I placed an order for two cakes at the Arlington Heights store for Christmas Eve dinner, requesting they not be frozen as was done a few times in the past. One was the Poznanski and the other dairy free. Both cakes were EXCELLENT, fresh and beautiful in appearance. I will definitely be returning for our next holiday treat. Thank you Bill! read more

I had the pleasure of working with Basia on the design and catering of our sweets table for our wedding in Lake Forest. Basia understood my vision and taste immediately and executed my dream sweets table perfectly. We received endless compliments regarding the deliciousness of the sweets as well as the presentation. Basia was incredibly lovely and professional. She even reached out after the wedding to offer her congratulations. I highly recommend working with Oak Mill Bakery for weddings and events! read more

See all

This place has completely fallen apart when it comes to customer service. Start hiring people who actually know how to help customers, because whatever you have going on now is unacceptable. What an absolute waste of my time. There were three employees--two glued to the phone and one barely helping the few people in the store. Clearly, these employees have zero capability or training, because they can't even manage more than one customer at a time. Honestly, fire this staff and hire people who are actually capable of multitasking and doing their jobs. If not, reviews like this will keep coming. Shame on you. This used to be a great place to shop for desserts, and now it's a disappointment. read more

I didn't know what to get, but the lady working at the front gave me loads of recommendations on what's good and what's popular. I got the chocolate chip cheesecake and a European cheese twist baked good. Both were so so good, I would highly recommend them. The place is huge with so many different things, I'm sure some things might not be the best but everything looked delicious. I would be willing to try pretty much anything! read more

It's everything you'd expect from a traditional neighborhood bakery. It can be crowded and that's a good sign to those people who expect good places to empty out when they walk in. It's Polish and Chicago and busy. It sure beats mass produced stuff. I'd stop at Rich's in the same parking lot to explore groceries or Paczki Cafe across the street for an amazing pastry treat. read more

Inflation is real! But makes sense, as the bakery needs to cover the increase in costs of their raw materials. A 6" cake here a year ago was $30. Now it's $45. The weekly special cookies 'n cream cake we picked up today for my dad's birthday was very fresh. The chocolate cake was extremely moist (one of the freshest cakes I've tried from here), and the Oreo cream filling was on point! The cake was adorned with 2 Oreo cookies as well. However, unfortunately, when having a piece 2 days later, I tasted something chewy in my mouth. Spit it out, and it was a small, clear, rubber looking piece. I spoke to management, returned the cake and material, and the complaint was filed and investigated within 2 days, with full resolution and refund issued for the glove that was in the cake. I appreciated the manager's attentive and thorough communication throughout the process. Service upon the original walk in visit left something to be desired too. I asked the young girl behind the counter what flavor one of the cakes was, and she mumbled something like I don't know. I asked if there was fruit inside it, and she answered by pointing to another case and saying those cakes had fruit. Finally, after asking if she could find out what flavor it was, she went to talk to a more experienced staffer who came over, while she herself just disappeared to help someone else. ‍ Oak Mill was a solid option for a reliable selection or special occasion cakes, and a cake monster I am. Note to self (if I ever return...) and other cake monsters: go to flavors are Ambrosia (hazelnut and chocolate cake with white chocolate mousse and raspberry filling), Dobosh (vanilla and chocolate with marzipan), and mango (vanilla and chocolate cakes with mango filling), which I enjoyed more than expected. Pear Charlotte also gets a nod, with the unique ladyfinger perimeter, pear element, and rum. Skip the straciatella. While the chocolate chip and walnuts with booze were alluring, it wasn't the best combination of flavors. Funfetti was also plain and not as good as expected. read more

See all

I ordered another cake for a birthday party here, and it wasn't my favorite. It was a vanilla cake with peach mousse and a passion fruit mousse layer inside. I thought it sounded good, but the taste itself was very disappointing. If I come back next time, I'll probably just stick to one of their classics. read more

Amazing sweets and cakes! We loved our wedding cake...we froze the top layer and opened it on our first anniversary and it tasted absolutely amazing. Thank you! read more

Awesome bright flavors Their variety is wonderful Great service Brilliant variety Would recommend to tantalize your tastes here read more

Very over-rated - and incredibly expensive and outrageous prices. No cake on the planet that's 10" is worth $100!! Have been going to them since they 1st opened back in 1986 or so. I recently ordered a " fresh fruit" birthday cake. Was very disappointed, the cake itself was dry, and they used all of 2 strawberries and 2 kiwi fruit and charged $100! What a rip-off. They truly have gotten so greedy over the years. Never again. They've lost their touch. read more

