Donut hole-y moly! We found a new must stop in OIB. We tried the French Toast, Pineapple, Banana Puddling, Peach Cobbler, Holland Filled, and Coconut Cream donuts. My favorite was the French Toast and my least favorite was the Banana Pudding. You can get a special offer if you first dine at Maria's. These donuts are one of a kind and definitely deserve a drop in. read more

Came here to take a breath away from a big beach house full of vacationing family. Wonderful place. Got a simple drip coffee and the Spilt Milk donut (picture half eaten because I got too excited to eat it). I'll be coming back tomorrow when they open before I head home! read more

Spilt Milk - Spilt Milk donut, coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

I keep coming back and forth with this place after the first awful experience I should have stayed away.. however I came back with family a few times even updated my review and it was ok but once again this place has been a nightmare. The employee working before closing she was awful to deal with. We walked in about 45 mins before closing and she had already started putting stuff away.. fine I get it. But when I asked if they had something she gets an attitude and was like NO WE ARE CLOSING I said ok (the coolers were EMPTY) I asked if they had any ice cream to go ready because sometimes they do. She says to me WE ARE CLOSING... it was literally 45 mins before closing. She did NOT want to help at all and after that experience I refuse to try again. She clearly didn't want to help customers and was only focused on leaving. read more

Tip: they bundle any leftover products in boxes, and sell them at a reduced price the next day, usually half off. They are in the corner. read more

Spilt Milk - Day-old doughnuts are still yummy - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

Grabbed some donuts this morning. It was quick in and out service. The staff was nice and friendly. As we were leaving a long line was forming. We are going to stop by late and have some gelato. read more

Spilt Milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

See all

The donuts are 10/10. So many unique flavors, the Samoa flavor is unbelievable. You truly can't go wrong with any of the options here. read more

Spilt Milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

Donuts are absolute gas! Everything about the experience was great. The Oreo one is unreal.

I have been craving a good donut for months. My family and I were in town on vacation and stumbled upon Spilt Milk and these donuts are so amazing!! We are going to go back again before we head home. read more

Just moved here and looked for a good donut shop.... This one tastes like Dunkin' donut and maybe worse. I choose their donut of the month (apple pie filling). Around where the filling is, it tasted raw! The store seemed clean and the girl who served me was friendly but when I had a question about a donut, she didn't know. Also she said the filings were "sent here except for the custard, we haven't had that in a while for some reason". I was under the impression it was all made there at the bakery?? I will not come back. read more

Spilt Milk - Apple pie donut (listed as the donut of the month) - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

See all

Over priced, ppl were rude. Haven't been in over a year. Went frequently when they first opened

Hands down, a gem of a place! Delicious donuts, tasty coffees, and a cool vibe. Love this place! The staff is so friendly and nice too.

This place was near a pizza place we were trying and they were selling their speciality donuts for a $1.00 each. Well we had to get a few to sample. The Samoa affectionately named after the Girl Scout cookies was outrageous. Loaded with coconut and chocolate on top. We are trying a blueberry, strawberry, Nutella and apple donut too. They make so many flavors you gotta try them all. Enjoyed browsing the selections. They sell good looking gelato too and other pasties. read more

Spilt Milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

See all

The donuts are the freshest, jelly donut the best...I come back time after time. Pizza next door, can't wait to try pizza. If the donuts are good I will try to get the pizza soon. read more

great coffee, great donuts and sweets! The cinnamon dulce latte was amazing and Riley was awesome!! will definitely be back!

