Great selection of different foods. We love getting the gyro and the Greek chicken. The only thing I did not appreciate is the fact that they charge for a cup of water. Minus 1 star since I've never had to pay for a cup of water anywhere which I found to be very weird. Water should be free everywhere. read more

It's been a few years since I stopped by since everything changed. The food quality used to be GREAT. Now it's beyond poor. Nothing is fresh, except the lettuce. The burger is literally cooked from frozen, they are dense overcooked patties, super dry. The chicken sandwich is severely overpriced for what it is. The chicken is discolored, and turning brown and pink from being cooked to death. I regret spending my money there. read more

Top 5 GREATEST chicken I've ever had in my life. I tried it once for a catered event, instantly was hooked. I had to search forever to find the true location and went back with some friends. I don't think there's a place in the city of Chicago that can beat the taste, the price, the quality, the family aspect, and the authenticity of Nicky's 58. If you go GET THE GREEK CHICKEN!!! read more

Really enjoyed the baby burger combo here at Nicky's. The burger patty was grilled perfectly and was juicy. Loved the onions on this burger and were a nice complement to the soft bun. Service was efficient and friendly. The decor is your typical local fast food spot in Chicago. Nothing to admire but gets the job done. Will definitely be back. read more

Nicky's The Real McCoy - # Big Baby Cheeseburger ( LB.) COMBO - Greek Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Go back to what you did best. You were one of the original Nicky's home of the Big Baby and very good gyros. Order a big baby now one bigger party and lettuce and tomato. One patty makes a difference and lettuce and tomato? Then another time ordered a gyros. I love tzatziki sauce. Get extra on the side. Eating it and thinking this is not tzatziki sauce. Asked my friend he agreed. More like tartar sauce. Go to counter and she says no that's tzatziki. No way. Taste it. Nope it's right Stopped going even though it's close to my house. It's a shame read more

I have gone to Nicky's for over 20 years and have enjoyed several items on their menu. I have never had a problem with the staff or food there. I guess as that saying goes "all things must come to an end." I ordered a gyro plate the other day. I decided to take some to work today however I found a bug in the container. That's a deal breaker for me. read more

See all

The flame grilled chicken sandwich as usual is really good. It was nice and juicy and in was in way dry! The fries when straight out of the frier are extremely crispy and very well salted. However, the Italian beef sandwich had an okay taste to it. There wasn't much flavor and the bottom of the bun was completely soaked and very soggy from the juices, even straight out of the container it was soggy which was a big downer. But the cheese was perfectly melted and had a very nice cheese pull which was amazing! Overall, good service even when packed and other food items on the menu are very good and very tasty! Would come back again! read more

Nicky's The Real McCoy - Flame-Grilled Chicken Sandwich - Greek Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Top-tier Grecian Chicken is the star here. It's actually addictive. They have mastered this chicken. It's rare that I find a place that can deliver juicy white meats consistently. I have ordered from here many, many times and every thing I have had has been fresh, high quality, and delicious. I don't think you can ho wrong with anything you order here. read more

Nicky's The Real McCoy - Half mixed Grecian chicken with salad. Perfectly cooked every single time. Salad is very fresh. - Greek Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I've been to several Nicky's around the city. But never this one. I have no complaints about any of them, but the Big Baby that I ate the other day from here, definitely hit the spot. This is a very busy location. People are constantly coming in and out of this joint. And for a damn good reason. Half of them are dining and and the other half are doing take out. The dining area is very spacious, and surprisingly very clean. The Big Baby came out very hot. The poppyseed bun was perfectly toasted and meat was very juicy and flavorful. It was covered with cheese and grilled onions with ketchup on the bottom part of the bun. The fries were also very good. They were think, frozen fries. Tasted similar to Mickey Ds, but crispier. Will definitely be returning very soon. read more

See all

The food is great, but charging $4 to use your card is crazy. As you can see they charge you twice (1.81) Make sure to check your receipt to get refund. They have a sign that tells you you will only get charge 5%. read more

Nicky's The Real McCoy - The food is great but paying almost $4 to use my credit card is crazy (SVC ) check your receipts - Greek Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Listen and listen good! THIS IS A FIVE STAR RESTAURANT..... Im not understanding anything less than 4 stars. Heres what you do....Order the grecian chicken (preferably dark meat) with the well-done option. Then come back to this review and thank me later. P.S. not forget to order extra grecian sauce on the side for later. You'll want to use it on your own food your prepare or other stuff that you order. If i ever get the recipe, its a wrap! lol Enjoy! read more

I order the gyro plate which was ok but the sauce they use is not the real gyro sauce they mix theirs with mayo

Charred is good but burned taste bad. The other side is even worse. Very dry not enough sauce. I don't know what's going on with you guys.. or if this is just bad because it was ordered through delivery. It's also extremely dry and there's not enough sauce ..Unfortunately I don't have my car at the moment.. :/ I normally look forward to eating this it's a treat... now it's like chicken jerky read more

