First off the service from CJ the bartender was 5 star and top notch. Coming from Buffalo it's hard to find any pizza that comes anywhere close to home or better which is probably the tallest ask. Because in Buffalo there are three things we take serious. Buffalo Bills Football, Wings and Pizza. However this Deep Dish with light sauce and crispy-curl pepperoni is amazing. First let's talk dough, it's perfect, super light and Fluffy and perfect. Then we have the Sauce, reminiscent of a lighter pizza &ut. Perfect. And the cheese is also a perfect blend of mozzarella and Munster. This pizza is BETTER than Buffalo pizza. I would rather have this than BUFFALOS BEST. Take the pe@si challenge and see for yourself. You will not be disappointed. read more

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub - Deep Dish Light sauce! - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Price and quality varies greatly within a 2 day period depending upon manager and kitchen staff on duty. Day one was perfect. Day two was the opposite. Higher cost for same item and far less quality/ toppings read more

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub - Day 2 pizza (higher price, lower quality) same order as day 1 - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Been over 2 years Spence we gave Noble Roman's a try. Pizza once again more crust than toppings. I think this will be our last attempt. Too many other pizza places in town. I can think of at least 3 less the. .5 mile from Noble Romans. read more

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub - More crust than toppings. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I dined in with some friends last night. I never been to this location before. We split a thick crust pizza that was delicious along with bread sticks. I'm very particular about bread sticks so they were so so. You order the counter and they bring the food to the table. Other than that everything is self serve. The noise was moderately average with people coming and going. The next I might try the salad bar if I out that way again. read more

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub - Pepper, mushrooms and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The deep-dish pizza was great, the breadsticks looked like "breadbones" hard as a bone! read more

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub - Noble Roman's breadsticks! - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I have eaten here numerous times. The food and service at this Noble Romans is exceptional! Also David G.; the person who's responsibility is to make the delicious dough, is great at what he does! Keep rocking it guys! read more

My mother loved Noble Roman's! Another place of nostalgia for me... I remember going as a kid and loving it but most were shut down, then popped up again like Little Cesar's and I'm not mad at it. I messed up by not going to the one me and her went to together but this place was still a win! I came in during Happy Hour, from 4pm-6pm, which I was not even aware of but did take advantage of. They have 1 topping personals, 6 wings, 6 breadsticks and slider for $5. You can also get drinks specials as well. I ordered the personal Sicilian, The Works w/ extra sauce. It was soooo good. It had crispy edges, cooked all the way through dough and cheesy, with the perfect amount of toppings. I was greeted immediately by the staff who worked the front and bar. They were very nice and welcoming with all the patrons. The inside was clean and was kept clean while I was there w/ the staff cleaning the floor and tables. I'll be going every weekend just for my mother with the added bonuses of everything else. Please go try for yourself!! read more

I'm not quite sure what happened to allow Noble Roman's to renew itself as a chain, but I'm definitely a fan of the increasingly popular "Craft Pizza and Pub" concept that has come to define the Indiana-based pizza chain. This location is located at 86th & Ditch. It's an older, decently-sized strip center and Noble Roman's has an ideal corner spot. I can't remember what was here prior to Noble Roman's. They have one accessible spot right at the corner right next to several pick-up spots for carry-out. There's a wheelchair ramp, not a curb cut. Technically, the main entrance is around on the side. The design is fairly typical for Noble Roman's. This one seems a little roomier than some, though most of the Noble Roman's locations are decent in size. This location has a way of dividing dining areas that feels a little less open concept and allows for a little less noise, though overhead music was louder than I'd have liked. I sat by the bar area. They have televisions - all of which were tuned on college football. They have some high-top options, though have plenty of accessible tables. I ordered what is pretty close to my usual at Noble Roman's - a personal sized sausage deep dish along with an order of garlic bread and my usual unsweetened iced tea. This order is a little weird in that some Noble Roman's locations seem to have it as a special - others charge regular price. I haven't quite figured it out yet, though it was regular price here (just over $15 total). I believe this is a newer location. I was the only person dining in while I was there, though they did have some carry-out orders. Employees were friendly and helpful. As you can tell by the photo, the garlic bread was just a bit off. they sliced it into two uneven slices and it was just a tad burnt (I do like crisper, darker bread but this was just a bit much). That said, it was still good. The pizza was rock solid. Noble Roman's is pretty consistent from location to location and the same was true here. Both items were served hot. They actually fixed my first iced tea, though that was likely due to the wheelchair. It is self-serve. They, of course, have the usual other options and they do have a pub area. Overall, this was a solid experience. I wouldn't say it's my favorite Noble Roman's location but I'd easily stop in when I'm in the area as I was today. I'd honestly say this was closer to 3.5, but I'm deferring upward due to the positive customer service. read more

