Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Off Track Pizza

    4.2 (51 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 1:00 AM (Next day)

    Order Off Track Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Off Track Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    OFF TRACK PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Off Track Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    David B.

    Good pizza. Service was quick. Stopped for lunch and had two slices of pepperoni. Could've just had one, it was big. But it was very tasty.

    Inside first floor
    Caleb M.

    This review is based solely on late night pizza. After a concert at Aura my wife and I drove to exchange street to get some Off Track Pizza. I had yet to try it while my wife had it at work at least once. We beat the after bars close rush I would expect for a Saturday. What a great spot to come to after a night out at the bars though to make sure you have some food before sleeping. We each got one pepperoni slice and the slices are large. Didn't take long for the staff to throw them in the oven to be warmed up, under three minutes. Like I said the slices are large and after that quick few minutes in the oven it came out perfectly crisp. Tasty and well made pizza with what I would assume is high quality ingredients. This will be an option for any nights we find ourselves in Portland wanting a late night bite for a reasonable price for value. Quick and friendly service. I look forward to returning to try more pizza and want to try their chicken parm sandwich as well!

    Crystal C.

    Great place to stop in when you want to grab a quick and inexpensive bite to eat. It's thin crust and comes in a variety of combinations . When you are out with your kids and are sick of getting the toppings they want, if you've had a few drinks and need some carbs, or if you don't want to spend your mortgage payment but want a tasty Old Port dinner, this is your place. Grab a slice from the already made selection or order a custom pie. Can't go wrong either way. They even have a lunch deal if you work in the area.

    Upstairs bar
    Cindy Y.

    So glad to have a pizza slice place right in the old port with a nice variety of flavors and $3 Rolling Rock. One large slice ranges from $4.50 to $6.50 and was more than enough for dinner. You just can't get dinner in the Old Port for anywhere near that price and the people watching is great! Thanks for the great service and a full belly!

    Maria M.

    ** Off Track Pizza - Portland, ME ** If you're craving a solid slice in Portland, **Off Track Pizza (15 Exchange St)** is definitely worth a stop! We tried a mix of slices and their **$14 CHICKEN PARM** sandwich, and here's the breakdown: **CHICKEN PARM** - A beauty! The **chicken cutlet, house vodka sauce, mozzarella, basil, and sesame seed bun** came together perfectly. The vodka sauce was flavorful, and the sesame bun was a nice touch. The only thing I'd change? The **chicken could've been crispier**! But overall, it **hit the spot**. **8/10** **SLICES:** **VODKA BURRATA** - Creamy burrata, basil, and vodka sauce? Yes, please. This was a standout! **TRUFFLE MUSHROOM** - Earthy roasted mushrooms with **black truffle, scallions, and white sauce**--great for truffle lovers. **THE MOOTS** - **Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, olive oil, garlic, and sesame seeds**--I loved the sesame seeds and, honestly, I'm a sucker for **ricotta**. **BUFFALO CHICKEN** - Fried chicken, mozzarella, **blue cheese crumbles**, and scallions. A good take on a classic. ** FAVORITES:** **The Vodka Burrata & The Moots**--both were cheesy, flavorful, and the sesame seed crust on the Moots was a game-changer! **Affordability:** **7/10** - Slices range from **$4-$6**, a fair price for the quality. **Ambiance:** **7/10** - **Cute grab-and-go spot** with **upstairs seating and an old arcade** for a fun retro touch! **Overall:** **8/10** - A solid slice shop that satisfies your **pizza cravings**. Definitely recommend stopping in if you're in **downtown Portland**!

    Salad dressings
    elizabeth m.

    Fun place to grab a slice and a cocktail. We got 4 slices to share and a chicken parm sandwich. All were outstanding. My ranking is as follows: Vodka burrata Buffalo chicken Mootz Truffle mushroom You can't go wrong with whatever you choose. They also offer salads and I noticed in the case they have some interesting salad dressings to pick from. If you go upstairs they have some pinball machines. Check it out!

    Cheese slice
    Alison M.

