Ocean Isle Creamery was the perfect treat after a round of mini golf! The flavors were great, the service was super friendly, and I loved that they had a cookie sandwich option. I got a cookie sandwich with Butterfinger ice cream, my husband got Butterfinger, and our daughter got the Barbie flavor, which is a fun mix of cotton candy and cake batter. Everything hit the spot! We'd definitely come back again. One thing to know is that anything other than cash has a 4% surcharge, but they do have an ATM onsite if you need it. read more

See all

The icecream is pretty good! We love the rocking chairs out front! Parking can be difficult when busy.

I hate to admit, but we visited the ocean aisle creamery multiple times during our stay in Ocean isle for a sweet delight! Each time we went, there was a line out the door because it was very popular spot! I tried several of the different ice cream flavors and every time I enjoyed each and every single one of them. I would highly recommend that you visit the ocean Isle creamery each time you come to Ocean Isle. I really enjoy that there were tables that you could sit at outside and enjoy your ice cream with the family. read more

See all

We stopped in after dinner for dessert! The line was almost out the door but was moving quickly. The available flavors are labeled and posted on surf boards on a pole - such a cute idea! We each got a kids cup with one scoop. I ordered carrot cake and the girl put peanut butter chip in by accident. Then I pointed it out, she quickly apologized and grabbed a new cup. The flavors were amazing and you could tell they make the ice cream on site! Definitely a great spot to stop in for dessert! read more

Seriously the BEST strawberry ice cream I've ever had ! Like think about it all the time and wish it was closer !

No idea why the reviews for this place aren't great. We went late at night and all the service workers were very nice and they were not out of anything. The ice cream itself was amazing. Very smooth and silky. Tons of flavors and we liked all the ones we tried. Also very reasonable prices in my opinion especially for a vacation spot. read more

My family of five went and we got a few different flavors , all of which were underwhelming. The Choc chip cookie dough had ice crystals in it, the mint chocolate chip only had a hint of mint, and the chocolate caramel just seemed like grocery store chocolate ice cream. Nothing 'creamy' about ocean isle Creamery ice cream at all and the lack of options for flavors was disappointing. I suggest you try to find another ice cream spot. read more

Weston and Kaylnn recommended me to this shop. So good. So wow. Thank you for making such a good birthday cake icecream cup and m&m double cone. I loved seeing the frat bros. read more

Ocean Isle Creamery - Weston & Kaylnn Koury - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

the ice cream is good but warning: they do not have any dairy free ice cream options!

Very friendly and numerous flavors to choose from ice cream and gelato. Great after dinner treat.

Very good ice cream! Fast service! The lines are long but not too bad, they are fairly quick at getting your order done.

Grabbed a couple of cones after dinner one night on Ocean Isle. The place is a happening spot at the 7-8pm hour. There was a socially distanced line out the door, and I recommend parking your car or golf cart at an adjacent parking lot because it's a bit hairy getting in/out of their parking lot with all the traffic and the outdoor picnic table seating sharing space in the lot. We ordered chocolate ice cream for the kids, Java Chip waffle cone, Birthday Cake waffle cone, and a Strawberry cake cone. All were very tasty, and I particularly liked the waffle cone flavor. Cute rocking chairs on the front porch if you're able to snag one! Reasonably priced to treat the family to a little dessert. One tip if you're not buying for the whole fam: $10 minimum for credit/debit card transactions, so bring cash for smaller purchases or they have an ATM off to the side you can use. read more

I have been to the Ocean Isle Creamery at least once each time that I have visited Ocean Isle due to proximity. The ice cream is not bad, although I will say that I have never been particularly excited about my ice cream choice. They are always busy, and it's cool that the ice cream is homemade. Although given these factors, standing in a line for ice cream in the heat during a pandemic isn't really my idea of a good time. To me it would be helpful if the ice cream was colder so it didn't melt so fast as we had to eat it outside for obvious reasons. I couldn't get halfway through my cone without having to toss it because it was melting everywhere. Think there were also only about eight flavors to choose from and the chocolate I had this time was a bit lacking in depth and flavor. Perhaps I'm spoiled by Jeni's and Graeter's back home but those cones are worth the wait! read more

