This is my second time at the establishment, in recent months, and didn't care for the bartenders' service. Both visits were during lunch hours. My food, chicken tenders and French Fries, was good but I didn't have a mixed drink as I wasn't feeling the vibe of the bartender. So I kept it to glasses of Pinot Now that I think about it, I can't tell if it were the same woman both times, which would make more sense to having a similar experience, and if so, I'd chuck it up to her having lackluster performance, rather than than the bar lacking overall. Either way, this will always be my go-to Downtown Brooklyn bar. read more

The key to enjoying O'Keefe's is to leave behind any expectations around ambiance and fancy frills. But it's a damn good, old school bar, with excellent drinks, happy hour deals, and surprisingly good food. This used to be my go-to happy hour spot when I worked in the area, and it took me months before I even knew it was called O'Keefe's because there's no signage. Whatever signs exist are there to advertise the available drinks, happy hour deals, and daily specials. That, and TV screens in every corner (most plugged into the sports channels). But don't let that fool you into thinking this is some gruff and dirty hole in the wall. Drinks are reliably good and the bartenders really know what they're doing around cocktails. Service has always been prompt, even when they're at their busiest. Best of all, whoever's in the kitchen needs some serious props because they elevate bar food to a whole new level. I've ordered wings nearly every time I've come, and you know they're good when all conversation 'round the table pivots to some version of 'How good are these wings?!' The honey garlic is easily my favorite, but I've never had a bad flavor. It seems silly to praise a bar for their fries, but they're excellent here too - starchy, screaming hot from the fryer, and perfectly salted. That said, ignore the healthier options. A Caesar salad came with just a handful of croutons and an absolute deluge of dressing that rendered the lettuce underneath nearly inedible. The space inside is larger than it looks outside. The front area has plenty of high tables and seating by the bar, while there are lower two- and four-tops towards the back (where the air conditioning is a little better felt since they tend to keep the windows and doors wide open by the entrance). There's also a second floor space, but I've never ventured up since I've always managed to find seating below. read more

See all

I will preface this by saying I'm not big on Irish pubs. However, they always are good to relax and just kick back for a couple drinks! Came here on a Thursday and it was pretty busy. Dont think they have a happy hour from what I saw but its very cheap regardless. Got a few blue moons, and yes they throw in an orange slice for those that are wondering. Had some fries which were good as well. Dont think Id go out of my way to come here but enjoyed it nonetheless read more

Clean inside, friendly staff, & nice old school vibe. Nice blend of all kinds of patrons of all walks of life, here in the hub across from Borough Hall. Delicious food - soups, salads, & sandwiches, w/ fair prices & portions. I somehow always slept on this place, but now I will def be back! Note: weird mix of music - cld def use more jazz / swing / big band. read more

The customer is not the priority, at all. What's the priority? The conversations between the staff, catching up, what happened in the previous shift, over the weekend etc., anything that entails ignoring the customer. They literally walked past my empty drink for over 10 mins, literally walking past money in their pocket. Empty water glass for 30 mins and I got offered a food menu 40 min in. When I ordered food, it went upstairs first, then in the back room then it sat at the end of the bar where you guessed it, wasn't a priority. Let's finish our conversations first, maybe even start new ones, then we'll get this food to the customer. Otherwise, it's a decent bar with a long time history. Fire the lazy and you'll make a lot more $ read more

We love that this spot opens until 2am daily, which leaves you with little options in the neighborhood. We came in for a late night bite and drinks. The AC was also blasting, which was much needed on a hot summer night. We had a few rounds of drinks ($9-10), which was reasonably priced and bartender was great about checking in. For food, we ordered the 10pcs Medium Wings ($14), Onion Rings ($8), and Mac & Cheese ($8.95). The mac and cheese was kind of petite and the wings were a bit on the tougher side, but sauce was good. The thing I loved here was the onion rings, which came in a huge basket. They were super crispy yet easy to bite into without losing the entire onion inside (iykyk). This will probably become one of our regular late night spots, especially for these onion rings! read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - Beer Battered Onion Rings, O Keefe's Mac and Cheese, and Medium Buffalo Wings. - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Standard bar, the wings were ok not as crispy as other places make the wings. Ordered a margarita, it was a little too sour read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

