A real curiousity located on the north side of Noblesville square. I was looking for a hard to…read morefind bolt that I thought they may have (but didn't). The owner knew exactly what I was talking about and indicated I would need to order it. He wasn't especially friendly but that's fine...it's hardware. Of more interest to me was a quick loop thru the store. Another reviewer mentioned it being part Mom and Pop and part museum. That is about spot on. I might toss in secondhand store also since there is a bunch of stuff here that (presumably) no one will ever want to buy and should probably just be pitched. The paint at the front of the house looks like it has been there since 1982, there are random dishes, overpriced paintings, etc. I did notice about 60 rubber ends for canes on a shelf. Really just a random assortment of aging stuff. From strictly a hardware perspective I would be hard pressed to say I would return. I want to support local business but not for the sake of buying old junk at 2015 prices. Some of the price tags were commensurate with 2015 but the merchandise is straight 80s and 90s. There might be a couple of values here but not the type of place I will look for them. So 2 stars for the selection and a plus 1 for the trip back in time.

Very interesting place on the square in Noblesville. I suspect it was a Western Auto back in the…read moreday (if you're old enough to know what those were). I'm not sure how to describe this place. It's 2 parts "mom & pop" hardware store (which means the people there actually know how to do stuff) and 1 part retail museum. Need an original Fry Daddy? They got it. Need brand new Corelle dishes with the 1985 pattern? They got it. Never opened. Need a replacement carafe for a 1979 Mr. Coffee? They got it. Need a 1987 Mirro 10inch frying pan? Yep. Like I said, it's like a museum. I love it! This might be the primary shopping destination for Christmas 2014. Can't get this stuff on Amazon.

Ok- i use this store a lot for odd and ends I need to pick up- and nearly everything they sell- is…read moregreat... but I would avoid the paInt.. we brought in a piece of our dining room wall to color match.. it was 2x2. They "color matched it-" when we said that is not the same color we showed them the sample again they said- it is what it is- put it on the wall to see.. on the can it won't dry the same color as it will on the wall. so we tried it... now we have to repaint the whole wall and likely room.. when we showed the people at ace they said- yeah we don't always get good results. Need us to make you a gallon so you can do the full room? I feel like this was a bit of a scam to sell me more paint.. but the people there are so nice I cant imagine then doing that. I am disappointed in how they knew the color was not right and didn't try to do fix it. I would Not use thrm for paint again.

Always Great! A very clean and neat store. Everyone is friendly and I can always get help on…read moreanything. I am not mechanical or handy at all and they go out of their way to help me find solutions for what I need.

This is the perfect small town hardware store. That have much more of a selection than it appears,…read morethe service is always great in being able to suggest what to use for whatever project you're working on. Yes it's a little bit more expensive than say Lowe's or Home Depot but the money you're saving in gas makes it worth it.

Always have had helpful, friendly service. Sullivan Hardware may not be as large a big-name chain…read morestore, but I have always been able to find what I needed! Once, I biked from my house to Sullivan Hardware, and on the way had a nut fall off my bike! Once I got to Sullivan's, the manager went out of his way to make sure I found the correct nut to replace the lost one, and even lent me a few tools to make sure everything was installed safely. I really appreciated his kindness and patience. Great little store. Definitely recommend!

Great place for good deals. If you buy a large mower or tractor accessories be sure to check out…read moretheir extended warranty. Sales folks always available and helpful. Great service

Because of the name, I suspect a lot of people don't think to go to this store. It has a broad…read moreselection of items. I needed a western shirt, and they had multiple options from wrangler. Not tractor supplies. They also had boots. Not a huge selection, but adequate. The prices seem reasonable. The store staff I have interacted with have always been friendly.

White's offers extraordinary customer service. We were greeted when we entered and asked if we…read moreneeded help finding anything. Several other clerks also asked if we needed assistance. Russell was very helpful. I was looking at gardening boots, but they didn't have my size. Russell called their other store and was able to offer some options. He was engaging and friendly. The store offers an array of grills, power tools, paints and general hardware supplies. The shelves are remarkably well organized and neat. Many shelves were empty as I assume they are preparing for spring inventory. Many items were on clearance including Yetis so there are some great deals. In the entry alcove is a fascinating history of the hardware store's evolution. The history dates back to at least 1889 when the store was located at 110 West Main Street in Carmel. The store has been owned by four families start with O. W. Nutt prior to 1889. Steve White bought the store in 1984 and built the current location on Rangeline Road in 1989. I love that someone took the time to capture the history. There's plenty of parking in their private lot. You can only enter or exit going north in Rangeline, but the roundabouts make going in the right direction easy.

Great staff who are super friendly. Well stocked with everything you need for home maintenance and…read moreeasy to navigate. Prices are pretty competitive for the area.

