What a great local pizza choice! We ordered as soon as we got to the condo after being recommended from front desk. Pizza was delicious And we even got it delivered which made it easy! read more

Got their 10 ct half golden bbq and sweet teriyaki and a med half Hawaiian bbq and monster meat pizza. The wings, though tender and not dry... I wasn't feeling the sauces. Of the 2 I liked the teriyaki more. They were swimming in the sauce so perhaps it was a bit much. Next time I'll try dry. But the med 1/2 specialty was bomb. Monster meat especially was right on point. I'll have to try thin crust next time. read more

We ordered online and it was super easy. When we went to pick up the food, the girl working the front was super nice and accommodating for any or all utensils that might have been needed. The Popeye pizza had incredible flavor. The meat lover was perfect as it had very little red sauce read more

I discovered NiMarco's Pizza on the way back from the Grand Canyon passing through Flagstaff to Phoenix. I called in my order & through that process got a gentleman on the phone. I gave him the order. Medium Half Pepperoni w/ hot honey and half Gary's Special No Olives or Mushrooms. Three times I told him medium Flagstaff Crust. When I arrived at the store I was greeted by an unfriendly young woman. When she got the pizza I said that a medium? No, it's a large. Well I ordered a medium, well I got to pay for a large. Two people a large specialty that's is only half a specialty because the other half is pepperoni. Plus the waste. We can't eat all that and paying for wasted food. Frustrating when it's not my mistake. The Pizza: The Flagstaff Crust was magnificent. Crispy bottom & sturdy to hold the toppings. The Half that was pepperoni & Hot Honey had plenty of honey and it added that spicy sweet flavor. The sauce is excellent and paired with the crust & sauce was delicious. The Gary's Special with Pepperoni, sausage, onions, & bell peppers was a phenomenal pie. Fresh vegetables, nice sauce, meat, and cheese. Perfect pie. I would definitely recommend the pizza. They only have one size apparently and it's large. I did tell the lady and it was there's nothing I can do attitude. Well I would rather not pay for something I didn't ask for. Also be friendly, I get it's busy and maybe your job sucks, but your attitude sucks worse. Be glad you have a job and that place has great pizza so you should be happy. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Half Pepperoni w/ hot honey Half Gary's Special - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Ordered take out pizza with our favorite toppings. Service was on time and the pizza is outstanding. Fresh, tasty toppings and the crust was perfect. read more

Nice place to catch a pizza, wings or salad. It was convenient for my wife and I as we were staying at the Day's Inn right next door. We had the small salads that fill us up fine. I added chicken for $1.50 to my Caesar Salad. My wife got a slice of pizza with green chili that did the trick. Lots of tvs and they serve beer. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Small Caesar Salad, add chicken for a buck 50 - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

We love NiMarcos pizza have been ordering from them for 4 or more years. We were very disappointed in our last one, mu first 2 pieces had no sauce or sausage on it and hardly no cheese there was no peppers or onions either. We ordered the Gary special like always. As we ate there was barely any sauce on the complete pizza. They went very heavy on the olives. We're is the sausage? Very disappointed in this pizza. Mary read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Wings were awesome the staff was amazing great atmosphere was conveniently located by hotel easy walking distance to and from hotel read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - 10 wings traditional medium - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Better than average takeout pizza. I suggest you put it in the oven before eating it to make it more crispy and warm.

Our favorite pizza place in Flagstaff! Pizza is fresh, ranch is amazing, and the wings are the BEST!! A little expensive but the food is really worth the price for fresh, whole ingredients and homemade dough and sauce!! Plus they also have good deals during the day. We've only ever ordered takeout but never had an issue picking up. I absolutely recommend to anyone who is thinking about trying it! Can't beat fresh food with fast and friendly service! read more

Great family eating--no nonsense, quick dining. Staff was friendly, and the dining area was very kid friendly. Recommended.