From service to food, nothing disappoints here. The staff showed authentic kindness. This place balances excellent food with superior attention. You're going to want to return here. I can see myself definitely coming back here. read more

The menu offers items that consistently work well. And everything else was so yummy, filled with spices that I normally don't eat. The staff was notably outstanding. The energy helps you enjoy your meal. I think this spot deserves your visit - I'm glad I discovered it. read more

Average, cookie cutter sports bar, nothing special at all. I'd be happy to give it three stars, but what makes this place especially terrible is the service. The entire staff makes you feel like they're doing you a favor by acknowledging your presence every 30 minutes or so. A few were trying, but the majority were so inhospitable that I can't imagine giving this place any of my business moving forward. Do yourself a favor and skip O'Keefe's. read more

What an incredibly sad sight. I spent my 20's at O'Keefe's. O'Keefe's was a neighborhood bar in the 1980's and 90's, where you could get a beer or a drink, right across the street from the courts - cops, DA's, college students and local residents could unwind in a relaxed bar atmosphere. They had a choice of 5 beers, which were $1.50. There was no shine. There wasn't supposed to be. There were no TV's (how does anyone watch TV with 12 of them at the same time?) No turkey burgers. They had wings, fries and bar food. You went to drink, socialize and listen to music on the jukebox. This place is nothing like the O'Keefe's it once was. The place used to be packed on Friday and Saturday nights. We used to close it down. The songs on the jukebox were songs everyone knew and could sing to. Beer was spilled on the old wooden floor, and it was normal. I can't even bring myself to go in it. It seems like an overpriced, yuppy establishment meant to siphon money from the wealthy people that now live there. They probably even serve goat cheese for the "trendy" transplants that have gentrified our once great Brooklyn. Sad. read more

A solid place to go to get a drink after work. Good place to get some bar food. The service was friendly and attentive

This reliable neighborhood bar should really clean up more given the lack of sports bars in the area. It's a breath of resh air and relief with jerseys and banners hanging on walls, plenty of space, and TVs lining the bar. I imagine it gets busy on Saturday and Sunday afternoons, but it was a perfectly civilized place to throw back a few beers and watch baseball. The food is expected pub grub, plenty of hearty favorites. Stick with the standards and you'll be satisfied. read more

One of the only Manhattan-Style Irish bars in the area, with your typical Irish pub & grille type menu, complete with a terrific steak sandwich!! I find that all my fave steak sandwiches are from Irish joints. The menu had lots of appealing choice, but I went with the "can't-go-wrong" O'Keefes Steak sandwich: ribeye cooked to preferred temperature, mozz, sautéed onions, peppers, shrooms. All on garlic hero. Delish! As was the French onion soup! Even the leftover soup part, ha! At many places the broth is bland and left behind once the bread and cheese is gone, but this onion soup was actually really tasty-so much that we were both dipping our sandwiches in it! My husband got a pulled pork grilled cheese on special. He liked it. I'm not really into Smokey-bbq flavor, or bbq sauce, so not necessarily my pick, but I tasted it and could see people loving it! read more

I ordered a side of vegetables. The bartender said the side was green beans which were great last time. So I ordered them. She brought out carrot sticks and celery with blue cheese similar to the side that would come with chicken wings. She said that was the only vegetable they had in the back. No problem but I didn't want it so had her return it. It's just not what I ordered. So I was ready to close and the same girl bartender ignored me. I only realized this when she handled the customer next to me and then didn't talk to me at all. Another guy said he'd help me. For some reason I sensed something, maybe that I was in trouble because of the vegetables. I ended up asking him if he's the owner or something like that. He said to me... yah something like that. So I closed and tipped well actually and left soon after. In general, they do have a nice happy hour there. They have long tables, lots of TVs also and it seems like an OK place to hang with friends. read more

Great food steak sandwich was very good. Service at the bar was excellent and punctual. Nice bar to get away from the city

Went in for a drink after work Everything sucked, including food and service Nope Never again read more

This place is open! Really just a bar for me on this trip but it's open. Say it again. OPEN. Update Yelp. Not closed read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Got the chicken Caesar wrap delievered. Came pretty quickly, it was okay probably wouldn't get again. Fries were good.