I've been a loyal customer of Oak Mill Bakery for over 20 years. The pear cake is my absolute favorite because it's light, not overly sweet, and always a hit with my friends and family. I used to enjoy their chocolate cream, chocolate-covered rogaliki, which had a delightful crunchy base made of egg whites and nuts. Unfortunately, they changed the recipe, and they're no longer as good, so I stopped buying them. While the pear cake used to be $27, it now costs close to $70 with tax. Because of this price increase, I don't visit as often anymore, which is better for both my wallet and my waistline. Despite this, the pear cake remains a special treat that I always look forward to. read more

Everyone were so ready to help. I was on a rush and they were able to help me to put together this 1 cake, using 3 different pictures for that look. They don't see making money first, but The happiness and satisfaction of their customers. Delivery man was so kind and respectful, and everything was professionally done. I also used them 9yrs ago for my daughter's christening, and cake had the shape of a bible and was perfectly made, as picture. That's the reason why I went back. Sincerely, Naomie H read more

Ordered a cake and cake pop for my son and niece's combined bday party. This bakery has been making my family happy since I was a little girl. So glad to see it running and continuing to give valuable customer service. There are so many questions that come up with ordering a cake so I value their patience, knowledge and helpful suggestion read more

Service s great and Food fresh delicious Highly recommend to buy birthday cake and pastries read more

Over the last few years I noticed a decline in quality and style of products sold by Oak Mill Bakery. I support this business for sentimental reasons but unfortunately my patronage will be ending. I purchased a bday cake today and it was a total disappointment. It tasted old, cheaply made and gone are the Polish European flavors once present in all Oak Mill sweets. This Bakery made my wedding cake and Sweet Table that is still talked about to this day by my family. It is so sad this business decided to drop its European roots and start making mass produced junk. read more

For my dad's birthday, I decided to stop by Oak Mill Bakery and get him a cake from here. It was my first time at Oak Mill but I remember my cousin wedding had a sweets table that was from Oak Mill Bakery and it was delicious. I was surprised by their vast selection of cakes. There were so many to choose from! I was worried because some bakeries offer a small selection to buy the day of but not Oak Mill! I ended up getting a Strawberry & Peach chocolate cake with custard and whip cream for my dad. It was delicious and my family loved it. I also got a slice of their marzipan roll and some cannolis to try. Unfortunately both were not to my liking. The marzipan was too gritty for me and the shell for the cannoli was stale. Nonetheless we went back to get a cake for my birthday and I picked out the Temptation cake. It was soooooooooooo good. Honestly it was one of the best tasting cakes I've ever had. I regret getting the smaller size. My whole family loved it as well! The staff were nice and knowledgeable about the cakes. The cakes are great and I would definitely come back for them! read more

See all

Disgusting, I dont recommend it. Rude stuff. Very low-level service. All cookies and sweets are made with nasty quality ingredients. I wanted to return the Donuts(because were old ) Girls, who spoke in Polish. They thought I didn't understand the Polish language. But start gossiping behind me. And I left donuts at the Store left . If you go this store you will regret . read more

I ordered online some special treats for my husband's birthday. Super easy when I picked them up two days later. My husband has a sweet tooth but does not like cake, so I had to be strategic in my selection. One of the items I picked out was the Pear Charlotte. It was the star of the party! It looked SO elegant and reminded us of the Great British Baking show. Also love the history behind this cake. It tasted very good and was so unique! Oak Mill Bakery is my bakery of choice now! read more

Oak Mill Bakery - a birthday cake on display - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

So if I need to be honest, I get this is a north west burbs institution. However this is by far the absolute worst bakery in the area. The staff is the worst, rude, cold, unapproachable and should not be the front of house face to meet clients. The items they sell are tasteless, zero flavor and assembled poorly. It was noted a lot of the goods were frozen and foul tasting. One of the pasties actually smells of mildew. It was also noted the kitchen prep area is very dirty very unkept. Many other bakery's in the area go where they appreciate customers. read more

How disappointing! Purchased several paczki today brought home and discovered they were stale and tasteless. read more

