NY Pizza in No. Main, Mansfield has the best grilled chicken salad with the best homemade pita bread in town. Try it!!!

Ordered 2 subs n fries. Both subs were toasted too long and burnt. No other way to put it. Veal Parm sub was awful. I asked for extra sauce. They maybe thought I meant hardly any sauce. It was so dry. Barely any sauce. Veal was overcooked n burnt n dry. Thought id break a tooth on it. Inedible. Ate half of a half n tossed. Chicken parm.also incredibly dry. Usually enjoy this place. Not today. Real bad read more

NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

See all

I would not give any stars but that isn't allowed I guess Ordered take out subs and boy I can't believe they actually served these to my father and brother. Atrocious is being kind. Dad asked for crisp bacon note the picture for the bacon coal like nugget , my brother ordered a veal Parmesan sub and was served a hockey puck. Do better have some pride in what you serve to the public read more

NY Pizza - Veal Parmesan sub, veal overcooked like a hockey puck - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

See all

Worst food and customer service ever!! Didn't have my order and made me wait an additional 40 minutes for an order that was supposed to be ready in 15!!! The employee lied and was super rude. Never going back and I recommend you don't go. read more

Do not eat here. This place advertises Halal products, however is not. Products are beef and pork blend. The manager told me the pepperoni was strictly beef, I am allergic to pork. I ate the pizza and had an allergic reaction. Asked another employee and was told the pepperoni is a beef pork blend. If you don't eat pork or are allergic this place false advertises and is not 100% beef as Halal should be. read more

Delicious pizza and apps, good prices, and friendly staff. One of the go-to's for my family!

NY Pizza of Mansfield. Ordered food online at 6 p.m. received it at 7:45 p.m. The food arrived cold. I suggest this establishment hire more drivers instead of the one person who works in the shop delivering all the orders. The driver found my bldg. but once she was in the bldg. She couldn't find my apartment. There are only 4 apartments in the bldg. which are numbered and I provided it when I ordered. If an establishment is going to keep people waiting the food should be exceptional for which it was not. I received an apology for my order being late but it was not sincere I was just being placated. read more

I am done with this place. I have given them so many chances. ordered a pizza and salad. 45 mins later I get a cold pizza and dirty salad. employees are yelling and swearing at each other. no offer to take money off. no thank you. no good night. horrible place. read more

Food is awesome Service has really taken off. Ambiance, they are ambitious and they will make many other renovations. read more

Growing up in NY and being here in MA has made me miss NY pizza. I figured I'd give this place a try. It was definitely good enough to come back again. I only tried their cheese so next time I'll try something else. read more

I eat at NYpizza today and I loved it . They served me a medium cheese pizza and was delicious! read more

NY Pizza - Small cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

Pizza is fantastic! Cooked just right, tastes fresh and crust is the die for! Service is fast and staff if friendly! Will be ordering again! read more

NY Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

I tried NY in Mansfield last night. I ordered the "Al Pacino" pizza (eggplant, carmelized onions and fresh tomatoes). I thought it was really good! The large is 16" and was almost too big for the box. I like the crust, not soggy at all in the middle as sometimes happens with veggie pies. It was tasty and great consistency. The eggplant was sliced so it tasted like eggplant and not too thin, not too thick. I liked that. I prefer a little more sauce but it was a great sauce. Good cheese, toppings were good too as far as amount goes. I will come back again and update my review when I have more details about "Consistent quality and service". read more

Food delicious, Monday at 11am made an online order because time matters. Went to pick up 2 pizzas at 11:30. OK sir, Got pizza a 11:55 ? Did't even start until I walked in the door even though they were already paid for. NEVER AGAIN!!!! read more