The "Bar" has always been the go to spot for my wife and I for years! It's been our Friday after work Buffalo Wings, Sliders, Chili Cheese Fries, and The Coldest of Beers decompression zone! read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - O'Keefe Bar and Grill - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Highly recommend the burgers! Nice cool spot to go and enjoy a drink after work, but don't sleep on the delicious food!

My bf and I stopped here to just watch the game for a bit. Super nice and big inside with flat screen TVs everywhere. Perfect sports bar! Ordered the crock of French onion au gratin. Soo yummy! read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - French Onion Au Gratin - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The drinks are good, the bartenders are nice and the vibe is cool but the happy hour is basically just beer and the food is your typical frozen bar food (fries and mozza sticks and chicken fingers which are hella dry). So come for a drink or two, but don't get food and don't expect a happy hour menu. read more

This is a good old fashioned bar. There are regulars, newbies, day drinkers and great bar food. There is a bouncer wed through the weekend and rarely ever more that 2 bartenders at a time. It's a little homey and lived-in. No hooks on the bar for your purse, the counter is large so you've gotta slump over to eat at the bar, some of the chairs wobble, and the bathroom is tiny and run down. The drinks are a bit pricey, there are a few large flat screens around and a jukebox for music. So why 4 stars? It has great bar food and good energy. Wanna hide away in the back and destress, sure, sit at the left corner table behind the bar. Wanna scream at you're favorite team on TV, feel free, pull up a chair at the bar and check out what's on tap. Or wanna meet with your crew and talk the night away, no problem, grab a high table on the right. Now let's talk food... BEST Wings in the area hands down! Meaty, well cooked, evenly divided and fresh. I like them dry with sauce on the side skin they stay extra crispy. Classic yet tasty sauce choices so you cant go wrong. The turkey burgers are the bomb. Always juicey and filling. The fries are simply delicious. I like the shoestring but the waffle are a strong second. Crispy, hot and made to order, salty, potato-ey goodness. They are a must. So if you're in the area, stop by, pull up a chair get comfy and stay a while. All are welcome and you won't regret it. read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - Turkey burger and fries - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Decent spot for happy hour food and drinks. Despite the location on Court Street in Downtown Brooklyn, the vibe is that of a neighborhood watering hole, as opposed to the corporate commercialism on display in the area. I came through last week with friends for taco Tuesday. 3 tacos for $3 is a great deal, and the tacos got the job done. They are on the small side, so consider getting several orders. Drink prices were reasonable, certainly cheaper than at artsy hipster joints, but with the corresponding reduction in selection. Note that they start a separate tab if you move from the bar to a table, do be sure to settle both at the end! read more

(this is all before rona) went with my dad since it was the only place to eat after my physical therapy up the block, I think it was like 1pm. I had a sandwich and my dad had the steak dish. Solid food for a hub in that busy area. Bartender with the tatta was cool. read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - Bar - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I will never go here again. I was charged for a drink that was not mine. When I tried to talk to the staff (my server Jane, Taylor the bartender, and a male bartender) on June 16, 2023 around 4pm, I was called a liar and said I had to pay for the drink. The male bartender threatened to call the cops on me because I was explaining to them this drink wasn't mine and said how embarrassing that would be for me. I asked them to pull cameras to show proof that that drink was not served to me. They refused to pull the cameras and instead called me a liar and said I'm never allowed back. This was such a traumatizing and terrible experience. I don't recommend going. This is not the first time something like this has happened at this bar. Save your money read more

Great spot to catch a drink after work and get dinner with friends. Friend bar staff.