Did you know that there are multiple Oak Mill Bakeries? I thought it was just the one location on Oakton and Milwaukee (Niles) until I called the Harwood Heights location and realized that there are multiple locations bearing the same name... Oak Mill Bakery (the original) is a place I've always wanted to visit and I'm glad I did when I went by there a few weeks for paczki's. Paczki's are Polish doughnuts that are filled with jelly and they come in a lot of yummy flavors. I've always wanted to try them and they had an assortment for "Paczki Day" (February 13th) which I went to sample. By the time I ended up at Oak Mill they only had a few flavors left but I'm glad I got to try the raspberry and blueberry flavors. They had sea salt caramel earlier in the day (yumm) but of course it was all sold out. They also had apricot and prune around the time I got there (near closing). I picked up a few other yummy desserts (peanut butter pop, red velvet cupcake, and some strawberry shortcake) and left with my yummy goodies. Pros: -prices are fair (all my items were around 14.00) -selection was decent (make more caramel paczkis and less prune) -service was fantastic (the employee working there went back twice to get me items from their freezer and instructed me that I needed to thaw them). Cons: -weird parking- as in you have to be on the Milwaukee side to get in and do all these weird u-turns or drive through the neighborhood -be prepared to wait. I waited about 15 minutes in line. I know it was Paczki Day so there were a bunch of people but it seemed like an eternity Tips: -They take CREDIT- it's no longer cash only- but the minimum limit was $10.00 before credit is accepted. -They don't like AMEX (not preferred). read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

Easy to miss if it weren't for my GPS. Nice, clean, and inviting interior. I ordered an 8" Chocolate Ganache cake for a birthday celebration. The white chocolate card with the Happy Birthday message was a let down as I was expecting a swirly script on top of the cake. However, the three-layer cake was delicious with a hint of coconut flavor and chocolate bits for texture. There was real buttercream and chocolate without syrupy sweetness. I will return and check out the other pastries when I'm in the neig read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Chocolate Ganache - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

I ordered 2 strudels to surprise the Mayor of Evanston for his birthday. HIGE HIT!! One cherry-- one apricot cheese. The decorative writing was a perfect touch-- just as I ordered. I have been patronizing this bakery for years(a lot more when I lived in Glenview) but have never written a review. They have never disappointed me-- and I am very fussy. Whether it's a special occasion-- for a special person-- you will always find what you need-- and they will follow your special requests down to the last detail. I love surprising people. Bring joy to another person's life-- brings joy to my own. The strudel s were such a hit-- it was SERIOUS competition to the birthday cake! Thanks ever so much! read more

THE OTHER LEBOWSKI Searching for the perfect wedding cake can be a series of ups & downs, strikes and gutters...... With a venue, band, and guest list all but locked up for our 2020 ceremony, the next item on the agenda was to nail down a bakery. My fiancée and I came here for a cake tasting on 9/21/19, having made an appointment for 10am. This European bakery is located on Milwaukee Ave in Niles, just north of Oakton. It's in a strip mall on the west side of the street, and parking can be a bit difficult. Oak Mill has a wide assortment of cookies, breads and small tartlets inside glass display cases, some of which are just beautiful. Upon arriving on-time (a rarity for me, but necessary given the importance of the situation), we were asked to wait at a table. A few minutes turned into 10, which grew to 20 minutes.....then 30. Halfway through, we were asked to move to another table as some other wedding couple pulled rank on us. Okay, rude. The actual cake tasting was $25 for what amounts to a few forkfuls. We sampled a French custard, lemon curd, and raspberry preserves with a few different frostings. Bill helped us, but he was pulled away several times to help with other customers. There were a lot of interruptions on top of a late start. With our hearts set on a 'tres leches' (three milks cake), we requested a small sample and were told it wasn't possible. We could only place an order for an *entire* $30 cake, since not even a small tester slice was available. My gut was telling me to walk away; I would never buy a car before test driving it first. In a total leap-of-faith move, we ordered their interpretation of a 'tres leches' and picked it up a week later. I should've known something was screwy when they showed us a picture of it covered in chocolate and we had to request it be left off......like it should be to begin with? As it turns out, they outsourced this project to another bakery who thought it'd be perfectly fine to soak the cake in Kahlúa. Not only is this not one of the "three milks", this is a coffee liquor. Not. Even. Close. The cake received 4 thumbs-down; 2 from both the prospective groom and bride-to-be. * TL;DR * White Russians make a great beverage; Eric S has been known to ask for another Caucasian. Those boozy flavors are great when served over ice in an Old Fashioned glass, but any recipe calling for you to soak a whole cake in it is a very unwelcome deviation. I should've listened to my instincts and not ordered a Mexican special occasion cake from a Polish bakery. As a traditional tres leches, it was a disaster and now we're stuck with the rest of it. It felt like opening a briefcase you think is filled with ransom money, and instead getting Walter Sobchak's dirty undies. That's bad enough, but they made us sit around for THIRTY minutes. Why even bother making an appointment with us? We've got lots of stuff going on -- especially on a Saturday in September -- having us sit for half an hour is really inconsiderate and tells us that A) our time isn't important B) our business doesn't matter to them. Needless to say, we're dropping Oak Mill like a 16lb bowling ball and finding some place else to handle our wedding affairs. His Dudeness is not pleased. You might as well have peed on his fuckin' rug. No, I don't recommend. This aggression will not stand, man! read more