Simple service with a walk up counter. The pizza was actually pretty decent. It's not really a sports bar vibe but it kind of try's. They offers a delicious variety of pies. The medium Gary's Special was packed with flavor, perfectly balancing a mix of fresh toppings. The Monster Meat pizza was a hearty choice, loaded with savory meats that satisfied every bite. For those with dietary preferences, the gluten-free personalized pizza was a great option, with a crispy coliflor crust that didn't compromise on taste. Overall, a great experience with generous portions and tasty options for all! Grab a beer and a slice! read more

See all

The Food was really good and employees were all very nice. Garlic bread was really cheesy and crucnhy, 8.5/10. Hot honey wings were amazing, 9/10. We ordered a half buffalo and half meat lovers option pizza. The buffalo was ok, didnt really give me "buffalo" pizza vibes but it was solid, meatlovers option was also pretty good, 8/10 on both. All in all, it was definitely worth the visit while we were in town. Solid 8.5/10 overall read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Half buffalo half meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

We are at NiMarco pizza in Munds Park on a Friday on a holiday weekend servers were great and working very hard. We arrived at 6:40 pm and it was busy, with a band. My wife ordered chicken wings, (Very Good she says.) I orders a personal pizza. The chicken wings came out in 15 minutes, my Pizza came out in 1 hrs and 20 minutes. My pizza dinner was burnt around the edge, and the other ingredients were well cooked. The bacon was burnt to little charcoal pieces. I reaize you were busy and a Friday night, but this is just poor form. The thee piece band was so loud my ears were ringing for 30 minutes after we left. I had to yell at the server to order, which I feel bad about. You need more workers in the kitchen, another over in the back, or maybe a better kitchen manager. read more

Their pizza was delicious. We ordered the Gary's Special large and an order of zucchini fries for pick up. I wasn't a fan of their zucchini fries or ranch dressing that went with it, but their pizza was amazing. We ate it at our hotel and it was a 3 minute walk from our hotel for pick up. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Gary's Special pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Food was amazing! Did an online order, from our hotel room. Pizza was delivered and was still really hot when we got it. My kids had zero complaints. Antipasto salad and pizza for the win!!!! read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Marely had great amazing customer service today! She helped me with ordering food and got the food out to me right away!

Best pizza in flagstaff. Actually best pizza in Arizona! We were so pleased with the large pepperoni pizza! Not only was the pizza good but the lady taking my order and who delivered it was so kind! The pizza sauce was so flavorful and crust was just as amazing! We highly recommend this pizza joint if you're in town! read more

Was traveling and this spot was a surprise. Outstanding food, especially the fried zucchini.

The food was amazing and the customer was also amazing! All of the workers are very nice and welcoming. If you're ever in the area and are looking for pizza this is the place for you!!! read more

Review: Ordered takeout from this place for two days straight--pizza and wings both times. The food itself was alright, nothing special, but the service left a lot to be desired. On the second day, they included an insanely hot sauce with the order that we definitely didn't ask for. I enjoy spicy food, but this was over the top, and they didn't even bother to give us a heads-up. It turned the meal into more of a challenge than something to enjoy. The fact that it was takeout made it even more frustrating since we couldn't ask them to fix it right away. If they paid more attention to the details, it would've been a much better experience. Decent food, but the service needs work, especially when it comes to takeout orders. You can really hurt people. I do not live in the area, but do not play games with people's food. read more

First time. Got 10 wings in "not so hot" Great! Cooked perfect. Medium Caesar salad, pre tossed. Good. Large ham and black olive pizza, split. Crust was amazing. Will definitely be back. Came at 5, missed the rush by 5-10 mins so get in early!!!! read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Large ham & black olive - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Disappointing. I don't really understand the good reviews. The pizza was so generic and greasy. Overloaded with bland greasy cheese and the sauce tastes canned. Crust has a nice crunch but simultaneously tastes undercooked and doughy and at the same time greasy? Weird. Looks like mostly high school and college kids working and cooking. Feels like a atmosphere for kids in the dining room, or immature adults who need to be surrounded by 20 tv screens at all times. So it's kids making pizza for kids. There's way better pizza in Flag. read more

Food good but they pay more attention to talking to customers instead of asking them to hold on a min they js leave you there to stand dumb and wings takes for ever, the girl said that I Orders wings 5 mins ago but order my food 20 mins ago and left without getting my wings read more