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub - Dining Room, Bar area - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Super impressed with this newly opened pizza place. They took over the old starbucks location near 86th and Ditch (south of 86th East of Ditch). We ordered two small pizzas and breadsticks using the online ordering and curbside pickup. The estimated time for pickup was accurate and we were greetly immediately as we pulled up to the curb. Friendly staff gave us our pizzas and we were on our way in mins - very fast! Both the small greek pizza and breadsticks were perfect! Will be back to explore more of the menu- they have a lot of speciality pizza! read more

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub - Greek Delight Pizza with Breadstick (missing pieces due to immediate consumption by photographer) - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Awesome service & awesome food! Derrick is doing an amazing job! No complaints here... Restaurant is always clean including the restroom. The staff works together! read more

The food is always delicious and the staff is courteous. We usually get take out from here, but I did notice a nice fresh salad bar that we plan to try at a later date. read more

Great deep dish! Always fast and hot. Bread sticks are yummy too. Haven't gotten delivery but the pickup is easy

Horrible experience. Went here on sat night the first red flag is when I tried to order a wine they said you don't want to spend money on the wines they're all really old no one orders those. Ok so then we ordered a pizza and breadsticks. After 30 min of waiting I ask if we can get the breadsticks before the pizza they apologize and said they're short staffed tonight and we got a few free break sticks. 20-30 min later they told us they lost our ticket and would make our pizza now. So we were there waiting for over an hour with my baby starting to scream bc it's past his bedtime and he's getting hungry. Eventually we get the pizza, it was on par with other chain pizzas, not bad. Only weird thing was the sauce was on top of the cheese so it was messy to eat. We got a free cookie and a coupon for a free pizza. This would have all been fine except I woke up at midnight with hot and cold chills, sweats, and was violently puking for the next 6 hours, couldn't even hold down water, while trying to take care of my baby at night. I'm pretty sure I got food poisoning given they said how old the wine is, I can't help but wonder what else is old. The salad bar did look like wilted lettuce and not great so not sure how fresh the ingredients are. Throwing the rest of the pizza out as well as the coupon. Tldr waited over an hour for the food and got violently ill after eating the pizza read more

Haven't had it since I was a kid. Oh, the nostalgia. Delicious pizza just like I remembered. also, the manager and his crew are awesome and their customer service is top tier. Place was very clean and welcoming. read more

Great place for amazing pizza and the atmosphere is the best place to enjoy All the sports there is. The service was amazing and couldn't ask for a better environment read more

Accidentally dropped a pizza while receiving and was given a new pie! My fault but thank you so much!!! Kayden, ceejay were amazing

My husband and I visit the Noble Romans on 86th St. at least twice monthly. We love the pizza, but the staff makes the difference. We usually sit at the bar and chat with them as they work. Sometimes, we will try to sort out where to go, and I will say, "We know that going to our Noble Romans is always social." The pizza is excellent, and the beer/cider is always cold. They are willing to chop up a lime for my Coors Light. Even if the bar is packed with a party, we will sit in a booth and have a great time just talking to each other and eating great pizza. So, you will have an excellent atmosphere and good food! Have fun! read more

I've heard a lot of good things about Noble Roman's Craft Pizza, so decided to try a pizza and salad through Uber Eats. The ambiance itself is nice and relaxing from what people have told me, but did not get to go inside this time, but next time, I will definitely dine inside to experience the full ambiance. I ordered the Pizza Margherita and the Italian side salad for dinner. I will say I was not impressed with the Pizza Margherita. It was Ok and tasted fine, but there was no flavor and no spice to the pizza. It was disappointing because I was expecting a great pizza, and fell short big time. I guess I will have to try another kind of pizza next time to see if it is better quality. The Italian side salad was delicious and wonderful. The combination of toppings and lettuce made it a perfect salad. I would order the salad again if I was dining inside the restaurant. I'm sure the pizza is good at Noble Roman's, but I just felt this pizza missed the mark. I will try another kind of pizza next time to see if it is better. The salad was incredible, so I would recommend the salads at Noble Roman's. read more

See all

We've had food from here twice - first from carry out and today we dined indoors. The food was pretty good. I would come back a million times just for the dessert breadsticks and pizza sliders. The boneless wings were ok, but nothing we would get again. They didn't have much sauce or flavor. When dining in, I had the Caesar salad. The dressing is "Royal Caesar." I'm not sure what it's supposed to be, but it was too creamy and not really tangy. Also the lettuce wasn't the best quality. I had to pick out several yucky pieces. The dining room is spacious and functional. It isn't particularly cozy or decorated. There were several huge TVs featuring sports. They were all muted, but I'm not sure if they turn on the volume when there are local games playing. The dining room doesn't have table service, other than bringing out your food. You order at the counter, take your number, then they bring the food to you. It was clean and the staff were nice. If we were in the area, we would be fine with stopping in. We had originally planned to go here for date night, but it definitely doesn't have a date night vibe. read more

