This is our go-to spot to pick up fresh halibut, haddock, crab, and/or scallops (and more) to cook…read morefor dinner when we are in Port Clyde. The fish is consistently fresh, well filleted, and fairly priced. We are usually flexible on what we pick up for dinner. I usually just ask what is freshest and we have never been disappointed. We also swing by when we are headed home from Port Clyde We get 5-10 lbs of fish, toss it in a cooler loaded with ice, and arrive home 12+ hours later with enough fish and scallops to fill our freezer. The white-haired guy who runs it on the days we have been here this year is friendly and helpful. The hours can be varied so call if you have a bit of a drive or are headed over for something specific. We called to check if they were open a few days ago and confirmed they were. The guy thoughtfully called us back after we talked to clarify that they were out of crab that day in case that's what we were looking for.

Fair prices, good place to get lobstahs!!!read more

Fresh lobster right out of the Atlantic daily. The guys pull them out of the water for you. You…read morecan pick them or they will. Fresh and delicious!. Best place to get lobster near Tenants Harbor.

This woman has rightfully earned the title of reining champ of fresh seafood purveyors. The…read morerelationships she maintains with local fishermen and women is evident in the quality of her selection. We were staying in South Thomaston for a month and the owner of the VRBO highly recommended her. We stopped by on several occasions and picked up mussels, clams, and halibut (got lobster straight from the dock and oysters from local oyster farmers). The halibut was so supreme that we ordered 50lbs to take home. She had them flash frozen and we are now completely ruined as far as fresh halibut is concerned :) Great selection of wines and local ciders. The only drawback: the parking lot is bitch to get in and out of (tiny). Stayed in Maine for three months, all over the state. Most restaurants were an epic disappointment.. yes you're cooking it yourself and your wallet will know you were there, but this was worth the effort and every cent!

Great fish market that has all the good stuff . Stopped by yesterday and picked up a couple of lbs…read moreof halibut . Excellent fish , very fresh . They also have often hard to find halibut cheeks . These are harder to get than chicken lips . Good fish , good prices , friendly staff.

Some of the best I have ever had! We were served them at The Shop in Portland and instantly fell…read morein love. We immediately went to the source and bought some to take home. Krista and young Sebastian were very friendly and helpful.

Amazing oysters and great directions for the self service oysters. I purchased a shucker knife and…read moreI love it!

Great food, great service! Everything is consistently the best! And you always run into someone you…read moreknow!

Visited there yesterday for a lobster roll for my wife and scallops for me. The lobster roll was…read moregreat...scallops not so much. The scallops were tiny and were either cooked while frozen or not fresh. Very bland too. My wife tried one and did not like that they squirted liquid when you bit into them. For $27 and then additional for fries and slaw, I would expect much better quality.

We've been buying our lobsters for the last several years at Owls Head. Wonderful experience, these…read morelobsters are taken right out of the ocean. No problems getting the size you want and a great price. Love cooking these guys and having a great, fresh lobster dinner.

This is where the lobstermen bring their lobsters after they empty their traps. You can buy fresh…read morelobsters, clams, mussels to take home. Or they will cook them for you to eat at a dockside picnic table and watch the lobsters being unloaded, weighed, and held until retailers pick them up. We ordered a just a pound of clams and a 1.5 lb lobster and butter to share. You can also purchase some sides and drinks. In hindsight we could have brought our own bread, salad and wine or beer and that would have been OK. But the seafood was enough for us. Very low key, no frills, and the lobster couldn't be fresher. Love that kind of place for half the price of a lobster roll somewhere much fancier. We'll be back.

Picked up lobsters and mussels for dinner. Lobstermen were unloading their catch of the day when we…read morearrived. Doesn't get much better or fresher than that. And supporting the locals is great too. We got ours live, but they will also cook them for you. You can also eat there, they have a deck overlooking the harbor with picnic tables. Enjoy

We really enjoyed the lobster roll kit sold on Gold Belly. Here In California, we rarely get fresh…read moretasting lobster. Usually the freezing and shipping destroys the fresh taste. The lobster roll kit arrived well-packed, very cold, not frozen (we appreciated that the rolls were not refrigerated) tasted sweet and fresh, had ample perfectly cooked lobster, and a great mix of tails, claws, and knuckles. It tasted as though it had just come off the boat. and made a truly memorable meal. There is no wonder it has been rated as the best lobster roll in Maine. It was worth every penny.

We had the four pack lobster rolls shipped to us in Oregon…read more The buns were extremely small, so we ended up substituting those. The lobster was so chewy we ended up tossing at least 30% of it (it might have been more). McLoons lobster was horrible. We would have been better off buying frozen lobster locally. In decades, we've never had chewy lobster from our local market (Zupans). I honestly don't know how they have the rave reviews they do, unless they are filtering out the bad ones. I can't in good conscience recommend them at all.

Finally! A place in Maine that offers quality and value! Did the oyster trail and these were by far…read morethe best tasting we've had not just in Maine but of all cold water oysters yet. Usually when a place calls them jumbo it's laughable but there was no false advertising here. What's even better is that they are the product of a father / daughter duo and I love to support local and family businesses. This place is nondescript but a must eat if you're in the area. No better pricing or quality.

What a convenient 24/7 source of raw oysters. Just park, open the fridge, and drop your cash in the…read moreblack box. Unfortunately, the oysters were extremely small and rightfully referred to as cocktail oysters. Because they were so small, it was hard to gauge their flavor and barely worth the time to shuck. They were clearly fresh and had a nice briny smell. I will check back later in the season to see if larger ones are available. I am hoping for the best next visit. Could one day perhaps be one of the wonders of Maine.

Great place for fresh fish and lobster from 1 pound to 4. Staff is very friendly and their skills…read moreat eyeballing the weight of shellfish is admirable. Asked for 2 pounds of steamers, got 2.02 pounds. Same with lobsters: asked for 1.5 and 3 pounds, got 1.47 and 3.2 on first try. I repeat, very friendly staff and right on Maine St., so you can run into Reny's and get some stuff you do not need at the same time. I will be back, often even though it's 20 minutes from home.

This is an excellent find in Damariscotta, ME. The seafood offerings are broad, and they try to…read moreoffer the most local fish possible. We purchased halibut to cook at home for four friends, and it was perfectly cut and delicious. We were very impressed with the quality of the products, the presentation of the fish, the variety of fish offered, and the friendliness and competence of the staff behind the counter. We were very impressed.