Stopped by here passing through flag. Had my kids with me, and they wanted pizza...and I wanted to avoid downtown because it gets crowded. No line, not too crowded, and the service was great. Ordered a large pepperoni and traditional hot wings. Only took about 15 minutes. Pizza was great, my kids kept commenting about the cheese pull. Crust was crunchy and soft on the inside. I have the pallet of a newborn baby, so I was only able to handle one wing before I started sweating like a...... I thought it was super spicy, my daughter said it was pretty good. They have a typical selection of beers on tap, which is great if you've been on the road for 3 hours, and your kids last about 15 minutes in the car before they decided to find how many nerves pops has and test the last one. Overall good dinning experience. Oh yeah, the playlist was awesome. 90s nostalgia from every genre, loved it. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Gluten free pizza amazing, serve was pickup and it was helpful and amazing, and the atmosphere was great when picking up my order.

PIZZA, FLAGSTAFF STYLE!!!! It's good and greasy. Not in a good or bad way. Just......PIZZA, FLAGSTAFF STYLE!!!! Overall crust is crispy but greasy. Cheese is gooey and greasy Topping-fresh and greasy. Pizza is tasty but greasy. read more

Best pizza place in the town of flagstaff. I like to order it crispy. Highly recommend grabbin fresh za from these guys.

You walk up and order, slices are warmed and served quickly, clean and family friendly. Seemed a popular place for a quick lunch

Great crust, a bit pricey for pizza but convenient to get to from our campsite. We ate the rest for lunch the next day and it reheated well. read more

It's your average pizza joint but with really good pizza. I thought the sauce was very tasty. Would eat there again.

I loved the vibe and location! The food was also super delicious.. We will definitely be back next time we're in town. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Classic pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

This pizza was really good! We are traveling through and tried to go to Fat Olives based on the reviews, and they had a long wait (over an hour) so we drove down and saw this place! Boy am I glad we came here instead! The pizza is really good - cheesy, and the right amount of crisp to the crust. We got a cheese pizza and a pepperoni & beef sausage (which they make homemade). It was delicious! You order at the counter and they bring it out. No wait for seating, no fuss, staff is super nice! They play 90's music which is cool and lots of tv's as well! Highly recommend! Will be back! read more

This one is the best one in Town. West one is a little skimpy on toppings. Hands down my favorite wings tho. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Eastside - Hot wings - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Some of the best pizza in town! Love it here. They have great wings too! It's convenient because I live very close to

RUBBER BAND CALAMARI. Complained after eating a few and tbey said I had the majority which I didnt. Not gonna argue. Avoid calamari at all costs and customer service sucks. Save your money. Go pizza hut read more

Chill vibe, great location, great service. We ordered a large pepperoni for our family and it was out in less than 10 minutes. The sauce tasted like it was made fresh from tomatoes and the crust was delicious. Not too greasy (for reference, I think Costco pizza is much too greasy), and all of our kids liked it. Family-friendly, and the restrooms were clean, so that was a bonus. Maybe a little pricier than other options but honestly not that much and tasted much more real and fresh than so many of the pizza places out there. read more

Outstanding! Staff were inviting and the cooks know what they are doing. My husband and I shared a large pizza with pepperoni and sausage (5 slices leftover). The crust is unbelievable good with a nice crunch. The toppings were fresh and pizza sauce is clearly made in-house. We highly recommend if you're in the Flagstaff area! read more

This location frankly sucks. Call in orders have been: lost, instructions ignored, burned, and made with skimpy toppings and little cheese / sauce. Pizza seems to be smaller and slices definitely are smaller. Haven't seen these issues at the Beaver Street location so guessing east side is to blame. Ownership needs to correct this or face the prospect of customers leaving for better pizza elsewhere. It's not like there are no other options. read more

Normally, the service and food is on point. Today, I bring someone for lunch and 45 minutes later still waiting for a pizza. This is ridiculous, people have jobs to get back to. When we walked through the door only 2 tables were seated. Came in at 11:35, still waiting no excuse. Definitely, not a stop for a quick lunch. read more