This place isn't too bad. I had never been to one of these Noble Roman Craft Pizza Pubs before. It ia definitely more upscale than your usual chain pizza parlor, but it's still a far cry from a date night place. The food is pretty much the same as what you would get from a regular Noble Roman's. Just with far more flat screen TVs. read more

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Noble Roman's Deep Dish Sicilian has always been my favorite pizza, but today I was disappointed to spend $22 on a medium pizza that had very little cheese, sauce, or toppings. I was the only person in the restaurant. Hmmm... read more

Love walking in and watching through the windows the pizza being made. It had been a long time that we had been here and were happy to share the experience with our kids. One of the servers noticed how excited our kids were to watch and brought some pizza dough to the table to play with. We ordered a deep dish alfredo the chicken and a thin crust cheese pizza. We love the combination of cheese that is put on the pizza and love the extra flavor that the muenster cheese brings in. Order of breadsticks and cheese is also yummy. Service was quick and everyone was friendl read more

The workers were so kind and thoughtful to offer us a drink while waiting in our order. I really appreciate the fresh service and it was a great clean atmosphere! read more

Great pizza. Clean restaurant and super friendly service. Highly recommend for a wonderful dining experience. Barbara Coleman read more

Avoid if you care about cleanliness! Place had only one table with customers yet all the booths were filthy. We had placed our order and every "clean" plate we picked up to take to the table was slimy with grease and we went through 4 knives and never found a clean one. Went back to the counter and got a refund as would not eat in a place that couldn't manage basic cleanliness. The Indianapolis Health Department definitely needs to pay them a visit! read more

Great service and food! There was a pleasantly surprising bar inside ........................................

David had amazing customer service and made me feel better about my life for the short time I spent in noble Roman's

Pizza is sooo good. Customer service was great. Store is so cute. Love this shop forever. Great memories here! read more

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub - Sloaner boner Swenson - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I love the food. Derrick is incredibly thoughtful and kind. Pizza was fast. I love the Yucatan Sunset pizza, the sweety drop peppers are fire. read more

Decided this Friday night to order from an old favorite......Noble Roman's. We visited the 86th and Ditch location only to be very disappointed when we got home. First, I ordered light red sauce. It was loaded with sauce with 1 piece having so much sauce on it, I could barely hold it. Secondly, the crust was burnt on the ends, but doughy in the middle pieces as if it hadn't cooked evenly. Thirdly, for $25+, I ordered a medium deep dish pizza with sausage, pepperoni, meatball crumbles and black Olives which I was charged $2.20 for EACH topping which we could barely see let alone taste. This was the worst pizza I have ever eaten and it surprised me so because it was our #1favorite some time ago. This will more than likely be my last time ordering if management will not resolve this issue. AWFUL for a Friday night staple in our house. read more

The worst pizza I have had in years. I have gone to this location since they opened. Sad. They forgot to put any sauce....like eating cardboard read more

I frequent this location for the lunch special. The staff is always super friendly and fun (especially Richard)! They make my order really quickly and it's always delicious. Highly recommend!! read more

Possibly the worst $9.80 spent on sandwich. Hardly any meat. I ordered the salad bar too, but after looking at it, got my money back. Not clean floors, rushed on ordering so the manager(?) could go back to the bar and talk to someone. Last experience was really good, now, never going back. Sad. read more

Ordered an individual-sized deep-dish sausage pizza, which only had approximately 10 tiny pieces of sausage on the entire pizza, which cost $1.10, which isn't worth the cost. read more

This place is awesome. Nice, clean and friendly. Reminded me of my childhood so much I called my Mom, who I haven't spoke to in years. Definitely coming back! read more

Great pizza and GREAT service! I have been a couple of times and couldn't ask for a better place to grab a beer and pizza! Staff and managers are all awesome! read more

We went to Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub at 86th and Ditch Rd, Indpls, IN 46260 for dinner tonight with neighbors. This was our first time here. We all enjoyed our choice of pizza. The pizza, bread sticks and salads were amazing! The staff and manager were very helpful and enthusiastic! I highly recommend trying this place out. read more

Not trying to be rude but I waited for an hour for a carry out after I was told 20minutes!

I order a chicken sandwich with bacon and there was barely any meat on it. Almost all bread. I also order boneless wings and they were dry and overcooked with only the sauce on them making the wings eatable. My wife ordered a small personal cheese pizza and enjoyed it. The service was friendly read more

This is the best pizza I had since I moved to Indianapolis. Don and Ali are the best, they are very friendly and I enjoyed talking with them. Their establishment is very clean and well maintained, now I know where I can get the best pizza in Indianapolis. read more