This is an affordable ice cream place with great portions for kids. It won't break the bank with a large family. I love the toffee delight personally but they have a wide variety of flavors for your palate. They practiced social distancing measures in line and staff were masked up too. Can't wait for next summer to frequent this establishment again. read more

Ocean Isle Creamery - customers at the counter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

Wont be going again. The line was out the door but it really wasn't worth it. The prices are ok but the ice cream really wasn't great. Not a lot of flavor. read more

Possibly the worst ice cream I've ever eaten in my life. The cookie batter ice cream tasted like coffee when I pointed this out to the ice cream dollar she said yeah a lot of people think that too. Then it turns out that most of the ice cream that we had tasted like bad coffee including the chocolate hazelnut and the butter pecan. Bland not creamy honestly what happened was I threw it out. read more

Not impressed. Super overpriced. I had a small cup of salted caramel with whipped cream and crushed Oreos, which was alright. But my friend had the mint Oreo and there was not one Oreo chunk in the ice cream. It was ridiculous. Expected more from a creamery! The ice cream at Breakers is better and cheaper. Just saying. read more

Ocean Isle Creamery - One scoop with whipped cream and Oreos -$5.55 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

See all

The absolute disregard for public health and safety during a global pandemic by Ocean Isle Creamery is astonishing. 1 star is still too many for Ocean Isle Creamery. The first girl working was leaning over the ice cream with her mask around her chin and repeatedly touching her face and seemed annoyed she was having to wear it. When she was asked to put her mask on properly she rolled her eyes and stormed off. The owner was not wearing her mask either and did not seem concerned when it was brought to her attention that her employees were not following CDC guidelines for Covid-19. The ice cream is overpriced and mediocre at best. Terrible experience overall. I would highly recommend choosing another ice cream shop when looking for a sweet treat. read more

I definitely wouldn't call this place a creamery. Everything seemed like it was bought in bulk from a food vendor. The sign says homemade, however, this ice cream definitely tasted like it was purchased at the grocery store and had lots of food coloring in it. My kids didn't mind it though. It is overpriced for the awful quality and service, but that's how it goes in vacation destinations. Service was awful. I get that this may be a place for high school kids to work summer jobs, but at least train them a little bit in customer service. I went last night (5/26/18) and the 3 girls standing at the counter were so rude and couldn't care less about the ice cream they served us. They looked annoyed to be taking a simple order (literally, a kids scoop in a cup with sprinkles), and didn't listen to me at all. I'd rather give my money to a place that actually makes an effort and wants repeat customers. We definitely won't be back! read more

We had a hankering for some ice cream and had noticed this place driving around Ocean Isle, so we stopped in and are glad we did. Some rather limited hours (hopefully that will broaden during the summer?), but the service and choices were wonderful. I usually fail-safe and order the chocolate at any new place I go and did so again here. Rich and creamy and very flavorful; a nine on a ten scale for chocolate in my estimation. Great place to stop in for a quick treat...I wonder if they do deliveries to Leland? read more

Ocean Isle Creamery - a man and a woman eating ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

As someone that's lived here for 5 years, I can't say that I'd recommend this creamery to anyone, even summer visitors desperate for a cold sweet treat. This place is always packed May-August, you will undoubtedly be waiting in a line backed up out the door and into the parking lot. The seasonal adolescent staff they have can be shockingly and unnecessarily rude. And most importantly, the ice cream is subpar: For the past five years I've occasionally stopped in on a whim & tried different flavors each time. Every single time, Im left unsatisfied, disappointed, and every flavor ends up tasting the same after 5 minutes--- you won't have the desire to finish even the smallest size. With rude staff, long wait lines, and bad ice cream--- you're better off taking the trip to Calabash & testing out the Calabash Creamery. People around here seem to have much better things to say about this shop & the owner is very sweet, he goes so far as to drop free tubs of ice cream off every now and then for my grandmother on his own initiative. Calabash Creamery over OIB Creamery any day. read more

So shocked to see such low ratings for this place! We got strawberry and Oreo cheesecake waffle cones here yesterday and they were amazing!!!! And huge! Yes they are expensive but we found the serving size and waffle cones to be worth it. We went early afternoon - no wait - and were glad when we drove past around 6:30 and the line was out the door! read more

