetti and meatballs. All were cooked very well, had lots of flavor and were eaten up quickly by everyone in my family. There was even enough for me to take for leftovers the next day for lunch which is perfect. For dessert we had cheesecake and a brownie sundae which were also quite yummy. My mom also had an irish coffee which sure did have a lot of whiskey which made her happy :) As for the wine, we split a carafe which was perfect and at a great price! I look forward to returning to Nicks and enjoying some more food. read more

Nick's - Chicken parm family size. Very yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

The best house salad and dressing ever! I don't normally put dressing on my salads but this place is an exception. I love whatever the dressing is made of and I could eat it every single day. Their pizza is also really delicious. It's the perfect Italian restaurant in the neighborhood. Even the littlest things like their homemade bread is a must try. The only thing about this place is there's no slices, only pies which is a good and bad thing because you get a whole pie of goodness but if you want just a small piece, you can't but that's ok, you would want the whole pie after a bite! The guys who make the pizza are super friendly and the girls on the counter was nice as well. Definitely try Nick's if you're in the area, or even if you're not! read more

Excellent salads. Huge portions. Pastas were cooked correctly. The fried calamari should have been crispier on the outside. Good service. Overall a very good experience read more

Picked up my daughter from airport from law school break with rest of family and we were hungry ! After the typical back and forth " what do you want " "whatever you want" dialogue we decided on nicks since we have never been ! Thursday night about 730 walked in as I used rest room my family was seated and by the time I got to table (not long lol) they had water bottle and bread for the table with dipping oil (onion type focaccia ) Deelish! One of the servers maybe a principle not sure told us specials which sounded good but we just wanted simple pizza ! Ordered two small pizzas for four of us one with meatball and one with sausage ! While waiting we were treated to on the house appetizer of eggplant parm . Super fresh and soo good and super nice gesture ! Pizzas arrived cooked prefect with ample toppings on both . Real crumbled meatball and sausage . The crust was light and crisp and the sauce super tasty . We polished off both except one of each slices . As we were leaving my kids (young adults ) said. Can't wait to come back it was sooo good! This will now be in rotation for when go out to eat ! Well done nicks ! read more

We live in Merrick and we have been going here for a long time! They make the best pizza, and when somebody isn't in the mood their other dishes have made others at our table envious! Haven't been their since COVID started, looking forward to the trip!! read more

Nicks pizza is consistently good! My family and I walked in over the weekend knowing we were having a House Salad and baked clams. Both sooo good! The dressing on the salad is unreal. I got grilled chicken 'in the oven' with eggplant. 3 large pieces of chicken with eggplant on time and mozzarella. The sauce is light and really delicious. The chicken Godzilla is also really good. Chicken cutlet with bruschetta. The cannolis are a MUST. The cream is whipped so it's a little different, but it's really delicious. Love this place. The service was a little off this time and that is the reason for 4 stars instead of 5. But I definitely suggest it! read more

See all

Be prepared to either shout, or wear noise-cancelling ear buds because Nick's is one LOUD restaurant , but the food makes the noise level worthwhile.You can get single or family portions and both are definitely filling, rich, flavorful (among other choices, we started with a pizza, of course, that had the freshest basil on top. SO good!), and presented fairly quickly by a fast-moving wait staff (it's crowded in here: one reason for how loud it is!). Nick's has modern decor and design, with high ceilings with exposed ductwork, slatted "fencing" that separates the entryway with the main restaurant, a full bar with large-screen TVs, framed illustrations on the walls, and it is fairly narrow (another reason why it is kinda crowded). It has a bit of a Manhattan restaurant vibe. Bring your appetite, and think about those earplugs. read more

See all

Awesome food, great environment and staff is warm and welcoming Always a great experience read more

love Nick's Pizza. Always great food and great service. The pizza, calzone, salad, chicken in the oven , all excellent. I know there were some legal issues but I would have to do more research on this. I don't want to jump to any conclusions without getting all the facts read more

I like this place. Went there for the first time and enjoyed the food. The entree portions are huge, although everything seems to be ala carte, which sucks. You are probably best off picking a couple of side dishes to share since the side dishes are priced and sized for two. I didnt give Nicks five stars because of their desserts. One of the people I was with wanted tartufo, which was on the menu. No tartufo. Ok, how about chocolate ice cream? The waiter comes back- no chocolate ice cream! She had to settle for a third choice, which put a bad end to an overall good experience. I will be back. read more

I've had Dog food that tastes better than this garbage... Additionally, the Oompa Loompa lookalike owner/manager clearly has an inferiority complex and was berating an older gentleman that simply asked "how long until our table is ready?" The owner/manager could use a lesson in customer service, and maybe a salad... read more

Nicks is a classic RVC restaurant that has been around for ever and still going strong. You can't go wrong ordering anything on the menu there. read more

Nick's - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

I honestly can say I never heard of Nick's until my friends suggested it tonight. Upon entering I noticed it was very clean and had a great overall ambiance. We sat down for dinner and we were greeted by our waiter who provided us with some delicious bread with olive oil. We started off with some fried calamari which was absolutely delicious. The calamari wasnt typical, it was very light and tasty. It wasnt greasy or overly fried at all. The service was fast and friendly. I was very impressed with the portion sizes as my wife and I shared the family style chicken in the oven. I highly recommend this dish. Be aware, none of the chicken entrees come with pasta, that is extra. Given the huge portion sizes, I dont think you even need the pasta. Overall, it was a wonderful experience. read more

See all

Very good pizza! This one of my favorite pizza places out in Long Island and it never disappoints! I definitely recommend going to Nicks Pizza! Here is a picture to make you guys drool read more

Nick's - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

It's okay. Foods not great but not terrible. Service can be a bit spotty. Ambiance is okay

Ate at Nick's tonight. Used to be a great place with exceptional food and service. It's been going downhill, but we decided to give it another shot. Terrible! Not enough staff- lots of confusion with orders and Sal was extremely rude when after 1 hr we had no main courses (when everyone else around us was getting their food) such a shame! read more

So glad we selected Nick's Pizza for our party location. The food was great. Customer service was terrific. The place was very clean. The atmosphere was cozy. We will be back. Pasta and sausage was delicious along with the sauté chicken and vegetables can't wait to go back read more

Horrible. I even sent an e-mail to formally complain and have yet to hear back from management. read more

See all

My favorite spot in RVC for pizza. Really good. The chicken parm is also rock solid- must have

This review is just for pizza. Been to Nicks in Forest hills very good. Nicks in RVC was definitely better. I ordered a large cheese pie well done for three people it's not big 8 medium size slices it was enough for us 18 dollars. The pizza is outstanding fresh mozzarella thin crust and a tasty sauce. Zero flop. Time for Barstool pizza to come to Nicks. Best pizza on Long Island. The pizza on the left is RVC rig read more

Nick's - Pizza Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

I have never had a bad experience here. I constantly order from Nick's and always love their food. I live in the neighborhood, so I can attest that their pizza is the best around here. Everyone who works here is kind and friendly. I have had a bunch of birthday, Christmas, graduation etc. celebrations here and they have all gone well. I am never disappointed. The pizza and bread are amazing. I love their chicken and pasta, too. You really can't go wrong with whatever you order. read more