My first time at Spilt Milk was absolutely amazing! Dayton was so friendly and personable and so easy to talk to. I went to get some pastries for a neighborhood function and mentioned I had never eaten anything from there, as I have been having stomach issues for a long time. This young man told me he hoped I would start feeling better soon. I thanked God for sending me there! When I'm feeling better I will most definitely go back to have a pastry and hopefully see this precious young man again. Thank you Dayton for making me feel important!! God bless you young man!!!! read more

Super cute little shop with lots of dessert options. Delicious gelato & donuts! Friendly service as well! read more

Spilt Milk - Dozen donuts - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

See all

Food quality. Variety of items available. Size of portions, taste quality of food. I have gotten several items from them. Always fresh and tasty. read more

Get your donut fix here! There's something about being at the beach and getting donuts for breakfast. This spot did not disappoint! They have your usual flavors and then fun creations like Nutella and banana pudding. We got a half dozen donuts and they were good the next day too! I will certainly get donuts from here every time I'm in OIB! read more

Spilt Milk - The regular donuts - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

See all

Really cute place for some gourmet donuts and coffee. We skipped the coffee, so my review is for the donuts. They're akin to Duck Donuts in flavor options...fun ones like Nutella stuffed, butterfinger topping, maple glazed with bacon crumble, and Spilt Milk which is an Oreo cream-filled. They have a glass wall so you can view the donut making process when they're in production mode. Service is excellent. Our first visit we were served by a sweet older woman who remarked that she worked with kids with autism (noticing our own boys on the spectrum), and our second visit we were served by a very friendly and personable young man who explained all the various flavors they had for sale that day. Highly recommend you pay them a visit when you're in the mood for donuts! read more

Spilt Milk - Storefront - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

Donuts are delicious and fresh!! Haven't tried any of the other desserts yet but will!!

Nothing was great and the donuts were inedible the next day where normally a donut would be...

I love donuts like these! Fluffy and satisfying. I chose the Holland cream, chocolate glaze and berry filled. Great donuts and made just right. I always like the opportunity to get a few and nibble on all of them. Great doughnut spot! read more

Spilt Milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

Awesome fresh donuts and delicious coffee. What else do you need? Warning, I gained 10 lbs. Just looking at all the goodies. If in the area, you have to stop in and get your sugar rush. read more

See all

Del ious bacon maple donut but honestly one of the worse lattes I've ever had. Latte was just melted ice milk drink. Truly horrible to drink. Staff very kind and locations very clean though. read more

Not a great latte but the donuts weren't bad! Even good the next morning! We got all of the frosting covered options

Bottom line: Spilt Milk has some amazing donuts, I enjoyed the ones I've had from there so far. Nice staff in a clean/modern shop setting. I recommend getting there early before the donut types you may want are sold out and gone for the day. The Deets: In seeing Spilt Milk on Yelp, I bookmarked it to try on my annual OIB trip and I finally got to try it out recently. It is located in the strip mall behind the Marathon gas station (next to the roundabout before you go onto the bridge/island). Going inside, there is a lot of space that is decorated nicely and looked clean/modern. They serve a lot of ice cream and donut choices, along with coffee and other beverages. Our trip this time involved getting a dozen donuts to take back to the beach house to enjoy. Split Milk did not disappoint in the variety of donuts shown on their menu displayed on TV monitors. Staff told us that they change up their flavors daily. The staff was very very patient in letting us look over the donut varieties and helpful/pleasant in assisting to pick out which ones we wanted to comprise our dozen to purchase to take back (please see the pic I got of the completed box). If I could point out any downside, it would be that many of our selections were out/not available for the day already at just after 10am. The interaction at the register was equally helpful/pleasant. No, they are not the cheapest donut to buy but when we got back and started eating them, I can see why they would be for a premium. So far, I have already enjoyed their cake donut and the Bavarian cream donut...amazing taste and very fresh. I would recommend trying Spilt Milk out for donuts based on my experience so far, and I cannot wait to try out their ice cream selections in the future! read more

See all

Cute place just over the bridge from Ocean Isle. We came over for the ice cream and each flavor was yummy. The milkshake was small compared to the price so did not necessarily have the value. The peach ice cream tasted fresh and the mango was sweet. The servers must have been overwhelmed because they weren't especially personable. They were efficient though. Would like to come back and try their donuts. Looks like they had some interesting options. read more