    Looking for a quick bite to eat before a show at the Cross arena and we came upon Off Track. Not a soul in the shop on Saturday night at 5p made us a little hesitant, but the reviews had me optimistic. Brick wall decor with window seating and stairs going up. Not sure if there is more seating because we didn't need more then two stools at the window. The selection of ready-made pizzas was OK, I went with cheese as the other toppings were not appetizing to me. Hubby got the salami and garlic. I really like the crust first and foremost. A good crust is a deal breaker. Then towards the end it of my slice, I had to start taking sauce off as it became over whelming for me. There must be lots of paste in their sauce. It was so strong, I couldn't tolerate it or another slice even though I was still hungry. Service was great. Not sure if we will back.

    Noah F.

    Went here after a few drinks around Portland. We really appreciate how you're able to purchase slices basically all night. There's never any long waits and prices are honestly not terrible especially for Portland. Got the cheese, pepperoni, and the truffle mushroom. They're crispy and have good flavor but definitely a little greasy. The mushroom truffle was by far my favorite. The flavors worked so well and I felt like it was just overall better cooked, less greasy, and had more character to it. Overall, although this isn't my favorite style of pizza, it's pretty good and would have it again. It's great how late they stay open and it's a pretty solid slice. They have great options and a good space and would recommend giving it a try.

    Sausage and ricotta
    Brett F.

    It's difficult to review a business when nearly all of the competition has closed, but Off Track is far better than Slice Bar and Bill's ever were. And it exceeds the slices at Otto as well. The owner has a mini empire of businesses on Exchange Street, and Off Track maintains the streak of all being good. Upon entering, you choose a slice (either $5.50 or $6.50) from six different options. After five minutes of reheating in the oven, it's served piping hot. And these slices are huge. One could easily be enough for dinner. The Sausage and Pepper consisted of sausage, ricotta, cherry bomb peppers and garlic cream sauce. It had some serious kick and rivaled the best pizza spots downtown. There are also sandwiches and salads during the day, but I'll always order pizza. There are 6 house-made bottled cocktails ($7) available as well. The Secretariat (scotch, ginger, lemon) was light and refreshing. Upstairs has prime people watching of Exchange Street, a pinball machine, a second bar, and tv's for sports. It's not fancy, but Off Track fills the desperate need for a really good slice bar.

    Old-fashioned he took his time to make this and the flavor is absolutely delicious
    Christine K.

    There is a bar above the off track pizza and it is absolutely amazing. You can order pizza at the bar and I tell you the bartenders are awesome. They make a mean ass old-fashioned that I absolutely love you. Do not need a chaser for that.

    Pepperoni pizza and dirty ranch
    Andie S.

    We went here for late night pizza and it did not disappoint. The dirty ranch to go with the slice was so good. Felt reminiscent of a late night spot in New York City in the best way possible!

    Kathryn M.

    We stopped in on a Wednesday evening because my son was feeling some pizza. It's a quaint pizza joint with counter seating facing the street and a few seats in the back. They weren't really busy. We ordered a slice of cheese pizza, chips, & a drink. It came to about $7.50. My son liked it. The employees were nice enough and they had it ready in minutes.

    The D.

    There are limited options when it comes to getting a slice of pizza in downtown Portland. Off track is relatively new and has made a good impression in the old port area. This isn't a surprise as it is one of Maranda's newest spots (sister restaurants with Blyth and Burrows, Via Vecchia, Papi, and the late Henry). Location is mint along with its hours since they serve an hour after the bars close. As for the pizza, I find it best when hot. The pepperoni is dialed, cheesy, greasy and crisp. Sausage a pepper pizza was spicy and flavorful. I felt it was a little dry but was still enjoyable. Same goes for the buffalo chicken slice. It was dry but when I paired it with their dirty ranch it was great. Overall, it's a great place to munch and we will return!