I had an excellent experience here while shopping for new vanities for my bathrooms. I had visited…read moretwo other locations earlier in the day and could not get any assistance. So I tried this location and an employee immediately approached and offered assistance. The employee, Hamid, was very helpful and extremely knowledgeable. He discussed the different models on display, and was able to answer all my questions. He helped me find the perfect vanities that fit all my specifications. The prices were much less than other retailers that I had checked out in the area. This location has many more vanities on display than other locations, and the customer service is top notch. Very pleased with the selection, prices, and especially the customer service.

The employees are knowledgeable and so friendly here. I have been many times buying goods for home…read morerepairs/improvement projects. Their employees in the Window Treatments area are helpful and patient answering questions. They even called me to confirm my large order before placing it and contacting the install company. Thus, ensuring I would not have issues later. The employee at the Doors section was so knowledgeable and talked me through my options of storm doors. I will pay a bit more here than at other home improvement stores for this type of service and dependability. Their installers are also professional, on time with their appointments, and provide quality work. I've never had an issue. You just have to be a bit patient as their installers could be backed up with appointments before they can fit you in. But I don't go in expecting a fast turnaround from order to install, so it doesn't bother me.

Spooky Season is officially upon us. I can always count on Menards every year for some pretty cool…read moreholiday decorations. While they do offer plenty of bargains on general merchandise storewide, the seasonal items can be a bit pricey in comparison. I tend to wait until after the holidays when those things go on sale and save them for the following year. I would say Michaels has similar decorations for about the price point and maybe a better selection typically with some coupons. I was on a mission for some scented witches broom sticks. Inventory said they had some in stock but they were not the scents I was looking for and when I did finally find some they were all combined in a box upstairs from last year with the old leftovers mixing pine with pumpkin spice so I will wait until they get some fresh ones. They were still full price but definitely from last season. Menards is a bit of a hassle with the rebate form that I always end up forgetting to fill out. It's still fun to see what they have though!

According to them, "you save big money when you shop Menards", but I can tell you that you won't…read morenecessarily save time by ordering online for pick-up in-store. I recently did so, expecting to save time and gain convenience, but was sorely disappointed. I placed an order online for a 5-gallon, food-grade pail, lid and lid opener. The instructions that accompanied my order confirmation were to enter the store and follow the signs for in-store pick-up. I did so, and was led from the front door, straight-through to the back of the store, and then to the furthest corner of the store from where I had entered. Surely, I had passed all of the items ordered during this trek. The store is massive, and if you are not familiar with the layout, online ordering would seem like a good, time-saving option, but that turned out to not be the case. Not to mention (as I mention), the "convenience fee" that I was charged to do so. This might be a good option for larger orders, but for the 3 item order that I placed, I would not suggest this.

I recently purchased a microwave from Home Depot and scheduled installation through their service…read more Unfortunately, the experience was extremely disappointing and concerning. The installer arrived but was unable to communicate in English, which made it very difficult to discuss the installation, ask questions, or address concerns. Communication is critical when someone is working inside your home, especially when installing an appliance that requires proper mounting and electrical safety. Even more troubling, the installation itself was poorly done and did not reflect the level of professionalism I expected from a contractor representing Home Depot. Allowing someone into your home requires trust, and this experience left me feeling uncomfortable and dissatisfied. When customers pay for professional installation through a major retailer like Home Depot, they expect qualified installers, clear communication, and quality workmanship.

Great staff and very helpful people with a lot of knowledge in all departments from the pro desk…read morethroughout

I must be broken, because whenever I see a Menards or hear someone say Menards, I immediately think…read moreabout a guy getting kicked in the stones, exclaiming, "Oh! Me nards!" But really, how could you not? The name of this place is Menards! Anyway, I visited this Menards, thinking, "Me nards! Me nards!" over and over in my head as I went in search of some indoor plants. But what do you know: They must not have indoor plants in late fall, because I could find nary a one. They didn't even have any outdoor plants. Apparently, Menards is not the place to find plants of any kind when the weather turns cold. So I walked around to see if maybe they were hiding the plants somewhere else, and I came across aisles of pet products, Christmas trees, patio furniture, paint, and lots of other things. Menards seems to be a one-stop-shop for home improvement. Parking is plentiful, and it's easy to get on and off the interstate.

As all my friends and relatives know, Menards is my favorite store. I've loved it since they opened…read morethe first Indy location in the former Target on Pendleton Pike back in the early 1990's. With many remodeling projects, I know I've saved tens of thousands of dollars over the years. I've joked that if they started carrying beer, I wouldn't need to shop anywhere else (they have Lottza Motta frozen pizza, what other hardware store can claim that?). I mostly go to the Fishers store now. I find the staff to be friendly and helpful and there's comraderie among them. I appreciate the family-owned Wisconsin/Northwoods culture and look forward to the weekly ads. I have never had any issues with missing rebates or returns. The website is excellent, it even tells you what aisle and shelf to find an item on. Menards makes shopping fun.