I love the cakes they made for my nephew!! I ordered a week in advance and they printed the pictures I sent them on top of the cake. It was a very easy process. They also added details on the side which made both cakes look better. The only reason why it's not 5-star is because it has more icing than bread. The taste is good but the icing was a lil overwhelming. Other than that, our whole family enjoyed what the cake represents! I will definitely re-order. read more

See all

Love Oak Mill, I've been going here for years. They've always come through with luscious cakes when I special ordered them. The cake is light and airy, the whipped cream frosting just right and the decorations are superb. They have done some amazing decorations on sheet cakes for me that have been a big hit. I'm surprised to see people had any problems with service. In all the times I've been there, service has always been good. I will definitely keep going here. read more

This place do not deserve not even 1 star. Last week I went with my friend who is shopping around for a wedding cake, the lady behind the counter was not very welcoming the manager wasnt there so she had me write my info for the manager to call me for appointment. She did not even direct us to the corner section where they have wedding cake displays, photo compilations etc we just helped out selves check out stuff. Fast forward today, so my friend went there for the appointment (I was not able to join her). My friend's appointment was 3pm but she got there at 2:30 and told the person behind the counter she has an appointment with Basia the wedding cake coordinator. My friend waited patiently. No Basia come out. So my friend left very disappointed. I learned about it and called the place right away and spoke to Basia. She claimed she was there the whole time and had not gotten a message that my friend was there. The person behind the counter may have not told Basia her 3pm is already there. And Basia knew she has 3 pm appointment and did not bother to check if the person arrived. What kind of customer service is that?!?! Such a disappointment! You just lost a customer. As much as I love your cakes, I will not set foot in your place of business ever again! read more

Customer service need some work. Asked for a 10" cake and was told they have to check their manager and would call back in 5 min. 40 min later had to call back and was told that it would be a special order and it is too late. Mind you called 48 hrs ahead. Are they expecting people to place order 10 days ahead for a simple 10" cake. So ridiculous. read more

We came here to pick up a birthday cake for our grand-daughter and we were very happy with our choice of a 6" strawberry whipped cream/custard cake. It was $25.67 all in including a $2 charge for a written cake message but at least the birthday placard is pretty large and is edible white chocolate. $26 may seem a bit pricey for a 6" cake but in comparing prices for premium quality products, they're in line with the top tier competition and this product was tip-top fresh and tasty and you could tell right away with the strawberries and almonds for example. Another reason for my high rating is they also have a huge selection of off-the-shelf quality choices and I'm sure they can customize just about anything you might like. I've personally never stepped foot in here til today, but the wife and daughter have used this place several times in the past. read more

See all

I've been going to Oak Mill Bakery for many years and I knew that is where I wanted to get my wedding cake from. Their pastries and cakes are just sooo good. Of course, I had a wedding cake in mind of course and It was the semi-naked cake. When we met with Basia, she convinced us to get the chocolate flavor since It will look better with the semi-naked look I was going for. We chose the raspberry mousse for the filler and let me tell you, It was sooo good. I knew I wouldn't be disappointed with the way our cake would taste. Now, where I was extremely disappointed was with the fact that my cake looked nothing like what I wanted. I have shown Basia the look that I was going for and she said that It was no problem to do. It didn't seem difficult in my eyes, no crazy designs, just semi-naked look. She did tell me that there is an extra cost to the semi-naked look, which initially shocked me. She told me that It was because It requires more work to get that look. I've attached photos for comparison with what I showed her via email and on my phone on multiple occasions. My florist put the flowers on my cake and thank God that she did because my cake would have just looked like a white cake...that's It, just a white cake, no semi-nakedness to It except for three SMALL streaks. You can even see the stands that each tier is propped on which cheapens the look of the cake even more. The first time that I saw my cake was when I walked up to it for my cake cutting ceremony. Imagine my disappointment. Of course, I hid my disappointment, but boy was I fuming. Not only because of the way that it turned out but also, I found out that my coordinator was having trouble getting ahold of Oak Mill Bakery. My coordinator was ready to go to a store to pick up a random cake in place because she didn't think it would show up since no one was getting back to her. Overall, I thank God that at least it tasted good and that the flowers were there because It really would have looked sort of sad. Please note: I'm only giving It 2 stars because the cake tasted good. read more