    Sausage and pepper with ricotta and garlic sauce

    See all

    Photo of Chris R.
    288
    41
    58

    2 years ago

    Some of the best pizza I've ever had. So good on a cold day. Gotta try to truffle mushroom

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mike O.
    1
    135
    4

    2 years ago

    Best pizza in Maine. Had dinner here last night, lunch here today and will be back tomorrow. Really great pizza!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of . ..
    0
    15
    7

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sam B.
    0
    20
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    They must import their water from NYC because this stuff checks the box. Amazing slices

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Good NY style pizza. Quick in and out . Large slices and fountain root beer always a win . Like the crispy burnt pepperoni cups.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Off Track Pizza

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 5,063 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Lucky Cheetah - Sichuan Cucumbers

    Lucky Cheetah

    4.2(89 reviews)
    0.0 miOld Port

    My wife and I popped in here at the recommendation of a local bartender for some cocktails after…read moredinner elsewhere. We didn't really look it up before hand and I think we were expecting more of like a dive bar and couldn't have been more wrong. As soon as we walked in the door, we were really digging the decor and overall layout of the place. We were seated right away at the bar and got a couple drinks pretty quickly. The bartender was a younger guy and super friendly. He was very approachable and was really knowledgeable about the gluten free experience (my wife has celiac), which got us excited to come back another day for dinner. My wife got the Short Story Long, which had a really interesting, herbal/vegetal flavor that she really enjoyed overall. I got the Pulp Fiction, which was a flavor bomb all the way with the hint of rye flavor but also a hint of fruit and other layers that was just really fantastic. We will absolutely come back here with the kids for dinner some night!

    Aurgh. Such a nice and sexy vibe inside, but the food was so horrible. They need to retrain the…read morekitchen. Crab and lobster Rangoon- so dry and stringy. Lobster dumplings- the wrapper was so thick! It was thicker than a momo. The lobster inside was over cooked. Baby corn - they said fried and tossed in a sauce, but it felt more like it was steamed. No wok char at all. The strawberry drink was so tart and the whiskey drink was super sour. Food would have been 1 star, but our server noticed our uneaten dishes when we asked for the bill he comped some of them, This place has such great potential, but it is definitely NOT authentic Chinese food. I mean...they served duck sauce at every table....but no duck on the menu?

    Photos
    Lucky Cheetah - Decor in the back room

    Decor in the back room

    Lucky Cheetah - Sweet & sour cod

    Sweet & sour cod

    Lucky Cheetah - Sweet & sour cod

    See all

    Sweet & sour cod

    Cuties - Bar

    Cuties

    4.6(53 reviews)
    0.0 miOld Port

    Finally made our way to check out Cuties after first hearing about them back in 2024 before they…read moreopened. From all indications they became very trendy and popular quickly. Due to its location it makes sense and I suspect the tourists flood into this place. For our visit we came for a small bite and pre-dinner drinks since we had a late reservation. When we showed up it was very busy and loud but we snagged some bar seats. Staff and bartenders were very friendly and welcoming! The vibes are trendy and modern, with a mix of seating types. Only real knock against the overall vibes/aesthetic would be the loudness making it difficult to talk at times. I do wonder how the noise is during the morning when they are more of a cafe/coffee spot. Drink wise they have a good variety of drink offerings and I chose their espresso martini. It is served nitro and has an orange peel on top to give you strong citrus on the nose. It was a very solid espresso martini but I have had better. My wife got Turbo Julius and really liked it. To hold us over until late dinner we also got the large serving of Crispy Pots and it was incredible for what they were. Potatoes were very crispy and aioli was tasty too! Overall a great spot for grabbing drinks and a quick bite to eat. Will need to return and check out the morning coffee options.

    When finding drink spots to visit in Portland, I saw Cutie's on a lot of people's lists and Tiktoks…read moreso knew it was a must-add! I loved how funky and trendy the bar looked, and they had a lot of variety in their drinks. I ordered the frozen watermelon margarita and thought it was great! Margaritas are always hit or miss for me, but I thought this one was good; perfect ratio of alcohol and sweetness, and the watermelon flavor really came through. Service overall was great, and the drinks came out pretty quickly.

    Photos
    Cuties
    Cuties
    Cuties - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    Off Track Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...