Nicky's The Real McCoy - Greek Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This place charges 5% for paying with cash and 10% for using credit cards. This is ridiculous! Who charges for paying with cash? They don't have the sign in Spanish and have the nerve to put out a tip jar. The cashiers are rude AND they got my order wrong! Will not be returning! read more

Nicky's The Real McCoy - Payment fee - Greek Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Usually have a great product but 1/3/25 first order of new year I was r disappointed my gyro sandwiches meat /pita no onions/tomatoes onion rings bland and onions taste different will be a while be order again. Two stars had a great amount of meat. read more

Watch out for the service charges! I asked why there was 2 service charges and the girl stated 1 was for using my credit card which is normal and the 2nd one was for the price on pork. I told her I am not purchasing pork and she said we charge that to everyone. Welcome to Chicago, you don't pay taxes only but you have to pay for the business to continue doing business. read more

Although this location is convenient, I haven't been to Nicky's in many years. I realized years ago that fast food just isn't the best thing for me. And I've been pretty good at staying away from it -- until yesterday. A wave of nostalgia has come over me since writing neighborhood Yelp reviews. When one of my friends wrote of the Nicky's "Big Baby" in a Yelp review recently - - well, it brought back memories of those tasty burgers. So, around 7 PM on a Wednesday (8/21/19), we found ourselves in Nicky's. I am assuming there are times when this place is very busy - - like days of yore. However, on this weekday evening it was not all that busy. The restaurant looked bright and clean. There is an adequate amount of seating and parking (enter from Kedzie Ave only). The young lady that took our order (most people are young to me these days!) was very nice. And now for the Big Baby.. . . I am glad I remembered to take a picture before I wolfed that baby down! The Big Baby was still very tasty, even though it was very salty. I tasted a few of my friend's fries and although he likes them, I don't really care for them. In all fairness, I don't care for most fries these days. I think Nicky's is a fine choice for fast food - - if you like /can eat - - fast food. My 4 Stars are for a fast food place and not a fine dining experience--so please keep that in mind! read more

Nicky's The Real McCoy - Nicky's Big Baby hamburger - Greek Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This is my review of the one in Garfield Ridge but it applies. New comments: 1. Nice cashier. Gage Park is nicer than I remember. 2. Very clean--unlike the ones in my memory. 3. Pleasant seating. For real. Not those cheap plastic chairs & tables of yore. 4. I got a Big Baby but I'm taking one bite per day til it's gone as a compromise with my cardiologist. Get in this time machine and go back to see what it was like before people worried about carbs, planking, and BMI. It's been over 30 years since I had a Big Baby and a Pizza Puff. Those get 5 stars. I recall the fries being soggy because the oil wasn't hot enough. I'll have to try them again, for Science. The menu has a lot of items but everybody I know would always order the same two things: Big Baby or Pizza Puff. Occasionally the gyro or shrimp would get some attention. I didn't have a cardiologist back then, but I'm sure she would approve of my life choices. Get some Nicky's on your way home from the movie rental store. Or the video arcade. read more

See all

Good is always good! But to try to place a call in and be on hold 9 minutes is ridiculous . I arrived and had to wait. When I mentioned it the cashier was like we didn't get a call...then realized oh we did, but for real could care less. And I'll be taking my money elsewhere read more

The Greek chicken is amazing!! I haven't ordered anything else from here! I can eat it everyday! The flavors and portions are perfect!

I can't get enough of the Grecian dark meat chicken meal. The chicken is nice and juicy and never over cooked or dry. I've also catered from them for small parties and everyone liked the food. Must try! read more

The Grecian chicken is delicious 10/10. Fries are 8/10. Bread is 10/10. The price could be better but it's delicious so it's worth it.

Grecian chicken is so good! Some of the best chicken I've had in Chicago. Great for takeout also, perfect for a work lunch! Highly recommended read more

Service charges if you don't use cash but the kicker is over here the Right hand often doesn't know what the Left hand is doing. I have been going here for years but I have watched customer service take a dive as the owner keeps hiring young girls that know less than a box of rocks. This last time I was there, I called the day before to pick up carnitas for getting on their usual weekend format. Drove all the way down from up north and a fat one with a nasty attitude wasn't helpful. These people have no accountability for what their employees say on the phone vs what happens when you arrive. I'm just tired of the crappy attitude when you F up! So I'm done with this place and I'm warning everyone because people don't have to put up with crap service when spending their money. I mean there isn't anything gourmet on the menu but it serves its purpose when you want something greasy. I'll go somewhere else or go without before I spend another dime in this place. 1 star for past gyros. read more

Grecian Chicken They should not be called 'the original Nickys'. The only thing the same is the location. The quality of the food, portions, and workers are nothing like 10 years ago. You could order 50 things and every single item would be correct. No matter how busy they were. Now if you order 2 things, something WILL be wrong. No salad with the Grecian chicken? A lump of dry bread? A tablespoon of bottled dressing? Nothing like the quality of the first, 'original' owners. Expensive, tho. Too bad, it's so disgusting now. read more

I been coming to this place since I was five years old . I always order forsure the chicken sandwich, big baby and gyro . They have snack size for certain items ex: gyro . They give you half of it and they charge you half the price . It pretty good deal if you don't want the entire gyro or if you just wanna try everything off the menu all times fav try the chicken sandwich & big baby !!! read more