I tried these guys again. What a mistake. They opened at 11. I ordered online at 11:05. I got there at 11:30 - I was in kind of a rush. When I finally got their attention (no one else there), he said their ovens are still warming up!!!! Come back in 10. I come back in 10. Again, being ignored. Finally he comes up and says the ovens aren't hot and they haven't started the pizzas yet!!!! Incredible!!!! I told him to cancel the order. I will never go back. Too many other good pizza places. read more

ordered a fish and chips with onion rings as a second choice, received a fish with no chips. fish and onion rings where not at all crispy and the rings where all stuck together. don't know how the pizza are But I'd pick somewhere else for anything but read more

Not sure how this makes it out the restaurant. My steak and cheese has little to no steak in it and the roll is burnt. Abysmal effort at edible food. Borderline robbery. read more

NY Pizza - "Steak and cheese" - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

See all

Cheese slices were so good! Very flavorful thin crust, delicious sauce, and the cheese was perfect (didn't just pull off/apart when eating). It was a quality slice. I don't live close and just happened to go when I was passing through town. I will definitely drive out of my way to go back again now that I know how good it is. The people were also really nice! read more

NY Pizza - two slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

I've tried the pizza twice. The visits each, one month apart. I was excited when I saw it. It looked delicious! The top was cooked almost perfect. The bottom was too done and the center was chewy and tough. I'm guessing the oven is a tad too hot. They need to adjust the temperature and cook time. read more

See all

Recently ordered a margarita pizza and half pepperoni and cheese for takeout. Nice crust and sauce. Overall a good pizza. Convenient parking. read more

Food delivered was hot but pizza was undercooked, nasty canned mushrooms and toppings were not evenly placed but piled in the middle. Mozzarella sticks had a weird off taste and the marinara tasted odd. read more

I swear at one point this was the best pizza around these parts, but the quality of their pizza has diminished greatly. I don't know if there are new owners or what but you need to fix this greasy mess you call NY pizza... read more

The 'famous' caprese literally had 2 tomatoes and maybe a few slivers of basil and didn't even have olive oil. Only giving 2 because the chicken was good. But the person who made this should find a different job read more

NY Pizza - The chicken sub I got was good but this is what they sold us for the 'famous' caprese sub. This person should be fired. - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

We ordered pizza during the quarantine. Got a confirmation email right away. Then waited an hour and 40 minutes and the food never came. Called thelir number a dozen times, got some bullshit message. NEVER GOT THE FOOD. read more

NY Pizza - Confirmed order at 7:58. It's 9:24 and no food. Called them a dozen times, got a message about my voice mail box. F*** this place. - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

Checked out the new pizza place in town for lunch. The two men inside were incredibly nice and helpful. My pizza came out fast and hot. I will be back soon! read more

NY Pizza - Medium buffalo chicken pizza with fresh basil on top. Just what I was in the mood for! - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

By far the best pizza in the Mansfield-Foxboro area. The crust is thin and crunchy. Never had a problem with service or delivery. This is my new favorite pizza-sub shop. Margarita pizza was outstanding. read more

2 hours, 10min for delivery. The app said 70-80 min. I called the restaurant 8 times over the course of a half hour to see what's up and they literally had the phone off the hook. Perfect place to order food from if you aren't hungry and have all night to sit around waiting. Otherwise, doesn't deserve your business. Plenty of other pizza and sandwich shops around here with way better service. Definitely not gonna be ordering from here ever again. Horrible. read more

Amazing pizza, crust is my favorite in town, this is a customer service issue, kitchen issue: stated not an allergy but requested half the pizza be No chz, other half chz .. was told this was not possible but I could order 2 med end get 1 chz 1 no chz. He then told me the kitchen is too busy to make my half and half pizza .. how is (1) pizza harder then making 2? we ordered elsewhere! And we are weekend regulars most of the year read more

So I'm new to the neighborhood. Strange times moving in during a public health emergency. Ordered today for the first time, using an online app. Couldn't have been more pleased. Great pizza and a burger. The burger comes with all the fixing, a salad and french fries. Pizza is great!! Can't wait to try other items from the menu!! Oh, and can't beat having it delivered by a great guy wearing a mask!! Thanks Jeff!! read more