Oak Mill Bakery - What my cake looked like. - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

See all

One of the better bakeries in the area. They have a nice selection of breads and pastries. We tried the eclair, Napoleon, doughnut, petit fours, opera cake, and a hedgehog cake. The service we received was excellent and all of my questions were answered well. The eclair has a nice chocolate topping that was not too thick, the pastry creme was just fine, I wish it had more natural vanilla flavor. The Napoleon was quite good. It had a nice puff pastry, but It left a tiny bit of a film in my mouth (I'm skeptical all butter was used). The coffee petit four was moist and had a good layering of buttercream but the chocolate petit four was dry and didn't taste very chocolaty. The doughnut was cooked well and stuffed with a lot of creme but the dough was slightly dry (maybe they are better in the morning, we came late in the day). The opera cake was fine. Nothing stood out that made this bakery seem special. Overall, I thought that everything tasted pretty good and from testing out many bakeries in the area, this was one that I would return for a visit or recommend. read more

See all

This place Is awesome! It has a homey feel and yet their work on wedding cakes and other bakery goods Is beautiful. We went there for our wedding cake tasting and design and the woman who helped us was very attentive. They had amazing designs to choose from and the flavours weren't half bad. Personally, my fiance and I liked the red velvet the best Also, they have a private parking lot so don't worry about street parking. Cake tasting Is appointment only but they also have pastries and ready made cakes. Did not try the pastry goods but they looked wonderful! read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Yum yum cake tasting - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

See all

Great cake we ordered but...let's not call it Nutella if it's barely going to have a Nutella flavor to it. Rich, chocolate whip creamy flavor and nice presentation but really lacked the flavor I was expecting it to have! read more

Our cake was beautiful moist and delicious. Basia especially helpful understanding and a pleasure to work with. A month later and we still have people asking us who made the cake. read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Wedding Cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

My family and I went for wedding cake tasting consultation and we had a great experience! We were seated and provided different cake flavors. There was a lot of flexibility and options provided. They are really willing to work with you to provide exactly what you are looking for on your big day. I could clearly tell that there was a lot of experience and expertise. We loved the cake flavors. I would recommend the lemon cake, poppy seed cake, raspberry mousse and lemon mousse. These flavors caught me by surprise and were really tasty!! Perfect for summer/ spring read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

My compliments to Oak Mill on having the good sense to employ Basia as a wedding consultant! She was very friendly and PATIENT with my tasting group of four (although mostly with me as I was quite talkative - I didn't know that the average tasting time was 45 minutes to one hour - we were there for about two hours). In my favor it is much more time consuming with four people vs. two (the two parties that arrived after us both had two - likely the folks getting married. Our bride and groom live in San Fran and we were family tasting proxies. Basia asked about the theme/style/motif of the wedding and other questions as she was trying to narrow down the options. She brought us out coffee and a tray of cakes. They looked lovely and we narrowed our group choice to strawberry mousse filing with chocolate and vanilla cakes. Sort of boring in light of the choices - but it should be delicious. Basia was also good with noting what items will not work well with other items and she was clear in advising when an item was going to cost "more per person." Our bride and groom were not getting the cake as a "part of a wedding package" but buying the cake "on their own." I didn't think that the cost of the cake and delivery was unreasonable - about $900. Weddings have to be Uber challenging as brides are hyper sensitive about everything being "just right." So my kudos to Basia, the well-respected Oak Mill bakery and to the hope that our wedding cake is "just right." :) read more

I have had their cakes 3x and bought from there 1x. I am not a dessert person but the cakes I had were good. Some of the specialty cakes are elegant but it is hard to swallow the price for a 6" cake, even if it is on par with others' pricing. I would not shy away from Oak Mill for your bakery needs. read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Valentine's Day treat. - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

Oak mill has done a great thing today! It was my grandpas birthday and these are some weird times. Rather than seeing him to celebrate his 90th birthday, we had to put those plans on hold! So I had oak mill deliver two of his favorite pies to him. He was so excited!!! Thank you so so much for helping me make his day better!! read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

A wonderful family-owned bakery!! We've tried many of their cakes thus far (strawberry shortcake probably bring our favorite). We went today for a cake tasting for our upcoming wedding and were fortunate to work with Basia. She was so kind and patient with us. Thank you to everyone there and we can't wait for our wedding cake!! read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Wedding Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Niles, Illinois

See all

it was recommended to check out Oak Mill Bakery. I noticed that the people behind the counter, handling the goods were not wearing gloves. One lady had her fingers on the cake so It was definitely not appetizing. read more