This location is annoying. I simply wanted my gyro cut in half and the girl at the counter told me she couldn't do it. She said something that it comes in a plastic container and that the owner refuses to cut them in half LOL like what a joke. I'm not going to sit there and argue with a little girl. A place that is too lazy to cut a gyro in half doesn't deserve my business. I simply took my money else where. I went to Big Als down the streets got the same gyro combo, CUT IN HALF and two dollars cheaper $.$ P.s and y'all know you didn't invent the Big Baby! read more

Very good food every time I go food is fabulous , even Uber eats food was amazing very fast cook

So good I always wanna eat the chicken the sauce is so good and we always need to get it but it is expensive put your prices lower XOXO

Worst meal I've had in ages. Absolutely the worst burger in Chicago. Reminds me of the Cheeseburgers we sold in the snack bar at the pool where I worked when I was 14. They came individually wrapped and frozen, pop em in the microwave for 2 minutes and voila. Only those were much better. The hotdog was just as bad as the cheeseburger: cold on the inside, barely lukewarm on the outside, stale bun, limp pickle. Fries came with hotdog and were - surprise!! - disgusting. A soggy mess of bland, undercooked potato. Gross. Can't understand why anyone would eat here, nor how they stay in business. In a word: disgusting. read more

I love this restaurant are used to live two blocks down from where it's at and I would always go and buy a big baby combo or a two hotdog special when they actually had it the chicken is delicious grilled or fried. The gyro is amazing. If you get the one with extra me if it's up to three people, me my wife and my son usually eat the whole thing to really good restaurant great food service is OK. Some of the girls that work in there are kind of ignorant, but ignore that due to the fact that the food is great, those cooks in the bag for Hispanic guys, they're amazing. They make miracles with food. the ambience is real good. They actually have a lot of space and tables. You can sit there and dine in with your family. I like it. I like it a lot I would recommend this to other people. read more

Not the same as it was back in the day . Just ordered 2 Maxwell Polsh pizza puff and fries . Got 2 hot dogs with ketchup. Called to see what happened they said it was a new girls fault . Got all but about 8 bucs back from that i wont see for a week asked for a couple things to make up the difference the arrogant manager on the phone to my Surprise said that is my problem and she is not going to pay for it . Been going here since the 80s . NEVER AGAIN !!!! Complete sell outs read more

Nicky's The Real McCoy - Apparently this is what 2 Maxwells look like .Refused to refund my money . No longer a neighborhood joint anymore. - Greek Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Didn't care for the fries, but everything else was good. Got hot dogs, gyros, and a pizza puff. The puff was cooked 30 seconds too long, but it was still good. The hot dogs were on point. No poppy seed buns, but I only saw those at Portillo's. They were dragged through the garden, so no complaints. And the gyro was the bomb diggity. My wife was in love.... It's Chicago food done the Chicago way. read more

This is my second time coming to Nicky's very good food here first time I came here I had got the Gyro with fries very good a lot of meat came on a Gyro just came here recently this week while I was in Chicago and had got the Grecian chicken dinner with Fries and garlic bread the chicken was very good marinated to perfection and a Greek salad was very tasty too I will be coming back here the next time I'm in Chicago read more

Nicky's The Real McCoy - Outside - Greek Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

As a customer of 15 years give or take it hurts me to write this review mostly focusing of the delicious chicken sandwich they use to have. It first started with giving a smaller piece of chicken with the sandwich and I let it go bc it was still very good so I would just order 2 instead. But within the last year they completely change their chicken to dark meat not chicken breast like it once was if that make sense. It is no longer the good old chicken sandwich I once knew at this point I ll rather get one for Wendy's down the block. I hope the owner reads this and can bring back the chicken sandwich I once knew growing up. read more

Placed an order for pick-up using the Grubhub option. The order was shortly cancelled because restaurant was closed. UPDATE INFO!! read more

I ordered extra tzatziki sauce with my gyro salad but I didn't get any. I also ordered extra dressing but I got ranch they didn't even tell me this at the counter they just gave me what they wanted and then charged me for it. Can I give them a minus 10? read more

They falsely advertise 'Save 5% by paying cash' and then charge you an extra 5% for paying cash.

The service here is horrible!!! Most of their cashiers look clueless half the time and make you repeat your order 3 times while having a conversation amongst themselves! They get so frustrated that they make you feel like not coming back. Frankly they look like they invest more time into splattering make up on their faces than actual customer service! read more

My gf and I frequent nicky's on 58th and Kedzie Ave. When we need our grecian chicken or big baby fix. My gf loves their grecian chicken (dark) as well as I do. Their double cheeseburgers (big baby) are also delicious. I also like their chicken sandwiches but i always ask for it on a pita bread. I noticed not only do they just carry their delicious grecian chicken, they now also sell mexican style chicken (pollo asado) which we have not tried yet but does look good. There's always plenty of seating if you want to dine in and plenty of parking as well. read more

See all