For a big group, I ended up just walking out rather than order. This could apply to more bars and restaurants than this particular place, but maybe it bares highlighting how frustrating group bills are at places with outdated and the uniquely NY practice of not offering individual bills for what individuals order. Following a professional event with some forty people, we wandered in to keep the good times rolling. When I started ordering I got put in a weird position by stagg of having to figure out who is at what table ordering what food so their waiters could have the right tips from table service. Mind you, I was ordering at the bar. When I relayed the message their staff should have handled to some people in my group - strangers mind you, since its a group- some were rightfully confused and said 'eh, not my problem.' I didnt want to deal with whatever mess the bill would be at the end, or ensuring the tip for the staff wasnt coming out of some unsuspecting last person standing. I just left. NYC needs to figure out better group bill policies. I think we've all felt strained to handle this awkwardness of people ordering different things and subsidizing folks who dont want to be subsidized but also dont want to do the math. read more

Worst bar experience ever, took 15 mins to get service at an empty bar while servers were chatting on the other end. Even ignored me while I tried to get their attention. The White customers next to me, who came in afterwards, had no problem getting prompt and hospitable service, however. Coming to this bar made me regret leaving the house - never again. read more

Love this bar but the waitress at 4:45 pm seated and served this lady that said she only had her Vaccination card but left her ID at work(LIE).  Putting all other patrons in danger of COVID! read more

You don't have to be an attorney or law student to grab a bite or have a drink here. Happy hour prices are a thumbs up. Or just sit in the back and order food. Different groups of people/friends can stand around the bar but not be on top of each other. I have had the wings a few times here and I like them. Good: -Happy Hour = $1 off all drinks -Nicely sized spaced -I order the 20 wings for a few bucks more than the 10 piece (bring the rest home) -Beers come out as fast as you can drink them Bad: -Being PICKY...you can only get one type or one sauce on your wing order (can't order 20 and say 10 hot/10 BBQ) read more

Great local bar near downtown. Beers were cold. Drink pour was generous and the burger was excellent. Bartender was attentive and friendly. What more can you ask. I would recommend highly read more

This place has been around since before the gentrifiers flooded the area. This was a working man's bar when I was a kid. it was one of several on Court Street. There was another bar where the Now closed movie theater is and the next block also. This is the last neighborhood bar left that serves regular drinks to regular people read more

I already made a review but I'll do it again. It's an awesome bar no negativity here. the mussels are amazing

Me and my friends went to celebrate my new job and we got very rude service from the waitress. The manager did nothing to address her rude behavior. Thank you for ruining our afternoon. WILL NEVER GO OR RECOMMEND THIS PLACE AGAIN. read more

We needed a spot to meet some friends and we ended up here. It was honestly so fun. Great drinks, tons of beer options, the bar tender, Damian, was cracking us up and the playlist was on point! I wish we had more spots like this in LA. read more

Ordered on uber eats waited an hr was so excited and hungry got my order and guess whattt...dang order is wronggggggg!!! Wth and the only thing right was my steak order which had no flavorrrrr not even salt n pepperr wthhhh annoying as hell. Uber will return my money but I waited an hr for the wrong stuff annoying n what I got isn't even delish. read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - What I got. Only thing right is steak - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Found this place on yelp but was pretty disappointed ultimately. The place was extremely loud, service was slow (and the waitress seemed like she did not want to be there at all), and food was low quality/not good. No napkins or silverware were provided or available. The waitress didn't come to check in on us and after waiting over 20 minutes for the check, we just went downstairs to close out. The wrong order was also brought out. We will not be returning. read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Good place to catch a game and chow on some bar food. Servers were friendly and drinks were reasonably priced. On my first visit, I asked the bartender for some food recommendations, and got the loyal "everything's good here" response. Knowing that couldn't possibly be true, I was back to square one and perused the menu again. A friend and I ended up splitting an order of the buffalo calamari, which was a tad rubbery, but well-sauced, and accompanied by some bleu cheese for dunking. Their buffalo sauce is VERY sweet here, to the point we almost mistook it for BBQ sauce. If you're looking for some heat, you may want to ask them for a side of Frank's Red Hot or similar. read more

O'Keefe's Bar & Grill - Buffalo calamari w/ a sweet buffalo sauce - American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York