Very disappointed because they've been okay in the past whenever we'd order takeout. Today when I called to follow up on an order that was promised 15 minutes earlier, I was told it was delayed because they had a HUGE order for 50 pizzas. No apologies or anything, just that they had that HUGE order so everything else was pushed back and it didn't wasn't indicated on the online ordering site. Well, we paid for our pizza too so HUGE order or not, it could've been prepped right along with the 50. Bad form, NY pizza. read more

Ordered a steak tip sub for $16.99 and got all of two pieces of steak. They added tomatoes which i did not ask for. A bunch of fillers to make the sub look decent. Save your money and stick to Stefanos. This place is trash read more

Took them 2.5 hours to deliver a pizza on Saturday night, when the app said 70 minutes. I understand being busy, but in that case don't accept so many orders and don't tell your customers "It should be there soon" when you call to get a status update. The food was cold and it wasn't good at all; at least we know never to order here again. read more

My boyfriend and I eat here AT LEAST once a week. The pizza is phenomenal. They will also work w you when you ask for extra accommodations (although sometimes they forget to give you dressing on the side! Only negative thing I could possibly say). Our faves include the buffalo chicken pizza, the chicken broccoli Alfredo, the Philly cheesesteak and of course old fashioned (extra!) pepperoni. Highly recommended!! read more

Looks like new owners...or the guys tossing the fresh dough has bailed...in place of pre made frozen crusts? This used to be puffy edge soft to bite. It's still Ok tasty pizza, and better then the other local trash, but it ain't NY no more. read more

With out a doubt the worst Italian sub I've ever gotten. Old tomatoes, onions and lettuce.

Brand new to Mansfield. Authentic New York style pizza. I grew up in NY, I ate great pizza for 30 years and this stacks right up to some of my favorites. Order a slice or take out a 20" family sized pizza. Excellent!! A must try, let's keep this gem around for a while pizza lovers! read more

NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Massachusetts

Ordered two wraps buffalo chicken, was quoted a price for the delivery which was only for the one wrap when driver showed up. Need to listen while taking orders on the phone, very important in accuracy of an order. Ordered extra Bleu cheese and received none but it was on the receipt. This is during a lunch break at work. Asked if they could bring it back on the way by, not right this second but we were quite understanding these things happen. Guess that Bleu cheese will never come. Not a good impression. Let me know about the Bleu cheese someday. Or somebody stole our Bleu cheese we will never know read more

I recently ordered 15 large pizzas for an event. Everybody loved the pizza! They were all hot and delicious. Every pizza cooked to perfection! I know putting together a large order isn't always easy, but these guys were awesome! The order was completed the moment I arrived, and they loaded up my vehicle for me. I can't wait to go back! Great job! I strongly recommend you paying them a visit. read more

We ordered four pizzas last Saturday night. We wanted to give this new restaurant a try.When I called I was put on hold 4 times and when I finally got through the person who answered the phone was very rude. Now I understand this is a new restaurant so we went forward with the order. The pizzas didn't have a lot of toppings and the sauce was minimal and the pizzas were very doughy. So you like doughy pizza without a lot of toppings or flavor than you probably should try NY pizza. Besides that the prices were very high in fact I thought I was mischarged so I went in today to try and get an answer but the five people standing behind the counter fail to understand the customers are priority over talking about their computer system and their backup computerserver at 3:30 in the afternoon. I basically was ignored so I couldn't even try to get my problem resolved. I would recommend Alberto's in in Norton and Stefanos in Mansfield. Both have very good pizza as well as friendly staff. read more

Love the pizza. About as close to NY as you're gonna get around here. A little light on the toppings a couple times, even when ordering extra? Online option to order "slightly undercooked" was the way to go for me- the kids love pulling apart the crust for the doughy center. read more