Ocean Isle Creamery - a hand holding an ice cream cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

If you want to find a place to buy both a sweet treat and clothing/swimwear, this place can cover it. Various ice cream flavors, and a boutique upstairs. Had both outdoor and indoor seating. Ice cream is creamy and sweet. Good place to stop and eat at. read more

Average ice cream and outside is VERY dirty. Multiple spoons, spills, and tables that haven't been wiped down. The rocking chairs out front are a nice touch. Also, not very customer friendly with signs all over such as, "2 tastes per customer," "$10min on credit cards," etc. Apparently the wait at night is outrageous too. Skip it all. read more

I took my family here for some ice cream and my oh my was it good. Although the wait was quite long, the ice cream was amazing. 10 out of 10 would come back again read more

Bottom line: Ocean Isle Creamery has OK frozen treats but the flavors are not overly impressive for the price. Huge space inside, needs filling with tables/chairs maybe. Great outside porch area to enjoy. Purchases under $10 are cash only. I like the frozen treat break available but feel they are capable of more here. Would I go back? Yep. Would I especially seek them out? Hmm, well I think it helps being conveniently located as you come in on Causeway Dr. The Deets: On various trips to OIB our group has stopped by Ocean Isle Creamery as it is right on Causeway Drive as you come off the bridge, and beside the realty office we pick our keys up from. As it is a great location on a heavily traveled road, it's hard to miss. It has a pretty small/cramped parking lot so be careful there. The outside itself is very bright, inviting, modern, and very beach shore like. Nice rocking chairs outside on a porch with ceiling fans make for a good place to settle down with your selections. As you go in, it is a huge open space, the ice cream counter itself does not take up very much of the area. More seating would help as it seems a bit empty for the space. The staff are mostly young student aged employees and on my visits have done ok with service for the most part. Do note that there is a $10 threshold before you can use credit/debit cards...I feel that would limit their business for some reason (why not $5?). There is a moderate list of choices for the ice cream/yogurt/sorbet selections that day. Be sure to look in the freezer itself as I found the list didn't exactly match what was in the freezer. This last visit I got the blueberry cheesecake and then the cheesecake flavors. I was not really overwhelmed by the cheesecake flavor itself in either one, but it was a nice cool break and refreshing dessert. The flavor and product itself was ok, but not a "wow factor." For the prices charged, I was expecting more of a "wow" there. It definitely helped cool me down on a very hot Saturday waiting to get into our cottage for the week. read more

Visited Ocean Isle Creamery on Memorial Day. They were very busy and in an attempt to speed up the wait they were taking orders before you got to the front of the line. This would have been a great idea if the ice cream board menu matched the actual selection! As far as location, they are 5 stars since the location is on the island. As far as taste, 0 stars. Our party of 3 had 3 different flavors and they all tasted like the same base flavor. Prices are very reasonable. So much potential here if they could have a great product to match the great location!! read more

Know what you are getting into! The lines are too long and the prices are too high. So if you're willing to stand in that and pay up, then go for it. You won't be let down by the quality of ice cream, but after you spend $20 for four ice creams, you won't exactly reach enlightenment either. I recognize the need to survive in a competitive market and all since summer is their major season, but again, I've been to other "homemade" ice cream places before, and the quality is higher and you get more for your money's worth. Not a let down, but not an enjoyable experience either mainly thanks to the line. On a plus, you are able to get two samples, but keep in mind, when you do that, you're going to be "that guy" who holds up the line. Then factor in someone who doesn't care, has 4-5 people in his family, and the kids want to try each flavor. Know what you're getting and it'll go fairly quick in terms of service. If you're game, then go for it. Otherwise, if you miss out on the ice cream, it won't be the end of the world. Expect to park on the side streets. read more

Certainly not my favorite place on the island to get ice cream but it was also not terrible so I am giving it three stars. The ice cream itself was ok - not great but not bad. The employees were rude though and I also have a problem with places making it look like they are more crowded than they really are. What am I talking about??? We had driven by a few times and saw the lines of people put the door so we figured that this was the ice cream place on the island. But when we actually went to visit we figured out pretty quickly what was going on. They have an employee stationed at the door only allowing a few people inside thereby making sure that there is a line out the door. At the time that we went everyone that was in line could have comfortably fit inside the building but they had to have the appearance of a "line" so they keep us outside. The line thing mentioned above, the rude employees, and the average ice cream combined with slightly high prices are all taking away one star from my review. read more