Decent donuts....however, having donuts at 3 for $5 to move yesterday's over production isnt the way to sell "fresh"! 3rd time I've been in and the glaze is thin and dry, the chocolate icing is separating and the dough is hard. Screaming day old! Need a new production manager! read more

We've had the great donuts before, but tonight we came in for the ice cream! The space is bright, with ample room and a good amount of seating. Loved that there was an option for a mini cup! The ice cream was delicious and I think made in house. There were a few of us so we had the chocolate, the hazelnut, the Cookie Monster, the dulce de Lexie and the birthday cake. Everyone raves about their flavors! read more

Three words: MAPLE BACON DONUT!! Everything else is awesome too! This is one of our favorite places when we want to be bad! Its really nice inside with clean and comfortable ambiance. I see a lot of people just hanging out here. If I hung out there, I'd weigh 1000 pds! read more

I bought a dozen assorted in two boxes and it felt like there was nothing in them. The custard and cream marble sized whole filling had disappeared into the dry dough. At their prices, there should be much more. A Little Debbie offering has more gravitas. Over the years, I've bought here before, but it's either a bad "fluke" experience or this placed has changed. I should have known better when I could see that the offerings were smaller than normal. People will pay a little more for quality, but not for airy memories. read more

Best donut I've ever had, hands down. I will be back for more! Looking forward to trying more of the flavors of the donuts and coffees too.

Ice cream was great that's all I can say. The Sanitation grade is currently a 93.5 and I can see why there were Flies all over the donuts and when one of the girls tried to give me one of the donuts that the flies had been hanging out on I told her No and explained how many flies were on the donuts and she stated "if we got rid of the donuts that all the flies were on we would have none " it's sad the owner is ok with this ,I am sure they could buy simple covers like bakeries have and that would solve all the problems ,but to intentionally be served a donut that a fly /flies have been hanging out on is so disrespectful, your lucky I gave you a 1 star read more

Tables were dirty. Customer service was rude and unhelpful. Even manager didn't care about customer questions. Donuts sold are NOT made that day. They sell the previous days first. I would definitely recommend Blondiez on OIB before I come back here again. read more

We liked the service and freshness. They were missing a few flavors we wanted. But good choice for a donut stop. read more

Spilt Milk - Fun donuts! Fresh! Our favorite is the Hazelnut or Boston Crème! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

Such a great little spot! I've driven passed it so many times and decided we needed to go in today and WOW was that the right choice. Got a variety of donuts and every one of them was delicious! The staff was friendly and even with a long line inside they got us in and out quickly! Recommend to everyone who's at OIB!!!! We got the strawberry short cake, apple pie, spilt milk, Boston cream, chocolate glazed and regular! All were amazing (my personal favorite was the spilt milk but my family loved the apple pie and strawberry short cake too! ) read more

Spilt Milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Ocean Isle Beach, North Carolina

Love this place you should go here every time you go to OIB. every time we have come here the staff has been so nice to us if I could give ten stars I would. perfect doughnuts, ice cream, and coffee I would come again, and the store looks really nice and it's the perfect place to get doughnuts. read more

The maple and bacon donut is awesome. What a great combination. It melts in your mouth.

Donuts are ok. If you like vanilla cream inside they assume you like chocolate. No vanilla cream options without chocolate. The amount of cream is very scared too. A glazed donut with vanilla cream would sell. Not sure why all of them have to be weird and complicated. Sometimes simple is better. Try it! I think you'll be surprised how popular it will be. ...if the cream amount inside is a lot like it was when you first opened. read more

We've been here a few times in the past and had good experiences; however, this past experience was not up to par. There was quite the line when we got there but it cleared out at as we were walking in. There was only a few people in front of us. But a young family/group took a good 10 min to order and get their stuff. Meanwhile, the two people working were racing around trying to make coffee and scoop ice cream and there's now 10 people waiting behind these people. During the busy season, you would think the owner/GM would supply a little better staffing so that customers could be taken care of in a more reasonable amount of time. I don't fault the people working, they were doing their best. read more