Three stars for Ocean Isle Creamery for the entire experience. The shop is clean and the service is average. At only TWO samples per person, you'd think it would be difficult to decide, however their selection is pretty sparse and their variety is very typical. I will say, their Praline ice cream was by far the best I tasted out and voting on that ice cream alone I'd say four stars. However, I also tasted the peach (eh), cookies and cream (lack of cookies and low grade cookies, tasted like they'd been frozen too long), and cookie dough (again, lack of dough and just eh flavoring). I don't want to go to an ice cream store that claims to have homemade ice cream and be less then thrilled by the majority of flavors. The cherry on top of the experience was that the next day we went over to The Breakers Arcade and ordered ice cream (ice cream is an every day beach necessity). The variety of flavors and selection was double what the creamery offers plus the ice cream all around tasted better AND was cheaper. Sorry Ocean Isle Creamery, but you need to step up your game if you're going to survive! read more

See all

Mediocre ice cream. Rude staff. Dirty location. They seemed annoyed that we were wearing masks despite there being a pandemic.

Unimaginably rude staff, extremely unprofessional management, and an owner who is obviously out of touch with how their business is being run....or maybe the owner holds similar awful work ethics as the rest of the employees. If even half of the population that gives this place business would check the Yelp reviews first (I wish I had), this place would not still be in business. Oh, and the ice cream, as other reviews mention is not great. All flavors basically taste the same...absent of the actual flavor advertised. read more

Just stopped in at the creamery for a milkshake and it was definitely not worth it. We got two shakes, and both had so much milk in them that they were like chocolate milk - not shakes. We could not even taste the ice cream, only milk. Neither my husband or I finished ours. They were $6 a piece and a total waste of money. We are local and live within walking distance, so it's too bad the food/shakes were bad - otherwise we would likely be back all the time. Strongly DO NOT recommend. read more

After dinner and drinks we were looking for a little something sweet to end the night and stopped for some ice cream. I got a hot fudge and my husband got a banana split. Both hit the spot. The business could have been a little cleaner, but the ice cream certainly hit the spot. read more

I wish I would have checked yelp before coming here. They get points for offering sorbet because my daughter is allergic to eggs and all their ice creams have eggs - so at least I was able to get her something but the glowing reviews stop there. I got the butterfinger ice cream and was actually pretty excited about it. I think I had 2 bites that actually tasted like butterfinger - the flavor just wasn't there. It wasn't bad, it just wasn't the flavor it was supposed to be. Hubs liked his hot fudge sunday, but the woman making it forgot to put hot fudge on it at first....ummmmm. okay. He of course pointed it out and she corrected it. I think we both thought the strawberry sorbet was better than either ice creams we had. disappointing. read more

2 Words: Just Okay. Ice cream was average. Service - Let's just say that the ice cream wasn't served with a smile... Not really much too say other than that. read more

Ocean Isle Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

I really wanted to like this place! But it's so not worth the price! $6 for a milkshake?? I got a scoop of cookies and cream, which tasted like regular vanilla. Even the cookies in them didn't have any flavor. The only indication I had that there were, in fact, Oreo-type cookies in there was the occasional sweetness from the filling. Other than that, the ice cream had no flavor. Earl got the mint chocolate chip, which was heavy of mint syrup, and and had frozen chocolate chips in it. Not impressed. On the plus side, the parking lost is big and easy to get in and out of. read more

We've always saved ice cream as an extra special treat. We're at the beach, so we've been here twice. They handle the large crowds quickly. Plenty of selections. Ice cream was very good, as was the sundae. Very good and we'll probably go one more time before our holiday is over. It is a bit pricey, but isn't everything these days? And besides you're at the beach!!! read more

The ice cream at the ocean isle cream left little to be desired. From the rude and immature staff to the block of ice in our scoop of ice cream we would not return. Also if you call yourself a creamery you should probably make your own waffle cones... read more

Pretty good ice cream not enough flavors every day ... way way to expensive... better places in ocean isle to get ice cream